如何识别有毒的人|UBC心理学教授
共 2 集
剧集目录
| 集 | 标题 | 时长 |
|---|---|---|
| P1 | 如何识别有毒的人|UBC心理学教授 上 | 45:17 |
| P2 | 如何识别有毒的人|UBC心理学教授 下 | 59:55 |
P1 · 如何识别有毒的人|UBC心理学教授 p01 上 (P1)
字幕摘录
| 时间 | 英文 | 中文 |
|---|---|---|
| 0:00 | How long does it take someone to spot a psychopath? | 要多久才能发现一个精神病人? |
| 0:02 | About five seconds. | 大约5秒钟。 |
| 0:04 | So most people think a psychopath looks dangerous. | 所以大多数人认为一个精神病人看起来很危险。 |
| 0:06 | They picture the villain in a movie, but that's not how it works in real life. | 他们在电影中描绘了反派,但现实生活中却不是这样. |
| 0:10 | We've done some research in my lab and we found | 我们在我的实验室做了一些研究 我们发现 |
| 0:12 | there are certainly some things that you can look for. | 肯定有一些事情你可以寻找。 |
| 0:14 | Have they ever done that with lying to figure out if people can spot lies? | 他们有没有说谎 找出人们能否发现谎言? |
| 0:18 | Thousands of times. | 数以千计. |
| 0:19 | You ask people what's the number one cue that someone is lying to you? | 你问别人谁在骗你? |
| 0:23 | They will say they can't look you in the eye, | 他们会说他们不能看你的眼睛, |
展开字幕全文(805 条)
| 序号 | 英文 | 中文 |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | How long does it take someone to spot a psychopath? | 要多久才能发现一个精神病人? |
| 2 | About five seconds. | 大约5秒钟。 |
| 3 | So most people think a psychopath looks dangerous. | 所以大多数人认为一个精神病人看起来很危险。 |
| 4 | They picture the villain in a movie, but that's not how it works in real life. | 他们在电影中描绘了反派,但现实生活中却不是这样. |
| 5 | We've done some research in my lab and we found | 我们在我的实验室做了一些研究 我们发现 |
| 6 | there are certainly some things that you can look for. | 肯定有一些事情你可以寻找。 |
| 7 | Have they ever done that with lying to figure out if people can spot lies? | 他们有没有说谎 找出人们能否发现谎言? |
| 8 | Thousands of times. | 数以千计. |
| 9 | You ask people what's the number one cue that someone is lying to you? | 你问别人谁在骗你? |
| 10 | They will say they can't look you in the eye, | 他们会说他们不能看你的眼睛, |
| 11 | but there's no research to suggest that that is true. | 但是没有研究可以证明这是真的 |
| 12 | However, there's an essential tool for detecting lies, which is... | 然而,有一个关键的工具 检测谎言,这是... |
| 13 | Oh, fuck. | 哦,他妈的。 |
| 14 | I know as I study dark personality traits, | 我知道,当我研究 黑暗的个性特征, |
| 15 | and I found that there's four different elements, | 我发现有四个不同的元素, |
| 16 | which are psychopathy, Machiavellianism, narcissism, and sadism. | 精神错乱、自恋和虐待 |
| 17 | And what we found is that people with higher levels of these traits | 而我们发现的是, 具有更高水平的这些特征的人 |
| 18 | engaged in Duchenne smiles, which is the activation around the eyes. | 参与Duchenne的微笑, 这就是激活周围的眼睛。 |
| 19 | And they also used a lot of hand gestures. | 他们也使用了很多手势. |
| 20 | Where does this come from? | 这是从哪里来的? |
| 21 | Well, research suggests that abuse, cold, uncaring, parenting style, | 研究表明 虐待 冷漠 冷漠 养育子女 |
| 22 | but also overvaluation of a child early in life | 儿童早期的估价 |
| 23 | may lead to more narcissistic views later. | 以后可能会产生更多的自恋情绪。 |
| 24 | Is there any other fascinating questions you've pursued in your lab? | 你实验室里还有别的问题吗? |
| 25 | Yes. | 对 |
| 26 | We studied the extent to which psychopathic personality traits | 我们研究了精神病人的个性特征 |
| 27 | could increase the amount of influence you have in government. | 可能会增加你对政府的影响 |
| 28 | And also there are three common mistakes people make | 还有三个常见的错误 |
| 29 | when dealing with dark personalities. | 当处理黑暗人格。 |
| 30 | We'll get into this more later. | 我们以后再谈这个 |
| 31 | And I'm wondering if you can spot any of these dark personality traits | 我想知道你能不能发现这些黑暗的个性特征 |
| 32 | just by looking at dating profiles. | 只是通过看约会简介。 |
| 33 | All right. | 好吧,我们走。 |
| 34 | So this is Ryan. | 这是瑞安。 |
| 35 | This feels like a red flag. | 这感觉就像一面红旗 |
| 36 | And then there's Haley. | 则有海利. |
| 37 | That would be associated with psychopathy. | 这和精神病有关 |
| 38 | OK. | 摆 |
| 39 | David is a brain surgeon. | 大卫是个脑外科医生 |
| 40 | Very impressive. | 非常令人印象深刻。 |
| 41 | But I'm seeing narcissism. | 但我看到自恋。 |
| 42 | So I guess this begs the question, | 所以我想这有点问题 |
| 43 | that if someone has those traits you've described, can they be cured? | 如果有人有你描述的特质 他们能被治愈吗? |
| 44 | So in my lab, what we found is that... | 所以在我的实验室里 我们发现的是... |
| 45 | This is super interesting to me. | 这对我来说太有趣了 |
| 46 | My team gave me this report to show me how many of you that watch the show subscribe. | 我的团队给了我这个报告 让我知道你们有多少人看节目 |
| 47 | And some of you have told us, according to this, | 你们中有些人告诉我们, |
| 48 | that you are unsubscribed from the channel randomly. | 表示您未从频道随机订阅。 |
| 49 | So, favour to ask all of you. | 所以,请问大家。 |
| 50 | Please could you check right now if you've hit the subscribe button, | 如果按下订阅按钮,请立刻检查一下 |
| 51 | if you are a regular viewer of the show and you like what we do here. | 如果你是节目的普通观众 你喜欢我们在这里做的事 |
| 52 | We're approaching quite a significant landmark on this show | 我们正接近这个节目的重要地标 |
| 53 | in terms of a subscriber number. | 以用户号码表示。 |
| 54 | So if there was one simple free thing that you could do to help us, | 所以,如果有一个简单的自由的事情 你可以帮助我们, |
| 55 | my team, everyone here, to keep this show free, | 我的团队,大家在这里, 保持这个节目的自由, |
| 56 | to keep it improving year over year and week over week, | 年复一年,周复一周, |
| 57 | it is just to hit that subscribe button and to double check if you've hit it. | 只需按下订阅按钮 并加倍检查是否按过了 |
| 58 | Only thing I'll ever ask of you, do we have a deal? | 我唯一要问你的,我们有协议吗? |
| 59 | If you do it, I'll tell you what I'll do. | 汝若作是语已. |
| 60 | I'll make sure every single week, every single month, | 我会确保每个星期 每个月 |
| 61 | we fight harder and harder and harder and harder | 我们更努力 更努力 更努力 |
| 62 | to bring you the guests and conversations that you want to hear. | 来给你带来宾客和你想听到的谈话 |
| 63 | I've stayed true to that promise since the very beginning of the Diary of a CEO | 自从《首席执行官日记》开始 我就一直信守诺言 |
| 64 | and I will not let you down. | 我不会让你失望的 |
| 65 | Please help us, really appreciate it. | 请帮助我们,真的很感激。 |
| 66 | Let's get on with the show. | 开展. |
| 67 | Professor Leanne Tenbrink, | 莱安·坦布林克教授 |
| 68 | at the very heart of your motivations, why is it you do what you do? | 在你的动机的核心, 为什么你做你做什么? |
| 69 | I want to make people less cynical about human nature, | 我想让人们少玩世不恭 |
| 70 | which I think might seem kind of paradoxical given what I study | 我觉得从我所研究的来看 可能有些矛盾 |
| 71 | because I study deception and dominance and so-called dark personality traits. | 因为我研究欺骗和统治 以及所谓的黑暗人格特征 |
| 72 | But I think when you understand those topics | 但我想当你明白这些话题 |
| 73 | and also that there's something you can do about it | 还有,你可以做点什么 |
| 74 | to make these interactions better, it's incredibly powerful | 为了让这些互动更好 它的力量非常强大 |
| 75 | and can give us a more accurate view of the world. | 并且能够让我们更准确地了解世界。 |
| 76 | And why are the population at large so interested in these subjects? | 为什么广大民众对这些学科如此感兴趣? |
| 77 | Because they are, they're fascinated by them. | 因为他们是, 他们迷上了他们。 |
| 78 | But what is underneath all of this sort of fascination and the curiosity, | 但是在这种迷恋和好奇心之下 |
| 79 | what are they trying to figure out when people are interested in psychopathy? | 他们想找出什么 当人们感兴趣的精神病? |
| 80 | I think one of the reasons why we are so interested in psychopathy | 我认为一个原因,为什么 我们对精神病如此感兴趣 |
| 81 | is because it's quite foreign to us. | 因为它对我们来说很陌生 |
| 82 | So most of us move through life caring about other people, | 因此我们大多数人 过着关心别人的生活 |
| 83 | having compassion for other people, telling a few lies here and there, | 同情别人, 说一些谎言在这里和那里, |
| 84 | but by and large being very truthful and honest and kind of playing by the rules. | 但总的来说,非常诚实,诚实 和那种玩弄规则。 |
| 85 | That's the opposite of psychopathy. | 这与精神病相反 |
| 86 | And so I think when you are faced with this personality | 所以我想当你面对这个性格 |
| 87 | that is quite the opposite of your whole experience of being alive, | 这与你活着的经历恰恰相反 |
| 88 | you're like, what's going on? | 你像,发生了什么事? |
| 89 | And I want to understand that. | 我想了解这一点。 |
| 90 | I think there's also an element, | 我想还有一点 |
| 91 | there actually is some research on true crime specifically | 实际上,有一些研究 真正的犯罪具体 |
| 92 | and why people are interested in true crime, | 以及人们为什么对真正的犯罪感兴趣, |
| 93 | tends to be a largely female audience. | 通常主要是女性观众. |
| 94 | And some of the motivations that people report | 以及人们报告的一些动机 |
| 95 | is wanting to understand and wanting to avoid becoming a victim of these people. | 想要理解和避免成为这些人的受害者。 |
| 96 | Is it possible to spot someone who is a psychopath? | 有没有可能发现一个精神病患者? |
| 97 | Yes. | 对 |
| 98 | How long, according to the research, does it take someone to spot a psychopath? | 根据研究,要多久才能发现精神病人? |
| 99 | Okay, you can get a kernel of truth about someone's personality, | 好吧,你可以得到一个内核 关于某人的个性, |
| 100 | the extent to which they're psychopathic, in about five seconds. | 大约五秒钟后 他们就会变得精神错乱 |
| 101 | Explain the research to me. | 跟我解释研究 |
| 102 | Okay, so this is research by Scott Lillenfeld and his colleagues. | 这是斯科特·利伦费尔德和他的同事的研究 |
| 103 | And basically what they did is they showed people five-second, | 基本上他们所做的就是 向人们展示5秒 |
| 104 | 10-second and 20-second clips of these interviews | 这些访谈的10秒和20秒短片 |
| 105 | where criminal offenders were being interviewed by a psychologist | 由心理学家采访刑事犯罪者 |
| 106 | and rated on their psychopathic personality traits. | 并被评为精神病人格特征 |
| 107 | And then you had random psychology student volunteer for research | 然后你有随机的心理学学生志愿从事研究 |
| 108 | watching five seconds of that interaction and making a rating of like, | 看着五秒钟的互动 并做出一个评级一样, |
| 109 | how callous do they seem? | 他们看起来有多冷酷? |
| 110 | How manipulative do they seem? | 他们看起来多管闲事? |
| 111 | And they found that there is actually a pretty reasonable correlation | 他们发现实际上有相当合理的关联 |
| 112 | between the ratings of these like, naive folks who watch five seconds | 在收视率之间,像, 天真的人 谁看5秒 |
| 113 | and the trained clinical psychologist who did hours long | 以及经过训练的临床心理学家,他做了几个小时的治疗 |
| 114 | interviews and gathered collateral information. | 访谈和收集附带信息。 |
| 115 | And so we partnered with Scott and we got these videos | 于是我们和斯科特搭档,我们得到了这些视频 |
| 116 | and we coded the like, verbal and nonverbal behavior. | 我们编码了类似, 口头和非口头行为。 |
| 117 | Like, are these people behaving differently? | 这些人的行为不同吗? |
| 118 | And what are people paying attention to? | 人们注意什么? |
| 119 | And what we found is that people with higher levels of these traits | 而我们发现的是, 具有更高水平的这些特征的人 |
| 120 | engaged in these, what we call Duchenne smiles. | 参与这些,我们称之为 Duchenne 微笑。 |
| 121 | They're a genuine looking smile, but they, yeah, that's the one. | 他们是真正的笑容, 但他们,是的,这就是。 |
| 122 | Okay, so what distinguishes these two kinds of smiles | 那么,是什么区别 这两种微笑 |
| 123 | is the activation around the eyes. | 是周围的激活。 |
| 124 | And it's the creation of like, crow's feet. | 这是乌鸦脚的创造 |
| 125 | So you kind of get, you know, lines in the corner. | 所以你有点,你知道, 线在角落。 |
| 126 | So a genuine person will have crow's feet when they smile, theoretically. | 因此,真正的人会有乌鸦的脚 当他们微笑,理论上。 |
| 127 | Theoretically. | 论曰. |
| 128 | Again, there can be botox and all kinds of things getting in the way of this. | 再说一遍,可能会有肉毒杆菌和各种东西阻碍我们 |
| 129 | But yeah, okay, so it's in the eyes. | 但是,是的,好的,所以它在眼睛里。 |
| 130 | Yes, it's totally in the eyes. | 是的,这是完全在眼睛。 |
| 131 | Whereas a non-Duchenne smile, you know, you have the same kind of upturned lips | 虽然一个非杜尚尼人的微笑,你知道, 你有着同样的 上升的嘴唇 |
| 132 | and maybe you're showing your teeth, you got a big grin, | 也许你在展示你的牙齿, 你有一个大的笑容, |
| 133 | but no activation around the eyes. | 但眼睛周围没有激活 |
| 134 | So you don't get those crow's feet. | 所以你不会得到那些乌鸦的脚。 |
| 135 | People who are high in these psychopathic personality traits, | 身高的人 这些精神病人的个性特征, |
| 136 | they were showing these kinds of like, you know, very happy looking smiles | 他们正在展示这种 像,你知道, 非常快乐的笑容 |
| 137 | as they were saying really hostile things. | 因为他们在说非常敌对的话 |
| 138 | So they were using like, happy expressions, hostile language at the same time. | 所以他们同时使用像,快乐的表达,敌对的语言. |
| 139 | So you get this kind of like weird emotional presentation. | 所以,你得到这种 奇怪的情感展示。 |
| 140 | They also use a lot of hand gestures. | 他们也使用了很多手势. |
| 141 | We call them illustrators. | 我们称他们为插画家。 |
| 142 | Those seem to be things that just, you know, random observers paid attention to | 这些似乎只是,你知道, 随机观察者关注 |
| 143 | and used to help guide their judgments, which of course is like such little information to go on. | 并用来指导他们的判断, 这当然像这么少的信息 继续。 |
| 144 | But it does suggest that, you know, you can get a sense of someone relatively quickly. | 但是它确实表明,你知道,你可以 得到一个相对快的人的感觉。 |
| 145 | But again, personality is something that exists across time and context. | 但同样,人格是存在于时间和背景之间的东西. |
| 146 | So you're going to get better data, the more data that you have | 所以,你会得到更好的数据, 你拥有的数据越多 |
| 147 | across those different times and places. | 在那些不同的时间和地点 |
| 148 | I've got two more facial expressions here. | 我这里还有两个面部表情 |
| 149 | So this is sadness. | 这就是悲伤。 |
| 150 | So some of the research that I've done has actually looked at people who've gone on TV | 所以,我所做的一些研究 已经实际上看 人们谁已经上电视 |
| 151 | and asked for help trying to find their missing loved one. | 并请求帮助 寻找他们失踪的亲人。 |
| 152 | And in some proportion of those cases, they were actually guilty of killing that person. | 在其中的一部分案件中,他们实际上犯有杀害此人的罪行。 |
| 153 | So they are like falsely pleading for help for someone they know is never coming back. | 所以他们就像是在为他们认识的人求救 却再也回不来了 |
| 154 | Wasn't this your PhD? | 这不是你的博士学位吗? |
| 155 | This is my PhD, yeah. | 这是我的博士,是的。 |
| 156 | What was your PhD in? | 你的博士学位是什么? |
| 157 | In psychology. | 心理学 |
| 158 | But I was in a more like forensic context at that time. | 但我当时更像是法医 |
| 159 | So I was studying behavioral cues to emotional high stakes deception. | 所以我在研究行为暗示 情感高度的欺骗。 |
| 160 | Are you trying to spot someone who was, say, in the media saying, | 你是想在媒体上看到 有人说 |
| 161 | I can't find my wife, please help me. | 我找不到我妻子了 请帮帮我 |
| 162 | A thousand percent. | 千分百计. |
| 163 | But they killed their own wife. | 但是他们杀了自己的妻子 |
| 164 | Yes. | 对 |
| 165 | Yeah. | 对 |
| 166 | So I was comparing a bunch of those cases to a bunch of cases where people genuinely | 所以我把这些案子 和人们真正认为 |
| 167 | had no idea where their missing loved one had gone. | 不知道他们失踪的亲人去了哪里 |
| 168 | And they were, you know, desperately pleading to have them home. | 他们急切地恳求他们回家 |
| 169 | And this is one of the differences that we saw in that set of videos where like, | 这就是我们在那些视频里看到的区别之一 |
| 170 | maybe you can try to do this with me, Stephen. | 也许你可以试着跟我做这件事 Stephen |
| 171 | Are you up for it? | 你愿意吗? |
| 172 | I'm up for it. | 我准备好了。 |
| 173 | I'm always up for everything. | 我总是为一切着想。 |
| 174 | So in the genuine sadness, you get the like downturn lip corners. | 所以,在真正的悲伤中, 你得到像下滑的唇角。 |
| 175 | Okay. | 摆 |
| 176 | So you did that pretty easily. | 所以,你这样做相当容易。 |
| 177 | What tends to be more difficult is this combination in the eyebrows. | 往往比较困难的是眉间这种组合. |
| 178 | So just your inner eyebrows comes upward and together. | 所以,只是你的内在眉毛 向上和在一起。 |
| 179 | Oh, you're pretty good. | 哦,你很不错。 |
| 180 | Nicely done. | 干得不错 |
| 181 | It was hard. | 这很难。 |
| 182 | So what we saw in the people who were lying was more like surprise. | 我们从说谎的人身上看到的 更像是惊喜 |
| 183 | Like they were able to kind of pull the lip corners down. | 好像他们可以把嘴角拉下来 |
| 184 | But instead of like the inner eyebrows going upward and together, | 而不是像内在的眉毛 向上和在一起, |
| 185 | the whole inner and outer eyebrows would go up, but not together. | 整个内侧和外侧的眉毛会上升 但不会一起上升 |
| 186 | So it's kind of like. | 所以有点像。 |
| 187 | And you could predictably tell from footage if someone had done it or not. | 你可以从镜头中预测出 如果有人做了与否。 |
| 188 | Like was there correlation? | 就像有关系一样? |
| 189 | Yeah. | 对 |
| 190 | So we were able to use four different cues. | 所以我们可以使用四个不同的提示。 |
| 191 | So two verbal and two nonverbal to predict with about 90% accuracy, | 因此,两个口头和两个非口头 预测大约90%的准确度, |
| 192 | who was lying and who was telling the truth. | 谁在说谎,谁在说实话。 |
| 193 | Caveat to that. | 洞穴到那个。 |
| 194 | We tried to replicate that more recently and we found much more modest effects, | 我们最近试图复制它 我们发现效果要小得多 |
| 195 | but we did find consistencies, especially with the verbal stuff. | 但是我们确实找到了配乐, 特别是口头上的东西。 |
| 196 | And there it was the number of words that people used as well as tentative words. | 那里是人们用到的字数,以及暂定字数。 |
| 197 | So liars would tend to say things like, if you see this, come home or call or whatever. | 所以,骗子会 倾向于说,如果你看到这一点, 回家或打电话什么的。 |
| 198 | It was kind of like a little vague about what this person should do if they saw it. | 这有点像有点模糊 这个人应该做什么 如果他们看到它。 |
| 199 | Saying things like, it wasn't like an argument per se that we were having. | 说一些类似的话, 它不是像一个争论本身 我们有。 |
| 200 | So they kind of left a lot of like gray area in the things that they were saying. | 所以他们把很多像灰色的地方 留在了他们所说的话里。 |
| 201 | Whereas the truthful people were like, when you see this, call me. | 诚心的民众们,好像,当你们看见这个的时候,你们应当召唤我。 |
| 202 | They were more sort of high conviction and precise. | 他们更具有高度的信念和准确性。 |
| 203 | Yes, exactly. | 没错 |
| 204 | I think down there we have some cards that say three signs someone is lying. | 我想下面有些牌 上面写着有人在撒谎 |
| 205 | So one cue to deception is sparse or ambiguous information. | 因此,一个欺骗的提示是很少或模糊的信息。 |
| 206 | So the most consistent effect we have that differentiates people who are telling the | 所以,我们最一致的效果 区别的人谁告诉 |
| 207 | truth from people who are lying is the amount of detail that they give. | 说谎者的真理,是他们所叙述的。 |
| 208 | So people who are lying tend to give fewer details. | 因此,说谎的人往往提供更少的细节。 |
| 209 | Interesting. | 有意思,这很有趣 |
| 210 | I thought it was the opposite. | 以为反. |
| 211 | Yeah, I hear this a lot where people are like, no, but liars will like, | 是的,我听到很多 在那里人们喜欢,没有, 但骗子会喜欢, |
| 212 | natter on and on and on. | 紧紧按住 |
| 213 | That's not what we find in the research whatsoever. | 这不是我们在研究中发现的 |
| 214 | Especially, especially when people don't have time to prepare. | 特别是当人们没有时间准备的时候. |
| 215 | So whenever people have time to prepare, they can start to look pretty much like a truth teller | 所以,每当人们有时间准备, 他们可以开始看起来差不多 像一个说实话的人 |
| 216 | on the amount of information they have. | 他们掌握的信息数量。 |
| 217 | But if you get someone on the spot, the truth teller just has to say, | 但如果你当场找到人 说实话的人只能说 |
| 218 | remember what happened and spit it out and tell you. | 记住发生了什么,吐出来告诉你。 |
| 219 | And you can even ask for more information. | 你甚至可以要求更多的信息。 |
| 220 | Tell me more about that and they can come up with more information about that. | 告诉我更多关于这一点, 他们可以想出更多的信息。 |
| 221 | Because they were there, right? | 因为他们在那里,对不对? |
| 222 | The person who is lying has a much harder task. | 说谎的人的任务更艰巨 |
| 223 | We call this they have increased cognitive load, which means that they need to come up with | 我们称之为他们增加了认知负荷 这意味着他们需要提出 |
| 224 | details on the spot. | 现场细节。 |
| 225 | They need to not contradict themselves. | 他们不必自相矛盾。 |
| 226 | They need to make sure they remember it for the next time they tell this lie. | 他们需要确保 记住它,下一次 他们说这个谎言。 |
| 227 | They also need to try to imagine like, what do you know already? | 他们也需要试着想象, 像,你已经知道什么? |
| 228 | And how do I not contradict or essentially step in it, right? | 我怎么能不自相矛盾 也不从本质上介入呢? |
| 229 | Whenever I'm trying to explain what actually didn't happen. | 每当我试图解释什么 实际没有发生。 |
| 230 | They must have high blood pressure anyway, just from knowing that they're not telling | 反正他们一定有高血压 因为他们不知道 |
| 231 | the truth. | 事实 |
| 232 | And that must make your cortisol spike to know that you're like... | 这一定让你的皮质素激增 知道你就像... |
| 233 | Yeah, we actually we've done some research in my lab to show that people who are lying | 是的,我们实际上已经做了一些研究 在我的实验室 显示在撒谎的人 |
| 234 | tend to have an increased cortisol reactivity relative to people who are telling the truth. | 相对于讲真话的人来说 皮质醇的反应力会增强 |
| 235 | You know, on this one, the reason why the reason why I was surprised to hear it is because | 你知道,在这个方面,为什么 我惊讶地听到它的原因是 |
| 236 | I'm a big true crime fan, like obsessed. | 我是一个真正的犯罪迷, 像痴迷。 |
| 237 | And I often watch the interrogation videos. | 我经常看审讯录像 |
| 238 | And I think I thought I heard before that when they're interviewing someone who is guilty, | 我想我之前听说了 当他们采访有罪的人时 |
