推荐微信扫码登录以获得更好的体验!另:🎉建议更新到最新版,以体验新功能!🎉 版本更新记录→

【TED演讲】人类的最佳饮食是什么?

【TED演讲】人类的最佳饮食是什么?

【TED演讲】人类的最佳饮食是什么?

发布于 2025-12-30 · 时长 19:12

字幕摘录

时间英文中文
0:16This is me ten years ago.这是我十年前。
0:19I weighed 40 pounds more than today, and like many people, I wanted to lose weight.我比今天重40磅 像很多人一样 我想减肥
0:26Like many people, I wanted to know what is the best diet for humans.和许多人一样,我想知道什么是人类最好的饮食。
0:32Many of us actually have an opinion about this question.我们许多人实际上对这个问题有看法。
0:36Some believe that a low-fat plant-based diet is the best.一些人认为低脂植物的饮食是最好的.
0:39Others that a low-carb diet rich in protein and animal fat is the best.另一些人认为低碳食物中富含蛋白质和动物脂肪是最佳的.
0:45Others have opinions on how much sugar we should eat, or how much salt, cholesterol, saturated fat for eggs or dairy products we should have in our diet.其他人对我们应该吃多少糖, 或盐,胆固醇,饱和脂肪 对于鸡蛋或奶制品, 我们应该在我们的饮食。
0:56But the question of what the best diet is, is a scientific one.但是,什么是最好的饮食问题, 是一个科学问题。
1:01So there should be no room for opinions or beliefs.因此,不应该有意见和信仰的余地。
1:05If diet A is really better than diet B, then a study that compares the two on enough people should show that definitively.如果A节食真的比B节食更好, 那么一项研究,如果把两者比作足够多的人, 就会明确表明这一点。
展开字幕全文(173 条)
序号英文中文
1This is me ten years ago.这是我十年前。
2I weighed 40 pounds more than today, and like many people, I wanted to lose weight.我比今天重40磅 像很多人一样 我想减肥
3Like many people, I wanted to know what is the best diet for humans.和许多人一样,我想知道什么是人类最好的饮食。
4Many of us actually have an opinion about this question.我们许多人实际上对这个问题有看法。
5Some believe that a low-fat plant-based diet is the best.一些人认为低脂植物的饮食是最好的.
6Others that a low-carb diet rich in protein and animal fat is the best.另一些人认为低碳食物中富含蛋白质和动物脂肪是最佳的.
7Others have opinions on how much sugar we should eat, or how much salt, cholesterol, saturated fat for eggs or dairy products we should have in our diet.其他人对我们应该吃多少糖, 或盐,胆固醇,饱和脂肪 对于鸡蛋或奶制品, 我们应该在我们的饮食。
8But the question of what the best diet is, is a scientific one.但是,什么是最好的饮食问题, 是一个科学问题。
9So there should be no room for opinions or beliefs.因此,不应该有意见和信仰的余地。
10If diet A is really better than diet B, then a study that compares the two on enough people should show that definitively.如果A节食真的比B节食更好, 那么一项研究,如果把两者比作足够多的人, 就会明确表明这一点。
11No opinions, no beliefs, just hard data, right?没有意见,没有信仰,只是硬数据,对不对?
12What is also clear is that if the best diet does exist, then we haven't yet found it.同样清楚的是,如果最好的饮食确实存在,那么我们还没有找到.
13Because the incidence of diet-related disease has increased dramatically in the past several decades.因为与饮食有关的疾病在过去几十年中急剧增加。
14Now, you might think it's because people don't listen to what we tell them.现在,你可能认为那是因为 人们不听我们的话。
15But in fact, that's not true.但事实上,这不是真的。
16People actually generally do follow dietary guidelines.人们通常都遵循饮食准则。
17But according to the Center for Disease Control, if you live in the United States,但据疾病控制中心说 如果你住在美国
18there's over a 70% chance that you're either overweight, diabetic or have non-alcoholic fatty liver disease.70%以上的概率 要么你超重,糖尿病 或者有非酒精脂肪肝病。
19And there's overwhelming evidence that diet and lifestyle are major drivers of these conditions.绝大多数证据表明,饮食和生活方式是造成这些状况的主要因素。
20So why is it that after so much research, we still don't have an answer to the seemingly simple question of what is the best diet for humans?那么,为什么经过这么多的研究, 我们仍然没有一个答案 似乎简单的问题, 什么是对人类最好的饮食?
