【TED】分歧时为何那么难倾听 · 深度聆听的框架
共 2 集
剧集目录
| 集 | 标题 | 时长 |
|---|---|---|
| P1 | 【TED】分歧时为何那么难倾听 · 深度聆听的框架 中英字幕 | 10:51 |
| P2 | 【TED】分歧时为何那么难倾听 · 深度聆听的框架 英文字幕 | 10:51 |
P1 · 【TED】分歧时为何那么难倾听 · 深度聆听的框架 p01 中英字幕 (P1)
字幕摘录
| 时间 | 英文 | 中文 |
|---|---|---|
| 0:04 | You know, there's something quite strange going on, | 你知道,有些事情是相当奇怪的, |
| 0:08 | because most of us believe we should be better listeners. | 因为我们大多数人认为我们应该是更好的听众。 |
| 0:11 | But as I found in my research, we find it so hard, | 但正如我在研究中发现的, 我们发现如此艰难, |
| 0:16 | especially when we disagree. | 尤其是我们不同意的时候 |
| 0:18 | There's a kind of psychological bug that gets in the way. | 有一种心理缺陷会妨碍到他们 |
| 0:22 | We fear that if we listen to people whose ideas we find unpalatable | 我们担心,如果我们听别人的 想法,我们认为不愉快 |
| 0:27 | will be contaminated without realizing it, | 将不知不觉地被污染, |
| 0:31 | and we've bought into a dangerous myth. | 我们被一个危险的神话迷住了 |
| 0:34 | Listening means agreeing. | 倾听意味着同意。 |
| 0:39 | So we avoid it. | 所以我们避开它。 |
展开字幕全文(198 条)
| 序号 | 英文 | 中文 |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | You know, there's something quite strange going on, | 你知道,有些事情是相当奇怪的, |
| 2 | because most of us believe we should be better listeners. | 因为我们大多数人认为我们应该是更好的听众。 |
| 3 | But as I found in my research, we find it so hard, | 但正如我在研究中发现的, 我们发现如此艰难, |
| 4 | especially when we disagree. | 尤其是我们不同意的时候 |
| 5 | There's a kind of psychological bug that gets in the way. | 有一种心理缺陷会妨碍到他们 |
| 6 | We fear that if we listen to people whose ideas we find unpalatable | 我们担心,如果我们听别人的 想法,我们认为不愉快 |
| 7 | will be contaminated without realizing it, | 将不知不觉地被污染, |
| 8 | and we've bought into a dangerous myth. | 我们被一个危险的神话迷住了 |
| 9 | Listening means agreeing. | 倾听意味着同意。 |
| 10 | So we avoid it. | 所以我们避开它。 |
| 11 | And instead, we fixate on trying to explain ourselves | 相反,我们坚持 试图解释自己 |
| 12 | more loudly, more fiercely, more insistently, | 更大声,更凶猛,更坚持, |
| 13 | if only they'd understand. | 如果他们能理解的话 |
| 14 | You know, I should know, | 你知道,我应该知道, |
| 15 | because I threw away a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity | 因为我放弃了一生一次的机会 |
| 16 | to understand one of Africa's most intriguing and powerful leaders, | 了解非洲最有趣和最强大的领导人之一, |
| 17 | because I wasn't ready to listen. | 因为我还没准备好听 |
| 18 | So let me tell you about a time when I was in Ethiopia | 所以,让我告诉你 当我在埃塞俄比亚的时候 |
| 19 | reporting for the BBC at the start of my career. | 我职业生涯开始时为BBC报道. |
| 20 | I'd landed an interview with its president | 我采访了总统 |
| 21 | and later Prime Minister Meles Zunawi. | 后任总理梅莱斯·祖纳维. |
| 22 | I was so proud. | 我很骄傲。 |
| 23 | This was my big scoop. | 这是我的大勺子 |
| 24 | But it was also a time when his opponents were tortured or disappeared. | 但这也是他的对手遭受酷刑或失踪的时期. |
| 25 | So the president, he was keen to talk about his record | 因此,总统,他热衷于谈论他的记录 |
| 26 | crop production of maize, of sorghum and barley, | 生产玉米、高粱和大麦, |
| 27 | critical in a country with a history of famine. | 在一个有饥荒历史的国家里, |
| 28 | But I refused to listen, | 但我拒绝听 |
