推荐微信扫码登录以获得更好的体验!另:🎉建议更新到最新版,以体验新功能!🎉 版本更新记录→

求职投了几百份简历,为何迟迟没回应?BBC What in

共 2 集

剧集目录

集标题时长
P1求职投了几百份简历,为何迟迟没回应?BBC What in 11:45
P2求职投了几百份简历,为何迟迟没回应?BBC What in 11:45

P1 · 求职投了几百份简历,为何迟迟没回应?BBC What in the World播客 p01 中英字幕(带重点词汇卡片) (P1)

字幕摘录

时间英文中文
0:00I have an Excel sheet with hundreds of jobs that I applied to,我有一个Excel表 上百个工作,我申请,
0:03where I basically track whether or not I received a response,在那里我基本上跟踪我是否收到答复,
0:06and a lot of the times I did not.很多时候我没有
0:08There's no magical sign that tells you,没有神奇的迹象告诉你,
0:10this is a good job.这工作不错
0:12And even some researchers are struggling to define甚至有些研究者也难以定义
0:14whether it's a real open position or not.是否是一个真正的开放位置。
0:17Imagine spending three hours perfecting your CV,想象一下,花了三个小时 完善你的CV,
0:20writing your cover letter,写封面信,
0:21filling in a million questions about yourself.填上无数关于你自己的问题
展开字幕全文(295 条)
序号英文中文
1I have an Excel sheet with hundreds of jobs that I applied to,我有一个Excel表 上百个工作,我申请,
2where I basically track whether or not I received a response,在那里我基本上跟踪我是否收到答复,
3and a lot of the times I did not.很多时候我没有
4There's no magical sign that tells you,没有神奇的迹象告诉你,
5this is a good job.这工作不错
6And even some researchers are struggling to define甚至有些研究者也难以定义
7whether it's a real open position or not.是否是一个真正的开放位置。
8Imagine spending three hours perfecting your CV,想象一下,花了三个小时 完善你的CV,
9writing your cover letter,写封面信,
10filling in a million questions about yourself.填上无数关于你自己的问题
11You send off the application and you never hear back.你把申请发了,就再也没有回音了
12No rejection, no reply, nothing.没有拒绝,没有答复,什么都没有。
13Welcome to the world of ghost jobs.欢迎来到鬼工作的世界
14They're jobs that employers are posting这些是雇主发来的工作
15with no intention to fill,无意填充,
16which means that your application is sent into the void.这意味着你的申请被送入了虚空。
17So yeah, it's not just dating apps that are ghosting us,所以,它不只是约会的应用 幽灵我们,
18the job market is ghosting us too.工作市场也在困扰着我们
19So why are employers posting ads for jobs that don't exist?为何雇主会张贴不存在的工作广告?
20And what can you do to spot red flags你能做什么来发现红旗
21so you don't spend hours of your precious time这样你就不用花你宝贵的时间了
22on those applications?这些申请?
23I'm Hannah, this is What In The World我是汉娜,这就是世界
24from the BBC World Service,来自英国广播公司世界服务社
25and I'm speaking to Megan Lawson,我在跟梅根·劳森说话
26who's a BBC business supporter他是英国广播公司的生意支持者
27and has been looking into this.并且一直在调查这件事
28Hey, great to speak to you again.嘿,很高兴再次和你说话。
29Thank you for having me.谢谢你邀请我
30So first of all, break down just how big of a problem this is,所以首先 破解这个大问题
31how many ghost job listings there are.有多少鬼职名单。
32Yeah, we know it's a problem.是啊,我们知道这是一个问题。
33The difficulty sometimes with something like this有时候这样的困难
34is working out how widespread the problem is.正在研究这个问题的广泛性。
35Because of course, there's no system that logs and flags当然没有记录和旗帜的系统
36every time a ghost job is uploaded.每次上传一个鬼活
37But we do know through various surveys that it is widespread.但我们通过各种调查确实知道它很普遍。
38So one survey from 2024 suggested that between 22% to 40%因此,2024年的一项调查表明,22%至40%
39of online job postings were ghost jobs.网上的工作是鬼活
40A separate US survey suggested that between 40% to 50%美国的一项单独调查表明,在40%至50%之间
41of companies have admitted to posting roles公司已承认担任职务
42without any intention to hire.无意聘请
43And then from the perspective of the job seeker,然后从求职者的角度来说
44来自Resume Builder的另一项调查
45suggested that 86% of job seekers had encountered表明86%的求职者遇到过
46what they suspected was a fake listing.他们怀疑是假名单
47Now, with some of these, we have to realise that, you know,现在,用其中一些, 我们必须意识到,你知道,
48not every job that is listed that doesn't materialise in a hire并不是每个被列出的工作 都没有在雇佣
49is a ghost job.是个鬼活儿
50Budgets can change, teams can be cut,预算可以改变,团队可以削减,
51but regardless of that,但不管怎样
52we know that there is a significant problem.我们知道有一个重大问题。
53I guess the big question behind this is why?我想背后的大问题就是为什么?
54Why would a company post a job that they never intended to fill?为什么公司会张贴一份 他们从未想完成的工作?
