英国保守党领袖在CBI年会上谈论政府政策 | 2024.11
字幕摘录
| 时间 | 英文 | 中文 |
|---|---|---|
| 0:03 | I hope you all had a nice lunch. | 我希望你们都吃过好午餐 |
| 0:04 | It's my privilege and pleasure to introduce you to a distinguished | 我很荣幸和高兴地向您介绍一位杰出的 |
| 0:12 | software engineer. | 软件工程师。 |
| 0:14 | She also has one of the toughest jobs in British politics. | 她也有英国政治中最艰苦的工作之一. |
| 0:19 | Ladies | 女士们 |
| 0:19 | and gentlemen, Kemi Badenoch. | 先生们,凯米巴迪诺 |
| 0:39 | How do you know whether a politician is actually going to do what it is they say they'll do? | 你怎么知道一个政客是否真的会做 他们说他们会做的? |
| 0:45 | You can only look back on their track record. | 你只能回顾一下他们的记录 |
| 0:48 | Making promises is easy, but if you really want | 做承诺很容易,但如果你真的想 |
| 0:52 | to know what someone is going to be like, look at what they did when they had the chance. | 看看他们有机会时做了什么 |
展开字幕全文(527 条)
| 序号 | 英文 | 中文 |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | I hope you all had a nice lunch. | 我希望你们都吃过好午餐 |
| 2 | It's my privilege and pleasure to introduce you to a distinguished | 我很荣幸和高兴地向您介绍一位杰出的 |
| 3 | software engineer. | 软件工程师。 |
| 4 | She also has one of the toughest jobs in British politics. | 她也有英国政治中最艰苦的工作之一. |
| 5 | Ladies | 女士们 |
| 6 | and gentlemen, Kemi Badenoch. | 先生们,凯米巴迪诺 |
| 7 | How do you know whether a politician is actually going to do what it is they say they'll do? | 你怎么知道一个政客是否真的会做 他们说他们会做的? |
| 8 | You can only look back on their track record. | 你只能回顾一下他们的记录 |
| 9 | Making promises is easy, but if you really want | 做承诺很容易,但如果你真的想 |
| 10 | to know what someone is going to be like, look at what they did when they had the chance. | 看看他们有机会时做了什么 |
| 11 | I'm | и琌 |
| 12 | just as leader of the Conservative Party, but as a former business secretary. | 也是保守党的领袖 但曾经是商业秘书 |
| 13 | Many of you would | 很多人会 |
| 14 | have heard me talk about how we needed to deregulate, and you would have seen examples | 听到我说我们需要如何放松管制 你会看到一些例子 |
| 15 | of how I try to lift the burden of businesses, often arguing with other parts of government, | 我试图减轻企业的负担, 经常与政府其他部门争论, |
| 16 | or trying to stop them bringing in yet more well-meaning but burdensome regulation. | 或试图阻止他们带来 更善意但繁琐的监管。 |
| 17 | I saw | 我看见了 |
| 18 | myself in that role as your champion around the cabinet table, and it is because I know | 我作为你的冠军 坐在柜台上 因为我知道 |
| 19 | that it is not government that creates growth. | 创造增长的不是政府。 |
| 20 | It is business. | 这是生意 |
| 21 | Government often needs to get out | 政府往往需要离开 |
| 22 | of the way, but this is a very difficult argument to make. | 但这是一个非常困难的论据。 |
| 23 | People want the government to fix | 人们希望政府解决 |
| 24 | everything. | 一切众生. |
| 25 | They want the government to solve everything, and if you ever sound hesitant, | 他们希望政府解决一切 如果你听起来犹豫 |
| 26 | then they will make you out to be a cruel, unfeeling person, as I have discovered to my | 然后他们会把你变成一个冷酷无情的人 正如我发现的 |
| 27 | own personal cost. | 个人费用 |
| 28 | This is partly how we have got ourselves into a state where debt is at record | 这也是我们如何让自己进入债务记录状态的 |
| 29 | levels, and we are spending more on debt servicing than we are on health, or on education, or on | 我们花费在还本付息上的钱比在卫生、教育、 |
| 30 | defence. | 辩护。 |
| 31 | That needs to change. | 这需要改变。 |
| 32 | We need growth. | 我们需要增长。 |
| 33 | Too often, we use the word growth as a throwaway | 我们经常把成长这个词当作丢弃 |
| 34 | comment, without actually thinking about how we can actually create it, or what it even is. | 评论,不考虑我们如何实际创建它,甚至是什么。 |
| 35 | Many times, when I'm speaking to members of the public, some assume that money comes from | 很多时候,当我对公众说话时, 有人假设钱来自 |
| 36 | government. | 政府。 |
| 37 | The concept of productivity is one that a lot of people don't understand. | 生产力的概念是很多人不明白的. |
| 38 | They think | 他们觉得 |
| 39 | all jobs are economically equal, whereas as business, you will know that some jobs are | 所有工作在经济上都是平等的,而作为企业,你会知道一些工作是 |
| 40 | and others less so. | 还有其他的 |
| 41 | I believe that we need to rewire our economy into one where the vast majority | 我认为我们需要把经济 重新连接到绝大多数 |
| 42 | of jobs are productive, and that those that are not change. | 工作是生产性的,没有变化。 |
| 43 | This is what I'm here to speak to you | 我就是来跟你说话的 |
| 44 | about today. | 大约今天。 |
| 45 | But first, I want to acknowledge the reason why I'm standing here not as a government | 但首先,我想承认为什么 我站在这里不是一个政府 |
| 46 | minister, but as the leader of the opposition, and it is because we conservatives got things | 部长,但作为反对派领袖, 这是因为我们保守派有东西 |
| 47 | wrong, and unless we explain where we got things wrong, we will repeat those mistakes. | 错误,除非我们解释我们哪里搞错了,否则我们将重复那些错误。 |
| 48 | My father | 我父亲 |
| 49 | was a GP. | 是一个GP。 |
| 50 | He always told me that if you get the diagnosis wrong, the treatment won't work. | 他总是告诉我,如果你得到 诊断错误,治疗不会奏效。 |
| 51 | You'll | 你会 |
| 52 | keep treating the patient over and over again, but they will never get better. | 不断治疗病人,但他们永远不会好起来。 |
| 53 | And that is what I fear | 那就是我所担心的 |
| 54 | is about to happen in the UK. | 即将在英国发生 |
| 55 | We haven't done the work which is needed to understand what the root | 我们还没有做 需要的工作 了解什么是根 |
| 56 | causes of our problems are. | 我们的问题的根源是。 |
| 57 | And I am worried because the Labour Party are not just repeating | 我很担心 因为工党不只是重复 |
