第72篇TED:为何值得聆听那些与你意见不同的人?
字幕摘录
| 时间 | 英文 | 中文 |
|---|---|---|
| 0:14 | In 1994, Charles Murray and Richard Hernstein co-authored | 1994年,查尔斯·默里和理查德·埃尔斯坦共同撰写. |
| 0:18 | The Bell Curve, an extremely controversial book | 贝尔曲线,一本极具争议性的书 |
| 0:22 | which claims that on average, | 它声称,平均而言, |
| 0:24 | some races are smarter and more likely to succeed than others. | 有些种族比其他种族更聪明,更可能成功. |
| 0:28 | Murray and Hernstein also suggest | 默里和埃尔斯坦也建议 |
| 0:30 | that a lack of critical intelligence explains the prominence of violent crime | 缺乏关键情报是暴力犯罪突出的原因 |
| 0:35 | in poor African American communities. | 在贫穷的非裔美国人社区。 |
| 0:39 | But Charles Murray and Richard Hernstein | 但查尔斯·默里和理查德·埃尔斯坦 |
| 0:40 | and Hernstein are not the only people who think this. | 而Hernstein并不是唯一这样想的人. |
| 0:44 | In 2012, a writer, journalist and political commentator | 2012年,担任作家,记者和政治评论员. |
展开字幕全文(199 条)
| 序号 | 英文 | 中文 |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | In 1994, Charles Murray and Richard Hernstein co-authored | 1994年,查尔斯·默里和理查德·埃尔斯坦共同撰写. |
| 2 | The Bell Curve, an extremely controversial book | 贝尔曲线,一本极具争议性的书 |
| 3 | which claims that on average, | 它声称,平均而言, |
| 4 | some races are smarter and more likely to succeed than others. | 有些种族比其他种族更聪明,更可能成功. |
| 5 | Murray and Hernstein also suggest | 默里和埃尔斯坦也建议 |
| 6 | that a lack of critical intelligence explains the prominence of violent crime | 缺乏关键情报是暴力犯罪突出的原因 |
| 7 | in poor African American communities. | 在贫穷的非裔美国人社区。 |
| 8 | But Charles Murray and Richard Hernstein | 但查尔斯·默里和理查德·埃尔斯坦 |
| 9 | and Hernstein are not the only people who think this. | 而Hernstein并不是唯一这样想的人. |
| 10 | In 2012, a writer, journalist and political commentator | 2012年,担任作家,记者和政治评论员. |
| 11 | named John Derbyshire wrote an article | 约翰·德比郡写了一篇文章 |
| 12 | that was supposed to be a non-black version of the talk | 这本来是非黑版的谈话 |
| 13 | that many black parents feel they have to give their kids today, | 许多黑人父母认为 他们今天必须给孩子, |
| 14 | advice on how to stay safe. | 如何保持安全的建议。 |
| 15 | In it, he offers suggestions such as | 他在其中提出了如下建议: |
| 16 | do not attend events likely to draw a lot of blacks, | 不参加可能吸引很多黑人的事件, |
| 17 | stay out of heavily black neighborhoods | 远离黑人社区 |
| 18 | and do not act the Good Samaritan to blacks in distress. | 并且不要把好撒玛利亚人 变成处于困境的黑人。 |
| 19 | And yet, in 2016, I invited John Derbyshire, | 然而在2016年 我邀请了约翰·德比郡 |
| 20 | as well as Charles Murray, | 还有查尔斯·默里 |
| 21 | to speak at my school, | 在我的学校演讲, |
| 22 | knowing full well that I would be giving them a platform and attention | 完全知道 我会给他们一个平台和关注 |
| 23 | for ideas that I despised and rejected. | 我鄙视和拒绝的想法 |
| 24 | But this is just a further evolution | 但这只是一个进化 |
| 25 | of a journey of uncomfortable learning throughout my life. | 我一生中学习的不适之旅 |
| 26 | When I was 10 years old, | 我十岁时 |
| 27 | my mother was diagnosed with schizophrenia, | 我妈妈被诊断为精神分裂症 |
| 28 | a mental illness characterized by mood swings and paranoid delusions. | 一种精神疾病 以情绪波动和妄想为特征 |
| 29 | Throughout my life, my mother's rage would turn our small house | 在我一生中,我母亲的愤怒会把我们的小房子翻开 |
| 30 | into a minefield. | 进入雷场。 |