55Yeah, I've come across multiple reasons for this.是的,我发现了很多原因
56One of them is that they will eventually hire其中之一就是他们最终会雇佣
57and they want to create more of a talent pool.他们想创造更多的人才库。
58So they're just putting out a job application,所以他们只是提出一个工作申请,
59seeing who might be interested in them,看看谁对他们感兴趣
60interested in applying and then know how to work有兴趣申请,然后知道如何工作
61with their applications, their adverts further down the line.和他们的应用,他们的广告 更下行。
62Another reason I've seen is a performative reason.我见到的另一个原因是表演性的原因.
63So say I own a business and I want to show to my competitors所以说,我有一个企业 我想展示给我的竞争者
64that, you know, I'm in growth mode,你知道,我在成长模式,
65we're doing well.我们做得很好。
66I might put out on LinkedIn that I'm hiring for three roles我可能会出演Linked 我雇的3个角色
67and the reality is I'm not,而现实是,我不是,
68but it looks outwardly as if the company is doing really well.但外表看起来公司表现很好
69The third reason I've come across,我遇到的第三个原因
70I've spoken to recruiters who have seen this我跟那些见过这个的招募者谈过了
71and to campaigners as well.还有竞选者
72They're worried that companies,他们担心公司,
73you know, when we do a job application你知道,当我们做一个工作申请
74and we enter sometimes our email address,我们有时输入我们的电子邮件地址,
75our phone numbers, home address, career history,我们的电话号码 家庭地址 职业生涯史
76really valuable information,真正有价值的信息,
77that those companies sometimes go on这些公司有时会继续
78and with this huge batch of data they've got有了这批大数据
79from all the various job candidates,从所有的工作候选人,
80that they go on and sell that.他们继续卖掉它。
81So another reason why ghost jobs are in existence.所以鬼职存在的另一个原因
82I mean, I've thought about it before我的意思是,我曾经想过它
83when I filled in those forms.当我填写这些表格。
84You give them so much personal information.你给他们这么多个人信息。
85Is there any protection in place有没有保护
86for candidates in those circumstances?在这种情况下,候选人?
87Do we know what happens to the personal information我们知不知道个人信息会怎样
88we give when we apply to jobs?我们申请工作的时候会给钱吗?
89Yes, the two people I mentioned there,是的,我提到的两个人,
90the recruiter and the campaigner招募者和竞选者
91who were both working in the States to change things,他们都在国家工作 改变事情,
92they didn't actually know where the data went,他们不知道数据流向哪里
93which was more worrying.这更令人担忧。
94But I was researching this this morning.但我今早在调查
95I thought, surely you can't just take people's data我想,你当然不能只拿别人的数据
96and do what you like with it.随你怎么说
97There are legal requirements in most countries大多数国家都有法律要求
98that companies are upfront about why they have your data,公司是领先 他们为什么拥有你的数据,
99that they are respectful in terms of他们尊重
100how long they have their data for他们有数据多久?
101and how necessary it is for them以及对他们多么必要
102to hold on to that data.以持有数据。
103I guess if we're thinking about the campaigners我想如果我们在考虑竞选者
104who want to change the system,谁想改变系统,
105they would probably question,他们可能会质疑,
106well, if companies are going to be putting out ghost jobs,如果公司要搞鬼工作的话
107which aren't the most ethical job postings,这不是最道德的工作职位,
108are they really going to be meeting these legal obligations?他们真的要履行这些法律义务吗?
109That's really worrying.真让人担心
110It's really worrying for applicants, isn't it?申请人很担心吧?
111And Megan, we've also been hearing from some people梅根,我们也听到有人说
112about their experiences of applying for jobs关于她们申请工作的经验
113and also ghost jobs.还有鬼活
114Hello, my name is Sundas.你好,我的名字是Sundas。
115I am from Seattle, Washington, and I am in tech.我来自西雅图,华盛顿,我是技术。
116And like many people in tech,和很多人的科技,
117I was laid off in the beginning of 2026,我在2026年初被解雇了,
118which basically kickstarted my very aggressive job hunt.这基本上启动了我非常有攻击性的工作狩猎。
119And during my job search, I employed two methods.在寻找工作期间,我采用了两种方法。
120The first method was basically applying第一个方法基本上是应用
121to a hundred jobs a day and basically seeing what sticks.每天有100个工作 基本上看到什么是粘着的
122And then on the other days,然后在其他的日子里,
123I would apply to 20 jobs a day我每天申请20个工作
124where I would tailor my resume specifically在那里,我会特别调整我的简历
125to that position.到那个位置。
126And I was still not receiving responses.我还没有收到答复。
127I was getting automatic rejections.我得到了自动拒绝。
128Sometimes recruiters would reach out有时招募者会伸出援手
129and they would tell me,他们会告诉我,
130oh, sorry, we are no longer filling these positions.哦,对不起,我们不再填补这些职位。
131I have an Excel sheet with hundreds of jobs我有一张有上百份工作的Excel床单
132{\fn黑体\fs20\shad2\2aH82\3aH20\4aH33\fscx95\3cH592001\be1}我申请进入我基本上追踪的地方
133whether or not I received a response.我是否收到回复?