| 58 | many of the mistakes which we made in government. | 我们在政府中犯下的许多错误。 |
| 59 | They are doubling down on them and combining them | 他们把双胞胎加在一起 |
| 60 | with an unprecedented raid on business. | 以前所未有的突袭业务。 |
| 61 | Today, we are all talking about the consequences of the | 今天我们都在谈论 |
| 62 | budget, but we do not yet know what the full consequences of the legislative programme will | 预算,但我们尚不知道立法方案的全部后果。 |
| 63 | like their employment rights bill designed by trade unions. | 譬如工会制定的《就业权利法案》。 |
| 64 | But there is no point in me just | 但我没有意义 |
| 65 | complaining about Labour when it was obvious that we conservatives lost the confidence of business. | 我们保守派显然失去了企业的信心, |
| 66 | I was not surprised at how many people attended Labour's prawn cocktail or smoked salmon offensive | 我并不惊讶有多少人 参加工党的虾鸡尾酒或抽鲑鱼攻击 |
| 67 | last year. | 去年的事了 说吧 |
| 68 | I know it is because you thought that we didn't understand what your needs and concerns | 我知道是因为你觉得我们不明白 你的需要和担心 |
| 69 | were. | 曾经是。 |
| 70 | And you knew we were going to lose. | 你知道我们会输的 |
| 71 | So as a first step to fix that, I have made sure that the | 因此,作为解决这个问题的第一步,我已经确保 |
| 72 | two people who are in the most business-facing roles in my shadow cabinet are people who have run | 两个人在我的影子内阁里 扮演着最能做生意的角色 就是那些跑过的人 |
| 73 | companies themselves, people who understand what you are about. | 公司本身,人 谁明白你是什么。 |
| 74 | Our shadow chancellor, Mel Stride, | 我们的影子总统梅尔·斯特里德 |
| 75 | was the widely respected chair of the Treasury Select Committee. | 是财务选择委员会受人尊敬的主席。 |
| 76 | Before Parliament, though, | 在议会面前, |
| 77 | Mel founded a successful business which he expanded into the US. | 梅尔创立了一家成功的企业, 他扩张到美国。 |
| 78 | Our new shadow business secretary, | 我们的新影子商业秘书, |
| 79 | Andrew Griffith, is a former Treasury Minister and chartered accountant. | 安德鲁·格里菲斯(Andrew Griffith)是一位前财政部长和特许会计师. |
| 80 | He has been a successful | 他已经成功 |
| 81 | financial analyst and asset manager. | 财务分析员和资产管理人。 |
| 82 | He has serious boardroom experience. | 他有认真的会议室经验。 |
| 83 | During the leadership | 领导期间 |
| 84 | contest, many people kept asking me, what are your policies? | 很多人一直问我 你的政策是什么? |
| 85 | This was something that I resisted | 这是我抗拒的东西 |
| 86 | because there is a lot that we need to fix before a party that has just started in opposition starts | 因为在刚刚开始的反对党开始之前,我们需要解决很多问题。 |
| 87 | with new policies. | 有了新的政策。 |
| 88 | I believe that we need to begin with first principles. | 我认为,我们需要从第一原则开始。 |
| 89 | If you are thinking about | 如果你在考虑 |
| 90 | opening a restaurant, you don't start off with what the menu will be. | 开一家餐厅,你不会从菜单开始 |
| 91 | So what are our principles? | 我们的原则是什么? |
| 92 | I believe that we need to have free and fair competition. | 我认为,我们需要有自由和公平的竞争。 |
| 93 | Not monopolies, not rent-seeking, | 不是垄断,不是寻租 |
| 94 | not corporatism, but a genuine competition that allows new entrants in and those who are no longer | 不是企业主义 而是允许新进入和不再进入的真正竞争 |
| 95 | productive to evolve or leave the economy. | 生产能够进化或离开经济。 |
| 96 | That is what free enterprise is about. | 这就是自由企业的目的。 |
| 97 | We conservatives | 我们保守派 |
| 98 | must be the party of business. | 必须是生意的一方。 |
| 99 | Not just big business, not just corporates, but small business, too. | 不只是大生意,不只是企业,还有小企业。 |
| 100 | Every big business started out as a small business and that is why I am so concerned that the burden | 每一个大生意都以小生意开始 所以我很担心这个负担 |
| 101 | on them is still increasing with taxes, corporation tax, employers, national insurance, | 税收、公司税、雇主、国家保险 |
| 102 | and new regulations. | 和新条例。 |
| 103 | The new government believes that invisible businesses can absorb these costs, | 新政府认为隐形企业可以吸收这些成本, |
| 104 | but it is everyday people who bear the brunt, either in higher prices or lower wages, sometimes | 但每天都有人首当其冲 要么涨价 要么低工资 有时 |
| 105 | both. | 两个都一样 |
| 106 | We may see the jobs which are lost as a result, but no one ever sees the jobs that never | 我们可能看到由于这些原因而失去的工作,但没有人见过从未有过的工作。 |
| 107 | get created. | 被创建。 |
| 108 | So I am here to show you that I understand businesses' values. | 所以,我在这里告诉你,我理解企业的价值观。 |
| 109 | I am not here | 我不在这 |
| 110 | to represent business interests, that's your job. | 代表商业利益 这就是你的工作 |
| 111 | I am here to let you know the Conservative Party | 我是来告诉你保守党的 |
| 112 | shares your values. | 分享你的价值观。 |
| 113 | I am often criticised for talking about capitalism. | 我经常因为谈论资本主义而受到批评。 |
| 114 | Someone once told me | 曾经有人告诉我 |
| 115 | that capitalism is old-fashioned. | 资本主义是老式的。 |
| 116 | I don't think so. | 亦不见. |
| 117 | I think it is important that we explain what | 我想我们必须解释一下 |
| 118 | capitalism in a free market environment means. | 资本主义在自由市场环境中的含义。 |
| 119 | Capitalism is not a dirty word. | 资本主义不是脏话. |
| 120 | Wealth is not a | 财富不是 |
| 121 | dirty word. | 脏话 |
| 122 | Profit is not a dirty word. | 利润不是脏话 |
| 123 | But we need to start explaining how these things deliver | 但我们需要开始解释这些事情是如何实现的 |
| 124 | for the people out there. | 给外面的人们 |
| 125 | People who often think that you are in it for yourselves and we the | 经常认为你是为了自己 我们 |
| 126 | politicians are in cahoots. | 政客们是串通一气 |
| 127 | People who think that business is all about greedy fat cats rather than | 那些认为生意是贪婪的肥猫 而不是 |