| 29 | incessantly circling back to human rights. | 不停地盘旋回到人权。 |
| 30 | To be honest, my questions, | 老实说 我的问题 |
| 31 | they were masks for my desire to confront the president. | 那是我对抗总统的口罩 |
| 32 | And what did he do? | 他做了什麽? |
| 33 | He edged further and further away from me, | 他离我越来越远 |
| 34 | behind his vast wooden desk, | 在他巨大的木头桌子后面 |
| 35 | and then cut the interview early. | 然后提前剪掉采访 |
| 36 | You know, it wasn't so much that I was wrong to hold the president to account. | 你知道,这不是太多 我错了让总统负责。 |
| 37 | That was essential. | 这很重要。 |
| 38 | But my lack of curiosity and my inability to listen | 但我缺乏好奇心,无法听 |
| 39 | caused him to put up his defenses, | 他为他辩护, |
| 40 | and so I walked away empty-handed. | 于是我空手离开 |
| 41 | And over the years, I've learned from my mistakes as a journalist | 这些年来,我从我的记者错误中吸取了教训 |
| 42 | and my work as an executive coach, | 我作为执行教练的工作 |
| 43 | and I've drawn on scholars, on psychologists and peace builders, | 我从学者、心理学家和建设和平者那里吸取了教训 |
| 44 | and I've woven these ideas together into a book | 我把这些想法编成一本书 |
| 45 | and an approach I call deep listening. | 以及我称之为深听的方法。 |
| 46 | Because the standard way we so often perform listening, | 因为标准的方式 我们经常进行听, |
| 47 | it starves us of real connections. | 它让我们失去真正的联系 |
| 48 | We struggle to engage with our coworkers, | 我们努力和同事接触 |
| 49 | with our family. | 与我们的家人。 |
| 50 | Just ask my own. | 问问我自己就好 |
| 51 | Anyone from a different background or generation, | 任何来自不同背景或世代的人, |
| 52 | anyone whose ideas conflict with our own. | 他们的思想和我们的思想相冲突 |
| 53 | Now, you see, I think I'm rational, | 现在,你看,我觉得我很理智, |
| 54 | and my sense is that you think you're rational. | 我的感觉是,你觉得自己很理智 |
| 55 | But we're all driven by our judgments, | 但我们都是受判决驱使的 |
| 56 | by our emotions and our past, | 我们的情感和过去 |
| 57 | clinging onto the moral high ground. | 坚持在道德高地上。 |
| 58 | The problem is that from an early age, | 问题是,从小, |
| 59 | we've been brought up to believe that listening means agreement, | 我们长大后相信 倾听意味着同意 |
| 60 | that listening signals obedience. | 倾听信号服从。 |
| 61 | You know, I remember my first teacher yelling at me, | 我记得我第一个老师对我大吼大叫 |
| 62 | listen to me. | 听我说 |
| 63 | And what she meant is, | 而她的意思是, |
| 64 | obey me, keep quiet, put those crayons away. | 听我的 安静点 把蜡笔收起来 |
| 65 | It wasn't really an invitation to listen. | 这不是真的 一个邀请听。 |
| 66 | It was a command to comply. | 这是服从的命令。 |
| 67 | And this muddling up of listening and agreement | 而这种混杂的听和协议 |
| 68 | means that now, as adults, | 意味着现在,作为成年人, |
| 69 | we fear listening to people whose ideas might disturb us. | 我们害怕听别人说话 他们的想法可能会打扰我们 |
| 70 | Will I lose myself? | 我会失去自己吗? |
| 71 | Will I be forced to change my mind? | 我会被迫改变主意吗? |
| 72 | Will I be changed? | 我会被改变吗? |
| 73 | At a primal level, | 在初级层面, |
| 74 | it can feel scary to open ourselves up to ideas | 打开我们自己的想法会感到害怕 |
| 75 | which clash with our values. | 与我们的价值观相冲突 |
| 76 | And the result? | 结果呢? |