134And a lot of the times I did not.很多时候我没有
135And to be completely honest, it's demoralizing.并且完全老实说,这令人士气低落.
136And it makes you wonder,这让你觉得奇怪
137are these jobs even actually hiring?这些工作甚至真的雇用?
138Are they ghost postings?他们是鬼的帖子吗?
139Are they only hiring internally?他们只是内部雇佣?
140I'm not sure.我不太确定 说不定
141Thank you so much for sending those in.谢谢你送来这些东西
142And you can hear how it makes你能听见它是如何
143an already really difficult process even tougher.一个已经非常困难的过程 更艰难。
144What are the impacts of these ghost jobs on job seekers?这些鬼工作对求职者有什么影响?
145I was really struck when I was speaking我说话的时候很惊讶
146to various job seekers who had applied申请的求职者
147for endless amounts of jobs,为了无尽的工作,
148sometimes had no rejection at all.有时完全没有拒绝。
149And they put to me the context that when you are job seeking他们给我的背景 当你在寻找工作
150and you are out of work,你已失业,
151often your confidence is already feeling pretty low.你的信心已经很低了
152Some people described it as demoralizing, soul crushing,有些人形容它 士气低落,灵魂压抑,
153and also giving them trust issues with the job market.也给他们与就业市场的信任问题。
154How do you know whether to bother spending a few hours你怎么知道要花几个小时
155putting together an application编组应用程序
156if there's a chance that that very job doesn't exist?如果那工作不存在的话?
157And these ghost jobs, they aren't new.这些鬼活儿不是新的
158It's something that has been happening for a few years now,这是已经发生 几年了,
159but we're seeing more of them.但我们看到更多的他们。
160And it comes at a time when the job market is just so tough.而它出现在一个 就业市场只是如此艰难。
161Yeah, we are constantly hearing just about是的,我们经常听到
162how many companies are making cuts,有多少公司在削减,
163how AI is reducing the head count at companies.AI如何减少公司头数.
164So for job seekers to know that in this already所以找工作的人应该知道这一点
165highly competitive market,竞争激烈的市场,
166that many of the jobs being listed列出的许多工作
167are fake jobs essentially is really demoralizing.假工作其实是士气低落
168And also from a policy perspective,并且从政策角度来说,
169so much government policy is made based upon如此多的政府政策是建立在
170how the job market is looking.就业市场的情况如何?
171If loads of companies are putting out jobs,如果大量的公司 提供工作,
172then it looks like companies are in growth mode看来公司在成长中
173and doing well.和做得不错。
174And that impacts the kind of measures that governments这会影响政府的措施
175create for job seekers to support them.创建求职者支持他们。
176So if it looks like there are more jobs out there所以,如果它看起来像有 更多的工作在那里
177than what there really are,而不是真正存在的东西
178there are many ramifications beyond just how it feels除了感觉 还有很多影响
179to that person applying in an already tricky job market.在已经很棘手的就业市场上申请的人。
180So it's actually distorting the data所以它实际上扭曲了数据
181and that is the data that governments use.这是政府使用的数据。
182In these scenarios, is there anything that can be done在这些假设中,有什么可以做的
183to stop companies from posting ghost jobs?阻止公司派鬼工?
184Are countries cracking down on it?各国是否正在对此进行打击?
185Not whole countries,不是整个国家
186but I've come across several parts of countries,但是,我遇到了多个国家,
187states that are doing it.正在这样做的国家。
188So in the US, New Jersey and California,所以在美国 新泽西州和加利福尼亚州
189they have policymakers there who are working他们有 决策者在那里 谁正在工作
190to make ghost jobs a thing of the past.让鬼工作成为过去的事
191They don't want them in their job market.他们不希望他们进入他们的就业市场。
192In Ontario, in Canada,在加拿大安大略省
193which is the province that's home to Toronto and Ottawa,是多伦多和渥太华的所在地
194as of January this year,从今年1月,
195there was new legislation put in place to say that有新的立法规定:
196companies had to be far more transparent with candidates公司必须对候选人更加透明
197and say, is this a job?说,这是工作吗?
198Is there going to be a job at the end到底有没有工作?
199of the recruitment process二. 征聘过程
200or is this a talent pool exercise?还是说这是人才库运动?
201They also are now legally required to tell people现在法律上要求他们告诉别人
202who have interviewed for a job.他们已经面试了工作。
203Within 45 days, whether or not they were successful or not.在45天内,无论是否成功。
204So just measures to increase transparency here.因此,只有增加透明度的措施。
205But I spoke to a lawyer in Canada at the start of this year但我今年初在加拿大跟律师谈过了
206and her concern was, who is going to vet this?她的担心是 谁去审查这个?
