推荐微信扫码登录以获得更好的体验!另:🎉建议更新到最新版,以体验新功能!🎉 版本更新记录→

为川普算算军事驱逐非法移民出境的航班成本 | 2025.2.

字幕摘录

时间英文中文
0:01On January 24th, the Trump administration started using C-17 military planes for1月24日,特朗普政府开始使用C-17军用飞机用于
0:07deportation, signaling a hard line against migrants.向移民发出强硬的信号。
0:10But a Wall Street但华尔街
0:11Journal analysis found these flights take longer, carry fewer people, and are日记分析发现这些航班需要更长的时间,载人较少,而且
0:15far more expensive than the government's typical deportation flights on civilian远比政府典型的 民用驱逐航班昂贵得多
0:19planes.飞机。
0:20For example, this one flight to India and back involved seven stops and例如,这趟飞往印度的航班 涉及7个停留
0:24at least two aerial refuels, a trip that likely cost nearly three million dollars.至少有两架航空加油机,这次旅行可能花费近300万美元.
0:30Here's why those military flights are a more expensive use of taxpayer money.这也是为什么这些军事航班更昂贵地使用纳税人的钱.
0:35President Trump campaigned on the promise to increase deportations.特朗普总统呼吁承诺增加驱逐.
展开字幕全文(111 条)
序号英文中文
1On January 24th, the Trump administration started using C-17 military planes for1月24日,特朗普政府开始使用C-17军用飞机用于
2deportation, signaling a hard line against migrants.向移民发出强硬的信号。
3But a Wall Street但华尔街
4Journal analysis found these flights take longer, carry fewer people, and are日记分析发现这些航班需要更长的时间,载人较少,而且
5far more expensive than the government's typical deportation flights on civilian远比政府典型的 民用驱逐航班昂贵得多
6planes.飞机。
7For example, this one flight to India and back involved seven stops and例如,这趟飞往印度的航班 涉及7个停留
8at least two aerial refuels, a trip that likely cost nearly three million dollars.至少有两架航空加油机,这次旅行可能花费近300万美元.
9Here's why those military flights are a more expensive use of taxpayer money.这也是为什么这些军事航班更昂贵地使用纳税人的钱.
10President Trump campaigned on the promise to increase deportations.特朗普总统呼吁承诺增加驱逐.
11And very soon很快地,我终于...
12we'll begin the largest deportation operation.我们将开始最大的驱逐行动。
13And a Department of Homeland还有国土部
14Security spokesperson told us the military aircraft are a way to increase安全发言人告诉我们 军机是增加的方法
15capacity and seats on flights.飞机容量和座位。
16But Immigration and Customs Enforcement, or但移民和海关执法部门,或
17ICE, is already set up to deport thousands of people each month throughICE 已经建立 每月驱逐数千人
18what they call ICE Air Operations.他们称之为ICE航空作业。
19ICE contracts private, for-profit air brokersICE 私人盈利航空经纪人合同
20to charter civilian planes, which are staged across the country for an* 包租民用飞机,在全国各地进行
21estimated 31 to 66 flights a week, according to contract documents.根据合同文件,估计每周有31至66次航班。
22Those这些
23regularly chartered ICE planes, which include the Airbus A320, are capable of经常包租的ICE飞机,包括空中客车A320,能够
24holding at least 140 passengers per flight.每班航班至少载有140名乘客。
25Officials have said they官员说
26typically transport 135 migrants.一般运输135名移民。
27And as for the price tag, this ICE website last至于价格标签 这个ICE网站最后
28updated in 2021 says they cost an average of $8,577 per flight hour.2021年更新时称,它们平均每飞行小时花费8577美元.
29But不过
302023 congressional testimony puts that figure around $17,000.2023年国会证词显示这个数字约为17,000美元.
31The Department of外交部
32Homeland Security didn't respond to our repeated requests for estimates, but two国土安全局没有回应我们一再提出的估算要求 但有两个
33former ICE officials confirmed the $17,000 number to us, so we'll use that前ICE官员向我们证实了17000美元的数字, 所以我们会使用
34to be more conservative in calculating the difference.更保守地计算差额。
35Here's how that compares这样比较
36to Trump's military deportation flights.前往特朗普的军事驱逐航班.
37Those are being carried out by C-17s.这些任务由17国小组执行。
38Air Force planes built to carry troops and cargo.空军飞机为运送部队和货物而建造.
39These planes are designed to这些飞机的设计目的是
40hold 102 paratroopers and their gear.持有102伞兵及其装备.
41And so far, they've been transporting目前为止,他们一直在运送
42roughly 80 migrants at a time.一次约80名移民。
43They cost $28,500 per flight hour, according to the每小时28,500美元
44Department of Defense.国防部.
45So the ICE charter flights are capable of holding one and因此,ICE包机 能够持有一个和
46a half times as many migrants at around 60% of the cost per hour of the military占军队每小时费用60%左右的移徙者人数的一半
47flights.飞行。
48And there's another factor making these military flights even more还有另一个因素 使得这些军事飞行更加
49The C-17s aren't using Mexico's airspace, adding hours to each trip.C-17不使用墨西哥空域,每次行程增加时数.