| 77 | A world in which we think it's better, | 这个世界,我们认为它是更好的, |
| 78 | even more moral, | 更讲道德 |
| 79 | to sidestep any encounters across divides. | 避免任何跨越分歧的遭遇。 |
| 80 | But in avoiding these exchanges, | 但是为了避免这些交流 |
| 81 | we only help deepen the fault lines of polarization | 我们只会帮助加深两极分化的断层 |
| 82 | that are tearing our families, our communities | 撕裂我们的家庭,我们的社区 |
| 83 | and, of course, our nations apart. | 当然,我们的国家是分开的。 |
| 84 | So let me give you an example. | 让我举个例子。 |
| 85 | Take the Baltic state of Latvia, | 取波罗的海国家拉脱维亚, |
| 86 | which has a traumatic history of decades under Soviet rule. | 在苏联统治下的数十年中, 都有一段痛苦的历史。 |
| 87 | And not long after the Russian full-scale invasion of Ukraine, | 在俄国全面入侵乌克兰后不久 |
| 88 | feelings there were running deep and high. | 感觉很深很高 |
| 89 | Threats of reinvasion were real. | 重新入侵的威胁是真实的。 |
| 90 | And suspicion was falling on the one in three Latvians | 怀疑在拉脱维亚的三分之一的人身上 |
| 91 | who were speaking Russian at home. | 他们在家里说俄语。 |
| 92 | So I was invited to train people from both communities together, | 所以我被邀请一起训练来自两个社区的人 |
| 93 | that's the Latvians and the Russian speakers, | 这是拉脱维亚人和俄语, |
| 94 | so they could practice deep listening to someone from the other side. | 这样他们就能深入地听别人的声音 |
| 95 | But how can you listen when your feelings are so strong | 但是当你的感情如此强烈的时候,你怎么能听呢? |
| 96 | and when there's so much at stake? | 当有这么多的利害关系? |
| 97 | So can I tell you about Ilona? | 我可以告诉你伊洛娜的事吗? |
| 98 | She's a Russian-speaking Latvian, | 她是讲俄语的拉脱维亚人, |
| 99 | and to be honest, at the start, | 老实说,一开始, |
| 100 | when she started using the deep-listening steps, | 当她开始使用 深听步骤, |
| 101 | it felt pretty unnatural. | 感觉很不正常 |
| 102 | It was hard for her to stay curious, | 她很难保持好奇 |
| 103 | and accept she didn't yet know what her neighbor might be thinking. | 承认她还不知道邻居在想什么 |
| 104 | But cautiously, she began putting the eight steps to work, | 但谨慎地说,她开始将这八步推向工作 |
| 105 | taking time out, for example, | 例如,抽出时间, |
| 106 | to listen to herself first | 先听自己的话 |
| 107 | and notice what her neighbor might provoke in her. | 注意她的邻居可能激怒她 |
| 108 | Maybe they reminded her of a bullying older sister, | 也许他们让她想起一个欺负的姐姐 |
| 109 | so she felt eight again, | 所以她又感觉到了8个 |
| 110 | powerless and trapped. | 无力而困. |
| 111 | Or she might notice how judgmental she was feeling. | 或者她可能注意到她的判断力 |
| 112 | That neighbor, she's selfish for sure. | 那个邻居 她很自私 |
| 113 | Or she might realize that she'd projected, like most of us, | 或者,她可能意识到 她的预测, 像我们大多数人一样, |
| 114 | the parts of herself she found hardest to accept, | 她自己最难接受的部分 |
| 115 | onto her neighbor. | 她的邻居。 |
| 116 | Because after all, we see the world not as it is, | 因为毕竟,我们看到的世界 并非如此, |
| 117 | but as we are. | 但就像我们一样 |
| 118 | Slowly, Ilona learned to put her own stuff aside, | 慢慢地,伊洛娜学会了 把她自己的东西放在一边, |
| 119 | so she could be more present with whatever unfolded, | 所以她可以更在场 与任何展开, |
| 120 | whatever her neighbor wanted to share. | 她邻居想分享的 |
| 121 | She didn't manage it every time, mind. | 她不是每次都会处理的 介意吧 |
