古人是怎么分辨哪些食物是安全的?
字幕摘录
| 时间 | 英文 | 中文 |
|---|---|---|
| 0:00 | Somewhere, tens of thousands of years ago, a person ate something they shouldn't have. | 在几万年前的某个地方 一个人吃了他们不该吃的东西 |
| 0:05 | We'll never know their name. | 我们永远不会知道他们的名字。 |
| 0:06 | We'll never know what it was. | 我们永远不会知道它是什么。 |
| 0:08 | A berry, a leaf, a root, a beautiful little mushroom. | 莓,叶,根,美丽小蘑菇. |
| 0:11 | But we know roughly what happened next, because it had happened before, | 但我们大概知道接下来会发生什么 因为以前发生过 |
| 0:15 | and it would happen again. | 它会再次发生。 |
| 0:17 | They got sick. | 他们生病了。 |
| 0:18 | Maybe they died. | 也许他们死了。 |
| 0:19 | And the people around them, the ones who watched, the ones who survived, remembered. | 周围的人,看的,活下来的人,都记得. |
| 0:24 | They remembered everything, and that memory passed from mouth to ear. | 他们回忆起一切,记忆从口到耳 |
展开字幕全文(369 条)
| 序号 | 英文 | 中文 |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Somewhere, tens of thousands of years ago, a person ate something they shouldn't have. | 在几万年前的某个地方 一个人吃了他们不该吃的东西 |
| 2 | We'll never know their name. | 我们永远不会知道他们的名字。 |
| 3 | We'll never know what it was. | 我们永远不会知道它是什么。 |
| 4 | A berry, a leaf, a root, a beautiful little mushroom. | 莓,叶,根,美丽小蘑菇. |
| 5 | But we know roughly what happened next, because it had happened before, | 但我们大概知道接下来会发生什么 因为以前发生过 |
| 6 | and it would happen again. | 它会再次发生。 |
| 7 | They got sick. | 他们生病了。 |
| 8 | Maybe they died. | 也许他们死了。 |
| 9 | And the people around them, the ones who watched, the ones who survived, remembered. | 周围的人,看的,活下来的人,都记得. |
| 10 | They remembered everything, and that memory passed from mouth to ear. | 他们回忆起一切,记忆从口到耳 |
| 11 | Across hundreds of generations, with no writing, no schools, no science, | 几百代人,没有写作,没有学校,没有科学 |
| 12 | is the only reason you're alive to watch this. | 这是你活着的唯一理由 |
| 13 | This is the story of how humans learned what was safe to eat. | 这就是人类如何学会什么是安全的饮食的故事。 |
| 14 | And it might be the most underrated achievement in the entire human story. | 这可能是整个人类故事中最受低估的成就。 |
| 15 | Here's the thing nobody tells you. | 这是没人告诉你的 |
| 16 | When we picture ancient survival, we picture the dramatic stuff. | 当我们想象着古代的生存, 我们想象着戏剧性的东西。 |
| 17 | The mammoth hunt, the cave lion, the blizzard, the spear raised against something with teeth. | 猛毛象狩猎 洞穴狮子 暴风雪 长矛用牙齿向某物举起. |
| 18 | But the truth is, the most relentless, every-single-day threat | 但事实是,最无情的, 每一天的威胁 |
| 19 | to an ancient human wasn't any of that. | 对一个古老的人类来说 根本就没有 |
| 20 | It was the perfectly innocent-looking thing. | 这是完全无辜的事情。 |
| 21 | Sitting on a branch at eye level, food doesn't roar, food doesn't charge. | 坐在眼层的树枝上,食物不咆哮,食物不收费. |
| 22 | Food just sits there, looking harmless. | 食物只是坐在那里,看起来无害。 |
| 23 | And roughly a third of the time, it's trying to kill you, because nature is not your friend. | 大约三分之一的时间 它想杀了你 因为大自然不是你的朋友 |
| 24 | We have this gentle, modern idea that natural means safe, | 我们有一个温柔的现代想法, 自然意味着安全, |
| 25 | that if it grows out of the ground, it must be wholesome. | 如果它从地里长出来 一定很好 |
| 26 | The plants would like a word. | 植物们想谈谈 |
| 27 | Plants cannot run away. | 植物无法逃跑 |
| 28 | They can't bite, they can't flee, they can't hide. | 他们不能咬人,不能逃跑,不能躲藏. |
| 29 | So over hundreds of millions of years, | 因此,在亿万年里, |
| 30 | they evolved the only defense available to something rooted to the spot. | 他们演化出了唯一可以用来防御 扎根于现场的东西 |
| 31 | Chemistry, a plant that tastes terrible or makes you vomit or stops your heart, | 化学,一种味道不好或让你呕吐或停止心脏的植物, |
