TED第13篇:和给我负面评论的人对话
字幕摘录
| 时间 | 英文 | 中文 |
|---|---|---|
| 0:15 | I've received hate online, a lot of it, | 我在网上收到很多仇恨 |
| 0:19 | and it comes with the territory of my work. | 它与我的工作范围。 |
| 0:22 | I'm a digital creator. | 我是个数字创作者 |
| 0:23 | I make things specifically for the internet. | 我特意为互联网做东西 |
| 0:27 | Like, a few years ago, | 比如,几年前, |
| 0:28 | I made a video series called Every Single Word, | 我做了一个视频系列 叫做"每个单词" |
| 0:31 | where I edited down popular films | 在那里我编辑了流行电影 |
| 0:33 | to only the words spoken by people of color | 只能说有色人种的话 |
| 0:36 | as a way to make a video series | 作为制作视频系列的一种方式 |
| 0:36 | as a way to empirically and accessibly talk | 以实证和易懂的方式 |
展开字幕全文(223 条)
| 序号 | 英文 | 中文 |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | I've received hate online, a lot of it, | 我在网上收到很多仇恨 |
| 2 | and it comes with the territory of my work. | 它与我的工作范围。 |
| 3 | I'm a digital creator. | 我是个数字创作者 |
| 4 | I make things specifically for the internet. | 我特意为互联网做东西 |
| 5 | Like, a few years ago, | 比如,几年前, |
| 6 | I made a video series called Every Single Word, | 我做了一个视频系列 叫做"每个单词" |
| 7 | where I edited down popular films | 在那里我编辑了流行电影 |
| 8 | to only the words spoken by people of color | 只能说有色人种的话 |
| 9 | as a way to make a video series | 作为制作视频系列的一种方式 |
| 10 | as a way to empirically and accessibly talk | 以实证和易懂的方式 |
| 11 | about the issue of representation in Hollywood. | 关于好莱坞的代表问题。 |
| 12 | Then, later, as transphobic bathroom bills | 然后,后来,作为变性人的浴室账单 |
| 13 | started gaining media attention around the United States, | 美国各地的媒体开始关注 |
| 14 | I hosted and produced an interview series | 我主持和制作了访谈系列 |
| 15 | called Sitting in Bathrooms with Trans People, | 被称为与跨人坐在浴室, |
| 16 | where I did exactly that. | 在那里,我确实这样做了。 |
| 17 | And then ... | 接着... |
| 18 | Sure, I'll take applause. | 当然,我会掌声。 |
| 19 | Thank you. | 谢谢 |
| 20 | And then, are you familiar with those unboxing videos on YouTube | 你熟悉YouTube上的解拳视频吗? |
| 21 | where YouTubers open up the latest electronic gadgets? | 在那里YouTubes打开最新的电子设备? |
| 22 | Great, so I satirized those in a weekly series | 好极了,所以我把周刊的这些都拍下来了 |
| 23 | where instead I unboxed intangible ideologies | 在那里我解开无形的意识形态 |
| 24 | like police brutality, masculinity | 就像警察的残暴 男性气概 |
| 25 | and the mistreatment of Native Americans. | 和虐待美国原住民。 |
| 26 | и... | |
| 27 | Thanks. | 谢谢 |
| 28 | One person applauding, God bless. | 一个人鼓掌,上帝保佑。 |
| 29 | (*Laughter*) | (* 笑声*) |
| 30 | Mom, hi. | 妈妈,嗨。 |
| 31 | (*Laughter*) | (* 笑声*) |
| 32 | So my work became popular. | 所以我的作品变得很受欢迎. |
| 33 | Very popular. | 非常受欢迎。 |
| 34 | I got millions of views, a ton of great press | 我得到了数百万个观点, 一吨伟大的媒体 |
| 35 | and a slew of new followers. | 和一群新教徒, |
| 36 | But the flip side of success on the internet is internet hate. | 但是互联网上成功的反面是互联网仇恨. |
| 37 | I was called everything, | 我被称为一切, |
| 38 | from beta to snowflake | 从β到雪花 |
| 39 | and, of course, the ever-popular cuck. | 当然了, 永远流行的cuck。 |