| 31 | Yet though I feared her rage on a daily basis, | 虽然我每天都担心她的愤怒 |
| 32 | I also learned so much from her. | 我也从她身上学到了很多 |
| 33 | Our relationship was complicated and challenging, | 我们的关系很复杂,很困难 |
| 34 | and at the age of 14, | 14岁时 |
| 35 | it was decided that I needed to live apart from her. | 决定我要和她分开生活 |
| 36 | But over the years, | 但多年来, |
| 37 | I've come to appreciate some of the important lessons | 我是来欣赏一些重要教训的 |
| 38 | my mother taught me about life. | 我妈妈教过我生活 |
| 39 | She was the first person who spoke to me about learning from the other side. | 她是第一个跟我谈论 从另一边学习的人。 |
| 40 | And she, like me, was born and raised | 和我一样 她出生长大了 |
| 41 | in a family of committed liberal Democrats. | 在一个坚定的自由民主党的家族里 |
| 42 | Yet she encouraged me to see the world and the issues our world faces | 她鼓励我看看世界和我们世界面临的问题 |
| 43 | as complex, controversial and ever-changing. | 复杂、有争议和变化 |
| 44 | One day, I came across the phrase affirmative action | 有一天,我发现了平权行动 |
| 45 | in a book I was reading. | 我在读一本书 |
| 46 | And when I asked her what the term meant, | 当我问她这个词是什么意思, |
| 47 | she spent what felt like an hour, | 她花了一个小时的感觉, |
| 48 | giving me a thorough and thoughtful explanation | 给我一个周密和深思熟虑的解释 |
| 49 | that would make sense to a small child. | 这对一个小孩来说是有意义的。 |
| 50 | She even made the topic sound at least as interesting | 她甚至让话题听起来至少有趣 |
| 51 | as any of my professors have. | 跟我的教授一样 |
| 52 | She explained the many reasons why people of various political views | 她解释了为什么人们有各种政治观点 |
| 53 | challenge and support affirmative action, | 挑战和支持扶持行动, |
| 54 | stressing that while she strongly supported it herself, | 她强调,虽然她本人坚决支持, |
| 55 | it was important for me to view the issue as a controversial one, | 重要的是,我认为这个问题是一个有争议的问题, |
| 56 | with a long history, a questionable future | 历史悠久,前途可疑 |
| 57 | and a host of complicating factors. | 和一系列复杂因素。 |
| 58 | While affirmative action can increase the presence of minorities | 虽然平权行动可以增加少数群体的存在 |
| 59 | at elite educational institutions, | 在精英教育机构, |
| 60 | she felt that it could also disadvantage hardworking people | 她觉得这样也不利于勤劳的人 |
| 61 | of different races from more affluent backgrounds. | 不同种族背景的人 |
| 62 | My mom wanted me to understand | 我妈妈想让我明白 |
| 63 | that I should never just write off opinions | 我不应该只是注销意见 |
| 64 | that I disagreed with or disliked, | 我不同意或不喜欢, |
| 65 | because there was always something to learn from the perspectives of others, | 因为总是有东西 从别人的角度学习, |
| 66 | even when doing so might be difficult. | 即使这样做也很难。 |
| 67 | But life at home with my mom | 但和我妈一起生活 |
| 68 | was not the only aspect of my journey that has been formative and uncomfortable. | 并不是我旅途中唯一一个 生动和不舒服的方面 |
| 69 | In fourth grade, she decided that I should attend a private school | 四年级的时候,她决定让我上私立学校 |
| 70 | in order to receive the best education possible. | 以获得尽可能好的教育。 |
| 71 | As a black student attending predominantly white private schools, | 作为一个黑人学生 在以白人为主的私立学校, |
| 72 | I've encountered attitudes and behaviors that reflected racial stereotypes. | 我遇到过反映种族成见的态度和行为. |