21What I'd like to propose to you today is that the reason we don't have an answer is because we've been asking the wrong question.今天我想向大家提出,我们没有答案的原因是我们一直问错问题.
22And it's the wrong question because it assumes that the best diet depends only on the food and not on the person eating it.而这个问题是错误的,因为它假设最好的饮食只取决于食物,而不是吃食物的人.
23But what if differences in our genetics, lifestyle or gut bacteria cause us to respond differently to food?但是,如果我们的基因、生活方式或肠道细菌的差异 导致我们对食物的反应不同呢?
24What if these differences explain why some diets work for some people, but not for others?如果这些差异解释了为什么某些饮食对一些人有效,而对另一些人却无效呢?
25What if our nutrition needs to be personally tailored to our unique makeup?如果我们的营养需要 适应我们独特的化妆品呢?
26This is exactly the question we set out to ask in our own research,这正是我们在自己的研究中要问的问题
27which I did with my colleague, Aron Elinov, and several graduate students from the Weizmann Institute of Science.我和同事Aron Elinov 以及魏茨曼科学学院的几个研究生一起做了这些
28To take a scientific approach, we first search for a metric of healthy nutrition that we should study.为了采取科学方法,我们首先要寻找我们应当研究的健康营养的尺度。
29Most studies examine weight loss or risk of heart disease after some diet.大多数研究都研究了一些饮食后的体重减退或心脏病风险.
30But the problem is that these are affected by many factors unrelated to diet.但问题是,这些因素受到与饮食无关的许多因素的影响。
31They take many weeks to change.它们需要很多周的时间才能改变。
32And in the end, you get a single measure of success.最后,你得到一个衡量成功的标准。
33And if it didn't work, well, then it's very hard to understand why.如果失败了 那很难理解为什么
34And so instead, we searched for a metric that would still be relevant for weight management and diet-related disease,因此,我们寻找一个指标 仍然与体重管理 和与饮食有关的疾病有关,
35but one that we could also easily and accurately measure across many people.但我们也可以轻松准确地测量到许多人。
36And this led us to focus on blood glucose levels and, more precisely, changes in blood glucose levels after a meal.这导致我们关注血糖水平, 更确切地说,一顿饭后血糖水平的变化。
37We call this a meal glucose response.我们称之为食糖反应。
38Why is it important?为什么重要?
39Well, because high glucose levels after a meal promote both hunger and weight gain.因为一顿饭后葡萄糖含量高 既会增加饥饿又会增加体重
40After we eat, our body digests the carbohydrates in the food into simple sugars and releases them into the bloodstream.进食后,我们的身体将食物中的碳水化合物消化成简单的糖,然后放入血液.
41From there, with the help of insulin, cells throughout our body remove the glucose from the blood so that they can use it as a source of energy.从那里,在胰岛素的帮助下,我们整个体内的细胞从血液中去除葡萄糖,以便它们能用作能量的来源.
42But insulin also signals our body to convert excess sugar into fat and store it.但胰岛素也表示我们的身体会将过量的糖转化为脂肪并储存.