| 32 | is a plant that gets eaten less often. | 是一种较少被食用的植物. |
| 33 | Toxicity is not an accident. | 毒性并非偶然。 |
| 34 | For a plant, toxicity is the entire point. | 对于植物来说,毒性是整个点. |
| 35 | Every forest your ancestors walked through was, from the plant's perspective, an arms race. | 你的祖先走过的每一片森林 从植物的角度来看都是一场军备竞赛 |
| 36 | And your ancestors were walking into it three times a day, hungry, | 你的祖先们一天走进它三次 饥饿 |
| 37 | with nothing but the equipment evolution had given them. | 除了装备的进化 什么都没有给他们。 |
| 38 | So let's talk about that equipment, | 所以,让我们谈谈那个设备, |
| 39 | because the first line of defense wasn't knowledge. | 因为第一道防线不是知识 |
| 40 | It wasn't culture. | 这不是文化。 |
| 41 | It was built into the body itself. | 它被建在身体本身。 |
| 42 | Start with taste. | 从味起. |
| 43 | That bitterness you hate, the thing that makes kids spit out broccoli, | 你讨厌的苦味 让孩子们吐出西兰花的东西 |
| 44 | and adults grimace at black coffee before they train themselves to tolerate it. | 在他们训练自己容忍黑咖啡之前 成年的黑咖啡 |
| 45 | That is not a flaw in your tongue. | 这不是你舌头上的缺陷。 |
| 46 | That is a 400-million-year-old alarm system. | 这是一个4亿年的警报系统。 |
| 47 | Bitterness is the flavor of alkaloids. | 苦味是烯烃的味道. |
| 48 | And alkaloids are the chemical family that includes strychnine, | 而烯烃是化学家族 包括石英 |
| 49 | nicotine, morphine, caffeine, and a long list of compounds | 尼古丁、吗啡、咖啡因和一长串化合物 |
| 50 | that range from mildly unpleasant to instantly lethal. | 从轻度不愉快到瞬间致命 |
| 51 | Your ancestors who found bitter things disgusting were your ancestors, | 你的祖先发现 痛苦的东西恶心是你的祖先, |
| 52 | who didn't eat the deadly bitter things, | 他没有吃致命的苦果, |
| 53 | which is precisely why they got to become your ancestors. | 这就是为什么他们要成为你的祖先。 |
| 54 | The ones with a relaxed attitude toward bitterness | 那些对痛苦态度放松的人 |
| 55 | tended not to make it into the family tree. | 往往无法进入家庭树。 |
| 56 | Humans have around 25 different types of bitter taste receptors, | 人类有大约25种不同的苦味受体, |
| 57 | far more than we have for sweet or salty. | 比我们吃甜食或咸食要多得多 |
| 58 | Think about what that ratio is telling you. | 想想这个比例会告诉你什么 |
| 59 | Evolution invested in one good detector for sugar | Evolution 投资一个很好的糖检测器 |
| 60 | and built 25 separate alarms for poison. | 并建造了25个单独的警报器 用于制造毒药 |
| 61 | That is not a species that expected the world to be safe. | 这不是期望世界安全的物种。 |
| 62 | That is a species braced for betrayal at every meal. | 这是一种每餐都有背叛的物种。 |
| 63 | There's a gene some of you have right now called TAS2R3-8 | 你们中有些人的基因现在叫做TAS2R3-8 |
| 64 | that determines how intensely you taste certain bitter compounds. | 这决定了你有多强烈的品味 某些苦的化合物。 |
| 65 | Some people are non-tasters. | 有些人是非塔师. |
| 66 | Some are super-tasters who find the same vegetable almost unbearable. | 有些是超级面包师 他们发现同样的蔬菜几乎无法忍受。 |
| 67 | That variation isn't random. | 变化不是随机的 |
| 68 | It's the surviving echo of an ancient hedge. | 这是古老的树篱生存的回声 |
| 69 | A group with a range of sensitivities is a group where someone will always flinch | 一个敏感度很高的团体 是一个总有人退缩的团体 |
| 70 | at the dangerous plant, even when others won't. | 在危险的工厂, 即使其他人不会。 |
| 71 | And it's not just taste. | 亦不单是味. |
| 72 | It's disgust itself. | 它本身令人厌恶。 |
| 73 | That full-body recoil you feel at the smell of rotting meat, | 你从腐烂的肉味中感觉到的全身后坐力 |
| 74 | the way your face scrunches and your stomach turns, | 你的脸痛而腹痛 |
| 75 | that is one of the oldest protective programs your brain runs. | 这是你大脑运行的最古老的保护程序之一 |
| 76 | Disgust is, at its core, a system for not putting deadly things in your mouth. | 恶心是它的核心, 一个系统 不把致命的东西在你的嘴。 |