| 239 | they will give lots of like a relevant detail on other parts of it. | 他们将就其中其他部分提供许多类似相关细节。 |
| 240 | I was watching the Jesse Smollett interview he did on TV. | 我在看杰西·斯莫莱特在电视上的采访 |
| 241 | Again, he had time to prepare. | 他还有时间准备 |
| 242 | So maybe that's the caveat. | 所以也许这就是警告 |
| 243 | And he really described a bunch of pointless stuff. | 他真的描述了一堆毫无意义的东西。 |
| 244 | He was like talking to the journalists. | 他就像跟记者说话 |
| 245 | He was like, you know, and then I landed and I called my manager who was in Australia | 他喜欢,你知道, 然后我降落,我打电话给我的经理 谁在澳大利亚 |
| 246 | because my manager is on tour with someone else. | 因为我的经理和别人在旅行 |
| 247 | And then even when he talked about going to Subway and getting the Subway wrap, | 然后,即使他谈到 去地铁 和获得地铁包装, |
| 248 | he mentioned that it was like a tuna wrap. | 他提到这就像一个金枪鱼包装。 |
| 249 | So like the details he was sure on, and that were probably true, | 所以就像他确定的细节 很可能是真的 |
| 250 | he seemed to really expand out. | 他似乎真的扩张了。 |
| 251 | And then when it gets into the other stuff, which is where the bulk of the lies took place, | 然后当它进入其他的东西, 这是大部分谎言发生的地方, |
| 252 | allegedly, it was quite vague. | 据称,这是相当模糊的。 |
| 253 | Yeah. | 对 |
| 254 | So we call that embedded lies, right? | 我们把这叫做嵌入式谎言,对吧? |
| 255 | So like he's giving lots of detail where it's truthful. | 所以他给了很多细节 哪里是真的。 |
| 256 | Yeah. | 对 |
| 257 | And then almost no detail where it's a lie, right? | 然后几乎没有细节 它在哪里是一个谎言,对不对? |
| 258 | And then lots of detail where it's truthful. | 然后很多细节 在它的真实。 |
| 259 | So you can also kind of like compare someone's baseline. | 所以你也可以比较一下某人的基线。 |
| 260 | Do they tend to give lots of detail? | 他们往往会给出很多细节吗? |
| 261 | Do they tend to be sparse on information? | 他们往往缺乏信息吗? |
| 262 | You can look for kind of deviations. | 你可以寻找一种偏差。 |
| 263 | And so if you notice that like someone tells you a really long story, | 所以如果你注意到有人告诉你一个很长的故事 |
| 264 | there's tons of detail about all these other things. | 还有其他很多细节 |
| 265 | And then in this part of the story, there's like very little information, | 然后在故事的这一部分, 有像很少的信息, |
| 266 | very sparse or ambiguous information, right? | 非常稀少或模糊的信息,对不对? |
| 267 | That can be a red flag. | 那可以是一个红旗。 |
| 268 | And I think what's important to remember is that there is no Pinocchio's nose. | 我想应该记住的是 没有皮诺曹的鼻子 |
| 269 | There's no like one cue. | 没有什么像一个提示。 |
| 270 | And so what you're looking for is just like these subtle cues | 所以你要找的就是这些微妙的提示 |
| 271 | that are like red flags and encourage you to follow up, ask more questions. | 这就像红旗 并鼓励你跟进, 问更多的问题。 |
| 272 | Dig in to that topic a little bit further. | 再深入一点 |
| 273 | You know, in the same way they did the research to figure out if members of the public could | 你知道,同样的方式,他们做了研究 找出公众是否可以 |
| 274 | just on the surface, tell if someone was a psychopath in 5, 10 or 20 seconds. | 就从表面上看 5、10或20秒内是否有人是个精神病人 |
| 275 | Have they ever done that with lying to figure out if people can spot lies? | 他们有没有说谎 找出人们能否发现谎言? |
| 276 | Literally thousands of times. | 字数千遍. |
| 277 | Really? | 真的吗? |
| 278 | Yeah. | 对 |
| 279 | So in my lab, we've actually had them steal a hundred dollar bill from a room. | 所以在我的实验室里,我们真的让他们 从一个房间里偷了100美元。 |
| 280 | And then we had someone come in and essentially interrogate them. | 然后有人进来审问他们 |
| 281 | And everyone had to deny it, right? | 而每个人都不得不否认,对不对? |
| 282 | So the people who took it were lying. | 所以拿它的人在撒谎 |
| 283 | And the people who did not take it were telling the truth. | 而那些没有拿它的人说的是实话 |
| 284 | And we put a hundred bucks on the line, right? | 我们花了100块在线上,对不对? |
| 285 | So like if you're able to convince this person that you didn't take it, | 所以,就像如果你能够说服这个人 你没有把它, |
| 286 | when you actually did, you can keep that at Benjamin. | 当你真的做了, 你可以保留在本杰明。 |
| 287 | And then we showed these videos to other people, right? | 然后我们把这些视频展示给其他人,对吧? |
| 288 | People are not very good at detecting these lies or really any kind of lies. | 人们不太擅长侦测这些谎言或任何一种谎言。 |
| 289 | On average, people perform at about 54% accuracy. | 平均来说,人们的表演精度约为54%. |
| 290 | Like if I gave you 12 videos, six are liars, six are truth tellers, | 就像我给你12个视频 6个是骗子 6个是说真话的人 |
| 291 | you'll get like six or seven, right? | 你会得到像六七,对不对? |
| 292 | What if someone is trained? | 如果有人受过训练呢? |
| 293 | Do the stats increase? | 数据增加吗? |
| 294 | So they can increase a little bit. | 这样可以增加一点。 |
| 295 | Yes. | 对 |
| 296 | What is better actually is learning how to ask better questions. | 更好的是学会问更好的问题。 |
| 297 | Oh, really? | 是吗? |
| 298 | Yeah. | 对 |
| 299 | So instead of just being like, here's a video of someone lying or telling the truth. | 而不是只是喜欢, 这里有一个视频 某人说谎或说实话。 |
| 300 | Like that's all you get. | 就像这就是你得到的。 |
| 301 | And just like, look at that and tell me if they're lying or telling the truth. | 碞钩禗и琌弧晾临琌弧痷杠 |
| 302 | Good lie detectors ask for more information or they ask unanticipated questions. | 良好的谎言探测器要求更多信息,或者它们提出意想不到的问题. |
| 303 | Where people haven't prepared for them. | 在人们还没准备好的地方 |
| 304 | And then those cues of deception, that like sparse information, | 然后这些欺骗的提示, 像稀疏的信息, |
| 305 | that like sense that they're thinking really hard is really going to kind of go off the charts. | 那种感觉,他们认为 真正的艰难 会真正去 一些图表。 |
| 306 | And so learning how to ask good questions is actually a really kind of essential tool | 所以,学习如何问好问题 实际上是一种真正的基本工具 |
| 307 | for detecting lies. | 用来侦测谎言 |
| 308 | I mean, we're going to have to go into that rabbit hole. | 我的意思是,我们要去 进入兔子洞。 |
| 309 | I've got to be careful here because people are going to take this out of context. | 我在这里必须小心 因为人们会把这件事从背景上说出去。 |
| 310 | Say that I suspect my partner is cheating on me. | 说我怀疑我的搭档在欺骗我 |
| 311 | And I sit them down and I go, babe, listen, are you cheating on me? | 我让他们坐下去 宝贝 听着 你在欺骗我吗 |
| 312 | And they go, no, absolutely not. | 他们去,没有,绝对没有。 |
| 313 | What would be a good question to ask, to ascertain if they are actually cheating on me? | 问一个好问题 问他们是否真的在欺骗我? |
| 314 | So I think where you first made a mistake is you asked a closed ended question. | 所以我认为你第一次犯错的地方 就是问了一个结束的问题 |
| 315 | Are you cheating on me? | 你在骗我吗? |
| 316 | No. | 没有 |
| 317 | You didn't even give them an opportunity to like have to come up with something more difficult. | 你甚至没有给他们机会 喜欢想出更难的事 |
| 318 | Right? | 对吧? |
| 319 | If you were like, okay, well, I think last Friday night you said you had to work late, | 如果你喜欢,好吧,嗯,我想上周五晚上 你说你不得不加班, |
| 320 | but I don't really believe that. | 但我真的不相信这一点。 |
| 321 | I think you were out with someone else. | 我想你和别人出去了 |
| 322 | You would say, tell me about, you know, work on Friday night. | 你会说,告诉我, 你知道,周五晚上的工作。 |
| 323 | And so then you're asking an open ended question. | 然后你问了一个没完没了的问题 |
| 324 | Let's role play. | 让我们扮演的角色。 |
| 325 | Okay. | 摆 |
| 326 | You're the one that suspects I'm cheating. | 你是那个怀疑我作弊的人 |
| 327 | Okay. | 摆 |
| 328 | And last Friday night I was up to something. | 上周五晚上我正忙着呢 |
| 329 | So that's the context. | 这就是背景。 |
| 330 | Let's do this. | 让我们做到这一点。 |
| 331 | Okay. | 摆 |
| 332 | I know you had to work late on Friday night. | 我知道你周五晚上得加班工作 |
| 333 | What were you working on? | 你在忙着什么? |
| 334 | Yeah. | 对 |
| 335 | It's a big investment deal that we're working on with a couple of the colleagues. | 我们正与几位同事合作进行一项重大投资交易. |
| 336 | We had to get a deck together. | 我们得一起打甲板 |
| 337 | So I was, yeah, I stayed till what? | 所以我是,是的,我一直待到什么? |
| 338 | 3 a.m. in the morning or something crazy like that. | 凌晨3点或者那样的疯狂 |
| 339 | And I ended up falling asleep on my desk. | 结果我睡在桌子上 |
| 340 | And yeah, that's a long one. | 是的,这是一个很长的。 |
| 341 | Anyway, what's for what we're doing today? | 总之,我们今天做什么? |
| 342 | What's for dinner? | 晚饭吃什么? |
| 343 | Okay. | 摆 |
| 344 | Red flags flying up. | 红旗飞起. |
| 345 | So I would ask more questions. | 所以我会问更多的问题。 |
| 346 | I would be like, oh, like what, what client were you working on this for? | 我将像,哦,像什么, 什么客户 你为这个工作? |
| 347 | What's the, what's the deck about? | 什么是,什么是甲板吗? |
| 348 | Yeah. | 对 |
| 349 | So we're doing an investment deal with them, with Google. | 所以,我们正在做一个投资交易 他们,与谷歌。 |
| 350 | So it's good. | 故为善. |
| 351 | Google's, yeah, it's Google. | 谷歌的,是的,这是谷歌。 |
| 352 | You, I could ask you like, okay, tell me about like what was in the deck. | 你,我可以问你喜欢,好吧, 告诉我什么是甲板上。 |
| 353 | Right. | 对 |
| 354 | And you give me a little bit kind of sketchy information and great question | 你给我一点点 粗略的信息和伟大的问题 |
| 355 | to have in your back pocket is just tell me more about that. | 在你的后口袋 只是告诉我更多关于这一点。 |
| 356 | Like you don't even have to like try very hard to figure out like, | 就像你甚至不用尝试 很难去想一样, |
| 357 | where am I going to stump them? | 我到哪里去砍他们? |
| 358 | Right. | 对 |
| 359 | If you just ask, tell me more about that. | 如果你只是问, 告诉我更多关于这一点。 |
| 360 | At some point, the liar is going to have a lot more trouble coming up with additional | 在某个时候,骗子会有更多的麻烦 提出额外的 |
| 361 | details than the truth teller who's the truth teller is going to be like, oh, well, | 细节比说真话的人 谁是说真话的人 会像,哦,嗯, |
| 362 | this is what the project was about. | 这就是项目的目的 |
| 363 | Like it was actually super annoying because I couldn't get the font on the, | 就像它实际上超级烦人 因为我不能得到字体上, |
| 364 | you know, on the slide deck to stay on the slope, whatever. | 你知道,在滑板上 停留在斜坡上,随便。 |
| 365 | Like you, as a truth teller, you were there and you know, all those annoying little | 像你一样,作为一个说真话的人, 你在那里 你知道,所有这些烦人的小 |
| 366 | things that maybe you didn't include in the first version of the story. | 可能你没有在故事的第一版本中包括的东西。 |
| 367 | But if someone asks you for more detail, you could go into more detail. | 但是如果有人问你更多细节的话,你可以更详细地说. |
| 368 | Whereas the person who's lying, who's making this up, that's much more difficult | 而说谎的人,是谁编造的, 那要困难得多 |
| 369 | for them to do because that didn't actually happen. | 让他们这么做是因为那不是真的 |
| 370 | And so they're going to be somewhat vague. | 所以它们会有些模糊。 |
| 371 | Yes, big. | 对,很大。 |
| 372 | And the details are going to be really difficult to verify. | 细节很难核实。 |
| 373 | So if they do give you some details, it might be like the things that you, | 所以,如果他们确实给你一些细节, 它可能会像你的东西, |
| 374 | you don't know the coworkers that you're working with, right? | 你不了解你的同事,对吧? |
| 375 | Oh, it's the new guy at work. | 哦,这是新人的工作。 |
| 376 | Like you don't know him. | 就像你不认识他一样 |
| 377 | So in general, liars tend to give fewer verifiable details. | 所以一般来说,骗子往往会提供较少可核实的细节. |
| 378 | And there's this actually really fascinating study that, you know, | 有个非常有趣的研究,你知道, |
| 379 | sometimes we're like, we're trying to like dissect, right? | 有时候我们喜欢解剖 对吧? |
| 380 | Someone's behavior. | 某人的行为。 |
| 381 | We're trying, we're paying attention to their words. | 我们在努力,我们注意他们的话 |
| 382 | We're paying attention like, oh, are they fidgeting or something, | 我们注意的像,哦,他们是 虚构什么的, |
| 383 | which is actually not a good cue to deception. | 这其实不是欺骗的好暗示 |
| 384 | We're looking at their eye contact, also not a good cue to deception. | 我们正看着他们的眼睛接触, 也不是欺骗的好提示。 |
| 385 | And we are trying to like create this crazy algorithm in our head, | 我们想在脑海中创造这个疯狂的算法 |
| 386 | like adding up all of these different behaviors to try to determine | 就像把这些不同的行为加起来 来决定 |
| 387 | whether I think you're lying or telling the truth. | 不管你是在撒谎还是说实话 |
| 388 | Actually, research suggests that if you just ask how verifiable was that statement, | 实际上,研究显示,如果你只是问 如何可核查是该声明, |
| 389 | that's a better strategy for trying to accurately detect lies | 这是试图准确发现谎言的更好的策略 |
| 390 | than trying to use all of these other cues that actually don't work. | 而不是试图使用所有这些其他的提示 实际上无效。 |
| 391 | If you ask yourself, how verifiable is the excuse this person I think his line gave me? | 如果你问自己 这个人给我的借口可以证明吗? |
| 392 | Yes, exactly. | 没错 |
| 393 | Interesting. | 有意思,这很有趣 |
| 394 | I think the broader finding is just that it is better to focus on one cue that works | 我认为,更广泛的发现只是,它更好 专注于一个线索 工作 |
| 395 | than to try to put together all of these like little cues that mostly don't work at all. | 而不是试图把这些像小提示一样的东西拼凑起来, 大部分都行不通。 |
| 396 | Okay. | 摆 |
| 397 | Yeah. | 对 |
| 398 | And the third one then? | 那第三个呢? |
| 399 | The third one, you know, we've kind of touched on it, | 第三个,你知道,我们已经 某种接触它, |
| 400 | but it's just visible cognitive effort. | 但这只是明显的认知努力。 |
| 401 | So all of this stuff, you know, the details that people need to come up with | 所以所有这些东西,你知道, 细节人们需要想出 |
| 402 | is really hard to do, right? | 真的很难做,对不对? |
| 403 | And they might be speaking really slowly. | 他们说话可能很慢 |
| 404 | They might be using lots of ums and ahs and errs. | 他们可能用了很多微米和错误 |
| 405 | They might be kind of like furrowing their brow, trying to figure things out. | 他们可能有点像在摸眉毛 试图弄清楚事情 |
| 406 | Again, it's important to remember that like you could pause for a million different reasons | 再说一次,必须记住,像你这样的人 可以停下来,因为一百万个不同的原因 |
| 407 | that are not deception related, right? | 与欺骗无关 对吧? |
| 408 | You could just be trying to remember something. | 你可能只是试着回忆一些事情。 |
| 409 | You could be furrowing your brow because I don't know, your forehead's itchy, whatever. | 你可能会在眉毛上发抖,因为我不知道 你的额头好痒,什么的 |
| 410 | So none of these are Pinocchio's nose, but they are reliably associated with deception. | 所以这些都不是皮诺曹的鼻子,但是它们与欺骗有可靠的联系. |
| 411 | What about body language? | 身体语言呢? |
| 412 | People always talk about body language. | 人们总是谈论身体语言. |
| 413 | People put a lot of stock into body language, particularly into like gaze aversion. | 人们将大量股票投入到身体语言中,特别是像目光厌恶一样. |
| 414 | So if you go around the world and you ask people what's the number one cue | 所以如果你环游世界 问人们第一线索是什么 |
| 415 | that someone is lying to you, they will say sketchy eye contact. | 有人在骗你,他们会说 眼神接触很模糊 |
| 416 | And there's no research to suggest that that is true. | 没有研究可以证明这是真的。 |
| 417 | And if you think about it for like a hot second, it makes so much sense, right? | 如果你一想到它 就像热的一秒钟, 它有这么多的道理,对不对? |
| 418 | Because I sometimes tell a lie, you sometimes tell a lie. | 因为我有时撒谎,你有时说谎。 |
| 419 | We all know the stereotype that liars can't look you in the eye. | 我们都知道 骗子不能看你的眼睛的定型观念 |
| 420 | So if I want you to believe me, I'm going to make sure I control my eye contact. | 所以,如果我要你相信我, 我会确保控制我的眼睛接触。 |
| 421 | Right? | 对吧? |
| 422 | And that's something that's well under our control. | 而这是我们完全控制的事情。 |
| 423 | And there's neurodivergence and things like that, which means that some people who have | 还有神经分裂和类似的东西, 这意味着有些人谁有 |
| 424 | sort of certain neurodiversities struggle with eye contact, but it doesn't necessarily | 某种程度上的神经分裂 与眼睛接触,但它并不一定 |
| 425 | mean that they're lying. | 就是说他们在撒谎 |
| 426 | Exactly. | 没错 |
| 427 | So there's some emerging research to suggest that people who are on the autism | 因此,有一些新兴的研究表明, 那些在自闭症的人 |
| 428 | spectrum are perceived as lying more when they're actually telling the truth. | 当他们说实话时, 光谱被认为是更多的谎言。 |
| 429 | And that's because of this eye contact thing, which people are using as a cue to | 那是因为这个眼睛接触的东西 人们用它作为提示 |
| 430 | deception, but in fact is unrelated to deception. | 欺骗,但事实上与欺骗无关。 |
| 431 | I mean, there's also like cultural differences, right? | 我的意思是,还有像文化差异,对不对? |
| 432 | In some cultures, it's more respectful, like not to look at you in the eye. | 在一些文化中,比较尊重,比如不看你的眼睛. |
| 433 | And so that can also lead to kind of errors in our judgment. | 所以这也会导致我们判断错误。 |
| 434 | And there's this sort of dark personality trait thing I hear a lot. | 我经常听到这种黑暗的个性特征 |
| 435 | Is it a triad? | 是三合会吗? |
| 436 | It was a triad. | 是个三合会 |
| 437 | Now we get a tetrad. | 现在我们得到一个四面体。 |
| 438 | Okay. | 摆 |
| 439 | So is that what this is? | 所以这是什么? |
| 440 | Yes. | 对 |
| 441 | Okay. | 摆 |
| 442 | So if you want to reveal what each of those is one at a time. | 所以,如果你想要揭示 每一个都是一个。 |
| 443 | Psychopathy, for example. | 比如说心理疗法 |
| 444 | What is psychopathy? | 什么是变态? |
| 445 | Psychopathy is a constellation that is a set of personality traits. | 心理疗法是一组人格特征的星座. |
| 446 | So it's not just one thing. | 所以这不仅仅是一件事。 |
| 447 | Having kind of a superficial charm, they're quite manipulative and they tend to be pretty | 有点肤浅的魅力,他们很能操控,而且往往很漂亮 |
| 448 | grandiose. | 爷爷 |
| 449 | So they've got a pretty inflated view of themselves. | 所以他们对自己的看法相当夸张。 |
| 450 | There's also emotional components. | 还有情感成分. |
| 451 | So they tend to have pretty shallow emotional experiences, a lack of remorse and guilt for | 因此,他们往往 相当浅浅的情感经历, 缺乏悔恨和内疚 |
| 452 | harming other people. | 伤害别人。 |
| 453 | And they tend not to take responsibility for their own actions. | 他们往往不为自己的行为负责。 |
| 454 | In addition, they tend to be pretty impulsive. | 此外,它们往往具有相当的冲动性. |
| 455 | So they are kind of living life by the seat of their pants and they're not really, you know, | 所以,他们是一种生活 在他们的裤子的座位 他们不是真的,你知道, |
| 456 | planning far out into the future. | 计划远离未来 |
| 457 | And so they might, you know, kind of mooch off of a family members or a romantic partner. | 所以他们可能,你知道, 某种mock 离开家庭成员或浪漫伴侣。 |
| 458 | And then lastly, they tend to break a lot of rules. | 最后,他们往往违反许多规则。 |
| 459 | So this might be just like workplace rules or social norms, | 所以,这可能是 就像工作场所的规则或社会规范, |
| 460 | but psychopathy has largely been studied in criminal populations. | 但精神病学主要是在犯罪人群中研究的。 |
| 461 | So this could also be laws. | 所以这也可以是法律。 |
| 462 | The other three of the so-called dark tetrad share some elements, | 其他三个所谓的黑暗四面体 有一些元素, |
| 463 | but also had some like unique flavors. | 但也有一些像独特的味道。 |
| 464 | So the next one we've got here is Machiavellianism. | 接下来的就是马基雅维利主义。 |
| 465 | And that is, you know, named after Niccolo Machiavelli, who wrote The Prince, | 这就是,你知道,以尼科洛·马奇雅维利的名字命名, 他写了"王子", |
| 466 | which is a kind of how-to manual to like gain and wield power effectively. | 这是一种如何手动 喜欢获得和有效使用权力。 |
| 467 | So as a personality trait, they tend to be pretty cynical about other people. | 因此,作为一个个性特征, 他们倾向于相当愤世嫉俗的其他人。 |
| 468 | They tell a lot of lies and they try to like manipulate people, but it's more like | 他们说了很多谎言 他们试着喜欢操纵人 但更像是 |
| 469 | three-dimensional chess, you know? | 三维棋,你知道吗? |
| 470 | Like they might learn a little tidbit about you, Steven. | 就像他们可能 学习一点点关于你,史蒂文。 |
| 471 | They'll be like, you know what? | 他们会像,你知道吗? |
| 472 | I could use that against him later. | 我以后可以用这个对付他 |
| 473 | I'm just going to like put that in my back pocket. | 我只是会喜欢 把它放在我的后口袋。 |
| 474 | And, you know, when I need to manipulate or like blackmail you in the future, right? | 而且,你知道,当我需要 操纵或喜欢讹诈 你在未来,对不对? |
| 475 | They'll have that available to them. | 他们会有他们可用的。 |
| 476 | So they're very interested in power, which of course is where the name comes from. | 因此他们对权力非常感兴趣,这当然是名字的来源. |
| 477 | Next one is Narcissism. | 下一个是纳西西主义。 |
| 478 | You know, that's one that people know pretty well, right? | 你知道,这是人们非常清楚的,对不对? |
| 479 | So these are people who tend to be very entitled. | 所以,这些人往往 是非常有资格。 |
| 480 | And they're very willing to exploit other people in order to get what they think they deserve, | 他们非常愿意利用别人来得到他们认为应得的东西, |
| 481 | right? | 对吧? |
| 482 | So it's like very relentless kind of self-focus. | 所以这就像非常无情的自我聚焦。 |
| 483 | This word has been used quite a lot in culture. | 这个词在文化中被大量使用. |
| 484 | 常掷诸 around. | |
| 485 | Constantly, yes. | 总是,是的。 |
| 486 | What's your view of that? | 你对此的看法如何? |
| 487 | I mean, narcissism, like all of these traits, exists on a continuum. | 我的意思是,自恋, 像所有这些特征一样, 存在于一个连续体上。 |
| 488 | So you or anyone else, myself, could take a measure, a self-report measure, | 这样你或者其他人,我自己, 可以采取一个措施, 一个自我报告措施, |
| 489 | the extent to which I have these traits, right? | 我在多大程度上有这些特征,对不对? |
| 490 | And you can land anywhere from very low to very high. | 你可以在从非常低到非常高的地方降落。 |
| 491 | Now, some of these traits, narcissism being one of them, actually has a, | 现在,有些特征,自恋是其中之一, 实际上有一个, |
| 492 | there's a personality disorder diagnosis at the incredibly high end, right? | 有一个人格障碍诊断 在令人难以置信的高端,对不对? |
| 493 | So this appears in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual, | 因此,这出现在《诊断和统计手册》中, |
| 494 | which is basically like a list of different mental disorders. | 这基本上就像一个列表 不同的精神障碍。 |