43And that's a primary way by which we gain weight.这就是我们增加体重的主要方法。
44In addition, fast flow of glucose into the blood often causes our body to release too much insulin,此外,葡萄糖快速流入血液 常常导致我们的身体释放过多的胰岛素,
45which could lower our glucose levels to below baseline, making us feel hungry and eat more.它会让我们的葡萄糖水平降低到低于基线, 使我们感到饥饿和吃得更多。
46Meal glucose responses are also very relevant for our health because they've been shown to be risk factors for obesity,食用葡萄糖反应对我们的健康也非常重要 因为它们被证明是肥胖的风险因素
47diabetes, cardiovascular disease and other metabolic disorders.糖尿病、心血管疾病和其他代谢障碍。
48A recent study that followed 2,000 people for over 30 years found that higher meal glucose levels after meals predict overall higher mortality.最近一项跟踪2000人30多年的研究发现,膳食后的葡萄糖含量较高,预言总体死亡率较高。
49Finally, and not least important, with recent technological advances, we can now follow a person's glucose levels continuously for an entire week.最后,同样重要的是,随着最近的技术进步,我们现在可以连续一周跟踪一个人的葡萄糖水平。
50And since the average person eats around 50 meals a week, it allows us to measure glucose responses to 50 meals in just a single week.由于一般人每周吃50顿左右的饭, 它让我们可以测量葡萄糖对一周内50顿饭的反应。
51Meal glucose responses also provide us with a way to directly measure the effect of every single meal,食糖反应也为我们提供了直接测量每餐效果的方法,
52as opposed to common approaches that only evaluate the effect of an overall diet.而不是仅仅评价总体饮食效果的共同办法。
53Now, of course, there are many factors beyond glucose levels that influence a healthy diet.当然,除了葡萄糖水平之外,还有许多因素影响着健康的饮食。
54But this is a very important one, and solving it can be a major step forward.但这是一个非常重要的问题,解决它可以成为向前迈出的重要一步。
55Luckily for us, we managed to convince 1,000 healthy people in this idea,幸运的是,我们说服了1000个健康人
56and we connected them to one of these small glucose sensors and tracked their glucose levels continuously for an entire week.我们把它们连接到一个小的葡萄糖感应器上 连续一周跟踪它们的葡萄糖水平
57And during that week, participants logged everything that they ate on a mobile app that we developed.在那个星期里, 参与者记录了他们吃的所有东西 在我们开发的移动应用程序上。
58And so that allowed us to measure glucose responses to 50 different meals for each person and around 50,000 different meals across all 1,000 participants,这样我们就能测量葡萄糖对每人50种不同膳食的反应, 以及所有1000名参与者约50,000种不同膳食的反应,
59making our study the largest one that was ever done on this problem until today.我们的研究是迄今为止 最大的研究
60So what did we find?我们发现了什么?
61Well, when we looked at averages, we saw trends.嗯,当我们看平均,我们看到趋势。
62For example, more carbohydrates in the meal generally increase the response.例如,食物中更多的碳水化合物一般会增加反应.
63This is not so surprising.这并不奇怪。
64Another, perhaps more surprising trend is that more fat in the meal generally decreased the response.另一种可能更令人惊讶的趋势是,餐中脂肪含量的增加一般会降低反应.
65But, and this is the key finding of our study, for every trend we found, there were many people who were very different from it.但是,这是我们研究的关键发现, 对于我们发现的每一种趋势, 有许多人都与它截然不同。
66Basically, when the same person ate the same meal on different days, the response was very similar.基本上,当同一个人在不同的日子吃同一顿饭时,反应非常相似.
67But when different people ate the same meal, the response was very different.但当不同的人吃同一顿饭时,反应非常不同.
68For example, white bread induced almost no effect on the blood sugar levels of some people.例如,白面包几乎不会对一些人的血糖水平产生影响。
69But in others, it induced huge spikes.但是,在另一些情况下,它引起了巨大的尖锐。
70And the same was true for every single food we tested, including rice, pizza, sushi and even chocolate.我们测试的每份食品同样如此, 包括大米,披萨,寿司,甚至巧克力。
71For every food, there were some people who had low responses, others who had medium responses, and yet others that had very high responses.对每种食物来说,有的响应率很低,有的响应率中等,有的响应率很高。
72It wasn't just about the food.不只是食物的问题
73It was also about the person eating it.也是关于吃它的人
74So while averages and trends are informative for any given individual, they may not mean much.因此,对于任何个人来说,虽然平均值和趋势是翔实的,但它们可能意义不大。
75Now, it wasn't just about how good the body was at handling sugar.现在,这不仅仅是关于 身体有多好 处理糖。
76Each person had different foods that spiked his levels.每个人的食物都不同 使得他的水平上升。
77Some people even had opposite responses.有些人甚至有相反的反应。
78For example, some people spiked for ice cream, but not for rice.例如,有些人为冰淇淋而尖锐,但不是米饭。
79But then others spiked for rice and not for ice cream.但后来其他人为了米而不是冰激凌而猛增.
80In fact, more people spiked for rice than for ice cream.事实上,比起冰激凌,更多的人喜欢吃米饭。
81Now, my wife is a clinical dietitian.我妻子是临床饮食学家
82So when I showed her this data, she was shocked because as a practitioner, she, of course, relies on general dietary guidelines.所以当我向她展示这个数据时,她很震惊, 因为作为一个医生,她当然依赖于一般的饮食指导。
83And so one of the first things that she tells her many newly diagnosed pre-diabetics is to stop eating foods such as ice cream and instead eat more complex carbohydrates such as brown rice.所以,她首先告诉她的许多新诊断的糖尿病前药之一,就是停止食用冰激凌等食物,而是吃更复杂的碳水化合物,如棕米.