| 77 | The expression is even the same across every culture on Earth. | 地球上每一种文化的表达甚至都是一样的。 |
| 78 | The wrinkled nose, the curled lip, because it's not learned. | 皱纹的鼻子,卷曲的嘴唇,因为没有学会. |
| 79 | It's standard human hardware. | 标准人文硬件. |
| 80 | Your ancestors who found decay revolting | 你的祖先发现腐朽令人厌恶 |
| 81 | avoided the bacteria that decay carries. | 避免了腐烂的细菌 |
| 82 | The ones who didn't, again, tend not to be anyone's ancestors. | 那些没有,再次,往往不是任何人的祖先. |
| 83 | So the body gives you a starter kit. | 尸体给你一个启动器 |
| 84 | Bitter is danger, rotten is death, sweet is probably energy. | 痛苦是危险 腐烂是死亡 甜美可能是能量 |
| 85 | But here's where it gets interesting. | 但这里变得很有趣。 |
| 86 | Because that starter kit is nowhere near enough. | 因为那个启动器还远远不够 |
| 87 | Plenty of deadly plants aren't bitter. | 很多致命植物并不苦 |
| 88 | Plenty of safe foods are. | 很多安全的食物是。 |
| 89 | The body's instincts are a blunt first filter and an ancient human. | 身体的本能是钝质的第一滤波器和古人类. |
| 90 | Relying on instinct alone would still be playing a very dangerous game. | 依靠本能 仍然会玩一个非常危险的游戏。 |
| 91 | So humans did what humans do best. | 所以人类做了人类最擅长的事 |
| 92 | They got clever. | 他们很聪明 |
| 93 | Strategy one was simple, brilliant, and brutal. | 战略一是简单、聪明和残暴的。 |
| 94 | The small dose. | 小剂量。 |
| 95 | When you encounter a new potential food, you don't sit down and eat a bowl of it. | 当遇到新的潜在食物时,不会坐下来吃一碗. |
| 96 | You take a tiny amount. | 你拿一点钱 |
| 97 | You rub it on your lips, your skin, and you wait. | 你涂在你的嘴唇,你的皮肤,你等待。 |
| 98 | Does it tingle? | 它会叮吗? |
| 99 | Does it burn? | 燃烧吗? |
| 100 | Does it blister? | 是水泡吗? |
| 101 | If it does, you stop. | 如果真的这样,你就停下来。 |
| 102 | If it doesn't, you taste a crumb and you wait again, hours sometimes. | 如果它没有,你尝到一个屑,你再等待,有时几个小时。 |
| 103 | Then a little more. | 再来一点 |
| 104 | Then you wait a full day. | 然后等满日. |
| 105 | This is remarkably almost exactly the protocol that modern wilderness survival guides | 这几乎就是现代荒野生存所指引的 |
| 106 | still teach as the universal edibility test. | 仍然作为通用的可读性测试进行教学. |
| 107 | And it wasn't invented in a manual. | 也不是在手册里发明的 |
| 108 | It was the accumulated logic of a species that had learned | 这是一个物种积累的逻辑 已经学会了 |
| 109 | the hardest possible way that the difference between food and poison | 食物和毒药之间最难的区别 |
| 110 | is often a difference of dose. | 通常是剂量的不同。 |
| 111 | The small dose strategy doesn't make a poison safe. | 小剂量策略不会使毒药安全. |
| 112 | But it turns a fatal mistake into a survivable one. | 但是它把致命的错误变成了一个可以生存的错误. |
| 113 | It buys the one thing an ancient human needed most, a second chance. | 它买的是古代人类最需要的 第二次机会 |
| 114 | Strategy two was even smarter. | 战略二更聪明 |
| 115 | Don't be the one who tests it at all. | 终不为试验者. |
| 116 | Watch something else do it first. | 先看别的东西 |
| 117 | Ancient humans were relentless observers of animals and not just as prey. | 古老的人类是动物的无情观察者,而不是像猎物一样。 |
| 118 | If you watch a bird gorge on a particular berry, | 如果你看到鸟峡谷上 特定的莓, |
| 119 | that berry probably won't kill a bird, which is useful information, | 莓汁可能不会杀死鸟, 这是有用的信息, |
| 120 | even if it's not a guarantee. | 即使这不是保证 |
| 121 | There's an old, hard-won wisdom embedded in this. | 此中蕴藏着一种古老,艰苦的智慧. |
| 122 | Watch what the animals eat. | 看动物吃什么 |
| 123 | It's imperfect because some things a bird can eat will harm a human and the reverse. | 它不完美,因为鸟类可以吃的东西会伤害人类,反之亦然. |
| 124 | But as a starting filter in a world with no other information, it tilted the odds. | 但作为一个没有其他信息的世界的开始过滤器,它倾斜了几率。 |
| 125 | Some researchers think this is part of how early humans found valuable foods, | 一些研究者认为这是早期人类如何找到有价值的食物的一部分, |