| 128 | people who are working hard, entrepreneurs and those who are making life better for all of us | 努力工作的人、企业家和为我们所有人改善生活的人 |
| 129 | one way or another. | 无论是哪种方式。 |
| 130 | Secondly, we have got to be more precise when we talk about growth. | 第二,我们在谈论增长时必须更加精确。 |
| 131 | It is not just about increased GDP. | 这不仅仅是增加国内生产总值。 |
| 132 | It is not even just about increased GDP per capita. | 这甚至不仅仅是关于人均国内生产总值的增加。 |
| 133 | You can increase GDP by increasing immigration, but no one feels richer. | 你可以通过增加移民来增加GDP,但没有人感到富裕. |
| 134 | In fact, some get poorer. | 事实上,有些人越来越穷。 |
| 135 | You can increase GDP per capita by getting more millionaires and billionaires to move to your | 通过让更多的百万富翁和亿万富翁 移居到你们 |
| 136 | country, but that won't necessarily make everyone else better off. | 国家,但这不一定会 使其他人更好。 |
| 137 | In fact, there are many studies | 事实上,有很多研究 |
| 138 | that show even when nothing has changed, we are more likely to feel worse when we compare ourselves | 即使没有发生什么变化 我们比起自己 更可能感到更糟 |
| 139 | with those who are a lot wealthier than us. | 那些比我们更富有的人 |
| 140 | I am talking about real growth. | 我说的是真正的增长。 |
| 141 | Growth that people can | 人能增长 |
| 142 | see, growth that people can feel. | 人能感觉到的成长 |
| 143 | Seeing an improved environment around them as well as | 周围环境得到改善以及 |
| 144 | having more money in their pockets to spend. | 他们口袋里还有更多钱要花 |
| 145 | Knowing that we have enough money to provide | 知道我们有足够的钱提供 |
| 146 | security to protect our families, but also to protect our country in increasingly dangerous | 安全保护我们的家人, 也保护我们的国家 在越来越危险的情况下 |
| 147 | times. | 时间。 |
| 148 | The bottom line is that economic growth is not the end in itself. | 底线是经济增长本身并不是目的。 |
| 149 | It is a means to an end. | 这是达到目的的手段。 |
| 150 | The end is to make people's lives better. | 终使众生得安乐. |
| 151 | We are not the only country to suffer from low growth. | 我们不是受低增长影响的唯一国家。 |
| 152 | It is plaguing almost all developed countries. | 它困扰着几乎所有发达国家。 |
| 153 | As trade secretary just after Covid, I traveled | 作为贸易秘书 刚过科维德,我旅行 |
| 154 | all around the world and in Italy, Mexico, Japan, the US, Australia, France, people were talking | 世界各地,还有意大利、墨西哥、日本、美国、澳大利亚、法国,人们在谈论 |
| 155 | about the same things. | 同样的事情。 |
| 156 | A higher cost of living, higher inflation, difficulties controlling mass | 生活费用较高、通货膨胀较高、难以控制人口 |
| 157 | migration. | 移徙。 |
| 158 | We are not alone in these problems, but we are unique in our circumstances and our | 在这些问题中,我们并非孤立无援,但在我们的情况和我们的情况中,我们是独一无二的。 |
| 159 | ability to get things moving. | 能够让东西移动。 |
| 160 | That is going to require a change of mindset. | 这需要改变心态。 |
| 161 | And that starts with | 一开始 |
| 162 | our politics. | 我们的政治。 |
| 163 | Politics needs to accept boundaries. | 政治需要接受边界。 |
| 164 | Every day in the legislature, someone has a great | 在立法机构里,每天都有人拥有一个伟大的 |
| 165 | new idea that sounds nice in principle, but in practice creates more red tape, more bureaucracy, | 原则上听起来不错的新想法 但实际上 制造了更多的繁文缛节 更多的官僚主义 |
| 166 | more burden. | 更重的负担。 |
| 167 | The incentive for us as politicians is to keep announcing new nice things. | 我们作为政治家的动机是不断宣布新的美好事物. |
| 168 | But the way | 不过路 |
| 169 | to fix things is not just about creating new laws. | 修补事物不仅仅是创造新的法律。 |
| 170 | We must not be a bureaucratic state. | 我们决不能是一个官僚国家。 |
| 171 | We need to | 我们需要 |
| 172 | get a proper diagnosis of what is going wrong. | 得到一个正确的诊断 什么是出错。 |
| 173 | Why is capital investment so low? | 为什么资本投资这么低? |
| 174 | Why is productivity | 为什么是生产力 |
| 175 | still so stubbornly stalled? | 还是这么固执地停滞不前? |
| 176 | I have read endless reports and many reviews with all sorts of potential | 我读过无穷无尽的报告 和许多评论 各种潜力 |
| 177 | solutions, improving skills or getting our pensions working harder for us. | 解决,提高技能 或让我们的养老金更加努力。 |
| 178 | And we have | 我们有 |
| 179 | brought in regulations and policies to address this. | 制定了相关法规和政策来解决这一问题。 |
| 180 | And yet still things are not getting better. | 然而,情况仍然没有好转。 |
| 181 | I think we need to look again. | 我想我们需要再看看。 |
| 182 | So I'm not standing here telling you that I have all the answers. | 所以我不站在这里 告诉你我有所有答案。 |
| 183 | I am letting you know that I have seen the system from the inside and it is broken. | 我想让你知道,我从内部看到了这个系统,它已经坏了。 |
| 184 | We are trying | 我们正在努力 |
| 185 | to fix problems with the wrong tools. | 用错误的工具解决问题。 |
| 186 | We are using a mindset and a paradigm that worked well | 我们的思维和范式是很好的 |
| 187 | in the late 20th century but does not work well when we have aggressive competitor economies | 20世纪后期,但当我们有充满侵略性的竞争经济体时,效果并不好 |
| 188 | like China and when there is rapid technological innovation, when our society is getting older | 像中国,当有 快速的技术创新, 当我们的社会正在老化 |
| 189 | and the birth rate is still too low. | 而出生率仍然过低。 |
| 190 | More quangos, more interference, more regulations, | 更多的 qua,更多的干扰,更多的监管, |
| 191 | more laws will not fix that. | 更多的法律不会解决这个问题。 |
| 192 | We need to ask ourselves what is the role of the state? | 我们需要问自己国家的作用是什么? |
| 193 | What can we do to create a level playing field and allow you to go out and fix those problems? | 我们能做些什么来创造一个公平的竞争环境,让你出去解决这些问题? |
| 194 | Finally, government itself must change. | 最后,政府本身必须改变。 |
