推荐微信扫码登录以获得更好的体验!另:🎉建议更新到最新版,以体验新功能!🎉 版本更新记录→

21分钟看懂金钱全图

21分钟看懂金钱全图

21分钟看懂金钱全图

发布于 2026-05-17 · 时长 21:12

字幕摘录

时间英文中文
0:00Nobody teaches you the truth about money.没人教你钱的真相
0:02I studied at an economics faculty for six years我在经济学系学习了六年
0:06and still didn't understand it.但还是不明白
0:09Nine years ago, I started reading every serious finance九年前,我开始读 每一个严肃的金融
0:12and money book I could find and summarizing them on YouTube.在YouTube上可以找到和总结钱书
0:16What I found contradicted almost everything I was taught.我发现的东西几乎与我所学到的一切相矛盾。
0:20So one day I went back to the professor I trusted most有一天我回到教授身边 我最信任的
0:24and asked him if what I was discovering was true.问他我发现的是否是真的
0:27He looked at me and said,他看着我说,
0:29yes, all of it.是的,所有这一切。
展开字幕全文(379 条)
序号英文中文
1Nobody teaches you the truth about money.没人教你钱的真相
2I studied at an economics faculty for six years我在经济学系学习了六年
3and still didn't understand it.但还是不明白
4Nine years ago, I started reading every serious finance九年前,我开始读 每一个严肃的金融
5and money book I could find and summarizing them on YouTube.在YouTube上可以找到和总结钱书
6What I found contradicted almost everything I was taught.我发现的东西几乎与我所学到的一切相矛盾。
7So one day I went back to the professor I trusted most有一天我回到教授身边 我最信任的
8and asked him if what I was discovering was true.问他我发现的是否是真的
9He looked at me and said,他看着我说,
10yes, all of it.是的,所有这一切。
11He knew, but the textbook said otherwise.他知道,但教科书上说相反。
12That's when I understood the confusion isn't an accident.那时我明白混乱不是偶然
13This video is the entire map of money.这段视频是钱的整个地图.
14Everything those 15 years taught me condensed into one place.那十五年的一切都让我凝聚在一个地方
15Let's start from zero.从零开始吧
16In 1903, an American doctor named William Furness1903年,美国医生威廉·弗内斯
17travels to a tiny island called Yap,前往一个叫Yap的小岛
18a small piece of land in the middle of the Pacific Ocean太平洋中部的小块土地
19that most people have never heard of.大多数人从来没有听说过。
20And he is confused by what he sees.而为所见所惑.
21The people of Yap use enormous stone disks as money.雅浦人民把巨大的石盘当作钱.
22Some of them are four tons of solid limestone,其中一些是4吨固体石灰岩,
23the weight of an elephant.大象的重量。
24You cannot carry them, you cannot move them.你无法携带,也无法移动
25They just sit there in the village,他们只是坐在村里,
26by the road, outside someone's house.在路边,有人家外面
27And here's the thing, they never move, ever.事情是这样的 他们永远动不了
28When someone buys something, ownership transfers,当有人买东西,所有权转让,
29but the stone stays exactly where it is.但石头一直留在原处
30Everyone in the village simply agrees村里的每个人都同意
31that stone now belongs to this family.那块石头现在属于这个家族
32But the story doesn't end there.但故事并没有在那里结束.
33Years ago, one family was transporting几年前,一个家庭正在运送
34a particularly large stone by canoe.一只特别大的石头靠独木舟
35A storm came and the stone sank to the bottom of the ocean.一场暴风雨来袭,石头沉到海底.
36Nobody can take it out, nobody can even see it.没人能拿出来,没人能看见
37It still kept circulating as money.它仍然以钱的形式流通。
38The entire island agreed that stone exists全岛都同意 石头存在
39and it belongs to this family, so they can spend it.它属于这个家庭,所以他们可以花它。
40The stone was never the point.石头从来都不是重点
41The agreement was.协议是。
42Two of the greatest economists in history,两位史上最伟大的经济学家
43Keynes and Milton Friedman,凯恩斯和米尔顿·弗里德曼
44disagreed on almost everything.几乎什么都有分歧
45These two guys argued about economics their entire lives.这两个家伙争论经济学 他们的整个生活。
46Both of them independently read about Yap Island两人都独立读过雅浦岛
47and both of them said the exact same thing.他们都说了同样的话
48These people understand money better than we do.这些人比我们更了解钱
49So if money is just an agreement,所以如果钱只是协议
50where did that agreement come from?协议从何而来?