84So as soon as she saw our data, she, of course, realized that for most of her patients, not only does her dietary advice not help,所以,当她看到我们的数据, 她当然意识到, 对于她的大多数病人, 不仅她的饮食建议没有帮助,
85but in fact, it pushes them faster to develop the very same disease that her advice was meant to prevent.但事实上,它促使他们更快地 发展出她建议要预防的疾病
86So these results of ours on such a large data set convinced us that responses to food are personal因此,这些我们的结果 在如此庞大的数据集 使我们相信,对食物的反应是个人的
87and that diets that maintain normal blood glucose levels must therefore be personally tailored to the individual.因此,保持正常血糖水平的饮食必须针对个人。
88They also show, in our view, why the current nutritional paradigm that searches for that one best diet is inherently flawed.我们认为,它们还表明,为什么目前寻找最佳饮食的营养模式本身就有缺陷。
89The best diet for humans does not exist.人类最好的饮食并不存在.
90Our responses to food are personal, so our dietary advice must also be personal.我们对食物的反应是针对个人的,所以我们的饮食建议也必须针对个人.
91And personalized dietary advice was our next challenge.而个性化的饮食建议 是下一个挑战。
92To tackle it, we measured many parameters across participants that we thought may explain people's variability in glucose response to meals.为了解决这个问题,我们测量了参与者中的许多参数,我们认为这些参数可以解释人们在食用葡萄糖反应中的变异性.
93And these included basic metrics and lifestyle factors like age, weight, height and physical activity,其中包括基本的衡量尺度和生活方式因素,如年龄、体重、身高和体育活动,
94but also blood tests, medical background and food frequency questionnaires,血液检测、医学背景和食物频率调查表,
95and also DNA sequencing of both the human genome and the gut bacteria composition of each person.还有DNA测序 人类基因组 和每个人的肠道细菌组成。
96Now, of these, the gut bacteria was perhaps the most novel component that we examined.其中,肠道细菌 也许是我们研究过的最新颖的成分。
97For hundreds of years, we know that bacteria live within our body,几百年来 我们知道细菌存在于体内
98but only with recent advances in DNA sequencing could we begin to study them extensively.但只有随着DNA测序的最新进展 我们才能开始广泛研究它们
99And when we did, we found that this vast collection of hundreds of different species that we each host,当我们这样做,我们发现 这个庞大的集合 数百种不同的物种 我们每个东道主,
100collectively termed our microbiome, has a major impact on our health and disease.统称为我们的微生物对我们的健康和疾病有重大影响。
101And what makes the microbiome even more exciting is that unlike our genetics,更令人兴奋的是 与我们的基因不同
102we can also change it even by simple means such as changing what we eat.我们还可以改变它 即使是简单的方法,比如改变我们的食物。
103Our bacteria help us digest some of the food that we eat and in turn produce molecules that are taken by our own cells and affect our physiology.我们的细菌帮助我们消化一些我们食用的食物,进而产生一些分子,这些分子被我们自己的细胞带走,并影响我们的生理.
104For example, in our own research, we studied artificial sweeteners,例如,在我们的研究中,我们研究了人工甜化剂,
105which the vast majority of us consume on a daily basis in various diet soda drinks and other products.我们绝大多数人每天在各种食用汽水饮料和其他产品中消费。
106And we found that consumption of artificial sweeteners alters the composition of the gut bacteria,我们发现人工甜化剂的消耗 改变了肠道细菌的成分,
107such that when transferred into mice, causes the mice to develop symptoms of diabetes.导致小鼠出现糖尿病症状
108And so this and several other studies led us to ask whether the microbiome would also be important for explaining people's glucose variability in response to meals.因此,这个研究和其他几项研究 促使我们问,微生物体对于解释人们的葡萄糖变异性 对食物的反应是否也很重要。
109And so we took this microbiome and other clinical data that we collected,于是我们收集了微生物群和其他临床数据
110and we used advanced machine learning algorithms to automatically search for rules that predict personalized glucose responses to meals.我们用先进的机器学习算法 来自动搜索 预测个性化葡萄糖对膳食反应的规则
111For example, one such rule could be that if you're over 50 and you have a certain bacterial species, then your response to a banana will be high.例如,一个这样的规则可能是,如果你超过50, 你有一个特定的细菌物种, 那你对香蕉的反应会很高。
112The overall algorithm combined tens of thousands of such rules that it automatically deduced from the data.总体算法结合了数以万计的这类规则,从数据中自动推导出来.