| 126 | like certain fruits and even fermenting fallen fruit. | 譬如有水果,甚至发酵的水果, |
| 127 | We followed the appetites of creatures who'd already paid the tuition. | 我们跟踪那些已经付学费的生物的胃口 |
| 128 | And strategy three, the rule that ties it all together. | 战略三,将它联系起来的规则。 |
| 129 | Change one thing at a time. | 一次改变一件事 |
| 130 | If you're going to try something new, try only one new thing | 如果你要尝试新事物,只尝试一件事 |
| 131 | and try it when nothing else is uncertain. | 并尝试它 当其他的不确定。 |
| 132 | Because if you eat three unfamiliar plants in an afternoon and you get violently ill, | 因为如果你在下午吃三棵不熟悉的植物 并且你生病了, |
| 133 | you've learned almost nothing. | 你几乎什么都没学到 |
| 134 | Which one was it? | 哪一个? |
| 135 | You've suffered for no usable knowledge. | 你因为没有有用的知识而受苦 |
| 136 | But if you change one variable and you get sick, now you know. | 但是如果你改变一个变量,你生病了,现在你知道了。 |
| 137 | Now you can tell the others. | 现在你可以告诉其他人。 |
| 138 | Now it goes into the database. | 现在它进入数据库。 |
| 139 | This is, quietly, the scientific method. | 这是,悄悄地,科学的方法。 |
| 140 | Isolate the variable. | 隔离变量。 |
| 141 | Observe the result. | 观察果报. |
| 142 | Record it. | 记录下来 |
| 143 | Share it. | 分享它。 |
| 144 | Ancient humans were running controlled experiments with their own bodies as the laboratory | 古人类用自己的身体作为实验室进行受控制的实验 |
| 145 | thousands of years before anyone wrote down a single rule of science. | 几千年前就有人写了一条科学规则 |
| 146 | They just paid for their data in a currency we no longer use. | 他们只是用我们不再使用的货币支付数据。 |
| 147 | Now here's where the story goes from impressive to genuinely astonishing. | 故事从令人印象深刻到真正令人惊讶。 |
| 148 | Because so far we've been talking about how ancient humans avoided poison. | 因为到目前为止我们一直在谈论古人类如何避免毒药. |
| 149 | But at some point, they did something far stranger and far more brilliant. | 但是,在某些时候,他们做了一些非常陌生,更辉煌的事情. |
| 150 | They started eating the poison on purpose and surviving. | 他们开始故意吃毒药 活下来了 |
| 151 | Let me explain. | 让我解释一下 |
| 152 | Because this is the part that should stop you cold. | 因为这是该让你寒冷的部分 |
| 153 | There is a plant called cassava, also known as manioc. | 有一种植物叫木薯,也叫木薯. |
| 154 | Today it feeds something like half a billion people. | 今天它养活了大约5亿人 |
| 155 | It is a staple, a foundation, a daily food across huge regions of Africa, South America, and Asia. | 它是一个主食,一个基金会,是非洲、南美洲和亚洲广大地区的日常食品。 |
| 156 | It is also, in its bitter wild form, loaded with compounds that release cyanide when you eat them. | 它还以苦的野性形式装入化合物,在食用时释放氰化物. |
| 157 | Raw bitter cassava can kill you. | 生苦木薯会杀了你 |
| 158 | Not metaphorically. | 不以喻义. |
| 159 | 青ide. | |
| 160 | The same poison from the spy movies. | 间谍电影里的毒药 |
| 161 | And yet entire civilizations built themselves on this plant. | 然而,整个文明都建立在这种植物上。 |
| 162 | How? | 怎么会? |
| 163 | Because somebody across uncountable generations of trial and error | 因为有人跨越无法统计的几代人 尝试和错误 |
| 164 | worked out an elaborate multi-step process to render it safe. | 设计了一个复杂的多步骤程序,使之安全。 |
| 165 | Depending on the tradition. | 取决于传统 |
| 166 | You peel it. | 你把它剥了 |
| 167 | You grate it. | 你抚摸它。 |
| 168 | You soak it. | 你浸湿了它。 |
| 169 | You ferment it. | 你发酵它。 |
| 170 | You press the liquid out. | 你按液体出来。 |
| 171 | You let it sit. | 你让它坐下。 |
| 172 | You cook it. | 你来煮 |
| 173 | Sometimes over days. | 有时过几天 |
| 174 | Each step removes a little more of the cyanide. | 每一步去除一点氰化物. |
| 175 | Skip a step. | 跳过一步。 |
| 176 | Do it wrong. | 做错了 |
| 177 | Rush it. | 冲啊 |