| 195 | It must change what it does if growth is ever properly | 它必须改变它的作用 如果增长是适当的 |
| 196 | to return. | 以归. |
| 197 | We didn't address this when we were in government and if Labour does not, they will fail. | 我们执政时没有讨论这个问题,如果工党不处理,他们就会失败. |
| 198 | Government is going to have to learn from business about how to work better, quicker and be more | 政府将不得不从企业中学习如何更好地、更快地和更多地工作 |
| 199 | responsive. | 反应 |
| 200 | We can no longer tolerate a situation where building roads takes decades, where treasury | 我们再也不能容忍 道路建设需要几十年 国库建设 |
| 201 | decision making means railways don't get built, where the planning system stops investments being | 决策意味着铁路不建 规划系统停止投资 |
| 202 | made by you and your colleagues. | 由你和你的同事们制作。 |
| 203 | Over the last two decades, you have all had to transform your | 在过去二十年里 你们都不得不改变自己 |
| 204 | models to account for massive societal and technological change. | 社会和技术的巨大变化的模型。 |
| 205 | It is time that government | 现在该是政府的时候了 |
| 206 | does the same because what we have now isn't working. | 做同样的事情,因为我们现在没有工作。 |
| 207 | They will tell you that there is no | 他们会告诉你,没有 |
| 208 | alternative. | 备选案文。 |
| 209 | Τ | |
| 210 | We need an alternative strategy so we can finally unleash the power | 我们需要一个替代策略 这样我们才能释放力量 |
| 211 | of business to make our country better. | 为了改善我们的国家 |
| 212 | I believe in the immense power of business to do good. | 我相信企业有能力做好事 |
| 213 | You may not be the public sector but many of you deliver critical services for | 你们可能不是公共部门,但你们许多人为 |
| 214 | the public. | 大众. |
| 215 | So I will stand up for the values of business. | 因此,我将支持商业价值。 |
| 216 | It's time to defend free enterprise | 是时候捍卫自由企业了 |
| 217 | and capitalism, to defend lower taxes, less borrowing and healthy real competition. | 和资本主义,以捍卫 较低的税收, 减少借贷 和健康的真正竞争。 |
| 218 | It's | 这是 |
| 219 | time to recognise that business is a force for change. | 是时候承认企业是变革的力量了。 |
| 220 | It is time to acknowledge that to get | 是时候承认这一点了 |
| 221 | real, meaningful growth that improves the lives of everyone in Britain, | 真正有意义的增长 改善英国每个人的生活, |
| 222 | we will have to change what we all do. | 我们必须改变我们所做的一切。 |
| 223 | And that is what the Conservatives, | 这就是保守党, |
| 224 | under my leadership, are now about. | 在我的领导下,现在就要开始了。 |
| 225 | Thank you. | 谢谢 |
| 226 | Thank you for that. | 谢谢你 |
| 227 | I think you're going to take | 我想你会采取 |
| 228 | two questions from media and then we'll go out to the audience to ask for your questions. | 媒体问了两个问题 然后我们到观众面前问你们的问题 |
| 229 | So I think there were two questions. | 我想有两个问题 |
| 230 | 来吧,天空新闻的Gopri Narwan。 | |
| 231 | Thank you very much. | 谢谢 |
| 232 | Would a Conservative government, under your leadership, reverse | 一个保守党政府,在你的领导下, 会扭转 |
| 233 | the Chancellor's decision to raise employers' national insurance contributions? | 总理决定提高雇主的国家保险费? |
| 234 | Well, one of the things which I have said is that where we can see that a change that has been | 嗯,我说过的一件事是, 在那里,我们可以看到一个变化 已经 |
| 235 | brought in in the budget will obviously not work and will not raise any money, we will change that. | 纳入预算显然不会奏效,也不会筹集任何资金,我们将改变这种情况。 |
| 236 | I said that, for instance, with the family farms tax, the agricultural property relief. | 我说,例如,家庭农场税,农业财产减免。 |
| 237 | We did not have employers' national insurance at this rate. | 我们没有按这个费率购买雇主的国家保险。 |
| 238 | So it's quite clear, certainly you look | 很明显,你看起来 |
| 239 | at the last budget and what we did, that we did not think it should be this high. | 在最后的预算和我们所做的, 我们并不认为它应该如此高。 |
| 240 | One of the things | 其中一个 |
| 241 | that we're going to have to do is rewire everything. | 我们要做的就是重整一切 |
| 242 | So what I'm not going to do is comment on every | 所以,我不打算做的 是评论每一个 |
| 243 | bit of micro-policy. | 有点微政策。 |
| 244 | There will be different budgets. | 预算将有所不同。 |
| 245 | There will be new things that occur. | 会有新的事情发生 |
| 246 | The system may change. | 该系统可能会改变。 |
| 247 | What I am starting with is principles. | 我首先要说的是原则。 |
| 248 | We believe that employers' national | 我们认为,雇主的国籍是 |
| 249 | insurance, while necessary to help us fund public services, is a tax on jobs. | 保险虽然是帮助我们资助公共服务所必需的,但是一种工作税。 |
| 250 | I know this from | 我知道这一点,从 |
| 251 | personal experience. | 个人经历。 |
| 252 | When employers have to pay it, it means that they have less money for higher | 当雇主必须支付时,这意味着他们没有足够的钱支付高额工资 |
| 253 | wages. | 工资。 |
| 254 | They may not create new jobs. | 他们可能不会创造新的就业机会。 |
| 255 | So we need to make sure that the balance is right. | 因此,我们需要确保平衡是正确的。 |
| 256 | The fact | 其实 |
| 257 | that so many organisations, especially those that have people who are on the lowest wages, | 如此众多的组织,特别是那些工资最低的组织, |
| 258 | are saying that this is becoming unaffordable means that we should look again. | 意思是我们应该重新审视一下 |
| 259 | And that's one | 就是这样 |
| 260 | of the first things that we're going to be doing when we start our policy platform. | 当我们开始政策纲领时,我们将要做的第一件事。 |
| 261 | Simon Jack from BBC. | 英国广播公司的西蒙·杰克. |
| 262 | Yes, thank you very much, Simon Jack, BBC News. | 是的,非常感谢,西蒙・杰克,英国广播公司新闻。 |
| 263 | You say that there is an | 你说有一个 |
| 264 | alternative. | 备选案文。 |
| 265 | What was the alternative to raising taxes to fill the black hole which was left by | 除了提高税收来填补黑洞之外 还有什么选择呢? |