| 73 | Several of my friends' parents assumed within minutes of meeting me | 我朋友的几个父母在见我后几分钟内 |
| 74 | that my best skill was playing basketball. | 我最好的技巧是打篮球 |
| 75 | And it really upset me to think that my race made it harder for them to see me | 想到我的种族 让他们更难看到我 |
| 76 | as a student who loved reading, writing and speaking. | 作为一名热爱阅读,写作和演讲的学生. |
| 77 | Experiences like this | 这样的经验 |
| 78 | motivated me to work tirelessly, | 激励我不懈地工作, |
| 79 | to disprove what I knew people had assumed. | 来证明我所知道的假设 |
| 80 | My mother even said that in order to put my best foot forward, | 我的母亲甚至说 为了让我最好的脚向前 |
| 81 | I had to be patient, alert and excruciatingly well-mannered. | 我不得不耐心 警惕 并且非常谨慎 |
| 82 | To prove that I belonged, | 为了证明我的归属 |
| 83 | I had to show poise and confidence, | 我不得不展现出浮华和自信, |
| 84 | the ability to speak well and listen closely. | 说话好听 仔细听的能力 |
| 85 | Only then would my peers see that I deserved to be there as much as they did. | 只有那时,我的同伴才知道我应该像他们一样在那里。 |
| 86 | Despite this racial stereotyping and the discomfort I often felt, | 尽管有这种种族成见 以及我经常感到的不适, |
| 87 | the learning I gained from other aspects of being at an elite private school | 我从上精英私立学校的其他方面学到的教训 |
| 88 | were incredibly valuable. | 非常珍贵 |
| 89 | I was encouraged by my teachers to explore my curiosity, | 老师鼓励我探索我的好奇心 |
| 90 | to challenge myself in new ways | 以新的方式挑战自己 |
| 91 | and to deepen my understanding of subjects that fascinated me the most. | 加深我对最让我着迷的主题的理解 |
| 92 | And going to college was the next step. | 接下来是上大学 |
| 93 | I was excited to take my intellectual drive | 我兴奋地走我的智力驱动器 |
| 94 | and interest in the world of ideas to the next level. | 和对思想世界的兴趣 到下一个层次。 |
| 95 | I was eager to engage in lively debate | 我很想参加热烈的辩论 |
| 96 | with peers and professors | 同行和教授 |
| 97 | and with outside speakers, | 和与外面的发言者, |
| 98 | to listen, to learn | 听,学习 |
| 99 | and gain a deeper understanding of myself and of others. | 更深入地了解我和其他人 |
| 100 | While I was fortunate to meet peers and professors | 我有幸见到同行和教授 |
| 101 | who were interested in doing the same thing, | 他们有兴趣做同样的事情, |
| 102 | my desire to engage with difficult ideas was also met with resistance. | 我提出困难想法的愿望也遭到了抵制。 |
| 103 | To prepare myself to engage with controversy in the real world, | 为了准备面对现实世界的争议 |
| 104 | I joined a group that brought controversial speakers to campus. | 我加入了一个团体 将有争议的演讲者带到校园。 |
| 105 | But many people fiercely opposed this group, | 但许多人强烈反对这个团体, |
| 106 | and I received significant pushback from students, faculty | 我得到了学生、教职员工的重大回击 |
| 107 | and my administration. | 和我的行政部门。 |
| 108 | For many, it was difficult to see how bringing controversial speakers to campus | 对许多人来说,很难理解 如何将有争议的演讲者带到校园 |
| 109 | could be valuable when they caused harm. | 当它们造成伤害时,可能是有价值的。 |
| 110 | And it was disappointing to me, facing personal attacks, | 面对个人攻击,我感到很失望 |
| 111 | having my administration cancel speakers | 要求我的行政部门取消发言 |
| 112 | and hearing my intentions distorted by those around me. | 并听到我的意图被周围的人扭曲。 |
| 113 | My work also hurt the feelings of many, | 我的工作也伤害了很多人的感情 |
| 114 | and I understood that. | 我理解这一点。 |