113This approach is actually similar to how websites like Amazon make book recommendations,这个方法实际上类似于亚马逊等网站如何提出书籍建议,
114except that we applied it to how people respond to food.只是我们把它应用到 人们如何回应食物。
115And we could show that this algorithm could then take any person, even people who are not part of our original study,我们可以证明,这个算法可以 带走任何人,甚至那些不属于我们最初研究的人,
116and predict the response to arbitrary meals with high accuracy.并准确预测对任意餐的反应。
117So as a final step, we asked whether we can also use this algorithm to design personalized diets that normalize blood glucose levels.作为最后一步,我们问我们是否可以使用这个算法来设计个性化的饮食,使血糖水平正常化。
118So we recruited and profiled new participants, and we asked the algorithm to predict two diets for each person.于是我们招聘了新的参与者, 并描述了新的参与者, 我们要求算法 预测每个人的饮食。
119In one diet, which we call the bad diet, we asked the algorithm to predict foods for which that person would have high responses.在一种我们称之为不良饮食的饮食中,我们要求算法来预测那个人会有高反应的食物.
120And in the other good diet, we asked it to predict foods for which that person would have low responses.在另一种良好的饮食中,我们要求它预测 哪些食物会低反应。
121And each person then followed each diet for one week.然后每个人都跟随每次饮食 一个星期。
122Now, by design, the diets had to be identical in calories.现在,从设计上讲, 饮食的卡路里是相同的。
123In fact, all breakfast, lunches and dinners had the same calories on different days.事实上,所有的早餐,午餐和晚餐在不同的日子里都有同样的卡路里.
124And it's also important to note that each person received a different personalized diet同样重要的是要注意 每个人的个性化饮食
125and that there were even some foods that were given to some people on their good diet, but to others on their bad diet.甚至有些食物 被给予一些人的 良好的饮食, 而其他人的不良饮食。
126Now, to show you that these diets are not the obvious ones you might think of, here they are for one of our participants.现在,为了向大家展示,这些饮食并不是你们可能想到的明显食物, 在这里,它们是为了我们的一位参与者。
127Now, take a moment and see if you can guess for yourself which one the algorithm predicted to be the good diet现在,花点时间,看看能不能自己猜一下 算法预测哪一个是好饮食
128and which to be the bad diet for this particular participant.这对这个参与者来说是糟糕的饮食。
129And as you look at these, notice that each diet contains foods that would not typically appear in standard diets.当你看这些东西时,请注意, 每种饮食都含有通常不会出现在标准饮食中的食物。
130And now for fun, let's play a quick guessing game.为了好玩,我们来玩个猜谜游戏
131And you all have to participate.你们都必须参加
132So raise your hand if you think the diet on the right is the good one.所以举手 如果你认为右边的饮食是好的。
133OK, now raise your hand if you think the diet on the left is the good one.好吧,现在举手 如果你认为左边的饮食是好的。
134OK, definitely we see nearly a 50-50 split here showing you that it's definitely not trivial to guess.好吧,我们肯定看到 将近50 -50分在这里 显示它绝对不是小猜。
135And I can tell you that for this participant, the algorithm predicted the diet on the right,我可以告诉你, 对于这个参与者, 算法预测 饮食在右边,
136the one with the ice cream, to be the good one.冰激凌的那个 做个好人
137And so now the only question is how good did these diets work?所以,现在唯一的问题是 这些饮食效果如何?