| 122 | Some conversations still left her tight-jawed and defensive, | 有些对话仍然让她 被紧紧的束缚和防守, |
| 123 | but she began to notice that in the moment. | 但她现在开始注意到了 |
| 124 | And then she experimented with something simple. | 然后她用简单的东西做了实验. |
| 125 | I meant to do that, silence. | 我本想这么做的 沉默 |
| 126 | The warm, empathetic kind, | 温和的,爱心的, |
| 127 | to allow her neighbor to reflect more | 让她的邻居更能反省 |
| 128 | and give Ilona a chance to make more sense of their perspective. | 并给伊洛娜一个机会 让他们的观点更有意义。 |
| 129 | Ilona found out that she could tap into something | 伊洛娜发现她可以挖掘一些东西 |
| 130 | called your third ear, | 呼唤你的第三只耳朵, |
| 131 | which is about tuning into what's important but unspoken. | 这是关于调和什么是重要 但没有说。 |
| 132 | And I like to think the third ear is located just next to our heart. | 我想第三只耳朵就在我们心脏旁边 |
| 133 | And our third ear can be more insightful than our conscious intelligence, | 我们的第三只耳朵 比我们有意识的智慧更有洞察力 |
| 134 | which relies on the two ears either side of our brain. | 它依赖于我们大脑的两边 |
| 135 | Afterwards, Ilona reflected | 之后,伊洛娜反应 |
| 136 | that maybe she could enable her neighbor to feel safe, | 也许她可以让她的邻居感到安全, |
| 137 | so they started to trust her and share more of their deeper story. | 所以他们开始信任她 并分享更多更深层的故事 |
| 138 | What Ilona discovered isn't unique to her. | 伊洛娜发现的不是她独有的 |
| 139 | We ran a big global research project with the BBC and the British Council, | 我们和英国广播公司和英国文化委员会 一起经营了一个大型全球研究项目 |
| 140 | recruiting over 1,000 people across 100 countries | 在100个国家招募1 000多人 |
| 141 | to train in deep listening. | 训练深听。 |
| 142 | Something remarkable happened. | 发生了一件了不起的事。 |
| 143 | People didn't just feel safer to express themselves and more connected, | 人们不只是觉得安全 表达自己和更多的联系, |
| 144 | they also started to question their own attitudes. | 他们还开始质疑他们自己的态度。 |
| 145 | And I've seen other research | 我看过其他的研究 |
| 146 | that shows that when people feel truly heard, | 说明当人们真正听到 |
| 147 | they actually soften their beliefs. | 他们实际上软化了自己的信仰。 |
| 148 | Now, that's a powerful incentive for all of us to deeply listen to others. | 现在,这有力地激励了我们大家深刻地倾听他人的声音. |
| 149 | So there's this woman, Hira. | 所以有个女人 希拉 |
| 150 | She's a Lebanese Muslim, | 她是一个黎巴嫩穆斯林, |
| 151 | and she wanted to learn how to listen more deeply. | 她想学习如何更深入地倾听 |
| 152 | Now, Hira's father was determined that she restrict her friendships | 希拉的父亲决定限制她的友谊 |
| 153 | to those with a similar upbringing, | 以同样的教养者发誓, |
| 154 | and she carried those judgments into adulthood, | 她把这些判决带到成年 |
| 155 | telling me that she used to be against Syrian refugees in Lebanon, | 告诉我她曾经反对黎巴嫩的叙利亚难民 |
| 156 | staying clear of them, | 远离他们, |
| 157 | because some allowed their girls to get married at 11 or 13, | 因为有些人允许她们的女儿在11或13岁结婚, |
| 158 | not living a proper Lebanese life, she said. | 她说,黎巴嫩人的生活不合适。 |
| 159 | I got to know Hira while training communities from Lebanon, | 在训练来自黎巴嫩的社区时 我认识了希拉 |
| 160 | and her breakthrough moment came when she understood | 她的突破时刻到了 当她明白 |