| 178 | And people get sick. | 而众生得病. |
| 179 | There's even a paralytic condition that appears in regions | 地区甚至出现麻痹症 |
| 180 | where cassava isn't processed correctly during times of famine | 在饥荒时期木薯处理不当 |
| 181 | when desperate people cut corners. | 当绝望的人们割角的时候, |
| 182 | The knowledge is not optional. | 知识非可选. |
| 183 | The knowledge is the food. | 知识是食. |
| 184 | Sit with what that actually required. | 顺其自然吧 |
| 185 | No one understood cyanide. | 没人懂氰化物 |
| 186 | No one understood chemistry or enzymes or the molecular structure of anything. | 没有人理解化学或酶 或任何东西的分子结构。 |
| 187 | Nobody could explain why the soaking worked or what the fermenting removed. | 没有人能解释为什么浸水有效 或除去什么发酵。 |
| 188 | They only knew that this exact sequence of steps performed in this exact order | 他们只知道这一系列步骤 都按这个顺序进行 |
| 189 | turned a plant that killed people into a plant that fed people. | 把杀人的植物变成喂人的植物 |
| 190 | And they knew it well enough to teach it perfectly to their children | 他们知道它足够 教他们的孩子完美 |
| 191 | who taught it to their children for thousands of years | 他教他们的孩子几千年 |
| 192 | without ever once knowing the why. | 没有一次知道原因 |
| 193 | They had the how. | 他们有办法。 |
| 194 | The how was enough. | 已经足够了 |
| 195 | The how kept them alive. | 如何让他们活着。 |
| 196 | And cassava is not alone. | 而木薯亦不独. |
| 197 | Acorns, a massive food source for ancient peoples across the northern hemisphere, | 橡树 是整个北半球 古老民族的大量食物来源 |
| 198 | are full of bitter tannins that make them inedible | 充满了苦味的丹宁 使它们无法食用 |
| 199 | and can damage your body if you eat enough raw. | 如果你吃得够生的 就能伤害你的身体 |
| 200 | So humans learned to leach them, grinding them and rinsing them with water, | 于是人类学会了浸泡,磨磨,用水冲洗, |
| 201 | sometimes for days, sometimes burying them in mud by a stream | 有时会埋在溪边的泥中 |
| 202 | until the bitterness washed away. | 直到苦水冲走 |
| 203 | And what remained was a nutritious, storable flower. | 剩下的是一朵有营养的、可储存的花。 |
| 204 | In Australia, Aboriginal peoples processed the nardu fern | 在澳大利亚,土著人民处理Nardu fern |
| 205 | and the seeds of the cycad both seriously toxic in their raw state | 和囊肿的种子 都有严重的毒性 |
| 206 | through soaking and grinding. | 通过浸泡和磨磨。 |
| 207 | And roasting techniques refined over tens of thousands of years. | 而烤制技术在数万年中不断完善. |
| 208 | These were not simple foods. | 这些不是简单的食物。 |
| 209 | These were chemistry projects run by people who didn't have the word chemistry, | 这些都是化学项目 由没有化学这个词的人管理, |
| 210 | executed flawlessly across hundreds of generations | 百代人无瑕疵地被处决 |
| 211 | because the alternative was death. | 因为另一种方法是死亡。 |
| 212 | And here's the part that turns it from a fun fact | 这是从一个有趣的事实开始的 |
| 213 | into something with weight behind it. | 进入它背后有重量的东西。 |
| 214 | We actually have a record of what happens | 我们确实有记录 |
| 215 | when outsiders try to eat these foods without the knowledge. | 当外人试图不知情地吃这些食物时. |
| 216 | In 1861, two European explorers in Australia, Burke and Wills, | 1861年,两位在澳大利亚的欧洲探险家伯克和威尔斯, |
| 217 | found themselves starving in the outback. | 发现自己在背部挨饿。 |
| 218 | Local Aboriginal people were thriving in the same landscape, | 当地原住民在同一景色中蓬勃发展, |
| 219 | eating, among other things, that nardu fern. | 吃,除了其他东西,那纳杜花。 |
| 220 | The explorers got hold of nardu too. | 探险家也抓住了纳尔杜 |
| 221 | They ground it, they ate it, they ate a lot of it, | 他们把它搁浅,他们吃了它, 他们吃了很多它, |
| 222 | and they grew weaker and weaker | 渐渐变得脆弱, |
| 223 | and could not understand why. | 也不明白为什么 |
| 224 | Because they were eating, their stomachs were full, | 因为他们在吃东西 肚子都满了 |