| 40 | Don't worry, I will break these terms down for you. | 别担心,我会帮你破解这些条件的 |
| 41 | So beta, for those of you unfamiliar, | 所以 对于你们这些不熟悉的人来说 |
| 42 | is shorthand online lingo for beta male. | 是Beta男性的短手在线语言。 |
| 43 | But let's be real, I wear pearl earrings | 但说实话,我戴珍珠耳环 |
| 44 | and my fashion aesthetic is rich white woman running errands, | 我的时尚美学是有钱的白人女人跑腿 |
| 45 | so I'm not angling to be an alpha. | 所以我不想当个阿尔法 |
| 46 | Doesn't totally work. | 没有完全工作。 |
| 47 | Um ... | 那个... |
| 48 | Now, snowflake is a put-down for people who are sensitive | 现在,雪花是给那些敏感的人的 |
| 49 | and believe themselves to be unique. | 并相信自己是独一无二的。 |
| 50 | And I'm a millennial and an only child, so duh. | 我是一个千年和独生子,所以。 |
| 51 | But my favorite, favorite, favorite is cuck. | 但我最喜欢的,最爱的,最爱的是Cuck. |
| 52 | It's a slur, short for cuckold. | 其脉沉涩,短为厥阴. |
| 53 | For men who have been cheated on by their wives. | 对于被妻子欺骗的人来说 |
| 54 | But friends, I am so gay that if I had a wife, | 但是朋友,我太同性恋了 如果我有一个妻子, |
| 55 | I would encourage her to cheat on me. | 我会鼓励她欺骗我。 |
| 56 | Thank you. | 谢谢 |
| 57 | Let's take a look at some of this negativity in action. | 让我们看看这种消极的动作 |
| 58 | Sometimes it's direct, | 有时候是直接的 |
| 59 | like Marcos, who wrote, | 像马科斯,谁写, |
| 60 | You're everything I hate in a human being. | 你是我最讨厌的人 |
| 61 | Thank you, Marcos. | 谢谢你 马科斯 |
| 62 | Others are more concise, | 其他的更简洁, |
| 63 | like Donovan, who wrote, | 就像多诺万写道: |
| 64 | Gay wad fag. | 同性恋同性恋 |
| 65 | Now, I do need to point out, | 现在,我确实需要指出, |
| 66 | Donovan is not wrong, OK? | 多诺万没有错,好吗? |
| 67 | In fact, he's right on both counts, | 事实上,他在这两个方面都是正确的, |
| 68 | so credit where credit is due. | 所以,信用是应该的。 |
| 69 | Thank you, Donovan. | 谢谢 多诺万 |
| 70 | Others write to me with questions, | 其他人给我写了问题 |
| 71 | like Brian, who asked, | 像布莱恩,谁问, |
| 72 | Were you born a bitch, | 如果你生下来就是个婊子 |
| 73 | or did you just learn to be one over time? | 还是你刚学会了做一个? |
| 74 | But my favorite thing about this | 但我最喜欢的一件事 |
| 75 | is that once Brian was done typing, | 布莱恩打完字后 |
| 76 | his finger must have slipped, | 他的手指一定滑了下来 |
| 77 | because then he sent me the thumbs-up emoji. | 因为他把大拇指给我发了 |
| 78 | So, babe, thumbs-up to you, too. | 所以,宝贝,拇指上,太。 |
| 79 | It's fun to talk about these messages now, right? | 现在谈这些消息很有趣吧? |
| 80 | And it's cathartic to laugh at them. | 笑他们也太夸张了 |
| 81 | But I can tell you that it really does not feel good to receive them. | 但我可以告诉你,它真的 感觉不好接受他们。 |
| 82 | At first, I would screenshot their comments | 一开始我会截取他们的评论 |
| 83 | and make fun of their typos, | 并嘲笑他们的恶行, |
| 84 | but this soon felt elitist and ultimately unhelpful. | 但是,这很快感到 精英和最终无益。 |
| 85 | So over time, I developed an unexpected coping mechanism. | 随着时间的推移,我开发了一个出乎意料的应对机制。 |
| 86 | Because most of these messages I received were through social media, | 因为我收到的大多数信息都是通过社交媒体 |
| 87 | I could often click on the profile picture of the person who sent them | 我经常点击寄信人的照片 |
| 88 | and learn everything about them. | 并了解他们的一切。 |