| 495 | You could go to a psychologist or psychiatrist. | 你可以去找心理学家或心理医生 |
| 496 | They could assess you and diagnose you if you have like extreme levels of narcissism. | 他们可以评估你,诊断你 如果你有 像极端自恋的程度。 |
| 497 | But like people land everywhere, right? | 但就像人们在任何地方着陆,对不对? |
| 498 | So I think part of the problem is that people say, oh, she's a narcissist, right? | 所以我认为问题的一部分是 人们说, 哦,她是一个自恋者,对不对? |
| 499 | He's a narcissist. | 他是个自恋狂 |
| 500 | Are they a narcissist or a psychopath? | 他们是自恋还是精神病? |
| 501 | And they make this kind of very binary distinction there, right? | 他们做出这种非常二进制的区分,对不对? |
| 502 | I guess I have qualms with those words for a couple of different reasons. | 我想我对这些词有疑问 有几个不同的原因 |
| 503 | You know, these exist on a continuum. | 你知道,这些存在于一个连续体。 |
| 504 | There's no clear like moment where it becomes you are a narcissist versus not a narcissist. | 并没有明确的瞬间 你变成自恋者而不是自恋者 |
| 505 | And so as with all of these other traits, it's a bit of a mouthful, | 和所有这些其他的特质一样, 它有点口味, |
| 506 | but I think it's more accurate to say they have relatively high levels of narcissism | 但我认为说他们的自恋程度比较高 |
| 507 | or psychopathy or whatever the case is. | 或者精神错乱,或者什么情况 |
| 508 | And you said that there's two main types of narcissist. | 你说有两种主要的自恋 |
| 509 | Yeah. | 对 |
| 510 | So increasingly, personality psychologists are identifying this kind of vulnerable type | 性格心理学家们越来越发现这种脆弱类型 |
| 511 | and a grandiose type. | 和壮丽的类型。 |
| 512 | And so grandiose is like one that we all know well, where it's like they've got this ego. | 如此的壮丽就像我们都知道的一样, 在那里他们好像有这种自我。 |
| 513 | It's huge. | 这是巨大的。 |
| 514 | It like cannot be popped, right? | 像不能弹出,对不对? |
| 515 | It's like they get this negative feedback and it's like nothing gets through to them. | 这就像他们得到这种负面的反馈 和它就像什么 得到他们。 |
| 516 | And they always think they should be the one in charge, etc. | 他们总是认为应该由自己来负责等等. |
| 517 | For those individuals, they tend to get very angry with a particular kind of threat to their ego. | 对于这些人来说,他们往往会因为某种对自我的威胁而非常生气。 |
| 518 | And that is like a failure to achieve. | 这就像失败。 |
| 519 | Like they wanted this promotion at work. | 好像他们想升职一样 |
| 520 | They didn't get it. | 他们没有得到它。 |
| 521 | Vulnerable individuals actually have kind of a very fragile ego. | 弱势个人实际上 有一种非常脆弱的自我。 |
| 522 | Interesting. | 有意思,这很有趣 |
| 523 | So it can be popped very easily, essentially. | 基本上,它很容易被弹出。 |
| 524 | So if they get negative feedback from people, maybe they get like socially rejected. | 所以,如果他们得到人们的负面反馈, 也许他们得到像社会拒绝。 |
| 525 | That's when they become quite angry. | 这时他们变得相当愤怒。 |
| 526 | That's more of a trigger for them. | 这更是他们的诱饵 |
| 527 | And is it you using the word angry as the outcome of both those types of narcissists? | 你是用愤怒这个词 来形容这两种自恋者的结果吗? |
| 528 | But I guess one would assume that maybe just from the wording that a vulnerable narcissist | 但我想人们会认为,也许仅仅从一个脆弱的自恋者的措辞来看, |
| 529 | would get more upset or more self-critical or something like that. | 会更不高兴 或更自我批评 或类似的东西。 |
| 530 | The research at least was focused on anger in response to these kinds of threats to their ego. | 研究的重点至少是愤怒,以应对他们自我的这些威胁。 |
| 531 | But certainly emotional, like combative. | 但肯定有感情,像战斗。 |
| 532 | This is when you're going to get a really negative response. | 这时候你将会得到 一个非常负面的反应。 |
| 533 | Like someone who is relatively low on narcissism of both kinds could take that kind of feedback | 就像对两种自恋相对低调的人 都能接受这种反馈 |
| 534 | that like, no, I don't think a second date is really for us, right? | 那样的话,不,我不认为第二次约会 真的是为我们,对不对? |
| 535 | Someone with vulnerable narcissism is going to respond badly. | 有个自恋狂的人会反应不好 |
| 536 | Do you know why I asked the question? | 你知道我为什么问这个问题吗? |
| 537 | It's just a front of mind because of a conversation I was having the other day | 只是因为我前几天的谈话 |
| 538 | where we were interviewing someone. | 在那里,我们正在采访某人。 |
| 539 | And during the interview process, they were very quick to say, | 在采访过程中,他们很快地说, |
| 540 | to claim credit for like all of the things the company they worked at had done. | 就像他们公司所做的一切 |
| 541 | And they were also very quick to say that they were like good at everything. | 他们也很快地说, 他们擅长一切。 |
| 542 | Even as I walked out of the room with them and I said, oh, can you, | 即使我和他们走出房间 我说,哦,你能, |
| 543 | can I message you on this particular app? | 我能给你发个信息吗? |
| 544 | They said, I'm amazing at that app. | 他们说,我对那个应用程序很在行 |
| 545 | Again, I'm anonymizing. | 再说一遍,我在匿名 |
| 546 | So a lot of this is slightly changed. | 所以很多事情都略有改变。 |
| 547 | And I walked out of the room weirdly having interviewed thousands and thousands of people | 我奇怪地走出房间 采访了成千上万的人 |
| 548 | over the years, thinking to myself, they were so lovely, | 多年来,我想,他们是如此可爱, |
| 549 | but it felt to me like it was more coming from a place of insecurity. | 但我觉得这更像是来自不安全的地方 |
| 550 | And when you look at their story, it's a story of someone who has been continually | 当你看他们的故事, 这是一个故事 某人一直持续 |
| 551 | counted out, overlooked for opportunities and almost has this, | 数数,忽略机会,几乎有这个, |
| 552 | a bit of a chip on their shoulder to try and be, prove themselves. | 他们的肩膀上有一块芯片 来证明自己 |
| 553 | Now, when I, another person I think would look at that same pattern of behavior and say, | 现在,当我,另一个人 我认为会看 同样的行为模式 并说, |
| 554 | oh, that person's a narcissist. | 哦,那个人是个自恋狂。 |
| 555 | So when I had vulnerable narcissist versus this sort of grandiose one, | 所以当我有脆弱的自恋 与这种优雅的, |
| 556 | I was wondering if is at all linked to what I'm saying. | 我在想这是否和我说的有关 |
| 557 | Like for vulnerable narcissism, the reason that they would respond so poorly to this | 就像对脆弱的自恋, 原因 他们的反应如此糟糕 |
| 558 | kind of rejection is that they need kind of constant admiration and positive feedback | 那种拒绝是 他们需要一种 不断的钦佩和积极的反馈 |
| 559 | from other people to keep their ego like going. | 从其他人 保持他们的自我 像去。 |
| 560 | I called this person's former employer to get a reference. | 我给这个人的前雇主打了电话 以获得推荐信 |
| 561 | And they said about him that one of the quotes was he always needs a gold star. | 他们提到他,其中一句是 他总是需要一颗金星。 |
| 562 | What's the difference between deep insecurity and narcissism in this regard? | 在这方面,深层的不安全和自恋有什么区别? |
| 563 | The deep insecurity, it would need to be coupled with these like entitlement. | 严重的不安全状况需要与诸如此类的权利结合起来。 |
| 564 | There's still a grandiose sense of self. | 犹有大乘自性. |
| 565 | It's just that it is quite fragile. | 只是它相当脆弱。 |
| 566 | So they're like, they think they're really good and they're willing to exploit other people | 所以他们喜欢,他们认为 他们真的很好 他们愿意剥削别人 |
| 567 | to get what they think they deserve. | 以获得他们认为他们应得的。 |
| 568 | And they may feel like they've been victimized, right? | 他们可能觉得自己是受害者,对吧? |
| 569 | And that's why they haven't gotten all of the accolades that they think they deserve. | 这就是为什么他们还没有得到 他们认为他们应得的所有功劳。 |
| 570 | Now, I think kind of regardless of where this person, you know, sits on this continuum, | 现在,我想不管这个人在哪里, 你知道,坐在这个连续体上, |
| 571 | you know, they might still have like incredible skills. | 你知道,他们可能仍然有 像不可思议的技能。 |
| 572 | They might have the abilities that you're looking for. | 他们也许有你要找的能力 |
| 573 | And so is this something you can manage or is this going to create problems? | 这是你能处理的还是会制造问题? |
| 574 | I didn't get any sense that they were entitled or that they would use other people to their | 我完全不明白他们是否有资格... ...或者他们会利用其他人去他们那里 |
| 575 | advantage. | 优势。 |
| 576 | I got the impression that people would generally like them and that they weren't entitled at all. | 我得到的印象是, 人们一般会喜欢他们, 他们根本不有资格。 |
| 577 | They still had these sort of self-promotional traits. | 他们仍然有这种自我促进的特质。 |
| 578 | And I think in society, the minute someone's like overly self-promotional, | 我想在社会上, 一个人的分钟 像过度自我促进, |
| 579 | we run to the sort of narcissist category versus it could be other things, I'm presuming. | 我们跑到那种自恋类 相对于它可能是其他的事情, 我假定。 |
| 580 | I mean, I think in that situation, right, you need to be quite mindful of the situation | 我的意思是,我认为在这种情况下, 正确的,你需要 相当注意的情况 |
| 581 | as well, right? | 同样,对不对? |
| 582 | So like our behavior is kind of a combination of both our personality and the situation | 所以,就像我们的行为 是那种结合 我们的个性和情况 |
| 583 | that we're in. | 说我们加入。 |
| 584 | And so if you're at a job interview, like your whole goal is to show people like, | 所以如果你在面试 就像你的目标就是向人们展示 |
| 585 | I can do this job. | 我可以做到这一点。 |
| 586 | I've got the skills that you need. | 我有你需要的技能 |
| 587 | And so in a job interview, we might kind of come across as like a more confident, more, | 所以在一次面试中 我们可能会像一个更自信的 |
| 588 | you know, we're presenting ourselves in the best possible light. | 你知道,我们正在展示自己 在尽可能最好的光。 |
| 589 | But I think we're very quick to rush to a personality assessment. | 但我觉得我们很快就要进行个性评估了 |
| 590 | It's called the fundamental attribution error. | 这被称为根本归属错误. |
| 591 | So it's like when I see someone behave in a particular way, like they're maybe being | 所以,这就像当我看到某人的行为 在一个特定的方式, |
| 592 | all the things that they can do really well, I could be like, oh, that's narcissistic, | 所有他们能做的都很好, 我可能喜欢,哦,那是自恋, |
| 593 | right? | 对吧? |
| 594 | That's a personality trait. | 这是一个个性特征。 |
| 595 | And we tend to be more likely to do that to others. | 我们更可能这样对待别人。 |
| 596 | But if I was in their shoes, I would be like, I was just trying to show Steven like what | 但如果我是在他们的鞋, 我会是喜欢,我只是 试图向史蒂文是什么 |
| 597 | I could do. | 我可以做到这一点。 |
| 598 | It's the situation that made me act kind of bigger than my britches, right? | 情况让我表现得比我的胸围大,对吧? |
| 599 | So we need to also be aware of like, the situation can impact our behavior. | 所以我们也需要意识到 情况会影响我们的行为 |
| 600 | And so we want to be not too quick to make a personality attribution where the situation | 因此,我们不想太快 做出个性归属的情况 |
| 601 | could explain that. | 可以解释这一点。 |
| 602 | And that's maybe a really important point to make here is that personality is a consistent | 这或许是一个非常重要的点在这里 是人格是一个一致的 |
| 603 | pattern of thinking, feeling, and behaving over time and across context. | 思考,感受, 和行为的方式 时间和背景。 |
| 604 | So if you've only got one interaction with this person, you've only got one interaction | 所以,如果你只有一个互动 与这个人,你只有一个互动 |
| 605 | with this person, you probably get a sense of their personality, but you might see them, | 有了这个人,你可能会感觉到他们的个性, 但你可能会看到他们, |
| 606 | you know, out with their friends or with their family and they might not be kind of so boastful, | 和他们的朋友或家人出去 他们可能不会那么自夸 |
| 607 | right? | 对吧? |
| 608 | And that might suggest that this is really the situation talking, not the personality. | 这可能说明,这是真正的形势 谈论,而不是个性。 |
| 609 | And what are the gender differences in narcissism in terms of both different types of narcissism? | 在两种不同的自恋中,自恋的性别差异是什么? |
| 610 | You mentioned vulnerable narcissism and also grandiose narcissism. | 你提到了脆弱的自恋 和宏伟的自恋。 |
| 611 | And then I guess there might be some other gender differences in our ability to like | 然后我想我们可能还有其他的性别差异 在喜欢 |
| 612 | spot these behaviors. | 注意这些行为 |
| 613 | So when it comes to all of these traits that we're talking about, men tend to score somewhat | 所以,当涉及到我们所说的所有这些特征时, 男人往往得到一些 |
| 614 | higher than women. | 高于妇女。 |
| 615 | And that's quite a consistent finding. | 这是一个相当一致的发现。 |
| 616 | That is not to say that women cannot score like very high on these traits. | 这并不是说,妇女在这些特征上不能获得很高的分数。 |
| 617 | There are certainly cases and there's quite a bit of overlap, but on average, you know, | 肯定有案子 而且有相当的重叠, 但平均来说,你知道, |
| 618 | the averages for men tend to be higher than the averages for women. | 男性的平均数往往高于女性的平均数。 |
| 619 | And there's a fourth brick. | 则有第四砖. |
| 620 | That's the newest and the latest one, which is sadism. | 这是最新的和最新的, 这是虐待。 |
| 621 | When you hear sadism, you might jump to like pretty extreme. | 当你听到虐待, 你可能会跳到 相当极端。 |
| 622 | Yeah, I was thinking of like the devil and stuff. | 是啊,我想 像魔鬼之类的东西。 |
| 623 | Yeah. | 对 |
| 624 | I mean, I first started studying sadistic behavior in the context of like sexual homicides. | 我的意思是,我首先开始研究虐待行为 在类似性谋杀的背景下。 |
| 625 | Like I was reading through these descriptions of criminal behavior and I was looking for | 就像我在读这些关于犯罪行为的描述 我在找 |
| 626 | signs of sadistic treatment of the victim. | 受害者受到虐待的迹象。 |
| 627 | So it's like, it can get incredibly extreme, right? | 所以,它会变得非常极端,对不对? |
| 628 | And that's probably where our mind goes. | 这可能是我们的思想去的地方。 |
| 629 | But there's also like kind of more everyday versions. | 但也有类似 更多的日常版本。 |
| 630 | One good example is like online trolling. | 一个好的例子是像在线巨怪。 |
| 631 | So we know that people who are relatively high in sadism tend to, they take pleasure | 所以我们知道 虐待倾向比较高的人 往往很快乐 |
| 632 | in other people's pain, right? | 在别人的痛苦,对不对? |
| 633 | And so you could do that in incredibly like gruesome, horrifying ways, or you could just | 这样你就可以用令人难以置信的恐怖方式 来做这件事 或者你可以 |
| 634 | be like pushing people's buttons online, trying to get people upset. | 就像在网络上按下别人的按钮, 试图让人们生气。 |
| 635 | They all share kind of three things. | 他们都有三样东西 |
| 636 | They are callous, so they don't care about other people. | 他们是无情的,所以他们不在乎其他人。 |
| 637 | They don't care about your feelings or your outcomes. | 他们不在乎你的感受和结果 |
| 638 | They're manipulative, so they're willing to lie and cheat to get what they want. | 他们有操纵性,所以愿意撒谎和作弊以获得他们想要的东西. |
| 639 | And they're hostile toward other people. | 他们敌视别人 |
| 640 | So that's kind of like the core of all of these traits. | 这有点像所有这些特征的核心。 |
| 641 | That's what they share. | 这是他们分享的。 |
| 642 | Facades. | 法华果. |
| 643 | Are they good at hiding it? | 他们擅长隐藏吗? |
| 644 | Yes. | 对 |
| 645 | In fact, some of the like earliest descriptions of psychopathy in particular, | 事实上,一些类似 最早描述精神病,特别是, |
| 646 | described it as like a mask of sanity. | 把它描述成像一个理智的面具。 |
| 647 | And so it's like they can seem quite kind of normal on the surface. | 所以它们看起来很正常 |
| 648 | But if you kind of get a look underneath the hood, you see that they're not running | 但是如果你在引擎盖下面看到一副表情 他们不会跑 |
| 649 | the same kind of operating system that you are. | 同样的操作系统。 |
| 650 | What is the inverse of all this stuff? | 这些东西的反面是什么? |
| 651 | Because we've pointed at the traits and a lot of those are things people understand. | 因为我们指向了这些特质 很多都是人们理解的 |
| 652 | But there's also some misconceptions. | 但也有一些误解. |
| 653 | There's also the opposite, which is like people think narcissists or psychopaths can't hold | 反之亦然,就像人们认为自恋者或精神病患者不能坚持 |
| 654 | eye contact is one of the ones you hear all the time. | 眼睛接触是你一直听到的声音之一。 |
| 655 | What are some of these ones that through your research you've been able to debunk as not | 这些是什么 通过你的研究,你能够 解析为没有 |
| 656 | being true? | 是真的吗? |
| 657 | So I think one of the biggest ones is that all people with high levels of psychopathy | 所以,我认为其中最大的一个 是,所有的人 有高的精神病 |
| 658 | are violent. | 充满暴力 |
| 659 | And that's absolutely not the case. | 而事实并非如此。 |
| 660 | It kind of links to your tweet here. | 它有点链接到你的微博。 |
| 661 | Yeah. | 对 |
| 662 | So most people think a psychopath looks dangerous. | 所以大多数人认为一个精神病人看起来很危险。 |
| 663 | They picture the villain in a movie, but that's not how it works in real life. | 他们在电影中描绘了反派,但现实生活中却不是这样. |
| 664 | So you probably noticed that like in that description that I gave you, kind of a long | 所以,你可能注意到 就像在描述 我在给你, 有点长 |
| 665 | winded description of psychopathy with all those four different elements, I did say that | 我用这四个不同的元素 来形容精神病 |
| 666 | there was rule breaking, right? | 有打破规则,对不对? |
| 667 | And sometimes that's criminal rule breaking. | 有时候这是犯规 |
| 668 | So that could be violent behavior, but it's not necessarily so. | 所以这可能是暴力行为, 但不一定是这样。 |
| 669 | So psychopathy is like a risk factor for violent behavior, but there's plenty of people who | 所以精神变态就像一个危险因素 对于暴力行为, 但有很多人谁 |
| 670 | would score relatively highly and never engage in violent behavior. | 得分会比较高 也永远不会有暴力行为 |
| 671 | They might break rules in other ways, right? | 他们可能会以其他方式违反规则,对吧? |
| 672 | So I think whenever we hear the word psychopathy, what comes to mind is like a Ted Bundy, right? | 所以,我想每当我们听到精神病这个词, 想到什么像一个泰德邦迪,对不对? |
| 673 | Ted Bundy type character. | 泰德·邦迪的类型角色。 |
| 674 | He reportedly scored I think 39 out of 40 or something on the psychopathy checklist | 据报道,他得分... ...我想40分中有39分... |
| 675 | revised, which is a measure that psychologists will use to assess how psychopathic someone | 这是心理学家用来评估精神病患者 |
| 676 | is. | 没错 |
| 677 | So yeah, he's a bit of a poster boy for those traits, but certainly people can score | 所以,他是一个有点海报男孩 这些特点,但肯定 人们可以得分 |
| 678 | highly without being a serial murderer. | 绝对不是杀人犯 |
| 679 | In terms of the amount of the population that have one of these dark personality traits, | 就拥有这些黑暗人格特征之一的人口数量而言, |
| 680 | what are the numbers? | 号码是什么? |
| 681 | How common is it? | 有多常见? |
| 682 | So this is a complicated question because as I told you, all these traits exist on a | 所以,这是一个复杂的问题,因为正如我告诉你, 所有这些特征都存在于一个 |
| 683 | continuum. | 连续 |
| 684 | So the proportion of people that we say are high on these traits depends on where you | 因此,我们所说的人的比例 高于这些特征取决于你在哪里 |
| 685 | put that cut point, right? | 把切点,对不对? |
| 686 | If we're talking about psychopathy and clinical levels, that means a score of 30 out of 40 | 如果我们说到精神病和临床水平 也就是说40分中有30分 |
| 687 | on the psychopathy checklist revised or higher, that's about 1% of the population. | 在精神病检查表上, 修改或提高, 大约1%的人口。 |
| 688 | Narcissistic personality disorder, so again, very extreme levels of those traits, enough | 神经性人格障碍,所以,再次,非常极端的这些特征,够了 |
| 689 | to warrant a diagnosis, that would be 2 to 5%. | 诊断结果为2%至5%。 |
| 690 | We don't have clinical cutoffs for sadism and Machiavellianism. | 我们没有治疗虐待症和马奇雅维利主义的临床断层。 |
| 691 | What we do have is a ton of data of people who have completed self-report questionnaires. | 我们确实掌握了完成自我报告问卷调查的人的大量数据。 |
| 692 | So like one way that you can kind of get a sense of how many people are high on these | 所以,就像一种方式,你可以 一种感觉有多少人 高在这些 |
| 693 | traits is by looking at the proportion of people who on average agree with the items. | 其特征是研究平均同意这些项目的人口比例。 |
| 694 | Like if I say, I am a born leader, to what extent do you agree with that? | 如果我说,我是天生的领袖,你在多大程度上同意这一点? |
| 695 | That's a narcissism item. | 这是一个自恋项目。 |
| 696 | If you say, yeah, I agree with that. | 如果你说,是的,我同意这一点。 |
| 697 | To what extent do you say, you like to see other people get hurt, say sadism trait? | 你说你喜欢看到别人受伤 说虐待症的特征吗? |
| 698 | Yeah, I agree with that, right? | 我同意,对吧? |
| 699 | So if you just look at the people who on average agree with the items that we use to self-report, | 所以,如果你只是看看 人们谁平均同意 我们用来自我报告的项目, |
| 700 | assess these traits, it's about 10% of the population. | 评估这些特征 大约占人口的10% |
| 701 | And where does this come from? | 这是从哪里来的? |
| 702 | Does this come from childhood trauma? | 这是来自童年的创伤吗? |
| 703 | When you think about some of these individuals you have on these photos in front of you here, | 当你想起你面前这些照片上的一些人时 |
| 704 | where do you think their antisocial or dark triad or dark personality behaviour stems from? | 你觉得他们的反社会或黑暗的三合会或黑暗的人格行为从何而来? |
| 705 | Is it something that happened in their childhood? | 是他们小时候发生的事吗? |
| 706 | Is it genetics? | 是遗传学吗? |
| 707 | Is it something else? | 是别的东西吗? |
| 708 | The answer is both. | 答案是两个。 |
| 709 | So the research suggests that with respect to psychopathy, narcissism, quite similar, | 因此研究显示,对于精神病,自恋,相当相似, |
| 710 | the variation in someone's score on that personality trait is about 50% genetic | 一个人在性格特征上的分数变化 大约50%是遗传性的 |
| 711 | and about 50% environmental experiences. | 和大约50%的环境经验。 |
| 712 | And so it can in some ways make us realise that these people didn't ask to be this way | 因此,在某些方面,它可以让我们意识到 这些人并没有要求这样 |
| 713 | because you don't get to choose your parents, so you don't get to choose your genetics. | 因为你没有选择你的父母, 所以你没有选择你的遗传。 |
| 714 | And then when it comes to those environmental experiences, often they're | 然后,当涉及到这些环境经验, 他们常常是 |
| 715 | like early life experiences and not good ones. | 像早期的生活经历 而不是好的。 |
| 716 | So research suggests that abuse, really kind of cold uncaring parenting style early in life | 因此,研究显示虐待, 真的很冷漠的不照顾 父母的方式在早期 |