51How did it start?怎么开始的?
52You've probably heard the barter story.你可能听过易货的故事
53First, humans bartered.首先,人类交换。
54You give me your fish, I give you my bread.你给我你的鱼,我给你我的面包。
55Then it got complicated, so we invented money.后来事情变得复杂了 所以我们发明了钱
56That story is not true.这故事不是真的。
57In 1776, economist Adam Smith wrote it down in his book.1776年,经济学家亚当·斯密(Adam Smith)在书中将其写下来.
58He wasn't describing history,他没有描述历史,
59he was making a logical argument.他在进行逻辑辩论
60But for 250 years, economists treated it as a fact.但250年来,经济学家将它视为事实.
61Teachers taught it, textbooks printed it.老师教它,教科书也印刷它.
62Nobody checked if it was actually true.没人查是否是真的
63When anthropologists finally checked, they found nothing.当人类学家最终检查时,他们什么也没发现.
64Cambridge anthropologist Caroline Humphrey剑桥人类学家卡罗琳·汉弗莱
65spent her career looking for it.花了她的职业生涯寻找它。
66Her conclusion was simple.她的结论很简单。
67No example of a barter economy has ever been described.从未描述过易货经济的例子。
68Not in any culture, not in any era, not on this planet.在任何文化中,在任何时代,在这个星球上,都不行。
69All evidence suggests there never has been such a thing.所有证据显示,从来没有发生过这种事。
70And here's the part that flips everything upside down.而此部分翻转一切颠倒.
71Barter didn't come before money, it came after.巴特尔没有来之前的钱, 它来之后。
72People only bartered when their money system collapsed只有钱系统崩溃时 人们才会交换
73and they had nothing else.他们没有别的了
74Russia in the 1990s, Argentina in 2002.1990年代俄罗斯,2002年阿根廷.
75When the currency disappeared,当货币消失时
76people went back to swapping things directly.人们回去直接交换东西。
77It wasn't the beginning of money.这不是钱的开始。
78It was the emergency backup when money was gone.钱没了就是紧急支援
79What actually came first was much simpler.最先出现的是简单得多。
80You helped your neighbor build his roof.你帮邻居盖屋顶
81He helped you with your harvest later.他后来帮助你收割。
82No transactions, no haggling.没有交易,没有争吵。
83Just people remembering what they owed each other.只是人们记得 他们欠对方。
84The oldest writing ever discovered isn't love stories.最古老的写作不是爱情故事
85It isn't prayers.这不是祈祷
86It isn't laws.这不是法律。
87It's a debt record from over 5,000 years ago.五千多年前的债务记录.
88Found in Mesopotamia, what is today Iraq.在美索不达米亚发现的 今天是什么伊拉克。
89Someone borrowed tools and promised有人借工具答应
90to pay back after harvest.收获后还钱
91Merchants writing down what people owed them,商人写下人们欠他们的
92all of it scratched into clay tablets全部刮成粘土片
93that you can actually go and see in museums today.今天你可以去博物馆看看
94No coins, just promises recorded in clay.没有硬币,只是用粘土记录的许诺。
95The first coins showed up 2,700 years later2700年后第一批硬币出现
96in Lydia, what is called Turkey.在莉迪亚, 所谓的土耳其。
97Think about that.考虑一下
98For over 2,000 years, humans built cities, paid workers,两千多年来,人类建造了城市,有报酬的工人,
99ran entire civilizations on nothing but recorded promises.整个文明无所事事,只许有承诺。
100The coin came after the promise came first.硬币是先承诺的
101So let's put this all together.因此,让我们把这一切放在一起。
102Yap Island, ancient Mesopotamia,雅浦岛 古美索不达米亚
103two completely different places,两个完全不同的地方,
104two completely different times, same discovery.两个完全不同的时代 同样的发现
105The value was never in the object.该值从未出现在对象中 。
106It was always in the agreement about the object.它总是在协议 关于对象。
107Money was supposed to work like a measuring tool,钱应该像一个测量工具
108like a ruler.像一个统治者。
109A ruler only works because everyone agrees on a measurement.一个尺子之所以有效,只是因为每个人都同意测量.