| 115 | Of course, no one likes being offended, | 当然,没有人喜欢被冒犯, |
| 116 | and I certainly don't like hearing controversial speakers | 我当然不喜欢听到有争议的演讲 |
| 117 | argue that feminism has become a war against men | 认为女性主义已经变成了对男人的战争 |
| 118 | or that blacks have lower IQs than whites. | 或者说黑人的智商比白人低 |
| 119 | I also understand that some people have experienced | 我也明白有些人经历过 |
| 120 | traumatic experiences in their lives. | 他们生活中的创伤经历 |
| 121 | And for some, listening to offensive views | 对有些人来说,听攻击性的观点 |
| 122 | can be like reliving the very traumas that they've worked so hard to overcome. | 就像重温他们努力克服的创伤 |
| 123 | Many argue that by giving these people a platform, | 许多人认为,通过给这些人一个平台, |
| 124 | you're doing more harm than good, | 你伤害比伤害更多, |
| 125 | and I am reminded of this. | 并提醒我这一点。 |
| 126 | Every time, I listen to these points of view | 每次我都听这些观点 |
| 127 | and feel my stomach turn. | 并感觉我的胃转向。 |
| 128 | Yet tuning out opposing viewpoints doesn't make them go away, | 但是调和对立的观点 并不会让他们消失, |
| 129 | because millions of people agree with them. | 因为数百万人同意他们的观点。 |
| 130 | In order to understand the potential of society to progress forward, | 为了了解社会前进的潜力, |
| 131 | we need to understand the counter-forces. | 我们需要了解反部队。 |
| 132 | By engaging with controversial and defensive ideas, | 通过参与有争议的和防御性的想法, |
| 133 | I believe that we can find common ground, | 我相信我们可以找到共同点, |
| 134 | if not with the speakers themselves, | 如果不是讲者自己, |
| 135 | then with the audiences they may attract or indoctrinate. | 然后与观众 他们可能吸引或灌输。 |
| 136 | Through engaging, I believe that we may reach a better understanding, | 我相信,通过接触,我们可以达成更好的理解, |
| 137 | a deeper understanding of our own beliefs, | 更深入地理解我们自己的信仰, |
| 138 | and preserve the ability to solve problems, | 并保持解决问题的能力, |
| 139 | which we can't do if we don't talk to each other | 如果我们不和对方说话,那就不行了 |
| 140 | and make an effort to be good listeners. | 并努力做一个好的听众。 |
| 141 | But soon after I announced that John Derbyshire would be speaking on campus, | 但不久我宣布约翰·德比希尔将在校园演讲 |
| 142 | student backlash erupted on social media. | 学生的反弹在社交媒体上爆发。 |
| 143 | The tide of resistance, in fact, was so intense | 抵抗的潮流,事实上,是如此的激烈 |
| 144 | that my college president rescinded the invitation. | 我的大学校长撤销了邀请 |
| 145 | I was deeply disappointed by this, because as I saw it, | 我对此深感失望,因为我看到, |
| 146 | there would be nothing that any of my peers or I could do | 我和我的同伴都无能为力 |
| 147 | to silence someone who agreed with him | 让同意他的人沉默 |
| 148 | in the office environment of our future employers. | 我们未来雇主的办公环境 |
| 149 | I look out at what's happening on college campuses, | 我看着大学校园里发生的事 |
| 150 | and I see the anger, | 我看见愤怒, |
| 151 | and I get it. | 我知道这一点。 |
| 152 | But what I wish I could tell people is that | 但我希望我能告诉大家 |
| 153 | it's worth the discomfort, it's worth listening, | 它值得不适, 它值得倾听, |
| 154 | and that we're stronger, not weaker, because of it. | 而我们更强大,而不是更弱, 因为它。 |
| 155 | When I think about my experiences with uncomfortable learning | 当我想起我的经历 不舒服的学习 |
| 156 | and I reflect upon them, | 我回顾他们, |