138And what I'll show you next is in our view perhaps the most striking result that came out of our study.接下来我要给你们看的是 我们的研究中 最引人注目的结果
139So here are the continuous glucose levels of this participant when following the bad diet.这就是这个参与者在跟踪不良饮食时的连续葡萄糖水平。
140And you can clearly see abnormally high glucose levels after meals,餐后可以明显看到异常高的葡萄糖含量,
141indicating that this participant has impaired glucose tolerance and is likely pre-diabetic.表明该参与者已损害葡萄糖耐受性,并可能具有糖尿病前性。
142But on the good diet, the one with the ice cream and the same amount of calories as the bad diet,但是,在良好的饮食, 冰激凌和同样量的卡路里与不良的饮食,
143this same pre-diabetic participant achieves fully normal blood glucose levels血糖水平完全正常
144without even a single spike across the entire week.整个星期里连一分钱都没有
145Obviously, we were very happy to find out these results.显然,我们很高兴知道这些结果。
146And in fact, we found similar results for most participants for which we designed personalized diets using our algorithm.事实上,我们为大多数参与者找到了类似的结果, 我们用我们的算法设计了个性化饮食。
147Now, not only that, but the good diet also induced several consistent changes in the gut bacteria of most participants.现在,不仅如此,良好的饮食 也导致了大多数参与者的肠道细菌 发生了几处一致的变化。
148And it seemed that these changes were beneficial because bacteria that in other studies were associated with good outcomes这些变化似乎是有益的 因为在其他研究中细菌与良好结果有关
149tended to increase after the good diet and bacteria associated with disease tended to decrease.在良好的饮食和与疾病有关的细菌减少之后,病情趋于增加。
150And this result is, of course, very intriguing because it suggests that in addition当然,这一结果非常有趣,因为它表明,除此之外
151to normalizing blood glucose levels during the intervention week,在干预周内使血糖水平正常化,
152the good diet also induced beneficial effects that may persist even beyond the intervention week.良好的饮食也带来了有益的影响,甚至可能持续到干预周之后。
153So what's the take home message from all of this?那么,什么是回家的消息 从这一切?
154Well, based on the glucose responses variability that we saw across 1000 people,根据我们所看到的1000人的葡萄糖反应变异性
155our conclusion is that there is no single best diet for humans because we are all too different.我们的结论是,人类没有单一的最佳饮食,因为我们太不同了。
156It also means that if a certain diet hasn't worked for you, then maybe it was the wrong diet for you.这也意味着,如果某种饮食对你没有效果,那么也许这对你来说是错误的饮食.
157Your dietary failures may not be your fault.你的饮食衰竭可能不是你的错。
158Your diet may have failed simply because it did not take information about you as an individual into account.你的饮食可能失败了 只是因为它没有考虑你个人的信息
159So what can you do with this information now?你现在能拿这些信息做什么?
160Well, right now, you can actually measure your personal glucose responses to your favorite meals好了,现在,你实际上可以测量 你的个人葡萄糖反应 你最喜欢的食物
161using simple glucose devices that you can buy at your local drugstore.使用简单的葡萄糖设备,可以在当地药店购买.
162And I guarantee that you'll be surprised at which foods personally spike your glucose levels and which do not.我保证你会惊讶的是 哪些食物会令你的葡萄糖含量上升 哪些不会
163As a more complete solution, we are working hard to make our algorithms available to everyone作为一个更完整的解决方案,我们正在努力 向每个人提供我们的算法
164so that you'll be able from your home to provide basic clinical information about yourself,这样你就能从家里 提供自己的基本临床信息
165send a sample of your microbiome and in return receive personalized dietary advice.提供你的微生物样本,然后得到个性化的饮食建议。
166We are also starting longer term dietary intervention studies in both pre-diabetics and diabetics that will go on for a full year我们还在进行长期饮食干预研究 包括糖尿病和糖尿病前的治疗, 持续一年
167because we believe that if the effect of normalizing blood glucose levels that we were able to obtain in one week因为我们相信 如果血液糖浓度正常化 一周内我们就能得到
168could persist for a longer time period, then we might be able to reverse and even cure these conditions,可能会持续更长的时间 这样我们就能扭转甚至治愈这些状况
169which constitute one of the worst epidemics of our times.这是当代最严重的流行病之一。
170More broadly, I believe that we are entering a new era in the study of nutrition,更广泛地说,我认为我们正在进入一个研究营养的新时代,
171one in which we will move away from asking what is the best diet for humans我们不再问什么是人类最好的饮食
172and instead focus on the more appropriate question of what is the best diet for me.转而关注一个更合适的问题, 什么是对我最好的饮食。
173Thank you very much.谢谢
该视频共有字幕 173 条。解锁更多字幕为会员功能,请移动到 价格