110Think about a minute.考虑一下
111Minute is 60 seconds whether you're in Tokyo,一分钟是60秒 不管你在东京,
112New York or Cairo, always.纽约或开罗,总是。
113Nobody can change that.没有人可以改变这一点。
114Nobody wakes up one morning and says,没有人醒来 一天早上说,
115okay, today a minute is 55 seconds.好吧,今天一分钟是55秒。
116That stability is exactly what makes it useful.这种稳定正是它有用的原因。
117You can plan around it, trust in it completely.你可以计划,完全相信它。
118Money was supposed to work exactly the same way,钱应该用同样的方式
119a stable, reliable measure of value.一个稳定可靠的价值衡量标准。
120But here's the difference.但此分别.
121A minute exists in nature, nobody controls it.自然界存在一分钟 没人能控制它
122Money is a human agreement钱是人类的约定
123and human agreements can be changed silently人类协议可以默默改变
124without telling you.不告诉你。
125That's exactly why for thousands of years,这就是为什么几千年来,
126people tied money to something physical,人们把钱绑在身体上
127gold, silver, metal, something nobody could fake,金子、银子、金属,没人能伪造的东西,
128something that behaved more like a minute,某种行为更像是一分钟,
129fixed and impossible to print.固定且无法打印。
130That physical anchor kept everyone honest.那个物理锚使每个人都诚实。
131Then some guy came along and said,然后有人来了 说,
132forget the gold, just use paper.忘了金子,用纸吧
133And the whole world said, yes.全世界都说,是的
134You are now trusting a measuring tool你现在信任一个测量工具
135held by the same person who benefits由受益的同一人持有
136from making it shorter.从缩短。
137And here's what I couldn't stop thinking about.这就是我一直想着的
138How are people so naive?人们怎么这么天真?
139How did nobody just say no to paper money?怎么没人拒绝纸币?
140But then I actually looked at how it happened但后来我又看了一下事情的经过
141and I realized I would have said yes too.我意识到我也会答应的
142So would you.你也一样。
143It turns out that you don't have to convince people原来你不必说服别人
144to trust something you can print.相信可以打印的东西。
145China, about a thousand years ago,中国,大约一千年前,
146during the Song dynasty in a region called Sichuan,宋朝时期,在四川一带,
147they had a strange problem with money.他们有奇怪的问题 与钱。
148Their money was made of iron, heavy, low value,他们的钱是铁制的,又重又低
149and you needed a lot of it just to buy anything important.而你需要很多钱来买任何重要的东西
150Carrying enough iron to make a serious trade携带足够的铁 进行严肃的交易
151meant carrying kilos of metal through the vast empire.意思是带着一公斤的金属 穿过庞大的帝国
152It was slow, dangerous, and exhausting.它很慢,很危险,很累
153So ordinary merchants came up with something smarter.所以普通商人想出了更聪明的办法
154Leave your iron with a trusted local shop.把你的铁留给一家可信任的本地商店
155Get a receipt.拿张收据
156Trade the receipt instead of the metal.用收据换金属
157Lighter, faster, nobody gets robbed on the road.更轻,更快,没有人在路上被抢劫。
158Nobody invented this from above,没有人从上面发明这个,
159just regular people solving an annoying problem只是普通人解决一个烦人的问题
160in the most obvious way available.以最明显的方式
161And it worked, genuinely worked.和它的工作,真正的工作。
162Trade got easier, people's lives got better.贸易变得更加容易,人们的生活更加美好.
163Then the government noticed.后来政府注意到了.
164They stepped in and made it official,他们介入并正式宣布
165creating government-issued paper money called jiaozi,创建政府发行的纸币 叫做Jiaozi,
166which looked something like this.看起来像这样
167This was not a bad idea either.这主意也不错
168Instead of hundreds of different shop receipts, you had one.而不是几百张不同的店面收据, 你有一个。
169The problem came later.问题后来才出现。
170War is expensive,战争是昂贵的
171and printing paper is cheaper than finding silver.印刷纸比找银更便宜
172So they printed a bit more, then a bit more,所以,他们打印多一点,然后多一点,
173then more again.再来一次
174The ruler was shrinking.统治者在缩小。
175And once people noticed,一旦人们注意到
176they stopped trusting the measurement entirely.他们不再完全相信测量。
177They went back to the heavy iron coins他们回到重铁硬币上
178they spent generations trying to escape.他们花了几代人试图逃跑。
179The Chinese were the first to invent paper money.中国人最早发明纸币.