| 225 | and still, their bodies were failing. | 但是,他们的身体正在衰竭。 |
| 226 | They didn't know that nardu has to be prepared a specific way, | 他们不知道Nardu必须准备具体的方法, |
| 227 | that the Aboriginal method neutralized a compound | 土著方法使一个化合物失效 |
| 228 | that otherwise robs your body of the ability to use vitamin B1. | 否则会剥夺你的身体使用维生素B1的能力。 |
| 229 | They were eating the same plant as the people who survived. | 他们和幸存下来的人吃同样的植物 |
| 230 | They just didn't have the recipe. | 他们只是没有食谱。 |
| 231 | And the recipe was 40,000 years of accumulated knowledge | 食谱是四万年来积累的知识 |
| 232 | that you could not reverse engineer from a starving afternoon. | 你无法从一个饥饿的下午逆转工程师。 |
| 233 | They died, or near enough, of starvation, | 他们几乎饿死了, |
| 234 | with full stomachs, surrounded by food, | 满腹都是食物 |
| 235 | because food without the knowledge of how to prepare it isn't food. | 因为不知道如何准备的食物 不是食物 |
| 236 | It's a trap that looks like food. | 其陷阱外观如食物. |
| 237 | That, more than anything, is the answer to our question. | 这比什么都更能回答我们的问题。 |
| 238 | How did ancient humans know what was safe to eat? | 古人如何知道什么是安全的饮食? |
| 239 | They knew because someone before them had figured it out | 他们知道是因为他们之前的人已经知道了 |
| 240 | and refused to let the knowledge die. | 并拒绝让知识消亡。 |
| 241 | 说 about. | |
| 242 | Because it's the real engine of this entire story. | 因为它是整个故事的真正引擎. |
| 243 | Not taste, not instinct, not even individual cleverness. | 没有品味,没有本能,甚至没有个人的聪明. |
| 244 | The thing that actually kept the species alive was transmission. | 真正维持物种生命的是传播。 |
| 245 | The passing of knowledge from one mind to the next, | 知识从一个心灵传到另一个心灵 |
| 246 | accurately, repeatedly, across enormous spans of time. | 准确地,反复地,跨过巨大的时间跨度。 |
| 247 | Think about what a human group actually was in this light. | 想想在这个光线下 人类群体究竟是什么 |
| 248 | It was a living library. | 这是一个活的图书馆。 |
| 249 | An elder in a hunter-gatherer band wasn't just an old person. | 猎人加瑟尔乐队的长者不仅仅是个老人 |
| 250 | They were a database. | 他们是一个数据库。 |
| 251 | They carried in their memory the identity of hundreds of plants. | 他们在记忆中携带了上百种植物的身份. |
| 252 | Which ones fed you? | 哪个喂你的? |
| 253 | Which ones healed you? | 哪一个治愈了你? |
| 254 | Which ones killed you? | 哪一个杀了你? |
| 255 | Which looked safe but weren't? | 哪个看起来很安全,但是没有? |
| 256 | Which were safe only in spring, or only once cooked, | 在春天才安全,或者只煮过一次 |
| 257 | or only if you threw the first water away? | 或者如果你扔掉第一个水? |
| 258 | Which mushroom was dinner? | 哪个蘑菇是晚餐? |
| 259 | And which mushroom was the one that took your cousin 30 years ago? | 哪个蘑菇是30年前带走你表哥的? |
| 260 | That knowledge had no backup. | 这种知识没有备份。 |
| 261 | It existed in living heads and in spoken words, | 它存在于活生生的脑袋和口语中, |
| 262 | and absolutely nowhere else. | 绝对没有别的地方 |
| 263 | Which means every time an elder died before passing it on, | 也就是说每次老人去世前 |
| 264 | a piece of the library burned. | 图书馆的一块被烧了 |
| 265 | This is why ancient cultures treated their elders the way they did. | 这就是为什么古代文化对待他们的长者的方式。 |
| 266 | And why so many wrapped this knowledge in story, in ritual, in song. | 为什么这么多人在故事、仪式、歌词中 将这种知识包裹在一起。 |
| 267 | Because a dry list of 300 plants is almost impossible to remember. | 因为300种植物的干燥列表几乎是记不得的. |
| 268 | But a story, a song, a vivid warning with a frightening character in it that sticks. | 但一个故事,一首歌, 一个生动的警告, 里面有一个可怕的角色 粘着。 |
| 269 | Culture wasn't decoration laid on top of survival. | 文化不是以生存为重的装饰 |
| 270 | Culture was the storage medium. | 文化是存储媒介。 |
| 271 | The myths and the taboos and the songs were the hard drive, | 神话和禁忌 和歌曲是硬盘, |