207You know, we know our politicians, our governments,你知道,我们认识我们的政治家, 我们的政府,
208our civil services are already really busy.我们的公务员已经很忙了
209This very much relies on those who have been这在很大程度上依赖于那些曾经
210through the job market reporting通过就业市场报告
211if they feel that they have applied for a ghost job.如果他们觉得他们申请了鬼工作
212Thanks so much for joining us.非常感谢你加入我们。
213It was great to be here, thank you.很高兴能来,谢谢
214And we also got this video note with some advice我们还得到了这个视频说明 有一些建议
215for job seekers out there寻找工作的人
216when it comes to avoiding ghost job ads.当它涉及避免鬼职广告。
217Hi, I'm Patricia Parnett.嗨,我是帕特里夏・帕内特。
218I'm from Germany.我来自德国。
219I've been researching the topic of ghost jobs我一直在研究鬼工作这个话题
220since around three years.大约三年了
221First of all, there's no magical sign that tells you首先,没有神奇的迹象告诉你
222this is a ghost job.这是鬼活
223And even some researchers are struggling to define甚至有些研究者也难以定义
224whether it's a real open position or not.是否是一个真正的开放位置。
225Please look out for these five warning signs.请注意这五个警示标志.
226The more you see, the more suspicious.越见越疑.
227The first one is time.第一种是时间。
228Please make sure to only apply to roles that are recent.请确保仅适用于最近的角色。
229If you see something like reposted, updated,如果你看到类似重播 更新
230or promoted a couple of hours ago,或者几个小时前升职
231this usually indicates that the job is older than it seems.这通常表明工作比看起来要老。
232Please go to the official company career website请上公司职业官方网站
233to check whether the position is still online检查该位置是否仍然在线
234or if you can find more information like the date或者如果您能找到更多类似日期的信息
235when it was first published.当它首次出版。
236The second sign is description, specifically requirements.第二个标志是描述,具体要求.
237Is it super vague, very generic, general,是超级模糊, 非常笼统,一般,
238a little bit of everything?一点点的一切?
239This is a red flag.这是一面红旗
240It can also be the exact opposite.这也可能是完全相反的。
241It can be too vague, but also way too detailed.它可能过于模糊,但也过于详细。
242If you can see an entire wish list如果你能看到一个完整的愿望列表
243that includes everything,包括一切,
244all the passwords that you can imagine,所有你能想象的密码,
245and it sounds like two or three roles combined into one,听起来像是两个或三个角色合并成一个
246think twice.仔细想想
247Many people skip this one, essential details.很多人跳过这个, 基本的细节。
248If a company is seriously hiring,如果公司真的要雇用我
249they will usually tell you things like name他们通常会告诉你名字之类的事
250of the department, team, the product you're working on.部门,团队,你的工作产品。
251If everything is missing, be careful.如果一切都不见了,小心点。
252Number four, please go to candidate review websites四号,请到候选人审查网站
253and read reviews from other fellow candidates.并阅读其他候选人的评论。
254If they are super negative,如果他们是超级负面的,
255you can decide if you would like to invest your time or not.你可以决定你是否愿意投入你的时间。
256And finally, recruiting process.最后,招聘过程。
257If you are already interviewing, you can ask questions.如果你已经面试了 你可以问问题
258Why is the job open?为什么工作是开放的?
259When are you planning to fill it?你打算什么时候填满它?
260And please tell me more about the hiring process,请告诉我更多关于雇用过程,
261especially the timeline,尤其是时间
262because it doesn't help因为这样没用
263if you go through 10 rounds of interviews.如果你经过10轮采访。
264In a nutshell, if it sounds too good to be true,简而言之,如果听起来太好 不是真的,
265it probably is.也许吧
266And if it sounds too shady, it probably is.如果它听起来太阴暗, 它可能是。
267Thanks so much for sending that in.谢谢你送来
268And I wanna hear from you.我想听到你的声音。
269Have you ever applied for a ghost job你申请过鬼工作吗?
270or been ghosted by a company?还是被公司盯上?