| 717 | can increase the likelihood that someone will have higher levels of these traits later in life. | 能够增加某人在后世拥有更高水平的这些特征的可能性. |
| 718 | For narcissism, another variable is like over-evaluation of a child early in life | 对于自恋,另一个变数是 童年早期的过度评价 |
| 719 | may lead to more narcissistic abuse later. | 以后可能会出现更多的自恋症。 |
| 720 | What does that mean, over-evaluation? | 这是什么意思,过度评价? |
| 721 | So there's one study, it was a longitudinal study, and they asked parents like the extent | 所以有一个研究,这是一个纵向研究, 他们问父母喜欢的程度 |
| 722 | to which they told their kids like, you're special, you're like better than other kids. | 他们告诉他们的孩子喜欢, 你是特殊的, 你比其他的孩子更好。 |
| 723 | And the more the kids got that kind of feedback, | 孩子们得到的反馈越多 |
| 724 | the more likely they were to be more narcissistic later down the road. | 以后他们越是自恋 |
| 725 | They thought they were exceptional, they thought they were entitled to things that | 他们觉得自己很特别 他们觉得自己有权利享受 |
| 726 | other people were not entitled to. | 其他人没有权利 |
| 727 | And that's different than self-esteem. | 这和自尊不同 |
| 728 | We want our kids to have high self-esteem, we want them to know that they are cared for and worthy. | 我们希望我们的孩子有很高的自尊,我们希望他们知道,他们受到照顾和值得. |
| 729 | That comes from something different, that comes from a warm, responsive parenting style. | 这来自于不同的东西, 来自于一种温暖,反应灵敏的育儿风格。 |
| 730 | In that study, I was thinking about causation, and I was wondering if the parents themselves | 在研究中,我在考虑因果关系, 我在想父母是否自己 |
| 731 | had a genetic disposition to be narcissistic, is it conceivable that they then spoke highly | 他们的基因倾向是自恋的, 难道他们可以想象,然后会高谈阔论 |
| 732 | to their children, and actually maybe it wasn't the nurturing part, it was their nature, i.e. | 和他们的孩子们, 实际上,也许这不是 养育部分,这是他们的本性,即。 |
| 733 | that child also shared the genetics as the parent who had the proclivity to | 那孩子还分享了遗传学,作为父母亲,他们愿意 |
| 734 | tell them that they were the most amazing thing ever, does that make sense? | 告诉他们,这是有史以来最神奇的事情, 这有道理吗? |
| 735 | Totally, I mean, mostly I think about this in the context of psychopathy, | 完全的,我的意思是, 多数情况下,我想到这一点 在精神病的背景, |
| 736 | sometimes you've got a perfect storm, right? | 有时候你有一个完美的风暴,对不对? |
| 737 | So you might have a parent who has really high levels of these traits, so they're passing on | 所以,你可能有一个父母 谁真的高水平 这些特征,所以他们流传 |
| 738 | that potential genetic risk factor, but if you've got someone, a parent in your household who is | 但是如果你有个人的话 家里的一位家长 |
| 739 | callous, manipulative, impulsive, it's going to be very difficult to maintain a pretty stable | 无情的 操纵的 冲动的 很难维持一个很稳定的 |
| 740 | home life for that child. | 那个孩子的家庭生活 |
| 741 | And so they might end up experiencing, you know, some of those like abuse and cold kind | 这样他们可能会经历,你知道, 一些喜欢虐待和冷酷的种类 |
| 742 | of parenting styles that are also environmental risk factors for developing psychopathy later | 父母养育的作风,也是日后产生精神病的环境风险因素; |
| 743 | in life. | 在生活中。 。 。 |
| 744 | So they kind of get like a double whammy. | 所以,他们有点像一个双击。 |
| 745 | From all the research you've done, and all the studying of these dark personality traits | 从你做的所有研究 以及研究这些黑暗的个性特征 |
| 746 | you've done and self-esteem and everything in between, is there any way to increase one's | 你做了 自尊和一切 在两者之间, 有没有办法增加一个人的 |
| 747 | probability of being a good parent? | 做一个好父母的可能性? |
| 748 | Like from everything you've seen, what is the right | 就像你所看到的,什么是正确的 |
| 749 | approach? | 方法吗? |
| 750 | I know that's a difficult thing to say because kids are all different. | 我知道这很难说 因为孩子们都不一样 |
| 751 | I mean, warm and responsive parenting, is it? | 我的意思是,温暖和反应灵敏的育儿,是吗? |
| 752 | Like when you look at treatment for kids who | 就像你看着孩子的治疗 |
| 753 | are showing early warning signs of these callous and unemotional traits, that's the treatment that | 显示这些冷酷无情特征的预警迹象 这就是治疗方法 |
| 754 | seems to work. | 看来有用 |
| 755 | And actually, that's kind of like the silver lining in this whole, you know, | 实际上,这有点像 银河系在这个整体,你知道, |
| 756 | dark research area, is that early intervention with kids really can help reduce the likelihood | 黑暗的研究领域, 是早期干预儿童 真的可以帮助降低可能性 |
| 757 | of them developing high levels of psychopathic traits as they grow older. | 这些人随着年龄的增长而发展出高度的精神病特征。 |
| 758 | And usually it's like, it's training parents. | 通常它就像, 它的训练父母。 |
| 759 | You know, it's not like a kid comes in and talks | 你知道,这不像一个孩子进来说话 |
| 760 | to a therapist like once a week and then we're good, right? | 像每周一次的治疗师, 然后我们很好,对不对? |
| 761 | It's more training parents about | 更能训练父母 |
| 762 | how to respond in ways that don't like escalate, kind of create these kind of like dominance | 如何反应的方式不喜欢升级, 那种创造这种 像支配地位 |
| 763 | contests when the kid acts out, but also to reinforce and kind of model this warm and | 当孩子出场时, 还要加强 和这种模式 温暖和 |
| 764 | responsiveness. | 反应能力。 |
| 765 | But what's fascinating about psychopathy and callous and unemotional traits | 但精神变态 冷酷无情 |
| 766 | in kids, is that they tend to be not very responsive to punishment, they're very responsive | 在孩子身上,他们往往对惩罚反应不大,非常反应迅速 |
| 767 | to rewards. | 奖励。 |
| 768 | So if you see kids doing something kind or helpful, the like parent-child interaction | 所以,如果你看到孩子做一些 善良或帮助, 像父母与孩子的互动 |
| 769 | training teaches parents to repeat what they said, say that was a very kind thing to say, | 训练教父母重述他们的话 说这话真好听 |
| 770 | just like repeating, showing, responding to them, paying attention to their behavior when they do | 就像重复,展示,回应, 当他们这样做时注意他们的行为 |
| 771 | something good or kind, reinforcing it and giving that attention to increase the likelihood that | 某种好或好的东西, 强化它, 并给予这种关注 增加可能性 |
| 772 | you see it in the future. | 你将来会看到 |
| 773 | And so the inverse of that in terms of a bad way to respond to a child | 因此,反之 以坏的方式回应一个孩子 |
| 774 | that might lead to some of these dark personality traits in the future would be? | 将来这些阴暗的个性特征会是什么? |
| 775 | A cold and | 感冒,还有... |
| 776 | unresponsive parenting, getting angry, getting frustrated with them, I mean, physically harming | 没有反应的养育,生气, 对他们感到沮丧, 我的意思是,身体伤害 |
| 777 | them, that's child abuse is associated with increased likelihood of developing these traits | 虐待儿童与发展这些特征的可能性增加有关 |
| 778 | over time. | 随着时间的推移。 |
| 779 | You mentioned dominating in terms of dominating conversation, trying to outdo them. | 你提到主导对话 试图超越他们 |
| 780 | Yeah, so, I mean, and this is something that I think is not exclusive to parenting kids with | 是啊,所以,我的意思是, 这件事,我认为 并不只是为孩子做父母 |
| 781 | CU traits, but sometimes, you know, if a kid is having a tantrum, you'll like, you'll see a | CU的特征,但有时,你知道, 如果一个孩子有暴躁,你会喜欢,你会看到一个 |
| 782 | parent saying like, no, you can't have that. | 父母说,不,你不能有。 |
| 783 | And then they'll like, you know, increase the tantrum | 然后,他们会喜欢,你知道, 增加脾气 |
| 784 | level and like, no, you can't have that. | 水平和喜欢,不, 你不能有。 |
| 785 | But then once it gets to a certain point, you like give in, | 但一旦它到了某一点, 你喜欢屈服, |
| 786 | right? | 对吧? |
| 787 | What that teaches is that you just need to escalate your behaviour. | 它的教训是,你只需要 提升你的行为。 |
| 788 | You need to continue to | 你需要继续 |
| 789 | like dominate your parent, like kick it up a notch, kick it up a notch, and then at some point you're | 就像支配你的父母, 像踢它一个音节,踢它一个音节, 然后在某个时刻,你是 |
| 790 | going to win as a kid. | 小时候会赢 |
| 791 | So that kind of parenting is not going to extinguish the negative behaviour | 所以这种养育是不会消除消极行为的 |
| 792 | very effectively. | 相当有效 |
| 793 | And there's a brain scan there in front of you. | 在你面前有一个大脑扫描。 |
| 794 | What is that brain scan? | 脑部扫描是什么? |
| 795 | This is a scan of functional MRI. | 这是功能核磁共振扫描 |
| 796 | So what they're pointing out there is the prefrontal cortex. | 所以他们所说的是前额皮层。 |
| 797 | So | 这么说 |
| 798 | research suggests that people who have high levels of psychopathy tend to have less active | 研究表明,精神病高发者往往不那么活跃。 |
| 799 | and less connected prefrontal cortex. | 还有连接较少的前额皮层. |
| 800 | That's associated with impulse control. | 这和冲动控制有关 |
| 801 | It's also | 还有 |
| 802 | associated with kind of moral reasoning, moral thinking. | 与道德推理,道德思维有关 |
| 803 | If their, you know, brains are less | 如果他们的大脑越来越少 |
| 804 | same, moral or active during the same, moral or active during the same, moral or active during | 同一期间的道德或活动 |
| 805 | the same, moral or active during the same, moral or active during the same, moral or active during | 相同、道德或活跃于同一期间、道德或活跃于同一期间、道德或活跃于同一期间或 |
该视频共有字幕 808 条。解锁更多字幕为会员功能,请移动到 价格
P2 · 如何识别有毒的人|UBC心理学教授 p02 下 (P2)
字幕摘录
| 时间 | 英文 | 中文 |
|---|---|---|
| 0:00 | of during the same moral or impulse control task in those regions, this might help us | 在那些地区执行同样的道德或冲动控制任务时,这可能帮助我们 |
| 0:06 | to explain why they're more likely to behave impulsively, to, you know, not be empathetic | 解释为什么他们更可能 行为冲动,你知道的, 不同情 |
| 0:13 | to other people. | 给别人 |
| 0:14 | There's also the amygdala, which I don't think you can see on here, | 还有阿米格达拉 我想你看不到 |
| 0:17 | but – and it's on the inside. | 但是 - 它的内在。 |
| 0:19 | You can open it up. | 你可以打开它。 |
| 0:20 | Oh, okay. | 哦,还好。 |
| 0:21 | Let's see. | 让我看看。 |
| 0:22 | So, other research on psychopathy suggests that the amygdala, | 因此,其他关于精神病的研究 表明,阿米格达拉, |
| 0:27 | which is deep within our brain, is also associated with emotional response, particularly fear. | 和情感反应有关 特别是恐惧 |
展开字幕全文(1198 条)
| 序号 | 英文 | 中文 |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | of during the same moral or impulse control task in those regions, this might help us | 在那些地区执行同样的道德或冲动控制任务时,这可能帮助我们 |
| 2 | to explain why they're more likely to behave impulsively, to, you know, not be empathetic | 解释为什么他们更可能 行为冲动,你知道的, 不同情 |
| 3 | to other people. | 给别人 |
| 4 | There's also the amygdala, which I don't think you can see on here, | 还有阿米格达拉 我想你看不到 |
| 5 | but – and it's on the inside. | 但是 - 它的内在。 |
| 6 | You can open it up. | 你可以打开它。 |
| 7 | Oh, okay. | 哦,还好。 |
| 8 | Let's see. | 让我看看。 |
| 9 | So, other research on psychopathy suggests that the amygdala, | 因此,其他关于精神病的研究 表明,阿米格达拉, |
| 10 | which is deep within our brain, is also associated with emotional response, particularly fear. | 和情感反应有关 特别是恐惧 |
| 11 | And so we know that people with high levels of psychopathy tend to have – they experience | 因此,我们知道, 高水平的精神病患者 往往有,他们经历 |
| 12 | pretty low fear, and they're not very good at, like, aversive conditioning, right? | 相当低的恐惧, 他们不是很擅长, 像,逆向调节,对不对? |
| 13 | So, | 这么说 |
| 14 | like, if we get punished for something, we learn that whenever we, you know, come up | 喜欢,如果我们被惩罚的东西, 我们学会,每当我们,你知道,上来 |
| 15 | against that stimuli again in the future, we're like, oh, that turned out really badly | 以后再与这种刺激作对,我们就像,哦,结果很糟 |
| 16 | last time. | 上次是那个 |
| 17 | I'm going to avoid that. | 我会避免的 |
| 18 | So amygdalas in people with high levels of psychopathy | 精神病发作程度高的患者中 |
| 19 | tend to be both smaller and less active. | 往往既较小,也不太活跃。 |
| 20 | So there is, like, you know, brain differences, | 所以,有一样,你知道, 大脑差异, |
| 21 | neurological differences between people with high levels and low levels of psychopathy. | 高水平和低水平精神病患者之间的神经系统差异。 |
| 22 | So I guess this begs the question, that if someone has those traits you've described | 所以我想这很麻烦 如果有人有你描述的特质 |
| 23 | or if there are any one of these four things in this dark triad, these dark personality | 如果这四样东西中 有任何一种 黑暗的三角形,这些黑暗的个性 |
| 24 | traits, can they be cured? | 特质,可以治愈吗? |
| 25 | So some change is possible, but I mean, some. | 所以有些改变是可能的,但我的意思是,有些。 |
| 26 | Some being an operative word there. | 一些人在那里是一个执行语。 |
| 27 | So most | 所以大多数 |
| 28 | of the research we have on psychopathy in particular comes from criminal offenders. | 我们有关精神病的研究 尤其来自罪犯。 |
| 29 | So individuals who are incarcerated have to take part in some treatment while they're | 因此,被监禁的个人必须参加一些治疗,同时他们 |
| 30 | inside. | 进去 |
| 31 | And the research finds that they're not particularly motivated to change. | 而研究发现它们并没有特别的改变动机. |
| 32 | So that's | 这么说吧 |
| 33 | a big problem with, like, all of these things, because they don't particularly care about | 一大问题,喜欢,所有这些东西, 因为他们并不特别关心 |
| 34 | other people. | 别人。 |
| 35 | And it tends to be other people that they are hurting with their behavior. | 他们的行为往往伤害着其他人。 |
| 36 | And so it's like, why would I change? | 我为什么要改变? |
| 37 | This is like a you problem, not a me problem, right? | 这就像你的问题,而不是我的问题,对不对? |
| 38 | So motivation can be difficult to come by with this population. | 因此,动机可能很难通过 与这些人口。 |
| 39 | But if they do consistently | 但是如果他们坚持 |
| 40 | engage in cognitive behavioral therapies, you can reduce the likelihood of recidivism. | 参与认知行为疗法,可以降低累犯的可能性. |
| 41 | So the likelihood that they will reoffend upon release. | 因此,他们被释放后重新犯罪的可能性。 |
| 42 | Again, we're talking about | 再说一遍 我们说的是 |
| 43 | incarcerated individuals. | 被监禁者。 |
| 44 | When it comes to lower levels of these traits, it's really | 说到这些特征的较低水平,其实是 |
| 45 | interesting research by Nathan Hudson had people do these agreeableness challenges. | 内森·哈德森的有趣研究 让人们做了这些令人愉快的挑战。 |
| 46 | And agreeableness is kind of like the opposite of these traits. | 同意性与这些特征正好相反。 |
| 47 | So you would just ping them | 所以,你只是按他们 |
| 48 | on their smartphone every day and would say like, oh, you should give a compliment to | 每天在他们的智能手机上 都会说 你应该赞美一下 |
| 49 | You should reach out to a friend and just offer them some encouragement. | 你应该和朋友联系 给他们一些鼓励 |
| 50 | You should, | 你应该 |
| 51 | you know, buy coffee for the person behind you in line at the cafe today. | 今天在咖啡馆为后面的人买咖啡 |
| 52 | These little | 这些小 |
| 53 | things where people were encouraged to be kind, be helpful to other people, to see other | 那些鼓励人们善待他人 帮助他人 去看别人 |
| 54 | people's perspectives, and people who actually followed through on those did report having | 人们的观点, 以及那些真正关注这些观点的人 报告说, |
| 55 | lower levels of these traits after four months than at the start. | 四个月后,这些特征的水平低于开始时的水平。 |
| 56 | And in your book, under the section that says hard truths, dark personalities persist, you | 在你的书里,在说真话的章节下,黑暗的个性持续着,你 |
| 57 | write poisonous people aren't likely to change very much. | 写毒虫不会有很大变化 |
| 58 | Personality traits are by | 个性特征是由 |
| 59 | definition enduring. | 定义持久。 |
| 60 | Although some evolution of our character happens naturally, it takes | 虽然我们的性格有些进化是自然的,但需要 |
| 61 | decade data suggests that people become a bit more agreeable over time. | 十年的数据表明,随着时间推移,人们变得比较容易接受。 |
| 62 | And research | 还有研究 |
| 63 | with incarcerated men finds that even those with clinical levels of psychopathy are less | 发现即使是那些有精神病的病人 |
| 64 | likely to reoffend as they get older. | 可能会随着年龄的增长而重新犯罪 |
| 65 | Even so, waiting it out is likely to be a painful | 虽然如此,等待它出来 很可能是一个痛苦的 |
| 66 | strategy. | 战略。 |
| 67 | One study asked more than a thousand people who knew individuals who were psychopathic | 一项研究询问了一千多名认识精神病患者的人。 |
| 68 | for a long time, whether their behaviour had improved past the age of 50. | 很久以来,他们的行为是否已经超过50岁。 |
| 69 | Almost all respondents, | 几乎所有答复者, |
| 70 | 93%, said that as researchers put it, quote, the behaviour was just as bad or worse after | 93%的人说,研究者说, 引文,行为同样糟糕 或更糟 |
| 71 | age 50 than it had been previously. | 50岁比以前多 |
| 72 | Just as bad or worse. | 亦复如是恶或更恶. |
| 73 | Mm hmm. | 垛 |
| 74 | I mean, this is our personality, right? | 我的意思是,这是我们的人格,对不对? |
| 75 | So it's kind of like asking a tiger to change | 所以,这有点像 要求老虎改变 |
| 76 | their stripes. | 他们的条纹。 |
| 77 | So if you're not motivated to do it, as we know, people with these traits | 所以,如果你没有动机 这样做,我们知道,人 有这些特征 |
| 78 | tend not to be very motivated. | 往往没有很大的动机。 |
| 79 | That's where that, you know, 90 some percent of folks come | 这就是,你知道, 90%的人来 |
| 80 | in. | 进去 |
| 81 | It's like they're not, they're not dramatically changing unless they find some | 他们好像没有,他们不会大变 除非他们找到一些 |
| 82 | reason to do so. | 这样做的理由。 |
| 83 | One of the smartest things a business can do is build like a bigger company without | 企业最聪明的一件事 就是像大公司一样建设 |
| 84 | actually hiring like one. | 实际雇用像一个。 |
| 85 | But the problem we all face is that most companies don't have | 但我们都面临的问题是 大多数公司都没有 |
| 86 | every skill in house. | 家里的每个技能 |
| 87 | So when I look at the businesses seeing real success today, the | 所以,当我看 企业看到真正的成功今天, |
| 88 | consistent pattern with all of them is how quickly they move. | 与所有它们一致的规律是它们移动多快. |
| 89 | They bring in specialists | 他们带来专家 |
| 90 | with skills in emerging areas to keep themselves ahead. | 拥有新兴领域的技能,以保持领先。 |
| 91 | Even in our company, we spent the last | 即使在我们公司,我们花了最后一笔 |
| 92 | year pulling in talent across areas like AI native strategy, no code builds and product | 年度吸引人才跨越AI本土战略等领域,没有建立代码和产品 |
| 93 | workflows. | 工作流程。 |
| 94 | And we find this talent through our longtime partner, Fiverr Pro. | 我们通过我们的长期伴侣,Fiverr Pro 找到这种天赋。 |
| 95 | Their premium | 他们的保费 |
| 96 | service only shows you vetted talent. | 服务只显示你被审查的天赋。 |
| 97 | So you've always got the safeguard that anyone you pull | 所以,你总是有保障 任何人你拉 |
| 98 | in to help you with a complex project has the skills that you're after and will deliver | 帮助你完成一个复杂的项目 拥有你所追求的技能 并且会提供 |
| 99 | to the same high standards as your internal team. | 和你的内部团队一样高标准 |
| 100 | And most importantly, they'll keep up | 最重要的是,他们会跟上 |
| 101 | with the pace. | 以节奏。 |
| 102 | It's a simple strategy, but it lets us stay agile without compromising | 这是一个简单的策略,但它让我们保持敏捷 不妥协 |
| 103 | on quality. | 关于质量。 |
| 104 | So if you need these kind of skills in your business, head to pro.fiverr.com to | 因此,如果你需要这种技能 在你的生意, 头到pro. |
| 105 | find pioneering talent to fill your business's gaps. | 找到开拓性人才来填补你的生意空白. |
| 106 | 这是pro.fiverr.com的 你好,我没有 | |
| 107 | able to make that finance meeting. | 能够召开金融会议。 |
| 108 | Can you tell me what I missed? | 你能告诉我我错过了什么吗? |
| 109 | What I have in front | 我前面的东西 |
| 110 | 我是Whileper Flow的新收音机 | |
| 111 | And for me, it's been an absolute game changer. | 对我来说,它是一个绝对的游戏改变者。 |
| 112 | I spend most of my life sat in very, very long meetings with lots of different teams | 我一生中的大部分时间 都和很多不同的团队在很长很长的时间里会面 |
| 113 | and lots of different departments. | 很多不同的部门。 |
| 114 | In any given week, I could have 40, 50 meetings and | 在任何一周,我可以有 40,50次会议和 |
| 115 | sometimes more. | 有时更多。 |
| 116 | But also I sit in podcasts where lots of very interesting things get | 我也坐在播客里 有很多有趣的东西 |
| 117 | said. | 说 |
| 118 | And I need to focus on the conversation. | 我需要专注于对话。 |
| 119 | What Whisper Flow's note taker does for me | "Whileper Flow的笔记"收录者对我所做的一切 |
| 120 | is it captures the entire context of everything that's happened throughout my entire week. | 是它记录了我整个星期所发生的一切 |
| 121 | It labels who the people are that said what. | 上面标注了那些人说了什么 |
| 122 | And I can ask it for things that I might have | 我可以要求它的东西 我可能有 |
| 123 | forgotten, for actions, things that I said I would do that I haven't yet done. | 忘记了,作为行动, 我说我会做那些 我还没有做。 |
| 124 | It's | 这是 |
| 125 | building this sort of broader context of everything that's happening in my life. | 造就我生命中所发生的一切 |
| 126 | And it's incredible, | 这是不可思议的, |
| 127 | incredible superpower. | 不可思议的超能力。 |
| 128 | I love the fact that so many of you come up to me in the street | 我喜欢你们这么多人在街上来找我 |
| 129 | because you know I'm an investor in Whisper Flow and tell me how much it's changed your | 因为你知道我是Whisper Flow的投资者 告诉我它改变了多少 |
| 130 | life. | 活着 |
| 131 | It is the worst kept secret in productivity. | 这是生产力方面最糟糕的秘密。 |
| 132 | 狦稱秨 碞 whisper | |
| 133 | slash Stephen to download it right now and give it a try. | 砍Stephen把它下载下来 试试看 |
| 134 | And once you try it, I think | 一旦你尝试,我想 |
| 135 | you realize why we let them sponsor this podcast. | 你知道为什么我们让他们赞助这个播客。 |
| 136 | It's amazing. | 不可思议. |
| 137 | Is there anything else in this bucket that you find interesting? | 这桶里还有别的东西你觉得有趣吗? |
| 138 | Because I know you may | 因为我知道你可能 |
| 139 | or may not be working on a book that really focuses on deception. | 也可能不是在写一本真正注重欺骗的书 |
| 140 | But is there anything | 但有没有什么 |
| 141 | else that we haven't covered here that you think is pertinent or any research that you | 否则,我们没有覆盖 在这里,你认为相关 或任何研究你 |
| 142 | uncovered that was fascinating? | 发现那很迷人吗? |
| 143 | So in my lab right now, I've become increasingly fascinated with how we respond to people who | 所以现在在我的实验室里 我越来越迷上 我们如何回应那些 |