| 272 | and the format was chosen over thousands of years. | 并且该格式是在数千年中选择的。 |
| 273 | Precisely because it was the format a human brain could actually keep. | 正是因为它是人类大脑可以保留的形式。 |
| 274 | When a culture said, | 当一个文化说, |
| 275 | this plant is sacred and may only be touched after this ritual, | 这种植物是神圣的 只有在仪式之后才能被触摸 |
| 276 | that wasn't superstition getting in the way of practicality. | 迷信不会妨碍实用性 |
| 277 | Very often, that was practicality. | 通常,这是实际可行的。 |
| 278 | Encoded in the only language that could survive the centuries. | 以唯一能够生存下来的语言编码 |
| 279 | And this is the thing I really want you to feel. | 这就是我真正想要你感受到的。 |
| 280 | There was no shortcut. | 没有捷径 |
| 281 | Every single safe food you take for granted was paid for. | 每一份你认为是理所当然的安全食品都是付费的. |
| 282 | Somebody, somewhere, was the first to find out that this was poison, | 有人,在某处, 第一个发现这是毒药, |
| 283 | and they usually found out by dying. | 他们通常通过死亡来发现。 |
| 284 | The knowledge that a particular berry is deadly | 明知某种莓汁是致命的 |
| 285 | is not free information that was always just lying around. | 并非自由的信息 总是停留在身边。 |
| 286 | It is the fossilized memory of a real person's death, | 这是真实人的死亡的化石记忆, |
| 287 | carried forward by the people who loved them | 被爱着他们的人所继承 |
| 288 | and didn't want it to happen again. | 不想再发生这种事 |
| 289 | Your safe, boring grocery store, with its labels and its certainty, | 你的安全,无聊的杂货店, 及其标签和它的确定性, |
| 290 | sits on top of an invisible cemetery of people who tested the world | 坐在一个隐形墓园的顶端 里面是检验世界的人 |
| 291 | with their own bodies so that, eventually, you wouldn't have to. | 和他们自己的身体 这样,最终,你不用。 |
| 292 | Now, I want to be honest about something the way I always try to be. | 现在,我想诚实 的东西,我总是尝试。 |
| 293 | We tend to tell this story as a triumph, and it is. | 我们倾向于把这个故事说成是胜利,而它是胜利。 |
| 294 | But the system was not perfect, and pretending it was | 但这个系统并不完美,假装它 |
| 295 | does a disservice to how hard it actually was. | 伤害了它是多么艰难。 |
| 296 | Mushrooms, in particular, were and remain a nightmare, | 特别是蘑菇过去和现在都是噩梦, |
| 297 | because some of the deadliest ones look almost identical to safe ones, | 因为有些最致命的看起来 几乎与安全的一样, |
| 298 | and the deadliest of all, like the aptly named Death Cap, | 和最致命的, 象一个叫死亡帽, |
| 299 | taste fine, sit easy in your stomach, let you go to sleep feeling fine, | 味道很好,坐在你的胃里放松, 让你去睡觉感觉很好, |
| 300 | and then destroy your liver over the following days, | 然后在接下来的日子里摧毁你的肝脏 |
| 301 | long after the meal is forgotten. | 饭后很久就被遗忘了 |
| 302 | There is no instinct that catches that. | 没有什么直觉能抓住它。 |
| 303 | Bitterness doesn't warn you. | 苦恼不会警告你 |
| 304 | Disgust doesn't warn you. | 恶心不警告你。 |
| 305 | The small dose test fails, because the dose that kills you is small, | 小剂量测试失败了 因为杀死你的剂量很小 |
| 306 | and the symptoms are delayed. | 症状被推迟了 |
| 307 | This is exactly the kind of threat that pure instinct cannot solve, | 这正是纯粹本能无法解决的威胁 |
| 308 | and it's exactly why the cultural knowledge mattered so much. | 这正是文化知识 如此重要的原因。 |
| 309 | The only defense against the Death Cap was someone, generations ago, | 唯一能防御死亡帽的人 几代人之前 |
| 310 | learning to recognize it on sight and teaching everyone else to fear it, specifically. | 学习在眼前认出它 并教别人害怕它,特别是。 |
| 311 | Where that teaching held, people lived. | 教书的地方,人们住。 |
| 312 | Where it broke. | 断之处. |
| 313 | Where a group was displaced. | 一个群体流离失所的地方。 |
| 314 | Or migrated to a new land with unfamiliar species. | 或以陌生的物种迁移到新地方。 |
| 315 | Or lost its elders too fast. | 或失其长者过速. |