| 266 | the previous government? | 前政府吗? |
| 267 | What taxes would you cut or what services would you cut to fill that black | 你将削减什么税 或者你将削减什么服务 填补黑色 |
| 268 | hole? | 洞吗? |
| 269 | Thank you, Simon. | 谢谢你,西蒙。 |
| 270 | So I disagree with the premise of the question. | 所以我不同意问题的前提。 |
| 271 | We need to stop looking | 我们要停止寻找 |
| 272 | at everything as if it's just a ledger where there's taxes raised and services delivered. | 在每件事物上,它就像一个分类账 在那里,有提高的税收和提供服务。 |
| 273 | Not everything that government does is public services. | 并非政府所做的一切都是公共服务。 |
| 274 | We can do things better. | 我们可以做更好的事情。 |
| 275 | We can redesign | 我们可以重新设计 |
| 276 | things. | 东西。 |
| 277 | I often use the football regulator as an example. | 我常以足球监管者为例. |
| 278 | That was something that we brought in. | 这是我们带来的东西。 |
| 279 | That is more government. | 这是更多的政府。 |
| 280 | Do we need a football regulator? | 我们需要足球管制员吗? |
| 281 | This is one tiny thing, but you look | 这是一件小事,但你看 |
| 282 | at the cumulative effect of all of the different bits of well-meaning regulation. | 所有不同位的善意调控的累积效应。 |
| 283 | You add them up | 你加起来 |
| 284 | and they become burdensome. | 他们变得烦琐。 |
| 285 | That is why I'm not talking about which tax will tweak here | 所以我才不说税税会在这里变 |
| 286 | or which service we're going to cut there. | 或者我们要去削减哪些服务。 |
| 287 | We need to completely change the way we talk about how | 我们需要彻底改变我们谈论的方式 |
| 288 | our economy works. | 我们的经济运作。 |
| 289 | What is it that we're trying to do? | 我们到底想做什么? |
| 290 | What should government be doing? | 政府应该做什么? |
| 291 | How should | 怎样才能 |
| 292 | it do better? | 它做更好吗? |
| 293 | Are we having people in the most productive places? | 我们在最有生产力的地方有人吗? |
| 294 | That's going to require a lot | 这需要很多钱 |
| 295 | of work. | 工作时间。 |
| 296 | That's why I talk about setting up policy commissions and deep, real reviews asking the | 这就是为什么我谈论建立 政策委员会和深入,真正的审查 问 |
| 297 | right questions, not just a policy tweak here or there. | 正确的问题,不只是政策调整 这里或那里。 |
| 298 | That's what we're going to do. | 即令众生. |
| 299 | If we're | 如果我们 |
| 300 | going to rewire the state, we need to start from there and not just adjust little knobs and levers | 我们要重整国家,我们需要从那里开始 不只是调整小把手和杠杆 |
| 301 | on tax or insurance. | 税收或保险。 |
| 302 | Let's think about everything from first principles. | 从初正理想一切法. |
| 303 | Right. | 对 |
| 304 | Thank you for that. | 谢谢你 |
| 305 | Now let's go to the floor. | 现在让我们去地板。 |
| 306 | We have a question on the left there. | 左边有个问题 |
| 307 | Yes, sir. | 是 长官 |
| 308 | Sorry. | 对不起 |
| 309 | I'm also Emilio from Politico. | 我也是政治人物埃米利奥 |
| 310 | You talked about we should be building roads much | 你说我们应该多修路 |
| 311 | quickly. | 快点 |
| 312 | How quickly? | 有多快? |
| 313 | We've seen videos of China building hospitals in nine weeks or whatever. | 我们已经看到视频 中国建设医院 在9周左右。 |
| 314 | Once we're past the planning stage, which they obviously don't have to worry about, | 一旦我们过了计划阶段 他们显然不必担心 |
| 315 | how quickly should we be able to build new roads or new hospitals or housing? | 我们应该有多快才能建造新的道路或新的医院或住房? |
| 316 | Secondly, you talked | 第二,你说了 |
| 317 | about, I can't remember the wording exactly, a rentier society or something like that. | 我无法确切地记得措辞 更富有的社会之类的 |
| 318 | What's | 何谓 |
| 319 | your view on leasehold and should it be reformed further? | 你对租借权的看法,是否应该进一步改革? |
| 320 | I think the question about how long should | 我想问题是应该多久 |
| 321 | we take is it's like asking how long is a piece of string. | 我们需要的是,它就像问 多久是弦的一部分。 |
| 322 | We are taking too long. | 我们花了太长时间。 |
| 323 | We know we are | 我们知道我们是 |
| 324 | taking too long because when I was business secretary, many investors would complain about | 花了太长时间,因为当我是商业秘书, 许多投资者会抱怨 |
| 325 | how long it took to get anything done in the UK versus Spain versus Italy. | 英国对西班牙对意大利的战役 需要多长时间才能完成 |
| 326 | The reason why is because | 原因就是因为 |
| 327 | they found the morass of bureaucracy just too difficult to deal with. | 他们发现官僚主义的泥潭 太难对付了 |
| 328 | We should be looking at | 我们应该看看 |
| 329 | what our competitor economies are doing. | 我们的竞争经济体正在做什么。 |
| 330 | We should be asking ourselves why it is that there is so | 我们应该问问自己 为什么有这样的 |
| 331 | much obstruction to getting things delivered. | 很难送货 |
| 332 | We have many, many failed projects to use as | 我们有许多失败的项目 |
| 333 | comparison. | 比较。 |
| 334 | We even have live projects like HS2, which we know have cost way too much money, | 我们甚至有像HS2这样的活项目 我们知道它花费太多钱 |
| 335 | are still not done. | 还没有完成。 |
| 336 | You look at, for instance, the Lower Thames Crossing. | 举个例子,你看看下泰晤士河 |
| 337 | I was given a figure | 我得到一个数字 |
| 338 | that the planning document for the Lower Thames Crossing has cost 300 million pounds. | 下泰晤士河的 规划文件花费了3亿磅 |
| 339 | We haven't | 我们没有 |
| 340 | built anything yet. | 建造了任何东西。 |
| 341 | Other countries, Norway, the Netherlands, they're able to do this a lot faster. | 其他国家,挪威,荷兰,都能够更快地做到这一点. |
| 342 | We are burdening ourselves in a way that is stopping anything from happening, and that is | 我们正以一种阻止一切发生的方式来负担自己,这就是: |
| 343 | what I want us to fix. | 我想要我们解决的 |
| 344 | On the question about leasehold, this is something that we set out | 关于租借权的问题,这是我们提出的 |
| 345 | a policy on. | 一个政策。 |