| 89 | I could see pictures they were tagged in, | 我可以看到他们被标记的照片, |
| 90 | posts they'd written, memes they'd shared, | 他们写的帖子,他们分享的纪念品, |
| 91 | and somehow seeing that it was a human on the other side of the screen | 不知何故在屏幕的另一边看到它是人类 |
| 92 | made me feel a little better. | 让我感觉好一点。 |
| 93 | Not to justify what they wrote, right? | 不是为了证明他们所写的,对吧? |
| 94 | But just to provide context. | 但只是为了提供背景。 |
| 95 | Still, that didn't feel like enough. | 不过 感觉还不够 |
| 96 | So I called some of them, | 所以我打电话给他们中的一些人, |
| 97 | only the ones I felt safe talking to, | 只有那些我感到安全说话, |
| 98 | with a simple opening question. | 有个简单的开场白 |
| 99 | Why did you write that? | 你为什么要写? |
| 100 | The first person I spoke to was Josh. | 我和乔希谈的第一个人 |
| 101 | He had written to tell me that I was a moron, | 他写信告诉我 我是个白痴 |
| 102 | I was a reason this country was dividing itself, | 我是这个国家分裂的原因 |
| 103 | and he added at the end that being gay was a sin. | 他最后补充说,同性恋是一种罪过。 |
| 104 | I was so nervous for our first conversation. | 第一次谈话我太紧张了 |
| 105 | This wasn't a comment section, | 这不是评论部分, |
| 106 | so I couldn't use tools like muting or blocking. | 所以我不能使用工具 像变形或屏蔽。 |
| 107 | Of course, I guess. | 当然,我猜。 |
| 108 | I could have hung up on him. | 我可以挂断他的电话 |
| 109 | But I didn't want to, | 但我不想这样 |
| 110 | because I liked talking to him, | 因为我喜欢跟他说话, |
| 111 | because I liked him. | 因为我喜欢他 |
| 112 | Here's a clip of one of our conversations. | 这是一段我们的对话 |
| 113 | Josh, you said that you're about to graduate high school, right? | 乔希,你说你即将毕业 高中,对不对? |
| 114 | Josh's voice on phone, Josh's voice on phone. | 乔什在电话中的声音,乔什在电话中的声音. |
| 115 | Am I allowed to use the H-E double hockey stick word? | 我可以用H -E双曲棍球词吗? |
| 116 | Oh, yeah, you're allowed to. | 哦,是的,你允许。 |
| 117 | It was hell. | 这是地狱。 |
| 118 | Really? | 真的吗? |
| 119 | And it's still hell right now, even though it's only two weeks left. | 虽然只剩两周了,但现在还是很糟 |
| 120 | I'm a little bit bigger. | 我有点大。 |
| 121 | I don't like to use the word fat, | 我不喜欢用脂肪这个词 |
| 122 | but I am a little bit bigger than a lot of my classmates, | 但我比我很多同学都大一点 |
| 123 | and they seem to judge me before they even got to know me. | 他们似乎在认识我之前就对我作出判断 |
| 124 | That's awful. | 这太可怕了。 |
| 125 | I mean, I also just want to let you know, Josh, | 我的意思是,我只是想告诉你,乔什, |
| 126 | I was bullied in high school, too. | 高中时我也被欺负了 |
| 127 | So did our common ground of being bullied in high school | 我们高中时被欺负的共同点也是 |
| 128 | erase what he wrote me? | 抹掉他给我写的东西? |
| 129 | No. | 没有 |
| 130 | And did our single-phone conversation | 我们的单人通话 |
| 131 | radically heal a politically divided country | 彻底治愈政治分裂的国家 |
| 132 | and cure systemic injustice? | 并纠正系统性不公正? |
| 133 | No, absolutely not. | 不,绝对没有。 |
| 134 | Right? | 对吧? |
| 135 | But did our conversation humanize us to each other | 但是我们的对话是否把我们的人性化了 |
| 136 | more than profile pictures and posts ever could? | 照片和文章都比不上? |
| 137 | Absolutely. | 当然 |
| 138 | I didn't stop there, | 我没有停下来, |