| 144 | are lying to us when we're not suspicious at all. | 当我们毫不怀疑的时候 对我们撒谎 |
| 145 | Because most of the research is like, | 因为大部分研究都像, |
| 146 | I give you a bunch of videos, and I tell you some of these people are lying, some are telling | 我给你一些视频, 我告诉你,有些人在撒谎,有些人在说 |
| 147 | the truth, and you make judgments about them. | 真理,你当判决他们。 |
| 148 | But that's not how real life works like at | 但现实生活不是这样的 |
| 149 | all, right? | 好吗? |
| 150 | So usually, we're having some sort of interaction with people. | 所以通常,我们和人们有某种互动。 |
| 151 | No one comes | 没人来 |
| 152 | in and says, you need to judge the veracity of this person. | 你得判断这个人的真实性 |
| 153 | We're just having a conversation. | 我们只是聊聊天 |
| 154 | And so I've been really interested in how conversations unfold, how interactions unfold | 所以我一直很感兴趣 如何对话 如何互动 |
| 155 | when one person is lying and the other person is just like, none the wiser. | 当一个人在说谎 而另一个人就像, 没有一个更聪明。 |
| 156 | And so we keep | 所以我们继续 |
| 157 | finding these pretty small but consistent effects that people feel less close to their | 发现这些微小但持续的影响 人们感觉不太接近他们 |
| 158 | interaction partner when someone is lying to them. | 当有人在骗他们时,就成为互动伙伴。 |
| 159 | Close. | 关闭。 |
| 160 | Yeah. | 对 |
| 161 | So we actually had this study where we got people to just converse, right? | 所以,我们实际上有这个研究 我们让人们只是交谈,对不对? |
| 162 | Talk | 说话 |
| 163 | to a stranger. | 对一个陌生人。 |
| 164 | One person was told to lie in response to everything. | 一个人被告知要撒谎,以应对一切。 |
| 165 | The other person | 另一个人 |
| 166 | had no idea that was going on. | 没想到会这样 |
| 167 | And at the end of that study, the dyads that had a liar | 在研究结束时 那些骗子们 |
| 168 | in them said, I feel less connected to this other person than dyads where both people | 在他们说,我感觉 与另一个人的联系 不如二人 |
| 169 | were telling the truth. | 说的是实话 |
| 170 | And so we also found that the more lies that people tell, they | 所以我们也发现 人们越多的谎言,他们 |
| 171 | just self-report on how much they lie in their everyday life, the more lonely they feel. | 只是自我报告 他们的日常生活中有多少谎言, 他们越感到孤独。 |
| 172 | And so we're finding this kind of bi-directional effect. | 所以我们发现了这种双向效应。 |
| 173 | And I think often people lie to spare | 我想人们经常撒谎 以示宽恕 |
| 174 | the feelings of others. | 别人的感情 |
| 175 | That's for the average person, not necessarily these traits here, | 这是普通人, 不一定这些特征在这里, |
| 176 | but for the average person, most of the lies that we tell are pro-social in nature. | 但对于普通人来说,我们所讲的大多数谎言都是亲社会的。 |
| 177 | Like, | 喜欢, |
| 178 | I tell you a lie because I don't want to hurt your feelings. | 我说谎是因为我不想伤害你的感情 |
| 179 | But we are finding that that | 但我们发现 |
| 180 | actually creates this like social distance between us as opposed to bringing us closer | 其实我们之间的社交距离 不像让我们更接近 |
| 181 | together. | 一起来 |
| 182 | And so I've been really interested in just kind of like the negative impacts | 所以我一直很感兴趣 就像负面的影响 |
| 183 | of telling lies, even when we do it for quote unquote good reasons. | 谎言,即使我们这样做 引用未引用的好理由。 |
| 184 | In that you talked about how when, if we were both sat down and you were asked to lie to | 你说过,如果我们都坐下来 你被要求撒谎 |
| 185 | I would walk away feeling like I was less close, i.e. | 我就会觉得自己不太亲近 |
| 186 | slash connected to you. | 与你相连的斜线。 |
| 187 | What is | 这是什么 |
| 188 | it in your, in your behaviour or in my perception that you think is causing this feeling of | 它在你,在你的行为 或在我看来,你认为 造成这种感觉 |
| 189 | disconnection? | 断开? |
| 190 | So we are finding that people who are lying are perceived as less warm. | 因此,我们发现,说谎的人被认为不那么温和。 |
| 191 | They're perceived | 他们被感觉到了 |
| 192 | as less competent. | 更不称职 |
| 193 | They're perceived as less moral. | 他们被认为道德水平较低. |
| 194 | Also, if we think about like some of | 而且,如果我们想 像一些 |
| 195 | the cues of deception that we talked about earlier, when people give relatively few details | 我们之前谈到的骗局, 当时人们给出的细节相对较少 |
| 196 | about themselves, conversations are based on this reciprocal exchange, right? | 关于他们自己,对话是基于 这种对等交换,对不对? |
| 197 | Like I | 喜欢我 |
| 198 | tell you something about myself, you tell me something about yourself, and like we start | 告诉你一些关于我自己的事, 你告诉我一些关于你自己的事, |
| 199 | to know each other, right? | 认识对方,对不对? |
| 200 | And so if you've got someone who's lying to you, they're giving | 所以,如果你有谁 骗你,他们给予 |
| 201 | you less information about themselves, for example. | 比如说,你对自己的信息较少。 |
| 202 | And so I don't feel like I know you | 所以我不觉得自己认识你 |
| 203 | at the end of our conversation. | 在谈话结束时 |
| 204 | Even though I'm not like actively suspicious that you're | 虽然我不是那种怀疑你的人 |
| 205 | lying to me about your likes and your interests and what you did on Friday afternoon, it comes | 对我撒谎 关于你的喜好和兴趣 和你星期五下午做的事,它来了 |
| 206 | across because you gave me less information. | 因为你给我的信息少了 |
| 207 | And that maybe I think he didn't really want | 也许我想他不想 |
| 208 | to talk to me. | 跟我说话。 |
| 209 | I mean, I'm so fascinated by this, the fact that you have a lab that tests this stuff. | 我是说,我对这个很着迷 你有一个实验室来测试这些东西 |
| 210 | What are some of the fascinating questions you've gone in search of answers for in your | 你为寻找答案而问的这些令人着迷的问题是什么? |
| 211 | lab? | 实验室? |
| 212 | One that I love is how much sympathy people feel for individuals who are lying or telling | 我最爱的就是 人们对撒谎或告诉别人的人的同情 |
| 213 | the truth about how sad they are. | 他们有多伤心的真相 |
| 214 | So like think back to the pleaders, right, that we | 所以,像想回想 律师,对,我们 |
| 215 | talked about. | 谈起过 |
| 216 | If you look at this face, right, versus this face, like how much empathy do | 如果你看着这张脸,对,对着这张脸, 就像多少同情 |
| 217 | you have for that person? | 你有这个人吗? |
| 218 | How sad do you feel? | 你有多伤心? |
| 219 | How willing are you to donate money to whatever | 你愿意捐钱给什么 |
| 220 | cause they're looking for? | 因为他们在找? |
| 221 | So like we studied this with the pleaders that we talked about. | 就像我们和我们讨论过的请愿者研究过一样。 |
| 222 | So people who went on TV and asked for help trying to find their missing loved one, half | 所以那些上电视求救的人 想找到他们失踪的亲人 一半 |
| 223 | of whom were actually responsible for killing that person they pleaded to find. | 这些人对杀害他们要求找到的人负有实际责任。 |
| 224 | And we showed | 我们展示 |
| 225 | people again, they weren't aware that some of these folks were lying and some were telling | 他们不知道有些人在撒谎 有些人在说 |
| 226 | the truth, but we showed them these videos and we said, how much sympathy do you feel | 真相,但我们给他们看这些视频 我们说,你有多同情 |
| 227 | for this person who's asking for help trying to find the missing individual? | 这个人是谁在寻求帮助 寻找失踪的人? |
| 228 | And how much | 多少钱 |
| 229 | money would you donate to a theoretical GoFundMe that would like help support the search for | 你愿意捐钱给一个理论上的GoFundMe吗? |
| 230 | this missing person? | 这个失踪的人? |
| 231 | And we find really consistently that people are more willing to donate money | 我们发现人们更愿意捐钱 |
| 232 | to the genuine pleaders relative to the deceptive ones and they feel more kind of sympathy and | 与那些欺骗者相对的 真诚的恳求者 他们更同情 |
| 233 | compassion for them, even though they're not, you know, they don't know that some of these | 同情他们,尽管他们不是,你知道, 他们不知道其中一些 |
| 234 | folks are actually like deceptive murderers. | 人们其实就像欺骗性杀人犯 |
| 235 | And the effects are like, you know, not gigantic, | 效果就像,你知道, 不是巨大的, |
| 236 | but it does suggest that like we're not completely clueless moving through the world. | 但它确实表明,我们不是 完全无能地穿越世界。 |
| 237 | But when | 但何时 |
| 238 | we reduce it to a simple binary, is this person lying or telling the truth? | 我们把它简化为一个简单的二进制, 这个人是说谎还是说实话? |
| 239 | We lose a lot | 我们输了很多 |
| 240 | of kind of like the nuance of how we move through our relationships and like, oh, I'm | 有点像 我们如何通过我们的关系的细微变化 |
| 241 | feeling kind of close to this person, closer to that person. | 感觉有点接近这个人 更接近那个人 |
| 242 | I'm willing to help this person | 我愿意帮助这个人 |
| 243 | more than that person. | 比那个人还要多 |
| 244 | Yeah. | 对 |
| 245 | So those are the kinds of things I've been interested in. | 这些都是我感兴趣的事情。 |
| 246 | 我和Vanessa van Edwards在播客上谈过几次 她经常做 | |
| 247 | of stuff around like body language and how you show up and she talks about warmth and | 身体语言之类的东西 还有你如何出现 她谈到温暖 |
| 248 | competence and how some people can over index on warmth. | 能力,以及一些人如何通过 指数在温暖。 |
| 249 | And maybe that brings them down on | 也许这让他们失望 |
| 250 | competence or they can over index on competence, but be less warm. | 能力或者他们可以超越能力指数,但不要那么热。 |
| 251 | Wanted to know if you had a | 想知道你有没有 |
| 252 | perspective on this, like how through your research and through all the studies you've done, | 关于这一点,比如如何通过你的研究 通过你所做的所有研究, |
| 253 | can you be warm and competent at the same time? | 你能同时温暖和胜任吗? |
| 254 | Or is there a bit of a trade off? | 还是有一点交换? |
| 255 | And like, | 喜欢, |
| 256 | even use the word warmth a second ago, what is it to be a warm person? | 甚至用温暖这个词 在一秒钟前, 它是什么是一个温暖的人? |
| 257 | Is it to be like, how? | 感觉怎么样? |
| 258 | No, it's like, it is the sense that someone is kind and honest and trustworthy. | 不,这就像,这是一种感觉 某人是善良,诚实和值得信赖的。 |
| 259 | It is your | 这是你的 |
| 260 | benevolent intentions toward another person, right? | 善意的对另一个人,对不对? |
| 261 | So we trust people to the extent that they are | 因此,我们信任人们的程度 |
| 262 | both warm and competent in the sense that like, I'm going to trust you if I think you have | 既温暖又能胜任 那种感觉,如果我觉得你有的话 我会信任你 |
| 263 | benevolent intentions toward me, that I think you like want to be kind to me. | 对我好,我想你喜欢对我好 |
| 264 | But also if I | 但如果我 |
| 265 | think you can actually execute on that thing, like do you have the competence, the ability | 认为你实际上可以执行 在那个东西, 就像你有能力,能力 |
| 266 | to actually, you know, do that thing, make that connection for me at work, right? | 实际上,你知道的,做那件事, 使这种连接我的工作,对不对? |
| 267 | It's like, | 这就像, |
| 268 | if you are just warm, but like you've got no, you don't have like the ability to back it up, | 如果你只是暖和,但像你有 没有,你没有 像能力备份, |
| 269 | then we tend to trust those individuals less. | 那我们就更不信任这些人了 |
| 270 | So this warmth, high warmth, | 因此,这个温暖,高温, |
| 271 | high competence tends to be associated with high trustworthiness. | 能力高往往与信誉高有关。 |
| 272 | And does high warmth come with certain behaviors? | 高温是否伴随着某些行为? |
| 273 | Yeah, I mean, one is just smiling. | 是啊,我的意思是,一个只是微笑。 |
| 274 | Eye contact, you know, it reminds me of the research by Alison Woodbrook, so I know has | 眼睛接触,你知道,它让我想起 艾莉森·伍德布鲁克的研究, 所以我知道 |
| 275 | been here before as well. | 以前也来过这里 |
| 276 | And, you know, being engaged and interested in your conversation | 而且,你知道, 订婚和感兴趣 与你的谈话 |
| 277 | partner, right? | 搭档,对吧? |
| 278 | These like immediacy cues, like you're leaning in, you're paying attention, | 这就像即时提示, 像你倾斜, 你注意, |
| 279 | you are smiling, you're making eye contact, these things are associated with warmth. | 你在笑,你在做眼睛接触, 这些东西与温暖有关。 |
| 280 | What about resting bitch face? | 那休息的婊子脸呢? |
| 281 | I am occasionally guilty of this thing when I concentrate. | 当我专心的时候 我偶尔会犯错 |
| 282 | So when we have very little | 所以,当我们很少 |
| 283 | information about a person, we're just trying to pick up on anything, right? | 一个人的信息,我们只是 试图得到任何东西,对不对? |
| 284 | In their body | 在他们身上 |
| 285 | language, their nonverbal behavior, to try to make an assessment of them. | 语言,他们的非言语行为, 试图对它们进行评估。 |
| 286 | If we've just got like | 如果我们刚刚得到像 |
| 287 | a quick look at your face, and there's a bit of a scowl on it, that signals to us anger. | 快速的看你的脸, 和上面有一点点的 s, 这给我们的愤怒。 |
| 288 | And anger | 愤怒 |
| 289 | is not a very, that's not a warm thing, right? | 这不是一个非常, 这不是一个温暖的东西,对不对? |
| 290 | And so that tends to decrease our perceived | 因此,这往往会减少 我们的感知 |
| 291 | trustworthiness of people. | 信任人们。 |
| 292 | Any other fascinating questions you've pursued in your lab? | 你在实验室里还找过什么有趣的问题吗? |
| 293 | So I've been really interested in psychopathy, as it relates to like leadership outcomes. | 所以我对精神病很感兴趣, 因为它涉及到领导的结果。 |
| 294 | So | 这么说 |
| 295 | whenever I finished my PhD, I was trying to figure out what I was going to do next. | 当我完成我的博士, 我试图 找出我下一步要做什么。 |
| 296 | And I was kind of | 我有点 |
| 297 | bummed out thinking about murder all the time. | 一直想着谋杀 |
| 298 | I was like, I really love these topics, but I got to | 我很喜欢这些话题 但我必须 |
| 299 | go somewhere else and like think about this in a different context. | 去别的地方,喜欢考虑 在不同的背景。 |
| 300 | It was shortly after like the | 刚过不久 |
| 301 | Bernie Madoff Ponzi scheme kind of fell apart. | 伯尼·麦道夫·庞齐计划崩溃了 |
| 302 | And I was like, oh, maybe like business school. | 我就像是,哦,也许像商学院。 |
| 303 | Like I could go to a different context and study these same like personality traits just in a | 就像我可以去不同的背景 研究这些 就像个性特征一样 |
| 304 | different area. | 不同区域。 |
| 305 | And I was also interested in like this notion of a successful psychopathy, | 我对这个精神病人成功的概念也很感兴趣 |
| 306 | because like since really early descriptions of psychopathy, there's been this suggestion that | 因为就像早期对精神病的描述一样 有一种暗示是 |
| 307 | these traits can actually help you to succeed, right? | 这些特征可以帮助你成功 对吧? |
| 308 | And I often hear that from people where | 我经常从人们那里听到 |
| 309 | they're like, yeah, like that's terrible behavior, but like, you know, sometimes that helps, right? | 他们喜欢,是的,喜欢 这是可怕的行为, 但喜欢,你知道, 有时有帮助,对不对? |
| 310 | And I'm like, does it? | 而我喜欢,是吗? |
| 311 | Like, what does the data say on that? | 数据上怎么说的? |
| 312 | 所以我和Dacher Keltner一起工作 | |
| 313 | Oh, Dacher's been here as well. | 达彻也来过了 |
| 314 | Has he? | 是吗? |
| 315 | I love that guy. | 我爱那家伙。 |
| 316 | He's so wonderful. | 他真厉害 |
| 317 | I love him. | 我爱他 |
| 318 | And so we studied, you know, the extent to which | 所以,我们研究,你知道, 程度 |
| 319 | psychopathic personality traits could increase the amount of influence you have in government, | 精神病人的个性特征 可能会增加你对政府的影响 |
| 320 | and also the amount of money that you make as a hedge fund manager. | 以及你作为对冲基金经理所赚的钱数额。 |
| 321 | Those are kind of the two | 两者都是一样 |
| 322 | cont- because I was like these hyper competitive contexts, right? | 因为我就像这些竞争激烈的环境,对吧? |
| 323 | Where maybe in government, | 也许在政府, |
| 324 | you can kind of like backstab and backroom deals and whatever. | 你可以有点像后台 后室交易之类的 |
| 325 | They might be able, | 他们也许可以 |
| 326 | you might be able to get lots of co-sponsors on your bills if you're using kind of these | 如果你用这些钱的话,你可能会得到很多的赞助商 |
| 327 | backroom tactics. | 后室战术。 |
| 328 | And then I thought with respect to money, maybe you're willing to | 然后我想到钱 也许你愿意 |
| 329 | take more risks, right? | 冒更多的风险,对不对? |
| 330 | You're willing to cut people or companies down in public. | 你愿意在公众场合 砍掉人或公司 |
| 331 | You're not so worried about hurting other people. | 你没那么担心伤害别人 |
| 332 | So I of course was like, these are situations | 所以我当然喜欢,这些是情况 |
| 333 | where people with high levels of psychopathy can shine. | 精神错乱程度高的人可以闪耀 |
| 334 | Dacher was like, no, it won't be. | 达彻说,不会的 |
| 335 | So we | 所以我们 |
| 336 | were kind of pitting these like good versus evil concepts against each other. | 是那种把这些像好 和邪恶的概念对彼此。 |
| 337 | And consistently, | 并始终如一, |
| 338 | we found that high levels of psychopathy was associated with less influence in government. | 我们发现高水平的精神病 与政府影响力较小有关 |
| 339 | It was also associated with making less money as a hedge fund manager. | 它还与作为对冲基金管理人挣钱较少有关。 |
| 340 | Whereas it's very like | 而这就像 |
| 341 | counterintuitive, I think, to people. | 反直觉,我想,对人。 |
| 342 | What about some of these other ones, | 还有其他的呢? |
| 343 | like narcissism and Machiavellianism? | 像自恋和马奇亚维尔主义? |
| 344 | What about those ones? | 这些呢? |
| 345 | So it really depends on like how you define success. | 这真的取决于你如何定义成功。 |
| 346 | So there is some research to suggest that | 所以有些研究显示 |
| 347 | narcissism, Machiavellianism can be associated with kind of rising up in ranks, maybe having | 自恋,马奇亚维利安主义 可能与队伍上升有关 |
| 348 | higher salary level. | 工资水平提高。 |
| 349 | But they're not associated with teams doing great, right? | 但他们和球队干得不错,对吧? |
| 350 | And honestly, | 说实话 |
| 351 | most of the research is on psychopathy. | 大部分研究都是关于精神病的 |
| 352 | The work that I'm interested in is that people | 我感兴趣的工作是人们 |
| 353 | with high levels of psychopathy, they talk a really good game and they make people think | 有高水平的精神病, 他们谈论一个非常好的游戏, 他们让人们思考 |
| 354 | that they're a great tactical communicator. | 他们是一个伟大的战术通讯员。 |
| 355 | They're very strategic thinkers. | 他们非常有战略意义 |
| 356 | But if you | 不过如果你 |
| 357 | they say they're a terrible manager, they tend to bully their subordinates, they create a huge | 他们说自己是个糟糕的经理 他们经常欺负下属 制造一个巨大的 |
| 358 | amount of stress for other people on their team. | 对团队中其他人的压力很大 |
| 359 | And their teams have worse outcomes because of it. | 而他们的团队也因此得到更糟糕的结果. |
| 360 | So when you're talking about team performance, | 所以当你谈论团队表现时 |
| 361 | you're saying narcissists typically aren't good at leading teams over the long term? | 你是说自恋者 通常不会长期领导队伍? |
| 362 | They tend to come across as like leadership material early on. | 它们往往像早期的领导材料一样出现。 |
| 363 | And there's this one study by | 还有一个研究 |
| 364 | Del Pallhaus, 这表现得很好。 | |
| 365 | It's like they had these student groups, | 就像他们有这些学生团体, |
| 366 | and they worked together throughout the term. | 他们在整个学期里一起工作。 |
| 367 | After the first meeting, they all made judgments | 第一次见面后 他们都做了判决 |
| 368 | about each other, how likeable they were, et cetera, et cetera, whether they seemed confident | 彼此之间,他们是多么的可喜, 诸如此类的, 他们看起来是否自信 |
| 369 | and smart and agreeable. | 和聪明,和愉快。 |
| 370 | The people who were high in narcissism came across really well in that first | 那些自恋狂的人 第一次遇到的非常棒 |
| 371 | interaction. | 互动。 |
| 372 | They said they knew what they were doing. | 他们说他们知道自己在做什么 |
| 373 | They came across very confident. | 他们遇到非常自信。 |
| 374 | They seemed like they could lead. | 他们似乎可以领导。 |
| 375 | They wanted to lead. | 他们想要领导。 |
| 376 | But then as the course of the term went by, | 但随着学期的过去 |
| 377 | people were like, this person is actually really hostile and like doesn't do their work, | 人们喜欢,这个人实际上是 真正的敌意,喜欢不做他们的工作, |
| 378 | and they're a pain in the butt. | 他们很烦人 |
| 379 | So certainly the thing that can make narcissism look good at the | 因此,肯定的东西 可以使自恋 看上去不错 |
| 380 | outset is our confusion of confidence and competence. | 首先,我们混淆了信任和能力。 |
| 381 | So when someone says they can do | 所以当有人说他们可以 |
| 382 | something, and they say it very confidently, we're like, oh, they got this, right? | 他们非常自信地说,我们就像, 哦,他们得到了这个,对不对? |
| 383 | But that's | 不过 |
| 384 | not the same thing as actually being able to do it. | 和真正能做到的不一样 |
| 385 | There's often like an assumption that people | 常有这样的假设: |
| 386 | that are actors or have certain roles where they're on stage performing have high levels of some of | 演员或某些角色 在舞台上表演 |
| 387 | these things. | 这些东西。 |
| 388 | Is there any truth to that at all? | 这到底有什么道理吗? |
| 389 | Not to my knowledge. | 据我所知,没有 |
| 390 | Although, so I think where | 虽然,所以我想在哪里 |
| 391 | it would mostly intersect is like if you have any training in like the Stanislavski technique, | 它大多会交叉 就像如果你有任何训练 像斯坦尼斯拉夫斯基技术, |
| 392 | which is like trying to experience an emotion. | 这就像尝试体验一种情感。 |
| 393 | Like if I need to portray an emotion to you, | 就像如果我需要 描绘一种情感给你, |
| 394 | I want to come across as genuinely sad in this scene or whatever. | 我想在这个场景里 遇到真正的悲伤 |
| 395 | I might recall a time in which | 我可能记得有一次 |
| 396 | I genuinely felt sad to try to like bring that emotion up as opposed to like trying to fake it. | 我真的觉得很伤心 试着把情绪提升起来 而不是假装 |
| 397 | I try to actually feel it. | 我试着真正感觉到它。 |
| 398 | So that kind of training might help you to like, you know, | 所以,这种培训 可能会帮助你喜欢,你知道, |
| 399 | mimic some emotions. | 模仿一些情绪。 |
| 400 | But I don't know of any research that would suggest that actors would be | 但我不知道有什么研究 表明演员会是 |
| 401 | higher in these traits or not. | 这些特征是否更高。 |
| 402 | Equally, we have some cards here, which are people's dating profiles. | 同样,我们有一些卡在这里, 这是人们的约会简介。 |
| 403 | Okay. | 摆 |
| 404 | And I'm wondering if you can spot any of these dark personality traits just by looking at | 我想知道你能不能通过观察 发现这些黑暗的个性特征 |
| 405 | dating profiles or any clues that might be associated with it. | 约会简介或任何可能与之相关的线索. |
| 406 | All right. | 好吧,我们走。 |