180And the first to be destroyed by it.而先被其灭者.
181London, 17th century, same pattern, different place.伦敦,17世纪,相同的图案,不同的地方.
182Imagine you live in this time.想象一下你活在这个时候
183You have gold, but the streets are dangerous.你有黄金,但街道很危险。
184Thieves are everywhere, wars, fires.盗贼无处不在,战火不息.
185Keeping it at home means risking everything you own.把它留在家里 意味着冒险你拥有的一切。
186So you leave it with the local goldsmith.所以你把它留给当地的金匠
187He already built vaults for his jewelry business.他已经为珠宝生意盖了金库
188For a small fee, he agrees to store your gold too,为了小费,他同意 储存你的黄金太,
189and hands you a receipt.并给你一张收据。
190A piece of paper saying exactly how much gold一张纸上写着多少黄金
191he is keeping safe for you.他保证你的安全
192And here's the thing,事情是这样的
193almost everyone in town used the same goldsmith.镇上几乎每个人都用同样的金匠
194So when you bought something from your neighbor,当你从邻居那里买东西时
195he had gold stored there too.他有黄金储存在那里。
196Instead of you walking across town to collect your gold,而不是你走过镇上收集你的黄金,
197walking back to hand it to him,走回去交给他,
198and him walking across town to deposit it again,然后他走过镇上再存一次
199you just handed him the receipt.你刚刚把收据交给他
200He could walk in any time and collect the gold himself.他随时可以自己走 自己拿金子
201Same result, 10 times easier.同样的结果,十倍的容易。
202Why would anyone do it any other way?为什么有人会这么做?
203One night, the goldsmith is lying awake in his bed一天晚上,金匠躺在床上
204and a thought creeps in.和一个想法爬入。
205All that gold is just sitting there doing nothing.那些金子只是坐在那里无所事事
206On any given day, maybe 10% of people在任何一天,也许10%的人
207actually come to collect it.其实是来收集的
208The rest just trade the paper receipts.其余的只是交换收据
209So what if, what if I lend some of it out?那么,如果,如果我借一些出来呢?
210Charge interest, nobody would ever know.收取利息,没人知道
211So he starts lending it out.所以他开始借出去
212A merchant needs money to start a business.商人需要钱来创业.
213The goldsmith hands him a receipt金匠给他一张收据
214and charges interest when he pays it back.并收取利息 当他偿还它。
215But whose gold is he lending?他借谁的金子?
216Yours, and you get nothing from that earned interest.你的,你从这赚来的利息一文不值
217You don't even know your gold is out there你甚至不知道你的金子在外边
218making money for someone else.为别人赚钱
219You think it's safely sitting in a vault.你认为它安全地坐在保险库里
220The goldsmith collects the interest.金匠收集利息.
221You carry the risk, he keeps the reward.你冒着风险,他留着赏金
222It's like you park your car in a garage for safekeeping就像你把车停在车库里保管
223and the owner secretly rents it out,主人偷偷地把它租了出来,
224making money from your car every day.每天用你的车赚钱
225Well, you think it's just sitting there safe.你认为它只是坐在那里安全。
226Now, the lending itself was actually useful.现在,贷款本身其实是有用的。
227Idle gold builds nothing.枯金无所建.
228Put to work and it creates jobs,投入工作并创造就业机会,
229builds things that wouldn't exist otherwise.建立的东西是不会存在的 否则。
230That part was a real discovery.那部分是一个真正的发现。
231But then the goldsmith gets greedy但金匠却贪得无厌
232and prints more paper receipts.并打印更多的纸张收据。
233He has, let's say 100 pieces of gold,他有100块金币
234but he prints 150 receipts.但他打印了150张收据。
235The extra 50 have nothing behind them.额外50人后面什么都没有
236He just made them up.是他编的
237A real receipt and a fake one looked identical.一个真正的收据和一个假的 看起来是一样的。
238There was no difference, so nobody could notice.没有区别,所以没人会注意到
239Soon prices start rising.价格很快开始上涨。
240Nobody knows why.没人知道为什么
241When everything was finally exposed,当一切终于被曝光时,
242you might expect outrage reform.你可能会期待愤怒改革。
243Instead, they made it official.相反,他们把它变成正式的。
244King William III was desperate for money to fund his wars.威廉三世国王急于寻求金钱来资助他的战争.