| 139 | because some of the hate I received was from my side. | 因为我收到的一些仇恨 是从我身边。 |
| 140 | So when Matthew, a queer liberal artist like me, | 所以当马修,一个同性恋的自由主义艺术家 像我一样, |
| 141 | publicly wrote that I represented some of the worst aspects of liberalism, | 公开写道,我代表了自由主义的一些最坏的方面, |
| 142 | I wanted to ask him this. | 我想问他这个 |
| 143 | You tagged me in this post. | 你把我贴在这帖子上 |
| 144 | Did you want me to see it? | 你想让我看吗? |
| 145 | I honestly didn't think that you would. | 我真的没想到你会这样 |
| 146 | Have you ever been publicly dragged? | 你有没有被公开拖过? |
| 147 | I have been, and I just said, no, I don't care. | 我去过,我只是说,不, 我不在乎。 |
| 148 | And did you not care? | 你不在乎吗? |
| 149 | Did you not care? | 你不在乎吗? |
| 150 | Oh, well, I cared, yes. | 哦,好吧,我关心,是的。 |
| 151 | At the end of these conversations, | 在这些谈话结束时, |
| 152 | there's often a moment of reflection, | 经常有一刻的反省, |
| 153 | a reconsideration, | 复议, |
| 154 | and that's exactly what happened at the end of my call | 而这正是发生 在我电话的结尾 |
| 155 | with a guy named Doug, | 和一个叫道格的人 |
| 156 | who had written that I was a talentless propaganda hack. | 谁写我是一个无能的宣传黑客。 |
| 157 | Did the conversation we just had, | 我们刚才的谈话 |
| 158 | does it make you feel differently about how you write online? | 你对网上的写作有不同的感觉吗? |
| 159 | Yeah, when I said this to you, | 是啊,当我告诉你, |
| 160 | when I said you were a talentless hack, | 当我说你是个无能的黑客时 |
| 161 | I had never conversed with you in my life, really. | 我这辈子从没跟你谈过 |
| 162 | I didn't really know anything really about you, | 我对你一无所知 |
| 163 | and I think that a lot of times that's what the comment sections really are. | 我认为,很多时候, 评论部分才是真正的。 |
| 164 | It's really a way to get your anger at the world out | 这真的是让你愤怒世界的方法 |
| 165 | on random profiles of strangers, pretty much. | 在随机的陌生人简介, 几乎。 |
| 166 | Yeah, right. | 没错 |
| 167 | But it definitely has made me rethink the way that I interact with people online. | 但它确实让我重新思考我和网上人互动的方式。 |
| 168 | So I've collected these conversations and many others for my podcast, | 所以我为播客收集了这些谈话和许多其他 |
| 169 | Conversations with People Who Hate Me. | 跟恨我的人交谈 |
| 170 | Before I started this project, | 在我开始这个项目之前 |
| 171 | I thought that the real way to bring about change | 我认为这是真正实现变革的方法 |
| 172 | was to shut down opposing viewpoints | 是关闭对立的观点 |
| 173 | through epically-worded video essays and comments and posts, | 透过文字化的视频散文和评论及文章, |
| 174 | but I soon learned those were only cheered on | 但我很快得知这些只是欢呼 |
| 175 | by the people who already agreed with me. | 由已经同意我的人。 |
| 176 | Sometimes, bless you, | 有时候,祝福你, |
| 177 | sometimes the most subversive thing you could do ... | 有时候,最颠覆的事情 你可以做... |
| 178 | Yeah, clap for him. | 是啊,为他鼓掌。 |
| 179 | Sometimes, the most subversive thing you could do | 有时候,你所能做的最颠覆的事情 |
| 180 | was to actually speak with the people you disagreed with, | 和那些你不同意的人说话 |
| 181 | and not simply at them. | 不只是在他们身上。 |
| 182 | Now, in every one of my calls, | 现在,在我的每一个电话, |
| 183 | I always ask my guests to tell me about themselves, | 我总是让我的客人告诉我自己的事 |