| 316 | People died. | 人们死了。 |
| 317 | Moving to a new environment was genuinely dangerous, | 进入新的环境是真正危险的, |
| 318 | because your entire inherited food map was suddenly wrong. | 因为你所有继承的食物地图都突然错了 |
| 319 | The plants were different. | 这些植物是不同的。 |
| 320 | The library didn't cover this section, | 图书馆没有覆盖这个部分, |
| 321 | and you had to start writing it again in the old currency. | 你不得不重新用旧货币写出来 |
| 322 | So when you zoom all the way out, | 所以,当你放大所有的方式, |
| 323 | what were ancient humans actually doing every day for 300,000 years? | 30万年来 古人类每天做什么? |
| 324 | They were running the longest continuous research program in human history. | 他们运行着人类历史上最长的连续研究计划. |
| 325 | No funding. | 没有资金。 |
| 326 | No labs. | 没有实验室。 |
| 327 | No publication. | 无刊. |
| 328 | Just observation, experiment, memory, and transmission, | 只是观察、实验、记忆和传输 |
| 329 | repeated across 10,000 generations. | 遍及一万代人间 |
| 330 | They isolated variables. | 他们隔离了变量。 |
| 331 | They ran trials. | 他们进行了审判。 |
| 332 | They recorded results in the only medium they had, which was each other. | 他们记录了他们唯一的媒介,也就是彼此。 |
| 333 | They built, collectively, | 他们集体建造, |
| 334 | an astonishingly accurate body of practical pharmacology and nutrition, | 一个惊人的准确的 实用药理学和营养体, |
| 335 | and they did it without writing a word of it down. | 他们没有写一个字就做了 |
| 336 | We call them primitive. | 我们称之为原始的。 |
| 337 | They were running science. | 他们运行科学。 |
| 338 | They just published their findings in songs | 他们刚在歌曲中发表了自己的发现 |
| 339 | and paid their research costs in lives. | 并付出了他们的研究代价 |
| 340 | And here's where it comes back to you. | 且道这里归汝. |
| 341 | Sitting wherever you're sitting right now. | 随所坐处而坐. |
| 342 | The next time you eat something, anything, | 下次你吃东西,什么都行 |
| 343 | the most ordinary snack imaginable, | 最普通的点心, |
| 344 | I want you to notice that you did not have to wonder if it would kill you. | 我想让你注意 你不必怀疑它会不会杀了你 |
| 345 | You reached out and you ate with total unthinking confidence. | 你伸出手,你吃 完全没有信心。 |
| 346 | That confidence is not natural. | 这种信心并不自然。 |
| 347 | That confidence is the single greatest inheritance | 这种自信是最大的遗产 |
| 348 | your species has ever handed down. | 你的物种 曾经放弃。 |
| 349 | It is the end product of an unbroken chain of human beings. | 它是人类连锁连锁的产物。 |
| 350 | Stretching back further than you can picture, | 伸缩得比想象的还远 |
| 351 | every one of them paying attention, | 他们中的每一个人,都要注意。 |
| 352 | remembering, and telling the next person what they learned. | 记得,告诉下一个人 他们学到了什么。 |
| 353 | You are the living edge of that chain. | 你是铁链的边缘 |
| 354 | The knowledge reached you. | 知识到达了你。 |
| 355 | It made it. | 它来了。 |
| 356 | Across all that time, across all those deaths, | 在这段时间里,在所有这些死亡, |
| 357 | the message got through, mouth to ear, | 消息通过,嘴到耳朵, |
| 358 | all the way to you, and the message was simple. | 对你来说,信息很简单。 |
| 359 | This one's safe. | 这个很安全 |
| 360 | We checked. | 我们查过了 |
| 361 | So you wouldn't have to. | 这样你就不用了 |
| 362 | So here's my question for you. | 我问你个问题 |
| 363 | If you had to start over in a forest you'd never seen, | 如果你不得不重新开始 在森林你从来没有见过, |
| 364 | with no labels and no certainty, | 没有标签,也没有确定性, |
| 365 | do you think you'd survive long enough to learn? | 你觉得你能活得够久吗? |
| 366 | Let me know in the comments. | 在评论中告诉我。 |
| 367 | Until then, take care of yourselves and eat something today, | 在那之前 照顾好自己 今天吃点东西 |
| 368 | knowing exactly how much it costs to make it safe. | 确切地知道要花多少钱才能安全 |
| 369 | I'll see you soon. | 后见. |
该视频共有字幕 370 条。解锁更多字幕为会员功能,请移动到 价格