271It does happen to all of us.这确实发生在我们所有人身上。
272And also thanks for your comments on our episodes也谢谢你对我们的节目的评论
273on how airport security works机场安全如何运作
274and whether those full body scanners can see you naked.那些全身扫描仪能否看到你裸体
275We've got loads of comments on that.我们对此有很多评论。
276And one of them about whether these scanners其中一个关于这些扫描仪
277are soon gonna be run on AI.马上就要上AI了
278A couple of you also asked about你们几个还问了
279what else those body scanners can see这些扫描仪还能看到什么
280and whether they can actually pick up on body piercings.以及他们是否真的能接起身体穿孔。
281And I was really interested in that我很感兴趣
282because I've got my little nose ring here.因为我有我的小鼻子环在这里。
283So I did some digging and I found out所以我做了一些挖掘,我发现
284that yes, they can detect your piercings,是的,他们会发现你的穿孔,
285but body jewelry doesn't really set off these alarms但尸体首饰并没有真正触发这些警报
286and you're rarely gonna be asked to take it off而且你很少被要求脱下来
287to go through security.通过安全。
288So thank you so much for your comments on that.因此,非常感谢你对此的评论。
289Please keep your comments coming.请继续评论
290And if you haven't seen that episode,如果你没看过那集
291在BBC世界服务YouTube频道
292and you can listen wherever you get your BBC podcasts.你可以在BBC播客的任何地方听
293But for now, I'm Hannah.但目前我是汉娜
294This is What In The World from the BBC World Service这是英国广播公司世界服务社的《世界》
295and we'll see you next time.下次见
该视频共有字幕 295 条。解锁更多字幕为会员功能,请移动到 价格

P2 · 求职投了几百份简历,为何迟迟没回应?BBC What in the World播客 p02 纯英文字幕 (P2)

字幕摘录

时间英文中文
0:00I have an Excel sheet with hundreds of jobs that I applied to,我有一个Excel表 上百个工作,我申请,
0:03where I basically track whether or not I received a response,在那里我基本上跟踪我是否收到答复,
0:06and a lot of the times I did not.很多时候我没有
0:08There's no magical sign that tells you,没有神奇的迹象告诉你,
0:10this is a good job.这工作不错
0:12And even some researchers are struggling to define甚至有些研究者也难以定义
0:14whether it's a real open position or not.是否是一个真正的开放位置。
0:17Imagine spending three hours perfecting your CV,想象一下,花了三个小时 完善你的CV,
0:20writing your cover letter,写封面信,
0:21filling in a million questions about yourself.填上无数关于你自己的问题
展开字幕全文(295 条)
序号英文中文
1I have an Excel sheet with hundreds of jobs that I applied to,我有一个Excel表 上百个工作,我申请,
2where I basically track whether or not I received a response,在那里我基本上跟踪我是否收到答复,
3and a lot of the times I did not.很多时候我没有
4There's no magical sign that tells you,没有神奇的迹象告诉你,
5this is a good job.这工作不错
6And even some researchers are struggling to define甚至有些研究者也难以定义
7whether it's a real open position or not.是否是一个真正的开放位置。
8Imagine spending three hours perfecting your CV,想象一下,花了三个小时 完善你的CV,
9writing your cover letter,写封面信,
10filling in a million questions about yourself.填上无数关于你自己的问题
11You send off the application and you never hear back.你把申请发了,就再也没有回音了
12No rejection, no reply, nothing.没有拒绝,没有答复,什么都没有。
13Welcome to the world of ghost jobs.欢迎来到鬼工作的世界
14They're jobs that employers are posting这些是雇主发来的工作
15with no intention to fill,无意填充,
16which means that your application is sent into the void.这意味着你的申请被送入了虚空。
17So yeah, it's not just dating apps that are ghosting us,所以,它不只是约会的应用 幽灵我们,
18the job market is ghosting us too.工作市场也在困扰着我们
19So why are employers posting ads for jobs that don't exist?为何雇主会张贴不存在的工作广告?
20And what can you do to spot red flags你能做什么来发现红旗
21so you don't spend hours of your precious time这样你就不用花你宝贵的时间了
22on those applications?这些申请?
23I'm Hannah, this is What In The World我是汉娜,这就是世界
24from the BBC World Service,来自英国广播公司世界服务社
25and I'm speaking to Megan Lawson,我在跟梅根·劳森说话
26who's a BBC business supporter他是英国广播公司的生意支持者
27and has been looking into this.并且一直在调查这件事
28Hey, great to speak to you again.嘿,很高兴再次和你说话。
29Thank you for having me.谢谢你邀请我
30So first of all, break down just how big of a problem this is,所以首先 破解这个大问题
31how many ghost job listings there are.有多少鬼职名单。
32Yeah, we know it's a problem.是啊,我们知道这是一个问题。
33The difficulty sometimes with something like this有时候这样的困难
34is working out how widespread the problem is.正在研究这个问题的广泛性。
35Because of course, there's no system that logs and flags当然没有记录和旗帜的系统
36every time a ghost job is uploaded.每次上传一个鬼活
37But we do know through various surveys that it is widespread.但我们通过各种调查确实知道它很普遍。
38So one survey from 2024 suggested that between 22% to 40%因此,2024年的一项调查表明,22%至40%
39of online job postings were ghost jobs.网上的工作是鬼活
40A separate US survey suggested that between 40% to 50%美国的一项单独调查表明,在40%至50%之间
41of companies have admitted to posting roles公司已承认担任职务
42without any intention to hire.无意聘请
43And then from the perspective of the job seeker,然后从求职者的角度来说
44来自Resume Builder的另一项调查
45suggested that 86% of job seekers had encountered表明86%的求职者遇到过
46what they suspected was a fake listing.他们怀疑是假名单
47Now, with some of these, we have to realise that, you know,现在,用其中一些, 我们必须意识到,你知道,
48not every job that is listed that doesn't materialise in a hire并不是每个被列出的工作 都没有在雇佣
49is a ghost job.是个鬼活儿
50Budgets can change, teams can be cut,预算可以改变,团队可以削减,
51but regardless of that,但不管怎样
52we know that there is a significant problem.我们知道有一个重大问题。
53I guess the big question behind this is why?我想背后的大问题就是为什么?
54Why would a company post a job that they never intended to fill?为什么公司会张贴一份 他们从未想完成的工作?