| 407 | So this is Ryan. | 这是瑞安。 |
| 408 | He's a chief of staff in Washington, D.C. Professionally trained to argue my point. | 他是华盛顿特区的幕僚长 他受过专业的训练来论证我的观点 |
| 409 | So yes, I'm probably going to win the debate about what to have for dinner. | 所以,是的,我可能会赢得辩论 关于什么可以吃晚餐。 |
| 410 | Okay, this feels | 好吧,这感觉 |
| 411 | like a red flag. | 就像红旗一样 |
| 412 | Savvy, strategic, and persuasive by trade. | 具有战略意义和说服力的贸易。 |
| 413 | I mean, this feels very much like | 我的意思是,这感觉非常像 |
| 414 | Machiavellianism,对不对? | |
| 415 | Kind of like controlling the situation, being kind of a smooth talker. | 有点像控制局势, 作为一个平滑的谈话者。 |
| 416 | Savvy meaning like they're controlling you. | 就像他们控制了你 |
| 417 | They're maybe using information to get you to | 他们可能利用信息来让你 |
| 418 | do what they want. | 做他们想做的。 |
| 419 | Strategic, right? | 战略,对不对? |
| 420 | We talked about that very kind of strategic social style, | 我们谈过那种战略社会风格 |
| 421 | where like they're not kind of impulsively behaving like someone with psychopathy. | 就像他们不像一个有精神病的人那样冲动 |
| 422 | They're | 他们是 |
| 423 | more like playing three-dimensional chess, right, to get what they want. | 更像是玩三维棋,对, 得到他们想要的。 |
| 424 | So that's quite a strategic | 所以,这是相当战略性的 |
| 425 | behavior. | 行为 |
| 426 | Also, co-occupying, exploring the city, enjoying great food, traveling, and keeping life | 还有 共同居住 探索城市 享受美食 旅行 保持生命 |
| 427 | interesting, looking for someone who makes me laugh. | 很有趣,找一个能让我笑的人 |
| 428 | So I think the words to me that are like, | 所以我觉得那些话就像, |
| 429 | might be used as like euphemisms essentially for some of the Machiavellian traits would be | 对于一些马奇亚维利的特质来说, 可能被用作委婉语 |
| 430 | savvy, strategic, persuasive, like I can get anybody to do anything because I'm just going to | 聪明,有策略,有说服力, 就像我可以让任何人做任何事情 因为我只是要去 |
| 431 | manipulate them into doing it. | 操纵他们来做 |
| 432 | Now, these could be red flags. | 这些可能是红旗 |
| 433 | He could be a perfectly nice guy. | 他可能是个好人 |
| 434 | But these are things that I would like go into that conversation thinking like, okay, does he | 但是,这些东西,我想 进入对话,像,好吧,他 |
| 435 | seem very cynical of people? | 似乎很愤世嫉俗? |
| 436 | Is he quite power hungry? | 他很饿吗? |
| 437 | Is he willing to manipulate other people | 他愿意操纵别人吗? |
| 438 | to his own ends and kind of step over other people for what he wants? | 为了自己的目的 和那种踩过别人 为了他想要的? |
| 439 | What about that last line about makes me laugh? | 那最后一行会让我笑吗? |
| 440 | I found that to be quite self-serving in a way | 我发现这在某种意义上是相当自私的 |
| 441 | because you're looking for something yourself there. | 因为你在那边找东西 |
| 442 | That obviously can be true. | 这显然是事实。 |
| 443 | We're all | 我们都是 |
| 444 | looking for someone that can make us laugh. | 找一个能让我们笑的人 |
| 445 | But whether you'd write that is, I don't know. | 但是,如果你会写,这是,我不知道。 |
| 446 | Just interesting. | 有趣的是,这很有趣。 |
| 447 | Potentially. | 潜在的。 |
| 448 | All right. | 好吧,我们走。 |
| 449 | So this is Hayley, who is a lawyer. | 这是海莉,他是一个律师。 |
| 450 | My friends call me Hurricane, | 我的朋友叫我飓风, |
| 451 | but you can call me Hayley, equal parts chaos and good company. | 但你可以叫我海莉, 等分混乱和良好的同伴。 |
| 452 | Chaos is immediately bringing up | 乱七八糟的一塌糊涂 |
| 453 | potential psychopathy because that's like that impulsivity. | 潜在的精神病 因为那就像那种冲动。 |
| 454 | You kind of don't really know | 你有点不知道 |
| 455 | where she's at. | 她现在在哪? |
| 456 | In women in particular, psychopathy can be associated with pretty volatile | 特别是女性,精神错乱可能与极不稳定 |
| 457 | emotions and connecting with like, we seem really close one day and then I'm really angry at you the | 感情和联系,像,我们似乎 真的接近一天, 然后我真的很生气你 |
| 458 | next day. | 第二天,我会去的 |
| 459 | I'll happily spend the weekend trying a new workout class or plotting a harmless prank | 我很乐意花一个周末 尝试一个新的锻炼课 或者策划一个无害的恶作剧 |
| 460 | on my friends. | 对我的朋友。 |
| 461 | That's the sadism. | 这就是虐待。 |
| 462 | Red flag. | 红旗. |
| 463 | So someone who is, you know, | 所以,一个人谁,你知道, |
| 464 | maybe delighting in someone else getting hurt. | 也许喜欢别人受伤 |
| 465 | That could be concerning. | 这可能是有关。 |
| 466 | Outspoken, | 直言不讳, |
| 467 | tough enough to handle myself. | 够坚韧的了 |
| 468 | Toughness is associated with psychopathy. | 坚韧与精神病有关 |
| 469 | Do you think you | 你觉得你 |
| 470 | can handle me? | 能对付我吗? |
| 471 | That's up to you. | 这取决于你。 |
| 472 | Okay. | 摆 |
| 473 | David is a brain surgeon. | 大卫是个脑外科医生 |
| 474 | Very impressive. | 非常令人印象深刻。 |
| 475 | So he's a surgeon | 所以他是外科医生 |
| 476 | by day, theater enthusiast and cocktail appreciator by night. | 白天,剧院的爱好者和晚上的鸡尾酒欣赏者。 |
| 477 | I'm confident enough to pick the | 我有足够的自信来选择 |
| 478 | restaurant, self-assured to admit when I'm wrong occasionally. | 餐厅,自我肯定的承认 当我错了偶尔。 |
| 479 | And my friends would describe me as | 我的朋友会形容我 |
| 480 | the life of the party. | 党的生活。 |
| 481 | So this is giving like potential narcissism cues, right? | 因此,这是给 像潜在的自恋提示,对不对? |
| 482 | So loves a lot | 所以爱很多 |
| 483 | of attention, life of the party, confident enough to pick, like he won't be wrong about picking the | 注意,党的生活, 足够自信选择, 就像他不会错选择 |
| 484 | restaurant, self-assured enough to admit when I'm wrong occasionally, he put in brackets. | 餐厅,自我保证 足以承认 当我错了偶尔, 他放在括号。 |
| 485 | So you might not see a ton of that behavior. | 所以你可能看不到一吨这样的行为。 |
| 486 | Don't worry. | 别担心 |
| 487 | I'm sure I can find the time for | 我敢肯定,我可以找到时间 |
| 488 | you somewhere. | 你在某个地方。 |
| 489 | Winky face. | 温基脸. |
| 490 | So you might not be a priority, but you know, again, so I'm seeing | 所以也许你不是首要任务,但你知道,再次, 所以我看到 |
| 491 | narcissism vibes here. | 这里有自恋情绪 |
| 492 | That's something I would, you know, pay attention to in our conversation | 你知道,在谈话中我会注意的 |
| 493 | would be like, does he ever ask anything about me or do we just talk about him and how fabulous | 他有没有问过我什么 或者我们只是谈谈他 以及他有多棒 |
| 494 | and amazing his life is the whole time? | 他的一生很奇妙吗? |
| 495 | So dating, you know, profiles are like an advertisement | 所以约会,你知道, 简介就像广告 |
| 496 | that you put out there. | 你放出来。 |
| 497 | So this is not an entire person's personality. | 所以这不是一个人的人格。 |
| 498 | So we can gather more | 这样我们就可以收集更多 |
| 499 | information over time, but some red flags there. | 信息随时间推移, 但有一些红旗在那里。 |
| 500 | This is Chad. | 这是乍得。 |
| 501 | He's in law enforcement in Texas. | 他在德州执法 |
| 502 | He's barbecuing in the picture, which feels on brand. | 他在画里烧烤,这感觉在品牌上。 |
| 503 | Looking for my wife who will join me | 寻找我的妻子 谁会加入我 |
| 504 | for life. | 一辈子 |
| 505 | No debt and no kids. | 没有债务和孩子。 |
| 506 | Don't worry, ladies. | 别担心,女士们。 |
| 507 | I'm house trained. | 我受过训练 |
| 508 | When I'm off duty, | 当我下班时, |
| 509 | I'm very independent. | 我很独立 |
| 510 | Y'all find me hunting outdoors, grilling or challenging my buddies, | 你们都发现我在户外打猎 烧烤或挑战我的朋友 |
| 511 | looking for someone genuine to share life's adventures with. | 找一个真正的人来分享人生的冒险 |
| 512 | Nice guy. | 不错的家伙。 |
| 513 | Seems okay. | 似乎还行。 |
| 514 | Yeah. | 对 |
| 515 | I wonder what he's girling. | 我想知道他在谈什么 |
| 516 | Yeah. | 对 |
| 517 | Okay. | 摆 |
| 518 | If I was to go on a date with any of these people, Haley, Ryan, David, Chad, | 如果我和这些人约会 海莉 瑞恩 大卫 乍得 |
| 519 | these dating cards that we just read out, what are the type of verbal and nonverbal cues that | 这些约会卡 我们刚刚宣读, 什么类型的口头和非口头提示 |
| 520 | I would be looking for, whether I was dating them or in a relationship with them to figure out if | 我将寻找, 无论是我约会 他们或与他们的关系 找出是否 |
| 521 | they had any of these dark personality traits? | 他们有这种黑暗的个性特征吗? |
| 522 | Again, these are kind of early warning signs that | 这些是预警信号 |
| 523 | you can look for things like do they interrupt you often, but refuse to tolerate it when you | 你可以寻找类似的东西 他们经常打断你, 但拒绝容忍 当你 |
| 524 | interrupt, right? | 打断一下,对吧? |
| 525 | And so this is kind of an indication of that impulsivity as well as | 所以,这是一种 表示这种冲动以及 |
| 526 | potential dominance over other people. | 有可能凌驾于他人之上 |
| 527 | They want to dominate you. | 他们想支配你 |
| 528 | And I mean, sometimes people get | 我的意思是,有时人们得到 |
| 529 | excited and they just want to interject and share something. | 兴奋,他们只是想插管 分享一些东西。 |
| 530 | Here, what we're really interested in | 在这里,我们真正感兴趣的是 |
| 531 | is it's a cue to impulsivity, but refusing to tolerate it when you interrupt. | 这是一种冲动的暗示, 但拒绝容忍 当你打断它。 |
| 532 | That makes them | 所以他们 |
| 533 | quite angry. | 相当生气。 |
| 534 | Do they consistently ignore personal or professional boundaries? | 他们是否一贯无视个人或职业界限? |
| 535 | So maybe you're at work | 所以也许你在工作 |
| 536 | or maybe you're on one of these dates, right? | 或者也许你在约会,对不对? |
| 537 | And you say, I'd really rather not talk about my family | 你说,我真的不想谈我的家人 |
| 538 | right now. | 现在 |
| 539 | And they continue to ask you about your family. | 他们继续问你的家人 |
| 540 | And you're like, I really don't want to | 而你喜欢,我真的不想 |
| 541 | talk about that right now. | 现在就说 |
| 542 | Okay. | 摆 |
| 543 | Yeah. | 对 |
| 544 | Tell me about your brother and this terrible relationship | 说说你哥哥和这个可怕的关系 |
| 545 | you have with them. | 你和他们在一起。 |
| 546 | So kind of always pushing on boundaries, even when they're set explicitly. | 所以,总是推 边界,即使它们被明确设置。 |
| 547 | Do they seem weirdly calm? | 他们看起来很冷静吗? |
| 548 | This is related to psychopathy and that kind of shallow emotional | 这和精神病有关 那种浅薄的情感 |
| 549 | affect. | 影响。 |
| 550 | Like they're not experiencing fear or sadness or concern for other people when you | 就像他们没有经历恐惧 悲伤或关心别人 当你 |
| 551 | expect they would in a conversation. | 期待他们会在谈话中。 |
| 552 | Do they seem to be an authority on every subject? | 他们是不是每个主题的权威? |
| 553 | This is a | 这个是 |
| 554 | narcissism vibe, right? | 自恋的氛围,对不对? |
| 555 | Like they know everything about everything and you don't know anything, | 就像他们知道一切 你什么都不知道一样 |
| 556 | right? | 对吧? |
| 557 | So they need to be the authority. | 所以他们需要成为权威。 |
| 558 | Do they offer impulsive off-the-cuff responses to your | 他们有没有对你的... |
| 559 | questions? | 问题? |
| 560 | So they're not really thinking about things. | 所以他们不是在想事情 |
| 561 | They're just saying whatever comes to | 他们只是说不管发生什么 |
| 562 | their mind immediately, a sign of potential impulsivity that's associated with psychopathy. | 他们的头脑立刻, 一个潜在冲动的迹象 与精神病有关。 |
| 563 | Do they seem to come across as tough, combative or cruel, right? | 他们看起来是坚强的, 战斗的还是残酷的,对不对? |
| 564 | So psychopathy associated with | 如此的变态与 |
| 565 | aggression, wanting to dominate people, cruelty, of course, sadism. | 侵略 想要统治人民 残忍 当然 虐待 |
| 566 | So Hailey here, she said about | 所以海莉说 |
| 567 | throwing pranks. | 扔恶作剧。 |
| 568 | She's called herself tough and asked if we could handle her. | 她自称坚强,问我们能不能对付她 |
| 569 | So maybe that's | 所以也许 |
| 570 | links. | 链接。 |
| 571 | Yep, exactly. | 没错 |
| 572 | This one's interesting. | 这个很有趣 |
| 573 | So do they make intense eye contact with you, | 他们怎么与你接触呢? |
| 574 | seeming to peer into your soul? | 似乎进入你的灵魂? |
| 575 | One of the things that clinicians have noted with people with high | 临床医生对高血压患者的发现之一 |
| 576 | levels of psychopathy is that they tend to make really intense eye contact. | 精神错乱的程度 在于他们往往 进行非常激烈的眼神接触 |
| 577 | Okay. | 摆 |
| 578 | Do they seem | 他们似乎 |
| 579 | to lack emotions related to self-awareness such as embarrassment, embarrassment or shame? | 缺乏与自我意识有关的情感,如尴尬、尴尬或羞耻? |
| 580 | These | 这些 |
| 581 | are the kind of broader self-conscious emotions like remorse, like guilt that are associated with | 是那种更广泛的自我意识的情绪 比如悔恨, 像内疚,与 |
| 582 | psychopathy, a deficit in those. | 神经病,有缺陷 |
| 583 | Do they spend a lot of time talking about themselves and show | 他们有没有花很多时间 谈论自己和显示 |
| 584 | much less interest in you? | 更不关心你? |
| 585 | That's our old friend narcissism. | 那是我们的老朋友自恋症 |
| 586 | And when others are struggling, do | 当别人挣扎的时候,做 |
| 587 | they find it enjoyable, annoying or boring? | 他们觉得很愉快,很烦人还是无聊? |
| 588 | And that would be associated with sadism. | 这和虐待有关 |
| 589 | This is something that I've made for you. | 这是我为你做的 |
| 590 | I realized that the Diarrhea audience are strivers, | 我意识到痢疾的观众是奋斗者 |
| 591 | whether it's in business or health, we all have big goals that we want to accomplish. | 无论是商业还是健康 我们都有我们想要实现的大目标 |
| 592 | And one of the things I've learned is that when you aim at the big, big, big goal, it can feel | 我学到的一件事是 当你瞄准一个大、大、大的目标时,它能感觉到 |
| 593 | incredibly psychologically uncomfortable because it's kind of like being stood at the foot of Mount | 令人难以置信的心理不适 因为这就像站在山脚下 |
| 594 | Everest and looking upwards. | 珠峰与上观. |
| 595 | The way to accomplish your goals is by breaking them down into tiny, | 实现你目标的方法就是把目标破碎成微小的 |
| 596 | small steps. | 楼梯 |
| 597 | And we call this in our team, the 1%. | 我们称之为团队中的1%。 |
| 598 | And actually this philosophy is highly | 其实这个哲学是很高的 |
| 599 | responsible for much of our success here. | 对我们在这里取得的大部分成功负有责任。 |
| 600 | So what we've done so that you at home can accomplish any | 所以,我们所做的,让你在家里可以完成任何 |
| 601 | big goal that you have is we've made these 1% diaries and we released these last year and they | 我们做了1%的日记 我们去年发布了这些 |
| 602 | all sold out. | 都卖光了 |
| 603 | So I asked my team over and over again to bring the diaries back, but also to | 所以我一再要求我的团队 把日记带回来,但也要求 |
| 604 | introduce some new colors and to make some minor tweaks to the diary. | 引入一些新的颜色, 并给日记做一些小调。 |
| 605 | So now we have a better range | 现在我们有更好的范围了 |
| 606 | for you. | 给你的 |
| 607 | So if you have a big goal in mind and you need a framework and a process and some | 所以,如果你有一个大目标 在心 并且你需要一个框架和一个过程和一些 |
| 608 | motivation, then I highly recommend you get one of these diaries before they all sell out once | 我强烈建议你先拿到一本日记 然后再卖掉一次 |
| 609 | again. | 再来 |
| 610 | 你可以去Thediary.com买你的 | |
| 611 | And if you want the link, the link is in the description | 如果你想要链接,链接在描述中 |
| 612 | below. | 见下文。 |
| 613 | There should be a button just down below here. | 这里下面应该有个按钮 |
| 614 | And if it says subscribed, you're already | 如果上面写着签了,你就已经签了 |
| 615 | subscribed. | 订阅。 |
| 616 | If it says subscriber, that means you're not yet. | 如果说是订户,那就说明你还没订户 |
| 617 | And if you're not subscribed, | 如果你没被订阅 |
| 618 | please could you do us a favor and hit that button. | 麻烦你帮个忙 按下那个按钮 |
| 619 | It helps to show more than you know. | 它帮助显示更多 比你知道。 |
| 620 | And according to the algorithm, you're someone that watches our show, but you haven't yet hit | 根据算法,你是看我们节目的人, 但你还没有击中 |
| 621 | that button. | 那个按钮 |
| 622 | Thank you so much. | 非常感谢 |
| 623 | Two things in mind. | 二谛念中. |
| 624 | The first thing is that these dark personality | 第一件事是这些黑暗的人格 |
| 625 | traits are very common relative to the impact they can have on lives. | 相对于它们可能对生命产生的影响而言,其特征非常普遍。 |
| 626 | I think they're extremely | 我觉得他们很厉害 |
| 627 | common. | 常见。 |
| 628 | And the second thing is that according to your book and some of the research, people don't | 第二件事是,根据你的书和一些研究,人们不会 |
| 629 | tend to change. | 变了 |
| 630 | So this leads me to the conclusion that we might have to figure out how to deal with | 因此,这让我得出一个结论,即我们也许必须想出如何处理 |
| 631 | these people. | 这些人。 |
| 632 | Because if we work in a company or a team or even if we work in a family, if I look | 因为如果我们在一个公司或一个团队工作 即使我们在一个家庭工作,如果我看 |
| 633 | at some of those stats around antisocial personality behaviors, it would suggest roughly one in five | 在那些关于反社会人格行为的统计中 大约五分之一 |
| 634 | people are going to be antisocial in some way. | 人们会以某种方式反社会 |
| 635 | So we can't just hope to avoid them in our lives. | 所以我们不能只是希望 避免他们在我们的生活。 |
| 636 | No, I mean, everyone's got a story, I think. | 不,我的意思是,每个人都有一个故事,我想。 |
| 637 | And I think people feel relatively powerless, like, | 我觉得人们感到相对无能为力,比如, |
| 638 | because the approaches that we tend to take with other people when they hurt us don't work very | 因为我们在别人伤害我们时 往往会和他们在一起 |
| 639 | well for these individuals. | 对这些人来说是好的 |
| 640 | When someone hurts us, we might be like, we show them, we tell them | 当有人伤害我们,我们可能会像, 我们向他们展示,我们告诉他们 |
| 641 | that really hurt me, and then they feel guilt and they might apologize. | 这真的伤害了我, 然后他们感到内疚 他们可能会道歉。 |
| 642 | Or we might punish them | 或者我们惩罚他们 |
| 643 | in some way, and then that leads them to avoid that behavior in the future. | 以某种方式,然后引导他们 避免这种行为在未来。 |
| 644 | These are precisely | 这些正是 |
| 645 | things that people with psychopathy, for example, doesn't really work. | 精神病患者的病情并不有效 |
| 646 | And so we're left being like, | 所以,我们离开 喜欢, |
| 647 | how do I deal with this? | 我该怎么做? |
| 648 | My tools are not working. | 我的工具不起作用。 |
| 649 | But I think what's really | 但我认为什么是真正的 |
| 650 | kind of powerful to know is that there are things that you can do. | 那种强大的知道是 有事情你可以做。 |
| 651 | So we've got seven | 所以我们有七个 |
| 652 | rules for dealing with people with dark personalities. | 处理黑暗人物的规则 |
| 653 | So the first one is to establish | 所以第一个是建立 |
| 654 | clear boundaries. | 明确界限。 |
| 655 | And I want to kind of preface this by saying like, setting out the rules is not | 我想先说一句 规定规则不是 |
| 656 | like a guarantee that they won't be broken, right? | 就像保证他们不会被打破,对不对? |
| 657 | We've talked about with respect to psychopathy, | 我们讨论过精神病 |
| 658 | that they tend to break the rules, like a defining feature of that personality. | 他们倾向于打破规则, 就像那个个性的决定性特征。 |
| 659 | But research suggests that establishing clear rules, making them explicit, decreases the | 但研究表明,建立明确的规则,使之明确,减少 |
| 660 | likelihood of kind of selfish behavior, for example, compared to if there's no rules whatsoever, | 比起没有规则 自私行为的可能性 |
| 661 | right? | 对吧? |
| 662 | So sometimes like, you know, in my workplace, we have a respectful workplace policy, | 所以,有时候,你知道, 在我的工作场所, 我们有一个尊重工作场所的政策, |
| 663 | which when I read it was like, why do people need to be reminded of this? | 当我读到它就像, 为什么人们需要 提醒这一点? |
| 664 | This seems so obvious, | 这似乎如此明显, |
| 665 | right? | 对吧? |
| 666 | But there's really good reasons to have a respectful workplace policy. | 但是有很好的理由来制定尊重工作场所的政策。 |
| 667 | One is that it makes | 一个是它使 |
| 668 | very explicit how we expect people to be treated here. | 我们非常明确地期望人们在这里受到怎样的待遇。 |
| 669 | That is going to decrease the likelihood | 这将会降低可能性 |
| 670 | of people even with, you know, kind of moderate levels of these traits, let's say, will violate | 即使有中等水平的特质 也会违反 |
| 671 | those rules. | 这些规则。 |
| 672 | And more than that, if they do violate the rules, you've got something written | 不止于此,如果他们确实违反了规则, 你写了什么 |
| 673 | down that's like, you're not supposed to do this. | 你不应该这么做的 |
| 674 | Otherwise, it's very hard to kind of do anything | 否则,很难做任何事情 |
| 675 | about it, right? | 关于它,对不对? |
| 676 | In a relationship, you can make this really clear, like what's okay, what's not | 在一个关系中,你可以说得很清楚, 像什么是好的,什么不是 |
| 677 | okay in this relationship. | 这段感情还不错 |
| 678 | And you got to tell the other person that it can't just be in your head, | 你得告诉另一个人 它不能只是在你头上, |
| 679 | right? | 对吧? |
| 680 | So you got to make these rules explicit. | 所以,你必须明确 这些规则。 |
| 681 | And it can also help to like, read in a buddy, | 也可以帮助喜欢, 读在朋友, |
| 682 | like if you've got a friend, and you're like, okay, these are the things that I want out of | 就像你有一个朋友,你喜欢, 好吧,这些都是我想要的东西 |
| 683 | a relationship partner, these are like no goes, these are behaviors that cross the red line. | 关系伴侣,这些就像不走, 这些行为跨越红线。 |
| 684 | Having, you know, a friend that knows what those are that can tell you when your boundaries are | 有个朋友知道这些是什么 当你的边界是 |
| 685 | slipping can be really useful. | 滑下去会有用 |
| 686 | I was thinking of one particular context that I know, and I'll keep | 我在想我知道的某个特定背景, 我会保持 |
| 687 | it anonymous as well, where there's five people that I know, it is a family that I know of, | 我认识五个人 那是我认识的家庭 |
| 688 | and they have five, five kids. | 他们有五个孩子 |
| 689 | And one of the family members was telling me that they are the | 其中一个家庭成员告诉我 他们是 |
| 690 | only one that has maintained a boundary against one of the older parents who's got a track record | 只有一个对年长父母之一有记录的 |
| 691 | like some of these dark personality traits. | 就像这些黑暗的个性特征 |
| 692 | And she was telling me that because she has always | 她告诉我,因为她一直 |
| 693 | maintained a boundary against the father who is the person that has dark personality traits, | 保持了与父亲的界限,父亲是具有黑暗人格特征的人, |