245Nobody would lend to him.没有人会借给他。
246So he looked at what the goldsmith had been doing所以他看了那个金匠一直在做的事
247and thought, I want that same power.我想,我想要同样的力量。
248In 1694, they founded the Bank of England.1694年,他们成立了英格兰银行.
249A group of merchants loaned the crown 1.2 million pounds.一批商人借出王冠120万斤.
250In return, the king gave them an official license作为回报,国王给了他们正式的执照
251to issue paper money,发行纸币,
252backed not by gold in a vault,没有金子支撑在金库里,
253but by the king's promise to repay.但是国王承诺要偿还
254The goldsmith created money from nothing金匠一无所获
255and called it a receipt.并称之为收据。
256The Bank of England created money from nothing英格兰银行从无到有创造力
257and called it a bank note.并称之为一张钞票。
258Different name, same trick.不同名字,同样的诡计。
259The fraud didn't get shut down.欺诈没有被关闭。
260It got a crown on top of it.其顶戴一冠.
261The ruler was now in the hands of the people统治者现在掌握在人民手中
262who benefited from shrinking it.他们从缩小中得益。
263And the rest of the countries didn't just watch.而其余诸国不单观.
264They copied it, almost every single one of them.他们复制了它,几乎每一个。
265That is why they call the Bank of England所以他们才叫英格兰银行
266the mother of all central banks.所有中央银行的母亲。
267Every central bank, every bank you have ever walked into,每个中央银行,每一个你走进的银行,
268all running on the same system the goldsmith invented,所有运行在同一系统 金匠发明,
269lying awake in his bed.躺在他床上醒着
270But the world wasn't ready to give up on honest money.但世界还没有准备好放弃诚实的金钱.
2711944, the war was almost over.1944年,战争几乎结束.
272And before the smoke even cleared,在烟熏之前
273the entire Western world sat down and agreed on one rule.整个西方世界坐下来 商定了一条规则
274Let us tie every currency to the dollar让我们把每种货币与美元挂钩
275and tie the dollar to gold.然后把美元和黄金绑起来
276Fixed, $35 for one ounce.固定,35美元一盎司。
277And for a while it worked.有一阵子了
278Europe rebuilt from rubble.欧洲从废墟中重建。
279People lived better than they ever had.人们的生活比以前更好。
280But underneath it all, a quiet problem was growing.但是,在这一切之下, 一个安静的问题正在增长。
281America was spending heavily美国花了很多钱
282on wars, on programs at home,关于战争, 关于家庭方案,
283and quietly it started printing to cover the gap.并悄悄地开始印刷以覆盖空白.
284The dollars were piling up.美元积聚。
285The gold wasn't.金子没有。
286And other countries started asking one very simple question.其他国家开始问一个非常简单的问题。
287If we all showed up at once,如果我们都马上出现
288would the gold actually be there?金子真的会在那里吗?
289The answer was no.答案是否定的。
290Countries slowly started showing up.各国慢慢地开始出现。
291France was the first to demand their gold.法国最早要求他们的黄金.
292The vault was emptying fast.保险库很快就空了
293The US President Nixon didn't wait for it to run out.美国总统尼克松没有等待它耗尽.
294On a Sunday evening in August, 1971,1971年8月的星期日晚间
295he went on television and announced他上电视宣布
296that the dollar would no longer be convertible to gold.美元不再可以兑换成黄金
297The last anchor was gone.最后一个锚不见了
298Overnight, every currency in the world一夜之间,世界上所有的货币
299became just paper backed by nothing but trust.成了只有信任的纸
300Think about what that meant for anyone sitting at home想想这对坐在家里的人意味着什么
301watching that broadcast.看广播
302If you had $100 in your pocket that night,如果那晚你口袋里有100块
303today the same $100 would buy you only $8 worth of things.今天同样的100美元只给你买8美元的东西
304Sit with that for a second.你坐一会吧
30592% of the value was gone价值的92%没有了
306while the number on the note stayed exactly the same.纸条上的号码完全不变
307That was 1971, half a century ago.那是1971年,半个世纪前。
308You would think in 50 years,你会认为50年后
309someone would have fixed this, built something better.有人会修好它, 建造更好的东西。
310Nobody did.没有人知道。
311In fact, the situation got even stranger.事实上,情况甚至变得陌生。
312Remember the goldsmith printing receipts he had no gold for?还记得金匠印收据 他没有金子?