| 346 | That's not what I'm talking about when I'm saying rent seeking. | 我说寻租时不是这个意思. |
| 347 | What I'm talking | 我说的 |
| 348 | about rent seeking, I'm not talking about landlords. | 关于寻租, 我不是说房东。 |
| 349 | I'm talking about businesses, | 我说的是生意 |
| 350 | which often just co-opt government into delivering things for them when they're not being productive, | 他们常常只是选择政府 为他们提供的东西 当他们没有生产, |
| 351 | and I think we could do a lot better in terms of examining where we are spending our money | 我认为我们可以做很多更好的 检查我们在哪里花我们的钱 |
| 352 | and whether they are in areas that are delivering productivity for our economy. | 以及它们是否位于为我国经济提供生产力的领域。 |
| 353 | Right, thank you for that. | 好的,谢谢你 |
| 354 | Can I just ask you to say who you are at the beginning of your question, | 我能不能请你先说说你是谁? |
| 355 | and please can we, I think we've done media for the moment, we're going to concentrate on | 请我们,我想我们已经做媒体 目前,我们将集中精力 |
| 356 | members. | 成员。 |
| 357 | Halfway down the aisle there, thank you. | 过道半路 谢谢 |
| 358 | Good afternoon, my name's Jass Singh. | 下午好 我叫贾斯·辛格 |
| 359 | I'm the founder of Empowerability. | 我是授权的创始人。 |
| 360 | I'm also a serving | 我也是服务生 |
| 361 | prisoner as I stand here today. | 今天我站在这里时被俘虏 |
| 362 | For Britain to prosper, all its people need to prosper. | 英国要繁荣,其全体人民都需要繁荣. |
| 363 | What point have we got with regards to social mobility in trying to get the hard-to-reach people | 在社会流动方面我们有什么意义? 试图让难以接近的人 |
| 364 | in our communities, those that are in excluded schools, people in referral units and in prisons, | 在我们的社区,那些在被排斥的学校里的人,在转诊单位里的人和在监狱里的人, |
| 365 | to get them retrained so they can make a meaningful contribution to society and start | 让他们重新接受训练 让他们能对社会做出有意义的贡献并开始 |
| 366 | lifting that burden on society in healthcare, in other addiction sort of recovery programmes, | 减轻社会在保健、其他戒毒方案中的负担, |
| 367 | because we always talk about building more rather than actually using what we've got and making it | 因为我们总是谈论建设 更多而不是实际使用 我们拥有和制造 |
| 368 | more efficient? | 更有效率吗? |
| 369 | Okay, I do agree. | 好吧,我确实同意。 |
| 370 | I do think that we can use what we have now a lot better. | 我认为,我们可以更好地利用我们现在所拥有的东西。 |
| 371 | And if you look at the stats on what we are spending on servicing debt, for example, I think | 举个例子,如果你看看我们用来还债的 统计数据,我想 |
| 372 | in my speech I said we spend more on defence and more on education. | 我在演讲中说,我们在国防上花费更多,在教育上花费更多。 |
| 373 | I think on health I'm not quite | 我觉得在健康方面我并不完全 |
| 374 | sure whether that is accurate on health, but certainly more on defence, more on education. | 确定这在健康方面是否准确,当然在国防方面更准确,在教育方面更准确。 |
| 375 | So we're not using our money in the place that's delivering the very best. | 所以,我们不是在用我们的钱 提供最好的。 |
| 376 | But to the point you | 但说到重点 |
| 377 | made about those who are disadvantaged, about social mobility, about giving people a second chance | 社会流动性 给人第二次机会 |
| 378 | like people who have been to prison, we need to make sure that we start, as I said, from first | 就像那些进过监狱的人,我们需要确保 我们开始,正如我说的,从一开始 |
| 379 | principles. | 原则。 |
| 380 | I've often talked about the importance of family. | 我经常谈论家庭的重要性。 |
| 381 | Yes, it is something many people think | 是的,这是很多人认为的 |
| 382 | we shouldn't talk about, it's not the business of government, but you look at the prison population, | 我们不应该谈论, 这不是政府的事, 但你看看监狱人口, |
| 383 | for example, you look at those who are severely disadvantaged, family has the biggest impact. | 举个例子,你看看那些处于严重不利境地的人,家庭的影响最大。 |
| 384 | What can we do to support families? | 我们能做什么来支持家庭? |
| 385 | Whether it's on getting mothers to work, whether it is on | 是否在让母亲工作,是否在 |
| 386 | childcare, or even in providing safer, stronger communities. | 儿童保育,甚至提供更安全、更强大的社区。 |
| 387 | These are things where we need to | 这些都是我们需要的东西 |
| 388 | look at what we're doing and whether it's just busy work or actually things that are making a | 看看我们在做什么 和它只是忙碌的工作 或实际上的东西 |
| 389 | meaningful difference to people's lives. | 给人们的生活带来有意义的影响。 |
| 390 | There are a lot of things that we did do when we were in | 我们做很多事情 当我们在 |
| 391 | government, which I think worked. | 政府,我认为是可行的。 |
| 392 | We had a troubled families programme, it was very specific, went into | 我们有一个麻烦的家庭计划, 非常具体,进入了 |
| 393 | literally into people's homes, but it was quite a complex way of delivering that sort of policy. | 进入人们的家, 但这是一个相当复杂的方式 执行这种政策。 |
| 394 | There may be better ways of doing that, and that's why I'm not sitting here saying we've got all the | 也许有更好的方法做到这一点, 这就是为什么我坐在这里说 我们已经得到了所有 |
| 395 | answers. | 答问. |
| 396 | We do not. | 我们没有。 |
| 397 | We've had 14 years of different flavours of conservative government, but we still | 我们有14年不同的风味 保守政府,但我们仍然 |
| 398 | have many of the challenges that our peer countries have, whether in France or Germany. | 我们的同行国家,无论是法国还是德国,都面临着许多挑战。 |
| 399 | What can we do | 我们该怎么办? |
| 400 | to try and turn things around, given the state of technological innovation, competitive countries, | 鉴于技术革新的状态,竞争的国家, |
| 401 | an ageing society, demography and so much more. | 老龄化的社会,人口等等。 |
| 402 | I think that there's a lot more that we can do. | 我认为我们可以做的更多。 |
| 403 | Thank you. | 谢谢 |
| 404 | Over on the left please. | 左边请。 |