| 694 | the father has almost left her alone and has gone for the other four siblings more so. | 父亲几乎抛弃了她 并且更喜欢其他四个兄弟姐妹 |
| 695 | And that the other four siblings are suffering because they don't have an established boundary. | 而另外四个兄弟姐妹因为没有既定的边界而受苦. |
| 696 | Whereas what I'm saying here is it's interesting that someone who has a boundary seems to be preyed | 而这里我要说的是,有趣的是,有人 谁有边界似乎被猎物 |
| 697 | on less by the narcissist or person with Machiavellian personality than those that haven't | 被自恋者或有马奇雅维利人格的人 比那些没有 |
| 698 | established one. | 建立了一个。 |
| 699 | And if that is true, then what is it about the psychopathic or narcissistic | 如果这是真的 那精神病人或自恋狂又是怎么回事? |
| 700 | person that is choosing easier targets or boundary-less targets? | 选择较容易的目标或无边界目标的人? |
| 701 | Does that hold as | 这是否是 |
| 702 | truth or is that just anecdotal? | 真相还是传闻? |
| 703 | So we do know from research that this is mostly in workplaces, | 因此,我们确实从研究中得知, 这大多是在工作场所, |
| 704 | that workplaces that have kind of codes of fairness, people with high levels of these | 拥有某种公平守则的工作场所, |
| 705 | traits are less likely to keep a bunch of the bonus money for themselves instead of | 特质更不可能自己留一大笔奖金 |
| 706 | among their team fairly. | 在他们的团队中公平。 |
| 707 | So there's evidence of like having rules in place increases the likelihood | 因此,有证据表明,像有 规则到位增加的可能性 |
| 708 | that they will follow those rules relative to like a no holds bar kind of situation. | 他们将遵守那些规则,而不是象禁闭一样。 |
| 709 | There's also research on how people with high levels of psychopathic traits kind of | 也研究过精神病性能高的人 |
| 710 | choose who to prey upon essentially. | 选择捕食对象 |
| 711 | And individuals who are not very assertive | 以及那些不自信的人 |
| 712 | tend to be more likely to, it's almost like they're picking the weakest of the herd or | 更可能,它几乎就像他们 选择最弱的群或 |
| 713 | something like that. | 类似的东西。 |
| 714 | So having asserting some boundaries can help to not have that target | 所以坚持一些界限 有助于没有目标 |
| 715 | on your back. | 背着 |
| 716 | I was thinking about a guest that I interviewed on this podcast that was telling me | 我在想我采访的一位嘉宾 那个播客告诉我 |
| 717 | she had gone through domestic violence and she was telling me about the love bombing process | 她经历了家庭暴力 她告诉我爱情爆炸的过程 |
| 718 | as to how this individual had like broken down her boundaries and her confidence over time | 至于这个人如何 喜欢打破她的界限和信心 随着时间的推移 |
| 719 | and then had isolated her from her friends and family, wouldn't allow her to call her mom. | 然后把她与朋友和家人隔离 不允许她打电话给她妈妈 |
| 720 | We give her a script when her mom called and those kinds of things. | 我们给她一个剧本 当她的妈妈打电话 和这些事情。 |
| 721 | And one of the remarkable | 和一个了不起的 |
| 722 | things I observed is how over time they'd sort of broken down their confidence in order to be | 我所观察到的是,随着时间的推移,他们会如何 打破他们的信心,以便成为 |
| 723 | able to seemingly control them. | 似乎可以控制他们。 |
| 724 | Is this a, is this common practice? | 这是惯例吗? |
| 725 | Yeah, in a domestic | 是啊,一个家庭 |
| 726 | violence situation. | 暴力状况。 |
| 727 | You know, it kind of reminds me of the kind of emerging research on gaslighting | 你知道,它让我想起 那种新兴的研究 燃气 |
| 728 | where someone would, you know, make their partner kind of dealt their sense of reality, | 在那里,有人会,你知道, 让他们的伴侣 处理他们的现实感, |
| 729 | kind of, you know, correcting them all the time. | 那种,你知道, 纠正他们所有的时间。 |
| 730 | Like you're being too sensitive, | 就像你太敏感一样 |
| 731 | you don't see the truth around you. | 你看不到周围的真相 |
| 732 | And I think what's kind of so insidious about that is that | 我觉得最阴险的是 |
| 733 | it makes you dependent on that other person. | 它让你依赖另一个人。 |
| 734 | And then the isolation can really decrease | 然后隔离会真正减少 |
| 735 | your ability to kind of like get out of it because you don't have someone else who can, | 因为你没有别人可以... |
| 736 | you know, check your sense of reality that you really are seeing and feeling and remembering | 你知道,检查你对现实的感觉, 你真的看到了,感觉和回忆 |
| 737 | things that really did happen, even though they're telling you that it didn't. | 事情真的发生了, 即使他们告诉你,它没有。 |
| 738 | What is | 这是什么 |
| 739 | gaslighting? | 燃气吗? |
| 740 | Because we throw around the term all the time, the minute someone lies, we say, | 因为我们老是用这个词 说只要有人撒谎 |
| 741 | Yeah, it's a pattern of denying someone's version of reality. | 是啊,这是一种模式 否认某人的版本现实。 |
| 742 | So you might tell people that, | 所以你可以告诉别人, |
| 743 | you know, they shouldn't be feeling the way that they're feeling things didn't happen, | 你知道,他们不应该 感觉的方式 他们的感觉 事情没有发生, |
| 744 | like they are remembering they happened, that they can't trust their own, you know, sense of, | 就像他们记得他们发生的事, 他们不能相信自己的,你知道,感觉, |
| 745 | you know, perception of reality. | 你知道,对现实的看法。 |
| 746 | And so it can be incredibly kind of destabilizing and isolating. | 所以它可以令人难以置信地 破坏稳定,孤立。 |
| 747 | And what is worrisome about that is that we really need other people to help us see reality. | 而令人担忧的是,我们确实需要其他人帮助我们看到现实。 |
| 748 | And so | 这样 |
| 749 | if we're only seeing it through like their lens of we can't be trusted, our own eyes, our own memory | 如果我们只看到它 通过他们的镜头 我们无法信任,我们自己的眼睛,我们自己的记忆 |
| 750 | can't be trusted, we start to depend on their perception, which is essentially a control | 不能相信,我们开始依赖他们的感知 这基本上是一种控制 |
| 751 | tactic. | 战术 |
| 752 | And research does suggest that people with high levels of these traits endorse these | 研究确实表明, 具有高水平特征的人 认可这些 |
| 753 | like, they don't see anything wrong with doing that to a romantic partner, which would probably | 喜欢,他们不认为有什么不对 这样做对一个浪漫的伙伴, 这可能会 |
| 754 | follow that they would be more likely to engage in it. | 他们将更有可能参与其中。 |
| 755 | A lot of romantic arguments would sound | 很多浪漫的争论听起来 |
| 756 | like gaslighting, I think, within that definition of like, you know, let's go back to the cheating | 像燃气,我想,在这个定义 喜欢,你知道,让我们回到欺骗 |
| 757 | example. | 实例。 |
| 758 | We said last Friday, I was doing something dodgy. | 我们上周五说, 我做了一些蠢事。 |
| 759 | You suspect I'm lying. | 你怀疑我在撒谎 |
| 760 | So you say to me, | 所以你对我说 |
| 761 | No, you weren't Steven, you weren't at the office till 3am. | 不,你不是史蒂芬,你3点才到办公室 |
| 762 | And I was I was I was at the office. | 我当时在办公室 |
| 763 | You | 你们 |
| 764 | were making this up in your head. | 是在你脑子里编出来的 |
| 765 | Yeah. | 对 |
| 766 | Who was gaslighting who that because you said you denied | 谁在点燃谁,因为你说你否认 |
| 767 | my reality and I'm denying your reality. | 我否认你的真实 |
| 768 | But were you actually at the office? | 但你真的在办公室吗? |
| 769 | Does it matter? | 有关系吗? |
| 770 | Like, | 喜欢, |
| 771 | Jeremy, I'm trying to figure out if the which which one of us was gaslighting behavior there. | Jeremy,我想知道我们中哪个人 在那里放毒气 |
| 772 | Yeah, I think it would be like if if I say like, you know, I feel insecure, I feel threatened by | 是的,我想这将是 如果我说喜欢, 你知道,我觉得不安全, 我感觉威胁 |
| 773 | like whatever you were doing on Friday. | 就像你周五做的事一样 |
| 774 | And you're like, no, you don't you don't like or you | 你就像,不,你不喜欢或你 |
| 775 | didn't feel that way. | 没有那种感觉 |
| 776 | There's no reason for you to feel that way. | 你没有理由那样想 |
| 777 | You're blowing things out of | 你在吹东西出来 |
| 778 | proportion. | 比例。 |
| 779 | It's essentially like denying someone's actual it's my experience is that I feel | 这基本上就像否认某人的 真实的,这是我的经验是,我觉得 |
| 780 | threatened. | 威胁。 |
| 781 | And so it's like, even if I might be wrong about that, that is my experience. | 所以它就像,即使我可能 错了,这是我的经验。 |
| 782 | So I could deny the facts. | 所以我可以否认事实 |
| 783 | Theoretically, I could say no, at 2am, I was falling asleep on my desk. | 理论上,我可以说不,在凌晨2点,我在桌子上睡着了。 |
| 784 | I could maybe argue with the facts. | 我也许可以和事实争论 |
| 785 | But it's when you start arguing with someone else's perception | 但当你开始和别人的观念争论 |
| 786 | of reality, yes, of their own subjective experience. | 是的,他们自己的主观经验。 |
| 787 | That's when you strained to this | 那时你紧张到这个地步 |
| 788 | gaslighting. | 气冲. |
| 789 | Okay. | 摆 |
| 790 | In the example I gave earlier for my guest, that's exactly what happened to | 我之前为我的客人举的一个例子 就是那样 |
| 791 | | |
| 792 | What he started to do is he started hiding her stuff in places. | 他开始做的就是 把她的东西藏起来 |
| 793 | So he put her car keys in | 他把她的车钥匙放进去了 |
| 794 | the fridge to make her feel like she'd gone crazy. | 冰箱让她觉得自己疯了 |
| 795 | Yeah, which is fucking crazy. | 是啊,这是他妈的疯了。 |
| 796 | That's bonkers. | 这是愚蠢的。 |
| 797 | Wild. | 疯狂 |
| 798 | Okay, that makes sense. | 好吧,这有道理。 |
| 799 | So that was establishing clear boundaries. | 因此,这是建立明确的界限。 |
| 800 | Really, | 真的吗? |
| 801 | what I was getting at is do they try and erode those boundaries? | 我得到的是 他们是否试图侵蚀这些界限? |
| 802 | What do they leave you alone? | 他们放过你什么? |
| 803 | So they're likely to try to push on them, but less so than if you have no boundaries at all. | 所以,他们可能试图推动他们, 但少于如果你没有边界。 |
| 804 | Okay. | 摆 |
| 805 | Yep. | 对 |
| 806 | So the next one is don't give them power over others. | 所以,下一个是不要给他们 权力凌驾于他人之上。 |
| 807 | We've talked about kind of | 我们谈过了 |
| 808 | all of these different traits and that they, you know, Machiavellianism is actually kind of named | 所有这些不同的特质, 他们,你知道,Machiavellianism 实际上是一种命名 |
| 809 | after the pursuit of power. | 追逐权力之后 |
| 810 | Psychopathy is associated with domineering people. | 心理疗法与玩弄人有关 |
| 811 | Narcissism, | 纳西西主义, |
| 812 | I'm better than you. | 我比你强 |
| 813 | I'm a born leader. | 我是天生的领导者 |
| 814 | All of these are kind of related to power. | 所有这些都与权力有关。 |
| 815 | People with these traits tend to be very interested in having power over other people, | 有这些特质的人 往往非常有兴趣 拥有对其他人的权力, |
| 816 | but we know from research that this does not tend to go well for those individuals who are | 但是我们从研究中了解到,对于那些身处此地的人来说,这往往并不好。 |
| 817 | working underneath them. | 在他们下面工作 |
| 818 | So at work, for example, we know that people who are working under a boss | 比如说,在工作的时候 我们知道在老板手下工作的人 |
| 819 | with more psychopathic traits report being more stressed out. | 更多的精神病特征报告 更加强调。 |
| 820 | They also tend to be more likely | 他们往往更可能 |
| 821 | to bring that stress home and that creates more family conflicts. | 将这种压力带回家,从而造成更多的家庭冲突。 |
| 822 | So it kind of spreads. | 因此,它有点扩散。 |
| 823 | It | 这个 |
| 824 | doesn't stay where it is. | 不待在这里。 |
| 825 | They tend to create division within teams. | 他们往往在团队内部制造分裂. |
| 826 | They also tend to increase | 它们也往往增加 |
| 827 | the likelihood of turnover intentions. | 交易意图的可能性。 |
| 828 | So, you know, if you're working for a boss with these | 所以,你知道,如果你工作 一个老板用这些 |
| 829 | traits, you're like, I got to get the hell out of here. | 特质,你喜欢, 我得到了地狱离开这里。 |
| 830 | So you're, you're churning through staff, | 所以,你正在通过工作人员, |
| 831 | right? | 对吧? |
| 832 | So giving them power over others is not a great way to, to kind of, yeah, to deal with them. | 因此,赋予他们支配他人的权力 并不是一个伟大的方法, 一种,是的,处理他们。 |
| 833 | So you don't want to give them power over others even when they want it, | 所以即使他们想要,你也不想给他们权力 |
| 834 | but there's other things that you can give them that they do want. | 但还有别的事情你可以给他们 他们确实想要。 |
| 835 | And this is essentially like | 这基本上就像 |
| 836 | negotiating 101, right? | 谈判101,对不对? |
| 837 | So like you can look for win-wins when you're negotiating with them, | 所以,就像你可以寻找双赢 当你与他们谈判, |
| 838 | recognizing that what they consider motivation to get to this win-win might not be what you consider | 承认他们认为实现这一双赢的动机 可能不是你认为的 |
| 839 | to be motivation to get to this win-win. | 成为实现双赢的动力 |
| 840 | So imagine that like you've got this, this employee who is | 所以想象一下,就像你有这个, 这个雇员谁是 |
| 841 | his subordinates and you're like, you really need to treat your team better because they are so | 他的下属和你一样, 你真的需要 对待你的团队更好,因为他们是如此 |
| 842 | stressed out and they, you know, are going home from work and they're crying to their spouses and, | 压力很大,他们,你知道, 下班回家, 他们哭着对配偶, |
| 843 | you know, they're bringing it home and they're, they're getting sick because of this. | 你知道,他们把它带回家 他们,他们生病了 因为这个。 |
| 844 | You're trying to make them feel compassion for other people to get them to behave better | 你想让他们同情别人 让他们表现得更好 |
| 845 | toward their team. | 他们的团队。 |
| 846 | That's not motivating to them, right? | 这不是激励他们,对不对? |
| 847 | It might be motivating to other people, | 它可能会激励其他人, |
| 848 | but people who with high levels of these traits, right, were callous, not concerned about other | 但他们有很高的特质,是的, 是无情的, 不关心其他 |
| 849 | people. | 人们 |
| 850 | However, that doesn't mean that they can't do something kind or helpful, right? | 然而,这并不意味着 他们不能做 善良或帮助,对不对? |
| 851 | They might | 他们可能 |
| 852 | just do it for a different reason. | 只是因为另一个原因 |
| 853 | So if you know that the team is suffering under this person's | 所以,如果你知道 球队正在受苦 在这个人的 |
| 854 | current like bullying management style, you could say, you know, you've got this, you know, sales | 就像欺凌管理风格,你可以说, 你知道,你有这个,你知道,销售 |
| 855 | bonus that's coming up, but your team is so stressed out that you're not going to meet that | 奖金即将到来,但你的团队 压力很大,你不能满足 |
| 856 | target and you're not going to get your, your bonus, right? | 目标,你不会得到你的,你的奖金,对不对? |
| 857 | You need to treat your, your team | 你需要对待你的团队 |
| 858 | differently. | 不一样 |
| 859 | Money, they like money. | 钱,他们喜欢钱 |
| 860 | They like power. | 他们喜欢权力。 |
| 861 | They like status. | 他们喜欢状态。 |
| 862 | And so it's not that they | 所以不是他们 |
| 863 | can't behave better. | 表现不好 |
| 864 | It's that they might do it for a different reason. | 可能是因为别的原因 |
| 865 | So trying to understand | 所以,试图理解 |
| 866 | what motivates them and trying to figure out how you can use that. | 是什么激励了他们 并试图找出 你如何使用它。 |
| 867 | The next one is use the carrot, | 下一个是用胡萝卜 |
| 868 | not the stick. | 不是那个棍子 |
| 869 | So we've talked about this a little bit where people, particularly with high levels | 所以,我们已经谈论了这一点一点点 在那里的人,尤其是高水平 |
| 870 | of psychopathy, very reward sensitive, but not very punishment sensitive. | 精神错乱,非常有报酬,但惩罚不够 |
| 871 | So you can try to punish | 这样你就可以惩罚了 |
| 872 | them, but literally their brains don't process punishment in the same way. | 但他们的大脑不会以同样的方式处理惩罚 |
| 873 | They don't develop | 他们不发展 |
| 874 | that kind of link between if I do this behavior, then fear of punishment again. | 那种联系 如果我这样做, 然后害怕惩罚再次。 |
| 875 | So like they're | 就像他们一样 |
| 876 | more likely to repeat it than people with low levels of these traits. | 与这些特征水平低的人相比,更有可能重复。 |
| 877 | So punishment, you know, | 所以惩罚,你知道, |
| 878 | there's a place for it, I suppose, but it's like, it's not going to be as effective with these | 有个地方可以使用,但是它就像, 它不会是那么有效 |
| 879 | personalities in particular. | 特别是个人。 |
| 880 | And I think what's terrible, what we are losing a huge opportunity | 我认为什么是可怕的,什么 我们正在失去一个巨大的机会 |
| 881 | on is that we don't use the carrot instead when the carrot is so powerful. | 我们不使用胡萝卜 当胡萝卜是如此强大。 |
| 882 | So sometimes people | 所以有时候人们 |
| 883 | are like, they're a bad person. | 他们就像,他们是一个坏人。 |
| 884 | I'm not going to reward anything that they do. | 我不会奖赏他们所做的一切 |
| 885 | Like I'm not going | 就像我不去一样 |
| 886 | to give them any kind of positive feedback because I think they're terrible, right? | 给他们任何正面的反馈 因为我觉得他们很糟糕,对不对? |
| 887 | But if they do | 但是,如果他们这样做 |
| 888 | something kind or honest or helpful, oh my God, reward them. | 善良或诚实或帮助, 哦,我的上帝,奖励他们。 |
| 889 | Reward them, not with power over | 奖赏他们,不要用权力 |
| 890 | others, but maybe with like a bonus at work with like a job title because they really care about | 其他人,但也许有像奖金 在工作 像工作头衔,因为他们真的在乎 |
| 891 | status. | 状态。 |
| 892 | That's a reward that they will really like. | 这是他们喜欢的奖励 |
| 893 | And you are going to increase the likelihood that | 你将会增加 |
| 894 | you get more of that behavior in the future. | 你将来会有更多这样的行为 |
| 895 | I think there'll be some people listening right | 我想会有人听对了 |
| 896 | now that are thinking, shouldn't you just fire these people? | 你不应该解雇这些人吗? |
| 897 | Shouldn't you get all of these | 你不应该得到所有这些 |
| 898 | people out of your life? | 人离开你的生活? |
| 899 | If they've got sadism, narcissism, Machiavellianism, | 如果他们有虐待,自恋,马奇亚维尔主义, |
| 900 | psychopathy. | 变态 |
| 901 | Shouldn't you just throw them out of your life? | 难道你不应该把他们赶出你的生活吗? |
| 902 | Yeah, I think given that there are, you know, a reasonably sized minority of the population | 是啊,我认为,考虑到,你知道, 有相当规模的少数人口 |
| 903 | has some elevated level of these traits, you're going to be chucking a lot of people, right? | 这些特质水平会提高 你会把很多人丢弃 对吧? |
| 904 | And they also might genuinely have some like really useful skills that just, you know, | 他们也可能真正拥有一些 像真正有用的技能, 只是,你知道, |
| 905 | you want in your company, you just need to learn how to manage this personality trait. | 你想在你的公司, 你只需要学会如何管理这个个性特征。 |
| 906 | And so | 这样 |
| 907 | I think even if, you know, you have kind of a low tolerance for these personality traits, | 我认为即使,你知道, 你有点不太容忍 这些个性特征, |
| 908 | you're not going to be able to completely avoid them at all times. | 你不可能随时完全避开他们 |
| 909 | It might not be your decision | 可能不是你的决定 |
| 910 | to chuck them out of the company. | 把他们赶出公司 |
| 911 | Yeah, exactly. | 没错 |
| 912 | It might be a person that you like, you want to | 这可能是一个你喜欢的人,你想 |
| 913 | have a relationship with them, even if that relationship is not perfect. | 和他们有关系 即使这种关系不是完美的。 |
| 914 | You know, maybe | 你知道,也许 |
| 915 | it's a brother-in-law, right? | 是个姐夫,对吧? |
| 916 | And you're like, he's such a pain in the ass, but I see him like | 而你喜欢,他是如此痛苦的屁股, 但我看到他喜欢 |
| 917 | twice a year. | 一年两次。 |
| 918 | And I don't want to cut him out because that means I don't get to see my sister | 我也不想把他截断,因为这样我就不能见我妹妹了 |
| 919 | anymore. | 现在。 |
| 920 | And I love my sister and I want to support my sister. | 我爱我妹妹 我想支持我妹妹 |
| 921 | And so I think there's just | 所以我认为 |
| 922 | like the, you know, stay or go question is just so complicated. | 就像,你知道,留下来或去问问题 只是如此复杂。 |
| 923 | And there's so many reasons why | 还有那么多原因 |
| 924 | you might not be able to do that. | 你可能无法做到这一点。 |
| 925 | And so we need to learn the skills to manage interactions with | 因此,我们需要学习管理与 |
| 926 | people as well. | 人们也一样。 |
| 927 | Next one is emphasize your common identity. | 下一个是强调你的共同身份。 |
| 928 | People with high levels of narcissism | 高自恋症患者 |
| 929 | are not particularly interested in like being fair to you or like, you know, being kind to you, | 不是特别喜欢公平对待你 或者说,对你好一点 |
| 930 | but they are interested in loyalty. | 但他们对忠诚感兴趣 |
| 931 | There's these studies that are really fascinating where they | 这些研究非常迷人 |
| 932 | just tell people like, Oh, you guys have the same birthday or you have the same fingerprint type, | 告诉大家 你们的生日或者指纹类型一样 |
| 933 | which I don't even think is a thing. | 我什至不认为是一件事情。 |
| 934 | Anyway, but people think we have some sort of commonality. | 无论如何,但人们觉得我们有某种共性。 |
| 935 | Then people are people with high levels of narcissism get less angry when you give them | 那么人们就是那些自恋程度高的人 当你给他们发怒的时候 |
| 936 | negative feedback if they think you've got something in common with them. | 如果他们认为你和他们有共同点 就会有负面反馈 |
| 937 | So if you start | 所以,如果你开始 |
| 938 | your conversation with, you know, maybe that, that uncle at Thanksgiving, who's like always | 你和那个感恩节的叔叔的谈话 和以前一样 |
| 939 | combative and talks about himself all the time and you're like, Oh, you know, we went to the same | 战斗和谈论自己 所有的时间,你喜欢, 哦,你知道,我们去了同样的 |
| 940 | university, we root for the same football team, whatever it is, you start with what you have in | 大学,我们为同一个足球队打根 不管是什么,你从你拥有的开始 |
| 941 | common. | 常见。 |
| 942 | You're like, okay, we are one. | 你就像,好吧,我们是一个。 |
| 943 | Right. | 对 |
| 944 | And then if you need to say, you know what, you really | 然后,如果你需要说, 你知道吗,你真的 |
| 945 | need to pick up your game and help them with the care of grandma, then he might be more willing to | 需要拿起你的游戏 帮助他们照顾奶奶, 那么他可能更愿意 |
| 946 | listen to that as opposed to just like getting negative feedback. | 而不是像得到负面反馈一样 |
| 947 | You know, people with high | 你知道,人们高 |
| 948 | levels of narcissism don't like that. | 那种自恋的情绪是不喜欢的 |
| 949 | So emphasizing your common identity can help to tamp that down. | 所以强调你的共同身份 有助于将它固定下来。 |
| 950 | I'd sat here with Tali Sharot, who's this neuroscientist, and she'd looked at the subject | 我和这位神经科学家Tali Sharot坐在这里 她看着这个话题 |
| 951 | of disagreement quite extensively. | 分歧非常广泛。 |