55Yeah, I've come across multiple reasons for this.是的,我发现了很多原因
56One of them is that they will eventually hire其中之一就是他们最终会雇佣
57and they want to create more of a talent pool.他们想创造更多的人才库。
58So they're just putting out a job application,所以他们只是提出一个工作申请,
59seeing who might be interested in them,看看谁对他们感兴趣
60interested in applying and then know how to work有兴趣申请,然后知道如何工作
61with their applications, their adverts further down the line.和他们的应用,他们的广告 更下行。
62Another reason I've seen is a performative reason.我见到的另一个原因是表演性的原因.
63So say I own a business and I want to show to my competitors所以说,我有一个企业 我想展示给我的竞争者
64that, you know, I'm in growth mode,你知道,我在成长模式,
65we're doing well.我们做得很好。
66I might put out on LinkedIn that I'm hiring for three roles我可能会出演Linked 我雇的3个角色
67and the reality is I'm not,而现实是,我不是,
68but it looks outwardly as if the company is doing really well.但外表看起来公司表现很好
69The third reason I've come across,我遇到的第三个原因
70I've spoken to recruiters who have seen this我跟那些见过这个的招募者谈过了
71and to campaigners as well.还有竞选者
72They're worried that companies,他们担心公司,
73you know, when we do a job application你知道,当我们做一个工作申请
74and we enter sometimes our email address,我们有时输入我们的电子邮件地址,
75our phone numbers, home address, career history,我们的电话号码 家庭地址 职业生涯史
76really valuable information,真正有价值的信息,
77that those companies sometimes go on这些公司有时会继续
78and with this huge batch of data they've got有了这批大数据
79from all the various job candidates,从所有的工作候选人,
80that they go on and sell that.他们继续卖掉它。
81So another reason why ghost jobs are in existence.所以鬼职存在的另一个原因
82I mean, I've thought about it before我的意思是,我曾经想过它
83when I filled in those forms.当我填写这些表格。
84You give them so much personal information.你给他们这么多个人信息。
85Is there any protection in place有没有保护
86for candidates in those circumstances?在这种情况下,候选人?
87Do we know what happens to the personal information我们知不知道个人信息会怎样
88we give when we apply to jobs?我们申请工作的时候会给钱吗?
89Yes, the two people I mentioned there,是的,我提到的两个人,
90the recruiter and the campaigner招募者和竞选者
91who were both working in the States to change things,他们都在国家工作 改变事情,
92they didn't actually know where the data went,他们不知道数据流向哪里
93which was more worrying.这更令人担忧。
94But I was researching this this morning.但我今早在调查
95I thought, surely you can't just take people's data我想,你当然不能只拿别人的数据
96and do what you like with it.随你怎么说
97There are legal requirements in most countries大多数国家都有法律要求
98that companies are upfront about why they have your data,公司是领先 他们为什么拥有你的数据,
99that they are respectful in terms of他们尊重
100how long they have their data for他们有数据多久?
101and how necessary it is for them以及对他们多么必要
102to hold on to that data.以持有数据。
103I guess if we're thinking about the campaigners我想如果我们在考虑竞选者
104who want to change the system,谁想改变系统,
105they would probably question,他们可能会质疑,
106well, if companies are going to be putting out ghost jobs,如果公司要搞鬼工作的话
107which aren't the most ethical job postings,这不是最道德的工作职位,
108are they really going to be meeting these legal obligations?他们真的要履行这些法律义务吗?
109That's really worrying.真让人担心
110It's really worrying for applicants, isn't it?申请人很担心吧?
111And Megan, we've also been hearing from some people梅根,我们也听到有人说
112about their experiences of applying for jobs关于她们申请工作的经验
113and also ghost jobs.还有鬼活
114Hello, my name is Sundas.你好,我的名字是Sundas。
115I am from Seattle, Washington, and I am in tech.我来自西雅图,华盛顿,我是技术。
116And like many people in tech,和很多人的科技,
117I was laid off in the beginning of 2026,我在2026年初被解雇了,
118which basically kickstarted my very aggressive job hunt.这基本上启动了我非常有攻击性的工作狩猎。
119And during my job search, I employed two methods.在寻找工作期间,我采用了两种方法。
120The first method was basically applying第一个方法基本上是应用
121to a hundred jobs a day and basically seeing what sticks.每天有100个工作 基本上看到什么是粘着的
122And then on the other days,然后在其他的日子里,
123I would apply to 20 jobs a day我每天申请20个工作
124where I would tailor my resume specifically在那里,我会特别调整我的简历
125to that position.到那个位置。
126And I was still not receiving responses.我还没有收到答复。
127I was getting automatic rejections.我得到了自动拒绝。
128Sometimes recruiters would reach out有时招募者会伸出援手
129and they would tell me,他们会告诉我,
130oh, sorry, we are no longer filling these positions.哦,对不起,我们不再填补这些职位。
131I have an Excel sheet with hundreds of jobs我有一张有上百份工作的Excel床单
132{\fn黑体\fs20\shad2\2aH82\3aH20\4aH33\fscx95\3cH592001\be1}我申请进入我基本上追踪的地方
133whether or not I received a response.我是否收到回复?
134And a lot of the times I did not.很多时候我没有
135And to be completely honest, it's demoralizing.并且完全老实说,这令人士气低落.