| 405 | If you want to ask a question, just waggle your hand vaguely in | 如果你想问一个问题, 只是摇动你的手模糊地 |
| 406 | the air and somebody with a paddle will come and tell you that you've just won the auction prize. | 空气和有桨的人会来告诉你 你刚刚赢得了拍卖奖 |
| 407 | Yes, over on the left sir. | 是的,左边的先生。 |
| 408 | Hi, Joe Parkinson from Wegrow. | 嗨,韦格罗的乔帕金森 |
| 409 | One of the things that I think about a lot | 我经常想到的一件事 |
| 410 | is the state pulling levers and basically nothing happening, because there's this perception that | 国家拉杠杆 基本上什么都没有发生, 因为有一种感觉, |
| 411 | you can just get into government and we'll just turn this dial and press that button and it'll | 你可以进入政府 然后我们打开这个拨号 然后按下那个按钮 |
| 412 | be fine. | 没事的 |
| 413 | There's a really excellent book by Sam Freeman about the problems of government. | 萨姆·弗里曼(Sam Freeman)著有一本关于政府问题的非常优秀的著作. |
| 414 | How can we undo those bottlenecks that mean that we announce a package that says we're going to | 我们怎样才能消除这些瓶颈 意味着我们宣布一个包裹 说我们要 |
| 415 | change these regulations and then nothing happens? | 改变这些条例,然后什么都没有发生? |
| 416 | It actually delivers growth. | 它能带来增长。 |
| 417 | So how do we undo | 所以,我们如何取消 |
| 418 | those bottlenecks within the British state at the moment to actually allow decisions that are made | 英国国内的这些瓶颈 现在实际上允许作出决定 |
| 419 | and resources are allocated, really manifesting themselves in change that affects people on a | 并分配资源,真正表现在对人民产生影响的变化中, |
| 420 | daily basis? | 日用吗? |
| 421 | Thanks. | 谢谢 |
| 422 | I think we're going to have to look again at how we see risk. | 我想我们必须再看看我们如何看待风险。 |
| 423 | If I look at | 如果我看着 |
| 424 | my experience in all the various government departments I was in, whether it's business | 我在所有政府部门的经验, 无论这是生意 |
| 425 | or trade or education or the treasury, risk appetite often precluded the way things were | 或贸易 或教育 或国库, 风险胃口 往往排除 事情的方式 |
| 426 | delivered. | 交付。 |
| 427 | I gave evidence to the post office inquiry recently about that, that we are trying | 我最近向邮局调查提供了证据 我们正在努力 |
| 428 | to create almost a zero risk environment. | 创造几乎零风险环境。 |
| 429 | So the bottlenecks tend to be in areas where the risk | 因此,瓶颈 往往在风险的领域 |
| 430 | assessment has been made in such a way that the benefit is less post the risk assessment. | 评估是在这样的情况下进行的,这样的好处在风险评估之后就更少了。 |
| 431 | This doesn't mean that we shouldn't think about risk, but I don't think the way we're doing it | 这并不意味着我们不应该考虑风险 但我不认为我们这样做的方式 |
| 432 | is particularly helpful. | 特别有帮助。 |
| 433 | We add in so many caveats, so many different legal, public law | 我们加了很多警告 这么多不同的法律 公法 |
| 434 | barriers, consultations, judicial review. | 障碍、协商、司法审查。 |
| 435 | You look at the planning system, how much people are able | 你看看规划系统,有多少人有能力 |
| 436 | to oppose things that should just happen anyway, not necessarily things that will be disruptive | 来反对那些应该发生的事情, 不一定会破坏的东西 |
| 437 | or destructive. | 或破坏性。 |
| 438 | I think it is about looking at the balance of risk. | 我认为,这是关于考虑风险的平衡。 |
| 439 | You look at what happens | 你看看会发生什么 |
| 440 | during COVID, for example, I think we got the balance of risk wrong there, but we cannot create | 举例来说,在COVID期间, 我认为我们得到了 风险的平衡 错了,但我们不能创造 |
| 441 | a zero risk environment. | 零风险环境。 |
| 442 | We need to get more people understanding that risk does create reward | 我们需要让更多的人明白 风险确实会带来回报 |
| 443 | and that if you do take risks and you lose the government cannot always be there to bail you out | 如果你真的冒着风险 失去政府 就不能一直在那里保释你 |
| 444 | but that if you do succeed then you should be able to enjoy those rewards. | 但如果你成功了,你应该能够享受这些奖励。 |
| 445 | So let's look again at risk, | 让我们再看看风险, |
| 446 | risk management, risk appetite and what it is we are genuinely able to bear and I think that that | 风险管理、风险胃口以及我们真正能够承受的,我认为 |
| 447 | will help us move and shift some of those levers that are actually quite stuck. | 将帮助我们移动和移动一些 杠杆实际上相当卡住。 |
| 448 | Right, just to say | 对,只是说 |
| 449 | we have a slight problem with a shy right. | 我们有一个小问题 一个害羞的权利。 |
| 450 | So we want to keep balance between the left and right | 所以我们要保持左右的平衡 |
| 451 | of our party. | 我们的党。 |
| 452 | I will look at them. | 我会看着他们。 |
| 453 | I'm going to go to the right hand side of the panel there, thank you. | 我去那边的右手边 谢谢 |
| 454 | Good afternoon, Dominic Collier from City and Guilds. | 下午好 市和公会的多米尼克·科利尔 |
| 455 | Our recent report Making Skills Work | 我们最近的报告《使技能发挥作用》 |
| 456 | highlighted that 91% of CEOs see developing skills as fundamental to boosting productivity. | 强调91%的首席执行官认为发展技能对提高生产力至关重要。 |
| 457 | As leader of the opposition, how will you focus on this area? | 作为反对派领袖,你将如何专注于这个领域? |
| 458 | Well I think I'll start by | 好吧,我想我会开始 |
| 459 | making us more specific about what we mean when we say skills. | 让我们更具体地说,当我们说技能时,我们意味着什么。 |
| 460 | I sat in many round tables, | 我参加了许多圆桌会议, |
| 461 | many meetings and everybody was talking about skills and we were speaking at cross purposes. | 许多会议,每个人都在谈论技能,我们是在谈论交叉目的。 |
| 462 | What exactly do we mean? | 我们到底是什么意思? |
| 463 | For some people it's basic social skills. | 对有些人来说,这是基本的社交技能. |
| 464 | I remember doing a prison | 我记得做一个监狱 |
| 465 | visit and I was told that we teach them skills and I asked to see what sort of skills they were | 我被告知我们教他们技能 我问他们是什么技能 |