313Private banks are still doing the exact same thing,私人银行也在做同样的事情
314just on a computer screen now.就在电脑屏幕上
31597% of all money today is digital今天97%的钱都是数字的
316and it is created by them,它是由他们创造的,
317not the central bank, not the government.不是中央银行,不是政府
318Most people think that banks are just the middlemen.大多数人认为银行只是中间人.
319They take deposits, keep 10% as reserve他们收存款,留10%作为储备
320and lend the rest out and that is how they make money.然后把剩下的借出去 这就是他们赚钱的方法
321This is also what I learned in my economics classes.这也是我在经济学课程中学到的.
322That is not what happens, not even close.事情不是那样的,甚至没有接近。
323Imagine you walk into your local bank.想象一下你走进你的当地银行
324You need $10,000, you sign a loan contract.你需要一万美元,你签个贷款合同
325That exact moment, two things happen.那一刻 发生了两件事
326The bank records your promise to repay银行记录你答应还钱
327as an asset on their books作为他们的账本上的资产
328and types $10,000 into your account.并且输入一万元入帐
329In that exact moment, money is created.钱就是在那一刻创造出来的
330Your signature is what created that money.你的签名就是创造这些钱的原因
331Now you can spend it, do whatever you want with it现在你可以花掉它,随心所欲
332as long as you pay back the $10,000 plus the interest.只要你还了一万美元加利息
333They didn't use their savings他们没有用他们的积蓄
334or use somebody else's deposits to give you that loan.或者用别人的存款给你贷款
335They just typed numbers on a screen他们只是在屏幕上输入数字
336but they still collect real interest on it.但他们仍然对它很感兴趣
337But wait, it gets even stranger than that.但等等,它会变得更陌生。
338You borrowed $10,000, but with interest,你借了一万块,但有利息
339let's say you owe $11,000 back.假设你欠我11,000美元
340That extra $1,000, where does it come from?那额外的1000美元,它从哪里来的?
341It was never created.它从未被创造。
342It doesn't exist in the system.系统不存在.
343The only way you can get it只有这样你才能得到它
344is if someone else borrows it first.如果别人先借的话
345But that someone owes back more than they borrowed too.但是有人欠的还比他们借的还多
346So another person has to borrow and another and another.所以,另一个人必须借款,另一个人和另一个人。
347The only way anyone can ever pay back their debt只有这样才能还清债务
348is if someone else is constantly taking on new debt forever.如果别人 不断承担新的债务 永远。
349The system doesn't just prefer this, it requires it.系统并不只是喜欢这个,它需要它。
350So more and more money keeps getting created所以,越来越多的钱 不断得到创造
351but the amount of goods and services in the world但世界上货物和服务的数量
352doesn't grow at the same pace.增长速度不同
353So each dollar you own buys a little less所以,你拥有的每一个美元 买少一点
354than it did yesterday.比昨天还糟
355And here's the part that took me a long time to accept.我花了很长时间才接受这个角色
356That is not an accident.这不是意外。
357Someone decided this.有人决定的
358Every major central bank in the world世界每个主要中央银行
359targets 2% inflation per year.每年通胀2%的目标。
360They call it price stability.他们称之为价格稳定。
3612% sounds harmless but compound it over a lifetime2%听起来无害 但它是终生的
362and it cuts the value of your savings roughly in half让你的积蓄减少一半
363every 35 years.每35年一次。
364The ruler is being shortened on purpose every single year.统治者每年都被故意缩短。
365Now here's the question.现在的问题是:
366If someone decided this, who did they decide it for?如果有人决定了, 他们决定是谁?
367Borrowers.借款人
368Inflation is good for borrowers.通货膨胀对借款人有利。
369You borrow with strong currency.你借的是强币
370You pay back with a weaker one.你用弱者还钱
371So the debt quietly shrinks.所以,债务悄悄的收缩。
372Now think about who the biggest borrower on earth is.现在想想世界上最大的借款人是谁
373Governments, every single one of them.政府,每一个政府。
374Debt so large it could never realistically be paid back这么大的债 根本还不回来
375but inflated away quietly over decades几十年来悄悄膨胀
376and suddenly it becomes manageable.突然变得可以控制
377The saver pays, the borrower benefits.储蓄者支付,借款者受益.
378This is not a flaw in the system.这不是制度上的缺陷。
379This is the system.这就是系统。
该视频共有字幕 380 条。解锁更多字幕为会员功能,请移动到 价格