136And it makes you wonder,这让你觉得奇怪
137are these jobs even actually hiring?这些工作甚至真的雇用?
138Are they ghost postings?他们是鬼的帖子吗?
139Are they only hiring internally?他们只是内部雇佣?
140I'm not sure.我不太确定 说不定
141Thank you so much for sending those in.谢谢你送来这些东西
142And you can hear how it makes你能听见它是如何
143an already really difficult process even tougher.一个已经非常困难的过程 更艰难。
144What are the impacts of these ghost jobs on job seekers?这些鬼工作对求职者有什么影响?
145I was really struck when I was speaking我说话的时候很惊讶
146to various job seekers who had applied申请的求职者
147for endless amounts of jobs,为了无尽的工作,
148sometimes had no rejection at all.有时完全没有拒绝。
149And they put to me the context that when you are job seeking他们给我的背景 当你在寻找工作
150and you are out of work,你已失业,
151often your confidence is already feeling pretty low.你的信心已经很低了
152Some people described it as demoralizing, soul crushing,有些人形容它 士气低落,灵魂压抑,
153and also giving them trust issues with the job market.也给他们与就业市场的信任问题。
154How do you know whether to bother spending a few hours你怎么知道要花几个小时
155putting together an application编组应用程序
156if there's a chance that that very job doesn't exist?如果那工作不存在的话?
157And these ghost jobs, they aren't new.这些鬼活儿不是新的
158It's something that has been happening for a few years now,这是已经发生 几年了,
159but we're seeing more of them.但我们看到更多的他们。
160And it comes at a time when the job market is just so tough.而它出现在一个 就业市场只是如此艰难。
161Yeah, we are constantly hearing just about是的,我们经常听到
162how many companies are making cuts,有多少公司在削减,
163how AI is reducing the head count at companies.AI如何减少公司头数.
164So for job seekers to know that in this already所以找工作的人应该知道这一点
165highly competitive market,竞争激烈的市场,
166that many of the jobs being listed列出的许多工作
167are fake jobs essentially is really demoralizing.假工作其实是士气低落
168And also from a policy perspective,并且从政策角度来说,
169so much government policy is made based upon如此多的政府政策是建立在
170how the job market is looking.就业市场的情况如何?
171If loads of companies are putting out jobs,如果大量的公司 提供工作,
172then it looks like companies are in growth mode看来公司在成长中
173and doing well.和做得不错。
174And that impacts the kind of measures that governments这会影响政府的措施
175create for job seekers to support them.创建求职者支持他们。
176So if it looks like there are more jobs out there所以,如果它看起来像有 更多的工作在那里
177than what there really are,而不是真正存在的东西
178there are many ramifications beyond just how it feels除了感觉 还有很多影响
179to that person applying in an already tricky job market.在已经很棘手的就业市场上申请的人。
180So it's actually distorting the data所以它实际上扭曲了数据
181and that is the data that governments use.这是政府使用的数据。
182In these scenarios, is there anything that can be done在这些假设中,有什么可以做的
183to stop companies from posting ghost jobs?阻止公司派鬼工?
184Are countries cracking down on it?各国是否正在对此进行打击?
185Not whole countries,不是整个国家
186but I've come across several parts of countries,但是,我遇到了多个国家,
187states that are doing it.正在这样做的国家。
188So in the US, New Jersey and California,所以在美国 新泽西州和加利福尼亚州
189they have policymakers there who are working他们有 决策者在那里 谁正在工作
190to make ghost jobs a thing of the past.让鬼工作成为过去的事
191They don't want them in their job market.他们不希望他们进入他们的就业市场。
192In Ontario, in Canada,在加拿大安大略省
193which is the province that's home to Toronto and Ottawa,是多伦多和渥太华的所在地
194as of January this year,从今年1月,
195there was new legislation put in place to say that有新的立法规定:
196companies had to be far more transparent with candidates公司必须对候选人更加透明
197and say, is this a job?说,这是工作吗?
198Is there going to be a job at the end到底有没有工作?
199of the recruitment process二. 征聘过程
200or is this a talent pool exercise?还是说这是人才库运动?
201They also are now legally required to tell people现在法律上要求他们告诉别人
202who have interviewed for a job.他们已经面试了工作。
203Within 45 days, whether or not they were successful or not.在45天内,无论是否成功。
204So just measures to increase transparency here.因此,只有增加透明度的措施。
205But I spoke to a lawyer in Canada at the start of this year但我今年初在加拿大跟律师谈过了
206and her concern was, who is going to vet this?她的担心是 谁去审查这个?