| 466 | teaching and it was basic things like teaching people to say please and thank you. | 教书是基本的 比如教人们说谢谢和谢谢 |
| 467 | The prisoners | 囚犯们 |
| 468 | who left prison who couldn't use the language that children use were unable to move very far. | 无法使用儿童使用的语言 却无法走得很远 |
| 469 | To the other extreme end of the line, you know, AI and so on, there is a huge spectrum | 至另一极端,你知道的,AI等等, 有一个巨大的光谱 |
| 470 | of skills development that is required. | 发展所需技能。 |
| 471 | Making sure that we are able to do so in a way where | 确保我们能够以这样的方式做到这一点: |
| 472 | we're developing the talents of people in this country, creating more second chances, not just | 我们正在培养这个国家的人才 创造更多的第二次机会 不只是 |
| 473 | assuming that what you did at A levels or at university is what you're going to do for the | 假设你在A级或大学里所做的 就是你将要做的 |
| 474 | older and we're all going to be working longer. | 年长,我们都会工作更长。 |
| 475 | So I would like us to be more specific about skills. | 所以我希望我们更具体地讲讲技巧。 |
| 476 | I sat in meetings where some people were talking about, you know, very serious manufacturing skills | 我坐着开会,有人在谈论, 你知道,非常严肃的制造技能 |
| 477 | 另一个人在谈论PowerPoint | |
| 478 | It's not the same thing. | 亦非一义. |
| 479 | We need to be more | 我们需要更多 |
| 480 | specific in our language. | 具体用我们的语言。 |
| 481 | We need to talk to each other better and I think that way we'll be able | 我们得好好谈谈 我觉得这样我们就能 |
| 482 | to develop a real policy that makes a difference. | 制定真正能有所作为的政策。 |
| 483 | Thank you. | 谢谢 |
| 484 | Question over there. | 那边问. |
| 485 | Hi, I'm Lenny | 嗨,我是兰尼 |
| 486 | Rolls from the University of Sussex. | 萨塞克斯大学的卷子 |
| 487 | I wondered, following on from that question, given the skills | 我想,从这个问题开始,鉴于这些技能 |
| 488 | that we're providing students that are coming through and how important universities are to | 我们提供的学生 即将通过 和大学有多重要 |
| 489 | the UK economy, what more you think government needs to do to support universities to be able | 英国的经济,你认为政府需要做什么 来支持大学的能力 |
| 490 | to deliver growth for the economy? | 为经济带来增长? |
| 491 | So I actually went to University of Sussex. | 所以我真的去了萨塞克斯大学。 |
| 492 | That was where I got | 我从那里得到的 |
| 493 | my first degree in engineering and it amazes me how much has changed in the last sort of 22 years | 我的第一个工程学学位 令我惊叹 在过去的22年里 |
| 494 | since I finished, how even the programming and the coding which I was doing there has become | 自从我完成了, 如何甚至编程和编码 我在那里做 |
| 495 | obsolete. | 过时。 |
| 496 | I think being able to stay current, being able to evolve with changing times is one | 我认为能够保持时态, 能够随着时代的改变而进化是其中之一 |
| 497 | of the things that universities find very difficult to do and being able to show what it is that | 大学认为很难做的事情 和能够显示是什么 |
| 498 | they're doing that's different, that is providing us with a competitive and comparative advantage | 他们这样做是不同的, 为我们提供了竞争和比较优势 |
| 499 | against our peer countries is key. | 对抗我们的同行国家是关键。 |
| 500 | I am quite worried right now about the ability for | 我现在很担心... |
| 501 | your key customers, that is students, to be able to pick the right course for what they want to do | 你的主要顾客,即学生, 能够选择正确的课程 他们想做什么 |
| 502 | in life. | 在生活中。 。 。 |
| 503 | I think that there is a lot of confusion about what you can do with courses. | 我认为,对于课程的设置,有很多混乱之处。 |
| 504 | Many courses teach knowledge, not necessarily skills. | 许多课程教授知识,不一定是技能。 |
| 505 | So you would have heard lots of people | 所以你会听到很多人 |
| 506 | sit in conferences like this and talk about, you know, better partnerships with business and | 参加这样的会议 谈谈更好的合作关系 |
| 507 | education sector and so on and so forth. | 教育部门等。 |
| 508 | I don't want us to deal just in cliches. | 我不想我们只用陈词滥调 |
| 509 | What does a | 何谓 |
| 510 | successful partnership like that really look like? | 那种成功的伙伴关系真的看起来像吗? |
| 511 | It's got to be something which we can measure. | 一定有我们能衡量的东西 |
| 512 | It's got to be something where the metrics are showing that what universities are doing | 这一定是一些 衡量标准显示 大学在做什么 |
| 513 | are making a difference. | 正在改变。 |
| 514 | And as I said, in the same competitive environment the business needs | 正如我所说 在同一竞争环境中 企业需要 |
| 515 | to work in, universities need to work in that competitive environment as well. | 大学也需要在这种竞争环境中工作。 |
| 516 | If universities | 如果大学 |
| 517 | are not delivering for their clients, for their customers, then they need to evolve or leave. | 不为客户,为客户, 那么他们需要进化或离开。 |
| 518 | And that's one of the things that I think that we can do better in terms of measuring | 我认为我们可以更好地测量 |
| 519 | the genuine outcomes of the people who are passing through our educational institutions | 通过我们的教育机构的人们的真正成果 |
| 520 | to make sure that they're getting what they are being promised because they mostly only get one | 保证他们得到承诺,因为他们大多只得到一个 |
| 521 | chance. | 机会 |
| 522 | They come out with a lot of debt and we need to make sure that we're making sure that they | 他们债台高筑 我们需要确保他们 |
| 523 | use that one chance as best as they can. | 尽可能利用这个机会 |
| 524 | Thank you very much indeed for that and thank you | 非常感谢,谢谢你 |
| 525 | for coming here today. | 今天来这里 |
| 526 | It's been great to see you here and so I know members will want to give you | 很高兴在这里见到你 我知道成员们会想给你 |
| 527 | a round of applause and say thank you. | 掌声掌声谢谢 |
该视频共有字幕 527 条。解锁更多字幕为会员功能,请移动到 价格