| 161 | not just intellectually but emotionally, | 不仅在智力上,在情感上, |
| 162 | that listening someone with different perspectives | 倾听不同观点的人 |
| 163 | is not a surrender or a betrayal of your values. | 不是投降或背叛你的价值观。 |
| 164 | Today, Hira has become sonning of a poster child for deep listening. | 今天,希拉成了一个海报孩子的代言人 来深入倾听。 |
| 165 | Every Tuesday, she now works with teenagers at a school for Syrian refugees. | 每个星期二,她都在一所叙利亚难民学校与青少年合作。 |
| 166 | And by listening in this new way to her students, | 用这种新方式倾听她的学生 |
| 167 | she's come to understand that more than one perspective is possible. | 她开始明白 不止一种观点是可能的 |
| 168 | It felt like a glimpse of light, she told me, | 感觉就像光的一瞥 她告诉我 |
| 169 | though it still takes strength, patience and an open heart. | 虽然这需要力量、耐心和开阔的心 |
| 170 | Hira is aware of the tensions which still exist | 希拉知道仍然存在的紧张局势 |
| 171 | between her ideas and those of others. | 她的想法和别人的想法之间 |
| 172 | She's still passionately against child marriages, | 她仍然热衷于反对童婚 |
| 173 | but she's finding ways to try harder to open and deepen her understanding | 但她正在想办法 更努力地打开和加深她的理解 |
| 174 | whilst keeping true to her values. | 在遵守她价值观的同时 |
| 175 | Now, I have a piece of good news for you. | 现在,我有一个好消息给你。 |
| 176 | You don't need to live in a conflict zone | 你不需要住在冲突区 |
| 177 | to practice deep listening while disagreeing. | 一边深思熟虑一边练习 |
| 178 | So I'd like to offer you a small, slightly risky experiment. | 所以我想给你做个小的,略具风险的实验。 |
| 179 | I'd like you to think of someone you know who sees the world differently, | 我想让你想到一个你认识的人 谁对世界的看法不同, |
| 180 | not the most extreme case, | 不是最极端的情况, |
| 181 | but someone where the disagreement really stings, | 但有一个分歧真的刺痛, |
| 182 | and then take time out to deeply listen to them | 然后花点时间去倾听他们的声音 |
| 183 | with as much curiosity and openness as you can manage. | 尽你所能的好奇和开放 |
| 184 | Notice your discomfort. | 注意你的不适。 |
| 185 | Notice your resistance. | 注意你们的抵抗 |
| 186 | And notice, too, if you have the courage to move past both, | 注意一点 如果你有勇气超越两者 |
| 187 | even if it feels a little awkward. | 即使感觉有点尴尬。 |
| 188 | I've found that over time, these experiences make me feel more alive | 我发现,随着时间的推移, 这些经历让我觉得更活泼 |
| 189 | as I open myself up to profoundly connecting with another person, | 当我打开我自己 与另一个人深刻的联系, |
| 190 | whatever their beliefs, | 无论他们的信仰如何, |
| 191 | and giving them the gift of feeling truly heard. | 并赐予他们真正被听到的感觉 |
| 192 | So deep listening, it's about respect for the other person's dignity | 这么深入的倾听,这是关于尊重他人的尊严 |
| 193 | and the fullness of their humanity, | 以及他们人性的充分性, |
| 194 | whatever they stand for. | 不管他们代表什么 |
| 195 | And now, with the stakes quite so high in our polarized times, | 现在,在我们两极分化的时代, 赌注如此之高, |
| 196 | just think what might be possible | 想想什么是可能的吗? |
| 197 | if we firmly and permanently separate listening from agreement. | 如果我们坚决和永久地分离 倾听与协议。 |
| 198 | Thank you. | 谢谢 |
该视频共有字幕 200 条。解锁更多字幕为会员功能,请移动到 价格
P2 · 【TED】分歧时为何那么难倾听 · 深度聆听的框架 p02 英文字幕 (P2)
字幕摘录
| 时间 | 英文 | 中文 |
|---|---|---|