| 952 | And she'd put people in these brain scanners and basically got | 然后她把人放进脑部扫描仪里 然后基本上 |
| 953 | them to disagree with each other at some point, and looked at what happened in their brain. | 他们彼此意见不一, 看着他们的大脑里发生了什么。 |
| 954 | And | 还有 |
| 955 | what she told me she observed is essentially, and I'm, you know, I'm generalizing wildly here, so | 她告诉我,她观察到的 本质上是, 而我,你知道,我 粗略地在这里,所以 |
| 956 | please do fact check me on the screen. | 请在屏幕上检查一下我 |
| 957 | She basically observed that the brain changed when | 她基本上观察到大脑在 |
| 958 | someone disagreed with you. | 有人不同意你的观点 |
| 959 | And I was on a phone call the other day with about 10 different people | 那天我和大约10个人在打电话 |
| 960 | from a company we're doing a deal with. | 我们正和一家公司达成协议 |
| 961 | And I just observed that one person would often open up | 我刚刚看到 一个人经常打开 |
| 962 | their rebuttal when they felt had a difference of opinion with the phrase, I completely disagree. | 当他们觉得对这句话有不同意见时 我完全不同意 |
| 963 | And then they would make their point. | 然后他们会说出他们的观点。 |
| 964 | And so funnily enough, I got straight off the call, | 这么有趣,我得到了直接的电话, |
| 965 | even though I'd written about this previously, I got straight off the call and like, | 虽然我之前写过这个 但我接到电话 |
| 966 | did it be better research as to whether I, I just find that to be quite ineffective behavior, | 研究一下我,我只是觉得那很无效 |
| 967 | or if there's research around it. | 或者如果周围有研究的话 |
| 968 | And what I found is it says, yes, there is extensive research | 我发现的是,它说, 是的,有广泛的研究 |
| 969 | across social psychology and behavioral economics and linguistics showing that opening a counter | 社会心理学 行为经济学 语言学 显示打开一个计数器 |
| 970 | argument or a rebuttal with explicit adversarial phrasing, like I disagree, actively will hinder | 如我所不同意的那样,用明确的对抗性措辞进行辩驳或反驳会积极妨碍 |
| 971 | your ability to persuade somebody. | 你说服别人的能力 |
| 972 | When you start a rebuttal with I disagree several psychological | 当你开始反驳 我不同意一些心理 |
| 973 | mechanisms trigger in the other person's brain. | 机制触发对方的大脑。 |
| 974 | And that goes into the detail about what goes on | 接下来的细节 |
| 975 | their brain. | 他们的大脑。 |
| 976 | I just, it seems somewhat linked to what you're saying there about like how you keep | 我只是,它似乎有点关联 与你说什么 在那里,喜欢你如何保持 |
| 977 | the other person receptive. | 对方接受。 |
| 978 | Totally. | 当然 |
| 979 | Okay, so this reminds me of another study on things like | 好吧,这让我想起了另一个研究 比如: |
| 980 | really domineering bosses. | 真的很迷人的老板们 |
| 981 | If you need to give them negative feedback, like, I don't know, say | 如果你需要给他们负面反馈,比如,我不知道,比如 |
| 982 | you hate the way that we're running this particular process, these three forms should be one form, | 你讨厌我们运行这个特定过程的方式, 这三种形式应该是一种形式, |
| 983 | like, why are we spending so much? | 为什么我们花这么多钱? |
| 984 | This is like, you know, the bane of office existence. | 这就像,你知道, 办公室存在的诅咒。 |
| 985 | If you say, this is so stupid, you need to change the way that we're doing, you know, | 如果你说这太蠢了 你需要改变我们的方式 |
| 986 | like kind of coming in hot, particularly people with high levels of narcissistic traits are like, | 特别是那些自恋性很强的人 |
| 987 | we don't like this kind of, you know, ego threat, your threat, you're criticizing me, | 我们不喜欢这种自我威胁 你的威胁 你在批评我 |
| 988 | you're giving me negative feedback. | 你给我的负面反馈。 |
| 989 | I'm just like shutting it down, right? | 我只是像关闭它,对不对? |
| 990 | I'm not, I don't even | 我没有,我甚至没有 |
| 991 | hear what you're saying. | 听听你在说什么 |
| 992 | Whereas if you phrase it as a question, like, what do you think if we turn | 如果你把它说成一个问题, 比如,你认为如果我们转向 |
| 993 | these three forms into one form? | 这三种形式变成一种形式? |
| 994 | Phrasing it as a question just kind of like makes it softer and | 把它描述成一个问题 就像它更柔软 |
| 995 | makes them more willing to just hear it. | 让他们更愿意听 |
| 996 | Like, maybe you ultimately won't get to that one form, | 就像,也许你最终不会得到 一种形式, |
| 997 | but you'll at least get a little bit further in that conversation. | 但你至少会更深入一点 |
| 998 | I think that's true for, | 我想这是真的, |
| 999 | you know, it's true for everybody. | 你知道,这对每个人都是真的。 |
| 1000 | But especially when it comes to people who are really domineering, | 但尤其当涉及到那些 真正迷人的人时, |
| 1001 | which these personalities tend to be. | 这些人格往往就是如此。 |
| 1002 | Okay. | 摆 |
| 1003 | So like you kind of co-create the solution. | 就像你共同创造了解决方案。 |
| 1004 | Really, you know, okay, interesting. | 真的,你知道,好吧,有趣。 |
| 1005 | Yeah. | 对 |
| 1006 | Okay. | 摆 |
| 1007 | Become a detective and notice their cues. | 成为一名侦探 注意他们的提示 |
| 1008 | So we know that they tend to lie a lot, | 所以我们知道他们经常撒谎 |
| 1009 | being manipulative, telling lies is kind of part of their MO. | 编造谎言是他们行为的一部分 |
| 1010 | That's what all of these traits share. | 这就是所有这些特征的共同点。 |
| 1011 | And so being able to identify, know what those cues of deception are, know that we're not looking | 因此,能够识别, 知道这些欺骗的提示是什么, 知道我们不是在寻找 |
| 1012 | for gaze aversion. | 以示厌恶。 |
| 1013 | We're not looking for fidgeting. | 我们不是在寻找虚幻。 |
| 1014 | We're looking for those lack of | 我们在找那些缺乏 |
| 1015 | verifiable details. | 可核实的细节。 |
| 1016 | We're looking for relatively few details. | 我们在找一些细节 |
| 1017 | We're looking for signs of cognitive | 我们在找认知的迹象 |
| 1018 | strain and maybe like following up, right? | 压力,也许像后续,对不对? |
| 1019 | If we start to see some of those red flags. | 如果我们开始看到一些红旗。 |
| 1020 | And finally, avoid face-to-face negotiations. | 最后,避免面对面谈判。 |
| 1021 | So this is like a really simple move that can | 所以这就像一个非常简单的动作,可以 |
| 1022 | be really helpful. | 真的很有帮助。 |
| 1023 | So some research out of same university as me, University of British Columbia, | 所以和我在同一所大学 不列颠哥伦比亚大学的一些研究 |
| 1024 | had people with various levels of these dark traits, engage in a negotiation. | 有不同层次的人 这些黑暗的特征,参与谈判。 |
| 1025 | It was just | 这只是 |
| 1026 | over like the price of concert tickets. | 就像演唱会票价一样 |
| 1027 | But what they found is that whenever those negotiations | 但是他们发现,只要这些谈判 |
| 1028 | occurred face-to-face, the person with the high level of psychopathic traits or any of these dark | 发生面对面的, 具有高度精神病特征的人 或任何这种黑暗 |
| 1029 | traits, they got a really good deal. | 特质,他们得到了一个非常好的交易。 |
| 1030 | Like they were able to command a whole bunch of money | 好像他们能指挥一大笔钱 |
| 1031 | for these concert tickets. | 这些音乐会的门票。 |
| 1032 | Whereas if they engage in this negotiation over text, that wasn't the | 如果他们就文本进行谈判,那不是 |
| 1033 | case. | 案例。 |
| 1034 | So if you need to negotiate with someone, these dark traits can be like really domineering, | 所以,如果你需要与某人谈判, 这些黑暗的特征 可能像真正的多明我会, |
| 1035 | really kind of, you know, superficially charming sometimes in person. | 那种,你知道,表面迷人 有时当面。 |
| 1036 | And then you can kind of like | 然后你可以喜欢 |
| 1037 | let your guard down and they're going to take advantage of you. | 放松警惕 他们会利用你的 |
| 1038 | If you reduce them to words | 如果你把它们简化成文字 |
| 1039 | on the page, they lose some of that like charisma, right? | 在页面上,他们失去了一些 像魅力,对不对? |
| 1040 | But there's also other like | 但还有一样 |
| 1041 | practical reasons. | 实际原因。 |
| 1042 | Like, you know, you've got a written version of what was agreed upon. | 比如,你知道,你有一个 书面版本的约定。 |
| 1043 | Like | 喜欢 |
| 1044 | you can't gaslight me and tell me, you know, I'm misremembering what we agreed upon later. | 你不能用毒气点燃我,告诉我, 你知道,我误记得我们后来商定的。 |
| 1045 | I've got | 我有一个 |
| 1046 | a written version here. | 这里有一个书面版本。 |
| 1047 | I've got some time to think about how I want to respond. | 我有一些时间来思考 我想如何回应。 |
| 1048 | Yeah, exactly. | 没错 |
| 1049 | And, you know, if violence is a concern, say you're talking about, this is a domestic | 而且,你知道,如果暴力是一个问题, 说你在谈论,这是一个家庭 |
| 1050 | violence situation. | 暴力状况。 |
| 1051 | 须 get出家. | |
| 1052 | You've got to maybe negotiate, you know, | 你可能得谈判,你知道, |
| 1053 | some sort of settlement in a divorce or something. | 离婚时的某种和解 |
| 1054 | Like being face-to-face can be dangerous, right? | 像面对面是危险的,对不对? |
| 1055 | It literally puts some physical distance between yourself and that other person | 从字面上来说,它使你和另一个人之间的距离 |
| 1056 | if violence is a concern. | 如果暴力是一个问题。 |
| 1057 | So there's all kinds of potential upsides to like, | 所以,有各种潜在的颠倒喜欢, |
| 1058 | if you got to negotiate, like pop it into text, put it into the chat, as opposed to | 如果你必须谈判, 就像把它写成文字, 把它放在聊天,而不是 |
| 1059 | sitting down face-to-face. | 面而坐卧. |
| 1060 | I was thinking about all the things that are linked to just having | 我当时在想那些和... 拥有... |
| 1061 | a bit more time, but also like the medium of text. | 多一点时间,但也像文本的介质。 |
| 1062 | And one of the things that came to mind is if | 而想到的一件事是,如果 |
| 1063 | someone does have those dark personality traits, they are probably more cautious about what they | 有人确实有这种黑暗的个性特征, 他们可能更小心他们是什么 |
| 1064 | say if it's permanent and it's written. | 说如是常住亦复如是. |
| 1065 | So like, if I was sending you an email, I might say something | 所以,如果我给你发邮件,我可能会说点什么 |
| 1066 | to you in person, but if I would I write that same thing on an email. | 但是如果我要在电子邮件上写同样的话 |
| 1067 | And the other one is | 另一个是 |
| 1068 | in written form, you, as the person that's receiving the, being on the receiving end, | 以书面形式 你作为接收者 处于接收端 |
| 1069 | you have time to show other people and get another perspective, even if it's like putting it into AI | 你有时间向其他人展示 并获得另一个视角, 即使它像把它放在AI |
| 1070 | or asking Google or checking if the facts are right or asking your husband or partner if this | 或问Google 或检查事实是否正确 或问你的丈夫或伴侣是否正确 |
| 1071 | is appropriate behavior. | 是适当的行为。 |
| 1072 | Totally. | 当然 |
| 1073 | And like involving other people can be so helpful. | 像让其他人参与会很有帮助的 |
| 1074 | So research suggests that whenever we discuss with other people before making a truth lie judgment | 所以,研究显示,每当我们讨论 其他人之前, 真相的判断。 |
| 1075 | about someone else's statements, we tend to be more accurate. | 关于别人的说法, 我们倾向于更准确。 |
| 1076 | Whenever we're making judgments | 当我们做出判断时 |
| 1077 | about someone's personality, if we're talking as a group, we tend to be more accurate. | 关于某人的个性, 如果我们作为一个群体来谈论, 我们倾向于更准确。 |
| 1078 | Another | 又一个 |
| 1079 | study that Dacher Keltner did, he talked to a bunch of girls in a sorority and asked them | 他和一群女生在联谊会上交谈 问她们 |
| 1080 | who gets talked about the most, like in gossip and also had people rate their personality. | 他们被谈论得最多, 就像在八卦中, 并且还有人评价他们的个性。 |
| 1081 | It was the Machiavellian, the more Machiavellian girls who were talked about the most. | 是马奇亚维利安人, 更多的马奇亚维利安人 谈论最多的。 |
| 1082 | Talked about positively or negatively? | 说正面还是负面? |
| 1083 | Negatively. | 负面. |
| 1084 | Yeah. | 对 |
| 1085 | And so, you know, people sometimes hear about like whisper networks | 所以,你知道,人们有时听到 像耳语网络 |
| 1086 | to like stay away from that guy at work or whatever. | 喜欢远离那家伙 在工作什么的。 |
| 1087 | So I would, you know, caution just | 所以我会,你知道的,小心 |
| 1088 | believing everything you hear in the rumor mill, but sometimes people, you know, spread information | 相信你在传闻厂听到的一切 但有时人们,你知道,传播信息 |
| 1089 | about this is my experience with this person. | 这是我和这个人打交道的经验 |
| 1090 | And we can learn from other people's experience | 我们可以学习别人的经验 |
| 1091 | before having to go through it ourselves if we pay attention. | 之前,我们不得不自己经历 如果我们关注。 |
| 1092 | And you've got three final cards down there, which I think are. | 你们有三张最后的牌 我认为是的 |
| 1093 | These are three common mistakes people make when dealing with dark personalities. | 这是人们在处理黑暗人格时犯下的三个常见错误。 |
| 1094 | So the first one is just believing there's nothing you can do. | 所以第一个只是相信 你无能为力。 |
| 1095 | So, you know, we've talked about how | 所以,你知道,我们已经谈论了如何 |
| 1096 | some of our, our go-to responses when people hurt us, like trying to make them feel badly, | 当人们伤害我们时,我们的一些回应, 就像试图让他们感觉很糟, |
| 1097 | trying to make them apologize to us, like trying to punish them don't work so well. | 试图让他们向我们道歉, 就像试图惩罚他们 效果不好。 |
| 1098 | But we've also talked about all of the things you can do. | 但我们也谈过你能做的 |
| 1099 | Right. | 对 |
| 1100 | So we don't need to feel | 所以我们不需要感觉 |
| 1101 | completely helpless. | 完全无助。 |
| 1102 | Another is assuming they have the same inner experience as you. | 另一个是假设他们和你一样有内在经验 |
| 1103 | You know, when we're trying to figure out what motivates people, again, we talked about this with | 你知道,当我们试图 找出什么 激励人们,再次,我们谈论了这一点 |
| 1104 | negotiation, right? | 谈判,对不对? |
| 1105 | Like what motivates you to do a thing might not be the same thing that motivates | 就像是什么激励你做一件事 可能不是同样的事情 |
| 1106 | me to do a thing. | 我做点什么。 |
| 1107 | I need to try to get into their head, figure out what their goals are. | 我需要试着深入他们的脑海里 找出他们的目标 |
| 1108 | What would be motivating to change their behavior in this situation and try to, you know, frame | 是什么促使他们改变行为 和尝试,你知道,陷害 |
| 1109 | our interaction in that way, try to convince them to change your behavior for that reason, | 我们通过这种方式进行互动 试图说服他们改变你的行为 |
| 1110 | not because I think they should or not because I would feel guilty if I did what they did. | 不是因为我认为他们应该或不应该 因为我会觉得内疚 如果我做了他们做了什么。 |
| 1111 | But lastly, you know, is thinking you can change them. | 但最后,你知道的,是认为 你可以改变它们。 |
| 1112 | So if your ultimate goal is like, | 所以,如果你的最终目标是, |
| 1113 | I'm going to stick around and they're going to be kind and honest and they're going to be super | 我要留下来,他们要 善良和诚实,他们会是超级 |
| 1114 | conscientious and helpful all the time and never going to break any rules. | 总是有良心和有帮助 永远不会违反任何规则 |
| 1115 | Like I think we also | 我觉得我们也是 |
| 1116 | need to be kind of clear-eyed about the likelihood of that happening. | 需要有一种清晰的眼睛 的可能性发生。 |
| 1117 | And so instead we need to kind | 因此,我们需要调和 |
| 1118 | of deploy some of these strategies for making our day-to-day interactions a little more positive, | 运用其中一些战略,使我们的日常互动更加积极, |
| 1119 | as opposed to just hoping that someday they're going to wake up, you know, with a different | 而不是只是希望有一天他们会醒来, 你知道,有一个不同的 |
| 1120 | personality. | 个性。 |
| 1121 | What is the most important thing we haven't talked about that we should have talked about | 什么是最重要的事情,我们没有谈论 我们本应该谈论 |
| 1122 | as it relates to your work? | 和你的工作有关吗? |
| 1123 | And again, zooming in on the people that are listening that might | 并再次放大 在那些正在听 可能 |
| 1124 | benefit them in their lives. | 使他们在生活中受益。 |
| 1125 | I think it's like a matter of numbers. | 我认为这就像一个数字问题。 |
| 1126 | So, you know, we've talked about the, you know, | 所以,你知道,我们谈过,你知道, |
| 1127 | 10% of people would generally agree with items that we use to measure these traits. | 10%的人一般同意我们用来衡量这些特征的项目。 |
| 1128 | That | 那个 |
| 1129 | means that 90% of people would generally not agree, right? | 意味着90%的人一般不会同意 对吧? |
| 1130 | So I want people to keep into | 所以我希望人们继续 |
| 1131 | perspective that like 90% of people, right, are good and kind and honest and not breaking | 90%的人是善良 善良 诚实 而不破裂 |
| 1132 | the rules. | 规则。 |
| 1133 | We've got this 10%, right? | 我们已经得到了这10%,对不对? |
| 1134 | That's not to say that 10% is causing little harm. | 这并不是说10%的伤害很小。 |
| 1135 | In fact, they're causing hugely outsized harm, right? | 事实上,它们造成了巨大的伤害,对不对? |
| 1136 | So like with respect to psychopathy, | 就像关于精神病一样 |
| 1137 | that's about 1% of the population that have clinical levels of it. | 大约1%的人口有临床水平 |
| 1138 | Offenders with clinical | 临床罪犯 |
| 1139 | levels of psychopathy account for about 50% of all serious crime. | 精神病患者约占所有严重犯罪的50%。 |
| 1140 | So these people are | 所以这些人 |
| 1141 | doing incredibly outsized harm. | 伤害大得惊人 |
| 1142 | And we also feel that in our lives too, right? | 我们也觉得我们的生活,对不对? |
| 1143 | Not necessarily | 不见得 |
| 1144 | in criminal rap sheets, maybe, but we've got like one person who's like constantly making | 在犯罪说唱板上,也许, 但我们有像一个人 谁喜欢不断制作 |
| 1145 | things hard because of these traits. | 由于这些特点,事情很困难。 |
| 1146 | They're causing strife at work. | 他们在工作时引起纷争 |
| 1147 | They're abusing people | 他们在虐待人 |
| 1148 | at home. | 在家的时候 |
| 1149 | And so if we can learn to mitigate the damage from just this small, relatively small | 所以,如果我们能学会 减轻损害 从这个小,相对小 |
| 1150 | group of people, then we can dramatically improve our lives, our workplaces, our interactions day | 一群人,然后我们可以大大改善 我们的生活,我们的工作场所,我们的互动日 |
| 1151 | to day. | 到今天为止。 |
| 1152 | We have a closing tradition on this podcast where the last guest leaves a question | 我们有一个封闭的传统 在这个播客 最后的客人留下一个问题 |
| 1153 | for the next guest, not knowing who they're leaving it for. | 对于下一个客人,不知道 他们离开它为谁。 |
| 1154 | Okay. | 摆 |
| 1155 | And the question that's | 问题是 |
| 1156 | been left for you is somewhat relevant. | 留给你有点关系 |
| 1157 | I like that you got this one. | 我喜欢你得到这个。 |
| 1158 | What is one great lie | 伟大的谎言是什么 |
| 1159 | we've all been told? | 我们都被告知了? |
| 1160 | I think one great lie we've all been told is that to be successful, you have | 我想一个伟大的谎言 我们都被告知 要成功,你有 |
| 1161 | to be in it for number one. | 成为其中的第一。 |
| 1162 | And you need to, you know, exemplify some of these traits in order to | 你需要,你知道, 示范一些这些特征,以便 |
| 1163 | get that promotion, to get that raise, to run that company that's worth millions of dollars. | 升职 升职 经营价值数百万的公司 |
| 1164 | And, you know, even I went searching for evidence for that to show that people with high levels of | 我连去寻找证据 都是为了证明那些高水平的人 |
| 1165 | psychopathy could use their kind of callous, cunning, you know, fearlessness in order to | 精神病患者可以使用他们那种 冷酷,狡猾,你知道的,无所畏惧 |
| 1166 | make more money as hedge fund managers. | 作为对冲基金管理者赚更多的钱。 |
| 1167 | And I found the opposite. | 我发现恰恰相反。 |
| 1168 | And so I think even in those | 所以我觉得即使在那些 |
| 1169 | areas where we think these traits lead to success, they fall short. | 我们认为这些特点导致成功的领域,它们还远远不够。 |
| 1170 | And really taking other people | 真正带走别人 |
| 1171 | with us and thinking about success as, you know, prestige and like respect from other people, | 和我们一起思考成功, 作为,你知道,威望 像尊重别人, |
| 1172 | care and concern about us from other people is a much truer version of success. | 关心和关心别人对我们的关心是更真实的成功版本。 |
| 1173 | Leanne, thank you so much. | 莉安,非常感谢 |
| 1174 | Thank you for writing a book that is incredibly illuminating in a way | 谢谢你写了一本书 以某种方式令人印象深刻 |
| 1175 | that is research based, whilst also being just unbelievably engaging. | 这是基于研究的,同时也是令人难以置信的参与。 |
| 1176 | And I think these subjects | 我觉得这些话题 |
| 1177 | are so pertinent to everybody listening. | 对每个人来说都很重要 |
| 1178 | And I know that they're going to love this conversation | 我知道他们会喜欢这次谈话的 |
| 1179 | because much like you were when you started your career, we're all just trying to figure out the | 因为就像你开始职业生涯时一样 我们都在想 |
| 1180 | ultimate barrier and opportunity that all sits in front of us. | 终极障碍和机会,大家都坐在我们面前。 |
| 1181 | And that's just other people. | 而这只是其他人。 |
| 1182 | And again, as you said on one of the cards, but you articulated really nicely earlier on, | 再说一遍,就像你在一张牌上说的, 但你刚才说得非常好, |
| 1183 | we kind of go through the world thinking that everyone else's internal experience is a mirror | 我们经历世界 以为其他人的内部经历是一面镜子 |
| 1184 | of ours. | 我们的。 |
| 1185 | And it's very easy to get frustrated or to feel like you're the problem or you're | 很容易感到沮丧 或者觉得自己是问题 或者你是 |
| 1186 | inadequate. | 不够充分。 |
| 1187 | If that's the lens that you take to life. | 如果这就是你夺走生命的镜头 |
| 1188 | And I think through your research, | 我认为通过你的研究, |
| 1189 | you do exactly what you said, which is in a weird way, you do make us more empathetic and maybe more | 你完全照你说的做 这很奇怪 你确实让我们更加同情 也许更多 |
| 1190 | optimistic and less cynical about the nature of human experience. | 乐观和较少的愤世嫉俗 人类经验的性质。 |
| 1191 | And so this is a wonderful, | 因此,这是一个美妙的, |
| 1192 | wonderful book for anyone that wants more information. | 对想要更多信息的人来说,这本书是很棒的。 |
| 1193 | I'm going to link it below Poisonous | 我要把它连到有毒的地方 |
| 1194 | How to resist them and improve your life. | 如何抵抗他们,改善你的生活. |
| 1195 | But also, it might be a good opportunity to buy this book | 砛硂琌禦诀穦 |
| 1196 | for someone else who you know is dealing with a slightly poisonous person. | 对另一个你认识的人来说 是和一个有点有毒的人打交道 |
| 1197 | Where do people go to | 人们到哪里去 |
| 1198 | support your work and to find more from you? Where do people go to support your work and to find more from you? | 支持你的工作 从你身上找到更多? 人们在哪里支持你的工作,并从你那里找到更多的东西? |
该视频共有字幕 1199 条。解锁更多字幕为会员功能,请移动到 价格