| 184 | and it's their answer to this question that allows me to empathize with them. | 他们回答这个问题 让我同情他们 |
| 185 | And empathy, it turns out, | 还有同情心 结果发现 |
| 186 | is a key ingredient in getting these conversations off the ground, | 是让这些对话消失的关键要素 |
| 187 | but it can feel very vulnerable to be empathizing | 但它会感到非常脆弱 同情 |
| 188 | with someone you profoundly disagree with. | 和一个你强烈不同意的人 |
| 189 | So I established a helpful mantra for myself. | 于是我为自己树立了助人的口碑. |
| 190 | Empathy is not endorsement. | 同情不是认可。 |
| 191 | Empathizing with someone you profoundly disagree with | 同情你所不同意的人 |
| 192 | does not suddenly compromise your own deeply-held beliefs | 不会突然损害你深厚的信念 |
| 193 | and endorse theirs. | 并认可他们。 |
| 194 | Empathizing with someone who, for example, | 同情某人,例如, |
| 195 | believes that being gay is a sin | 相信同性恋是罪 |
| 196 | doesn't mean that I'm suddenly going to drop everything, | 不代表我突然放弃一切 |
| 197 | pack my bags and grab my one-way ticket to hell, right? | 收拾我的行李 拿我的单程票去地狱,对不对? |
| 198 | It just means that I'm acknowledging the humanity of someone | 意思是我承认某人的人性 |
| 199 | who was raised to think very differently from me. | 他长大后对我的看法非常不同 |
| 200 | I also want to be super clear about something. | 我也想说清楚 |
| 201 | This is not a prescription for activism, right? | 这不是一个行动处方,对不对? |
| 202 | I understand that some people don't feel safe talking to their detractors, | 我知道有些人和他们的诽谤者谈话 并不安全 |
| 203 | and others feel so marginalized | 其他人感到如此边缘化 |
| 204 | that they justifiably don't feel that they have any empathy to give. | 他们有理由不觉得 他们有任何同情心给予。 |
| 205 | I totally get that. | 我完全明白这一点。 |
| 206 | This is just what I feel well-suited to do. | 这就是我觉得适合做的 |
| 207 | You know, I've reached out to a lot of people for this podcast, | 你知道,我联系了很多人 为这个播客, |
| 208 | and some have politely declined, | 有些人是恭敬地拒绝的, |
| 209 | others have read my message and ignored it, | 其他人读了我的讯息却置之不理, |
| 210 | some have blocked me automatically when I sent the invitation, | 有人自动封锁了我 当我发出邀请, |
| 211 | and one guy actually agreed to do it, | 和一个男人说好的 |
| 212 | and then five minutes into the call, hung up on me. | 5分钟后接到电话 挂断了我的电话 |
| 213 | I'm also aware that this talk will appear on the internet, | 我也知道这段话会在互联网上出现 |
| 214 | and with the internet comes comment sections, | 并随着互联网的出现, |
| 215 | and with comment sections inevitably comes hate. | 与评论部分 不可避免地出现仇恨。 |
| 216 | So as you are watching this talk, | 所以当你在看这个演讲时 |
| 217 | you can feel free to call me whatever you'd like. | 随便你怎么叫我都可以 |
| 218 | You can call me a gaywad, a snowflake, a cuck, a beta | 你可以叫我一个同性恋,一个雪花,一个小丑,一个β |
| 219 | or everything wrong with liberalism. | 或者自由主义有什么问题 |
| 220 | But just know that if you do, I may ask you to talk. | 但你要知道 如果你愿意的话 我可能会请你谈谈 |
| 221 | And if you refuse or block me automatically or agree and hang up on me, | 如果你拒绝或自动封锁我 或者同意挂断我 |
| 222 | then maybe, babe, the snowflake is you. | 也许,宝贝,雪花就是你。 |
| 223 | Thank you so much. | 非常感谢 |
该视频共有字幕 223 条。解锁更多字幕为会员功能,请移动到 价格