| 0:04 | You know, there's something quite strange going on, | 你知道,有些事情是相当奇怪的, |
| 0:08 | because most of us believe we should be better listeners. | 因为我们大多数人认为我们应该是更好的听众。 |
| 0:11 | But as I found in my research, we find it so hard, | 但正如我在研究中发现的, 我们发现如此艰难, |
| 0:16 | especially when we disagree. | 尤其是我们不同意的时候 |
| 0:18 | There's a kind of psychological bug that gets in the way. | 有一种心理缺陷会妨碍到他们 |
| 0:22 | We fear that if we listen to people whose ideas we find unpalatable | 我们担心,如果我们听别人的 想法,我们认为不愉快 |
| 0:27 | will be contaminated without realizing it, | 将不知不觉地被污染, |
| 0:31 | and we've bought into a dangerous myth. | 我们被一个危险的神话迷住了 |
| 0:34 | Listening means agreeing. | 倾听意味着同意。 |
| 0:39 | So we avoid it. | 所以我们避开它。 |
展开字幕全文(198 条)
| 序号 | 英文 | 中文 |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | You know, there's something quite strange going on, | 你知道,有些事情是相当奇怪的, |
| 2 | because most of us believe we should be better listeners. | 因为我们大多数人认为我们应该是更好的听众。 |
| 3 | But as I found in my research, we find it so hard, | 但正如我在研究中发现的, 我们发现如此艰难, |
| 4 | especially when we disagree. | 尤其是我们不同意的时候 |
| 5 | There's a kind of psychological bug that gets in the way. | 有一种心理缺陷会妨碍到他们 |
| 6 | We fear that if we listen to people whose ideas we find unpalatable | 我们担心,如果我们听别人的 想法,我们认为不愉快 |
| 7 | will be contaminated without realizing it, | 将不知不觉地被污染, |
| 8 | and we've bought into a dangerous myth. | 我们被一个危险的神话迷住了 |
| 9 | Listening means agreeing. | 倾听意味着同意。 |
| 10 | So we avoid it. | 所以我们避开它。 |
| 11 | And instead, we fixate on trying to explain ourselves | 相反,我们坚持 试图解释自己 |
| 12 | more loudly, more fiercely, more insistently, | 更大声,更凶猛,更坚持, |
| 13 | if only they'd understand. | 如果他们能理解的话 |
| 14 | You know, I should know, | 你知道,我应该知道, |
| 15 | because I threw away a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity | 因为我放弃了一生一次的机会 |
| 16 | to understand one of Africa's most intriguing and powerful leaders, | 了解非洲最有趣和最强大的领导人之一, |
| 17 | because I wasn't ready to listen. | 因为我还没准备好听 |
| 18 | So let me tell you about a time when I was in Ethiopia | 所以,让我告诉你 当我在埃塞俄比亚的时候 |
| 19 | reporting for the BBC at the start of my career. | 我职业生涯开始时为BBC报道. |
| 20 | I'd landed an interview with its president | 我采访了总统 |
| 21 | and later Prime Minister Meles Zunawi. | 后任总理梅莱斯·祖纳维. |
| 22 | I was so proud. | 我很骄傲。 |
| 23 | This was my big scoop. | 这是我的大勺子 |
| 24 | But it was also a time when his opponents were tortured or disappeared. | 但这也是他的对手遭受酷刑或失踪的时期. |
| 25 | So the president, he was keen to talk about his record | 因此,总统,他热衷于谈论他的记录 |
| 26 | crop production of maize, of sorghum and barley, | 生产玉米、高粱和大麦, |
| 27 | critical in a country with a history of famine. | 在一个有饥荒历史的国家里, |
| 28 | But I refused to listen, | 但我拒绝听 |
| 29 | incessantly circling back to human rights. | 不停地盘旋回到人权。 |
| 30 | To be honest, my questions, | 老实说 我的问题 |
| 31 | they were masks for my desire to confront the president. | 那是我对抗总统的口罩 |
| 32 | And what did he do? | 他做了什麽? |