| 157 | I've found that it's been very difficult to change the values | 我发现很难改变价值 |
| 158 | of the intellectual community that I've been a part of. | 我曾经是知识界的一员 |
| 159 | But I do feel a sense of hope | 但我确实有希望感 |
| 160 | when I think about the individual interactions | 当我想到个人互动时 |
| 161 | that I've been able to have with students who both support the work that I'm doing | 我和两个支持我工作的学生在一起 |
| 162 | and who feel challenged by it | 他们觉得自己是受刑罚的, |
| 163 | and who do not support it. | 谁不支持它。 |
| 164 | What I've found is that while it can be difficult | 我发现的是 虽然这很困难 |
| 165 | to change the values of a community, | 改变一个社区的价值观, |
| 166 | we can gain a lot from individual interactions. | 我们可以从个人互动中获得很多好处。 |
| 167 | While I didn't get to engage with John Derbyshire | 虽然我没有和约翰·德比希尔接触 |
| 168 | due to my president's disinvitation, | 因为我的总统不请自来 |
| 169 | I was able to have dinner with Charles Murray before his talk. | 在查尔斯·默里说话之前 我和他共进晚餐 |
| 170 | I knew the conversation would be difficult, | 我知道谈话会很困难 |
| 171 | and I didn't expect it to be pleasant. | 我没想到会很愉快 |
| 172 | But it was cordial, | 但它是真诚的, |
| 173 | and I did gain a deeper understanding of his arguments. | 我对他的论点有更深的理解 |
| 174 | I found that he, like me, believed in creating a more just society. | 我发现他和我一样 相信建立一个更公正的社会 |
| 175 | The thing is, | 事实是, |
| 176 | his understanding of what justice entailed was very different from my own. | 他对正义的理解与我的理解大不相同。 |
| 177 | The way in which he wanted to understand the issue, | 他想了解这个问题的方式 |
| 178 | the way in which he wanted to approach the issue of inequality, | 他想要处理不平等问题的方式, |
| 179 | also different from my own. | 也跟我的不一样 |
| 180 | And I found that his understanding of issues like welfare and affirmative action | 我发现他对福利和平权行动等问题的理解 |
| 181 | was tied and deeply rooted | 被捆绑和深深扎根 |
| 182 | in his understanding of various libertarian and conservative beliefs, | 他对各种自由主义和保守主义信仰的理解 |
| 183 | what diminishes and increases their presence in our society. | 减少和增加她们在我们社会中的存在。 |
| 184 | While he expressed his viewpoints eloquently, | 虽然他雄辩地表达了自己的观点, |
| 185 | I remained thoroughly unconvinced. | 我完全没有说服力 |
| 186 | But I did walk away with a deeper understanding. | 但我确实带着更深刻的理解离开了 |
| 187 | It's my belief | 这是我的信念 |
| 188 | that to achieve progress in the face of adversity, | 为了在逆境中取得进展, |
| 189 | we need a genuine commitment | 我们需要一个真正的承诺 |
| 190 | to gaining a deeper understanding of humanity. | 以加深对人类的理解。 |
| 191 | I'd like to see a world with more leaders | 我希望看到一个有更多领袖的世界 |
| 192 | who are familiar with the depths of the views of those | 他们熟悉这些观点的深度 |
| 193 | they deeply disagree with, | 他们确是不信道的, |
| 194 | so that they can understand the nuances of everyone they're representing. | 这样他们才能理解自己所代表的每个人的细微差别. |
| 195 | I see this as an ongoing process involving constant learning, | 我认为这是一个不断学习的过程, |
| 196 | and I'm confident that I'll be able to add value down the line | 我有信心,我可以增加价值 下线 |
| 197 | if I continue building empathy and understanding | 如果我继续建立同情和理解 |
| 198 | through engaging with unfamiliar perspectives. | 透过不熟悉的视角 |
| 199 | Thank you. | 谢谢 |
该视频共有字幕 199 条。解锁更多字幕为会员功能,请移动到 价格