207You know, we know our politicians, our governments,你知道,我们认识我们的政治家, 我们的政府,
208our civil services are already really busy.我们的公务员已经很忙了
209This very much relies on those who have been这在很大程度上依赖于那些曾经
210through the job market reporting通过就业市场报告
211if they feel that they have applied for a ghost job.如果他们觉得他们申请了鬼工作
212Thanks so much for joining us.非常感谢你加入我们。
213It was great to be here, thank you.很高兴能来,谢谢
214And we also got this video note with some advice我们还得到了这个视频说明 有一些建议
215for job seekers out there寻找工作的人
216when it comes to avoiding ghost job ads.当它涉及避免鬼职广告。
217Hi, I'm Patricia Parnett.嗨,我是帕特里夏・帕内特。
218I'm from Germany.我来自德国。
219I've been researching the topic of ghost jobs我一直在研究鬼工作这个话题
220since around three years.大约三年了
221First of all, there's no magical sign that tells you首先,没有神奇的迹象告诉你
222this is a ghost job.这是鬼活
223And even some researchers are struggling to define甚至有些研究者也难以定义
224whether it's a real open position or not.是否是一个真正的开放位置。
225Please look out for these five warning signs.请注意这五个警示标志.
226The more you see, the more suspicious.越见越疑.
227The first one is time.第一种是时间。
228Please make sure to only apply to roles that are recent.请确保仅适用于最近的角色。
229If you see something like reposted, updated,如果你看到类似重播 更新
230or promoted a couple of hours ago,或者几个小时前升职
231this usually indicates that the job is older than it seems.这通常表明工作比看起来要老。
232Please go to the official company career website请上公司职业官方网站
233to check whether the position is still online检查该位置是否仍然在线
234or if you can find more information like the date或者如果您能找到更多类似日期的信息
235when it was first published.当它首次出版。
236The second sign is description, specifically requirements.第二个标志是描述,具体要求.
237Is it super vague, very generic, general,是超级模糊, 非常笼统,一般,
238a little bit of everything?一点点的一切?
239This is a red flag.这是一面红旗
240It can also be the exact opposite.这也可能是完全相反的。
241It can be too vague, but also way too detailed.它可能过于模糊,但也过于详细。
242If you can see an entire wish list如果你能看到一个完整的愿望列表
243that includes everything,包括一切,
244all the passwords that you can imagine,所有你能想象的密码,
245and it sounds like two or three roles combined into one,听起来像是两个或三个角色合并成一个
246think twice.仔细想想
247Many people skip this one, essential details.很多人跳过这个, 基本的细节。
248If a company is seriously hiring,如果公司真的要雇用我
249they will usually tell you things like name他们通常会告诉你名字之类的事
250of the department, team, the product you're working on.部门,团队,你的工作产品。
251If everything is missing, be careful.如果一切都不见了,小心点。
252Number four, please go to candidate review websites四号,请到候选人审查网站
253and read reviews from other fellow candidates.并阅读其他候选人的评论。
254If they are super negative,如果他们是超级负面的,
255you can decide if you would like to invest your time or not.你可以决定你是否愿意投入你的时间。
256And finally, recruiting process.最后,招聘过程。
257If you are already interviewing, you can ask questions.如果你已经面试了 你可以问问题
258Why is the job open?为什么工作是开放的?
259When are you planning to fill it?你打算什么时候填满它?
260And please tell me more about the hiring process,请告诉我更多关于雇用过程,
261especially the timeline,尤其是时间
262because it doesn't help因为这样没用
263if you go through 10 rounds of interviews.如果你经过10轮采访。
264In a nutshell, if it sounds too good to be true,简而言之,如果听起来太好 不是真的,
265it probably is.也许吧
266And if it sounds too shady, it probably is.如果它听起来太阴暗, 它可能是。
267Thanks so much for sending that in.谢谢你送来
268And I wanna hear from you.我想听到你的声音。
269Have you ever applied for a ghost job你申请过鬼工作吗?
270or been ghosted by a company?还是被公司盯上?
271It does happen to all of us.这确实发生在我们所有人身上。
272And also thanks for your comments on our episodes也谢谢你对我们的节目的评论
273on how airport security works机场安全如何运作
274and whether those full body scanners can see you naked.那些全身扫描仪能否看到你裸体
275We've got loads of comments on that.我们对此有很多评论。
276And one of them about whether these scanners其中一个关于这些扫描仪
277are soon gonna be run on AI.马上就要上AI了
278A couple of you also asked about你们几个还问了
279what else those body scanners can see这些扫描仪还能看到什么
280and whether they can actually pick up on body piercings.以及他们是否真的能接起身体穿孔。
281And I was really interested in that我很感兴趣
282because I've got my little nose ring here.因为我有我的小鼻子环在这里。
283So I did some digging and I found out所以我做了一些挖掘,我发现
284that yes, they can detect your piercings,是的,他们会发现你的穿孔,
285but body jewelry doesn't really set off these alarms但尸体首饰并没有真正触发这些警报
286and you're rarely gonna be asked to take it off而且你很少被要求脱下来
287to go through security.通过安全。
288So thank you so much for your comments on that.因此,非常感谢你对此的评论。
289Please keep your comments coming.请继续评论
290And if you haven't seen that episode,如果你没看过那集
291在BBC世界服务YouTube频道
292and you can listen wherever you get your BBC podcasts.你可以在BBC播客的任何地方听
293But for now, I'm Hannah.但目前我是汉娜
294This is What In The World from the BBC World Service这是英国广播公司世界服务社的《世界》
295and we'll see you next time.下次见
该视频共有字幕 295 条。解锁更多字幕为会员功能,请移动到 价格