| 33 | He edged further and further away from me, | 他离我越来越远 |
| 34 | behind his vast wooden desk, | 在他巨大的木头桌子后面 |
| 35 | and then cut the interview early. | 然后提前剪掉采访 |
| 36 | You know, it wasn't so much that I was wrong to hold the president to account. | 你知道,这不是太多 我错了让总统负责。 |
| 37 | That was essential. | 这很重要。 |
| 38 | But my lack of curiosity and my inability to listen | 但我缺乏好奇心,无法听 |
| 39 | caused him to put up his defenses, | 他为他辩护, |
| 40 | and so I walked away empty-handed. | 于是我空手离开 |
| 41 | And over the years, I've learned from my mistakes as a journalist | 这些年来,我从我的记者错误中吸取了教训 |
| 42 | and my work as an executive coach, | 我作为执行教练的工作 |
| 43 | and I've drawn on scholars, on psychologists and peace builders, | 我从学者、心理学家和建设和平者那里吸取了教训 |
| 44 | and I've woven these ideas together into a book | 我把这些想法编成一本书 |
| 45 | and an approach I call deep listening. | 以及我称之为深听的方法。 |
| 46 | Because the standard way we so often perform listening, | 因为标准的方式 我们经常进行听, |
| 47 | it starves us of real connections. | 它让我们失去真正的联系 |
| 48 | We struggle to engage with our coworkers, | 我们努力和同事接触 |
| 49 | with our family. | 与我们的家人。 |
| 50 | Just ask my own. | 问问我自己就好 |
| 51 | Anyone from a different background or generation, | 任何来自不同背景或世代的人, |
| 52 | anyone whose ideas conflict with our own. | 他们的思想和我们的思想相冲突 |
| 53 | Now, you see, I think I'm rational, | 现在,你看,我觉得我很理智, |
| 54 | and my sense is that you think you're rational. | 我的感觉是,你觉得自己很理智 |
| 55 | But we're all driven by our judgments, | 但我们都是受判决驱使的 |
| 56 | by our emotions and our past, | 我们的情感和过去 |
| 57 | clinging onto the moral high ground. | 坚持在道德高地上。 |
| 58 | The problem is that from an early age, | 问题是,从小, |
| 59 | we've been brought up to believe that listening means agreement, | 我们长大后相信 倾听意味着同意 |
| 60 | that listening signals obedience. | 倾听信号服从。 |
| 61 | You know, I remember my first teacher yelling at me, | 我记得我第一个老师对我大吼大叫 |
| 62 | listen to me. | 听我说 |
| 63 | And what she meant is, | 而她的意思是, |
| 64 | obey me, keep quiet, put those crayons away. | 听我的 安静点 把蜡笔收起来 |
| 65 | It wasn't really an invitation to listen. | 这不是真的 一个邀请听。 |
| 66 | It was a command to comply. | 这是服从的命令。 |
| 67 | And this muddling up of listening and agreement | 而这种混杂的听和协议 |
| 68 | means that now, as adults, | 意味着现在,作为成年人, |
| 69 | we fear listening to people whose ideas might disturb us. | 我们害怕听别人说话 他们的想法可能会打扰我们 |
| 70 | Will I lose myself? | 我会失去自己吗? |
| 71 | Will I be forced to change my mind? | 我会被迫改变主意吗? |
| 72 | Will I be changed? | 我会被改变吗? |
| 73 | At a primal level, | 在初级层面, |
| 74 | it can feel scary to open ourselves up to ideas | 打开我们自己的想法会感到害怕 |
| 75 | which clash with our values. | 与我们的价值观相冲突 |
| 76 | And the result? | 结果呢? |
| 77 | A world in which we think it's better, | 这个世界,我们认为它是更好的, |
| 78 | even more moral, | 更讲道德 |
| 79 | to sidestep any encounters across divides. | 避免任何跨越分歧的遭遇。 |
| 80 | But in avoiding these exchanges, | 但是为了避免这些交流 |
| 81 | we only help deepen the fault lines of polarization | 我们只会帮助加深两极分化的断层 |