50A defense辩护
51official told us that's because Mexico requires diplomatic clearance at least官方告诉我们是因为墨西哥至少需要外交许可
52seven days in advance for each flight.每次飞行都要提前7天
53Take a look at these flights on January1月看这些航班
5424th.24号
55This deportation flight from El Paso to Guatemala City used civilian这次从埃尔帕索飞往危地马拉城的驱逐航班使用了平民
56aircraft.飞机。
57It lasted a little more than three hours, carried 105 migrants and它持续了3个多小时,载有105名移民,
58likely cost the government $55,000 in flight time.可能政府花了5万5千元的飞行时间
59On that same day, this在同一天,这个
60military deportation flight also ran from El Paso to Guatemala City.军事驱逐航班也从埃尔帕索飞往危地马拉城。
61It lasted一直这样
62nearly six hours, transported 80 migrants and cost the government $166,000 in将近六个小时,运送80名移民 政府损失166,000美元
63flight time.飞行时间。
64Costs that doubled when the aircraft flew back to the United States.当飞机飞回美国时,费用增加了一倍。
65It's not clear why the military plane was used that day.不清楚当日为何使用军机.
66In the weeks before在前几周
67Trump's inauguration, it was the norm for ICE to run three deportation flights to特朗普就职典礼 ICE开三趟驱逐航班
68Guatemala on Fridays, according to the Migration Institute of Guatemala.危地马拉移民研究所说,星期五是危地马拉。
69But on但继续
70only one of those lower-cost ICE air flights ran, along with two of the more只有一架成本较低的ICE飞机 和两架直升机一起运行
71expensive military flights.昂贵的军事飞行。
72Then there's the India flight, which transported about然后是印度的航班,它载着我们
73a hundred migrants.100名移民。
74Flight tracking data from Flight Radar 24 shows it made at24号飞行雷达的飞行跟踪数据显示
75least seven stops on its trip around the world.环球旅行至少停了七趟
76And it was refueled in the air at它在空中加油时
77least twice by KC-46s out of Honolulu and KC-135s out of Okinawa.火奴鲁鲁的KC -46和冲绳的KC
78Those这些
79The Journal's analysis found this one trip cost more than $2.8 million.《日刊》的分析发现,这次旅行费用超过280万美元。
80Potentially adding to the cost, the tankers that did the refuel over Hawaii在夏威夷加油的油轮 可能会增加成本
81flew out and back from New Jersey in the days before and after the India mission.在印度传教前后几天从新泽西飞出并返回.
82Now let's look at flights to Guantanamo.现在我们看看飞往关塔那摩的航班
83On February 4th and 6th, the US used C-17s2月4日和6日,美国使用C-17
84to transport migrants deemed high-risk to US facilities at Guantanamo Bay.将被认为高风险的移民运送到关塔那摩湾的美国设施。
85These这些
86flights only carried about a dozen migrants each, which means for a飞机只载着大约12名移民,这意味着
87four-and-a-half-hour flight, it cost more than $10,000 per person, a number that4个半小时的飞行,每人花费超过10,000美元,这个数字
88doubles when you account for the return flight.返回航班时加倍。
89The US is also sending C-130 J美国也派出C-130 J
90planes to Guantanamo now, which shake out to about the same price since they are现在飞往关塔那摩的飞机 与现在的一样价格
91less expensive per hour but take longer to get there.每小时比较便宜,但需要更长的时间才能到达。
92In an email, a DHS在电子邮件中,一个DHS
93spokesperson told us the administration is racking up flights with around 40 in发言人告诉我们,政府 正在打压航班 大约40英寸
94the last seven days, including ICE planes, commercial flights, Department of过去七天,包括ICE飞机、商业飞行、
95Defense flights and foreign flights.防卫飞行和外国飞行.
96The Journal couldn't verify these figures《日刊》无法证实这些数字
97and DHS didn't provide additional details.人口与健康调查没有提供更多的细节。
98ICE does not release data orICE 不发布数据或
99comprehensive breakdowns on the number of flights or the number of people on飞行次数或乘机人数的综合细目
100flights.飞行。
101But the number of ICE Air's chartered deportation flights is但ICE航空的包机驱逐航班是
102actually down when you compare the first two weeks of the Trump administration to事实上,当你把特朗普政府的头两个星期 比作
103the same time period last year, according to data collected by Thomas根据托马斯收集的数据
104Cartwright, who tracks deportations using publicly available flight records withCartwright,他利用公开的飞行记录追踪驱逐出境的情况,并使用
105(原始内容存档于2018-09-25). Province group, Witness at the Bords.
106We reached out to the Department of我们联系了国防部
107Government Efficiency for comment on the high cost of military deportations.政府对军队驱逐费用高昂的评论效率。
108In an在一个
109email, a spokesperson wrote,一位发言人写道,
110Homeland Security told the Journal it expects return and removal numbers to国土安全部告诉《日刊》说,它预计返回和清除号码会到
111increase significantly.大幅增加。
该视频共有字幕 111 条。解锁更多字幕为会员功能,请移动到 价格