| 82 | that are tearing our families, our communities | 撕裂我们的家庭,我们的社区 |
| 83 | and, of course, our nations apart. | 当然,我们的国家是分开的。 |
| 84 | So let me give you an example. | 让我举个例子。 |
| 85 | Take the Baltic state of Latvia, | 取波罗的海国家拉脱维亚, |
| 86 | which has a traumatic history of decades under Soviet rule. | 在苏联统治下的数十年中, 都有一段痛苦的历史。 |
| 87 | And not long after the Russian full-scale invasion of Ukraine, | 在俄国全面入侵乌克兰后不久 |
| 88 | feelings there were running deep and high. | 感觉很深很高 |
| 89 | Threats of reinvasion were real. | 重新入侵的威胁是真实的。 |
| 90 | And suspicion was falling on the one in three Latvians | 怀疑在拉脱维亚的三分之一的人身上 |
| 91 | who were speaking Russian at home. | 他们在家里说俄语。 |
| 92 | So I was invited to train people from both communities together, | 所以我被邀请一起训练来自两个社区的人 |
| 93 | that's the Latvians and the Russian speakers, | 这是拉脱维亚人和俄语, |
| 94 | so they could practice deep listening to someone from the other side. | 这样他们就能深入地听别人的声音 |
| 95 | But how can you listen when your feelings are so strong | 但是当你的感情如此强烈的时候,你怎么能听呢? |
| 96 | and when there's so much at stake? | 当有这么多的利害关系? |
| 97 | So can I tell you about Ilona? | 我可以告诉你伊洛娜的事吗? |
| 98 | She's a Russian-speaking Latvian, | 她是讲俄语的拉脱维亚人, |
| 99 | and to be honest, at the start, | 老实说,一开始, |
| 100 | when she started using the deep-listening steps, | 当她开始使用 深听步骤, |
| 101 | it felt pretty unnatural. | 感觉很不正常 |
| 102 | It was hard for her to stay curious, | 她很难保持好奇 |
| 103 | and accept she didn't yet know what her neighbor might be thinking. | 承认她还不知道邻居在想什么 |
| 104 | But cautiously, she began putting the eight steps to work, | 但谨慎地说,她开始将这八步推向工作 |
| 105 | taking time out, for example, | 例如,抽出时间, |
| 106 | to listen to herself first | 先听自己的话 |
| 107 | and notice what her neighbor might provoke in her. | 注意她的邻居可能激怒她 |
| 108 | Maybe they reminded her of a bullying older sister, | 也许他们让她想起一个欺负的姐姐 |
| 109 | so she felt eight again, | 所以她又感觉到了8个 |
| 110 | powerless and trapped. | 无力而困. |
| 111 | Or she might notice how judgmental she was feeling. | 或者她可能注意到她的判断力 |
| 112 | That neighbor, she's selfish for sure. | 那个邻居 她很自私 |
| 113 | Or she might realize that she'd projected, like most of us, | 或者,她可能意识到 她的预测, 像我们大多数人一样, |
| 114 | the parts of herself she found hardest to accept, | 她自己最难接受的部分 |
| 115 | onto her neighbor. | 她的邻居。 |
| 116 | Because after all, we see the world not as it is, | 因为毕竟,我们看到的世界 并非如此, |
| 117 | but as we are. | 但就像我们一样 |
| 118 | Slowly, Ilona learned to put her own stuff aside, | 慢慢地,伊洛娜学会了 把她自己的东西放在一边, |
| 119 | so she could be more present with whatever unfolded, | 所以她可以更在场 与任何展开, |
| 120 | whatever her neighbor wanted to share. | 她邻居想分享的 |
| 121 | She didn't manage it every time, mind. | 她不是每次都会处理的 介意吧 |
| 122 | Some conversations still left her tight-jawed and defensive, | 有些对话仍然让她 被紧紧的束缚和防守, |
| 123 | but she began to notice that in the moment. | 但她现在开始注意到了 |
| 124 | And then she experimented with something simple. | 然后她用简单的东西做了实验. |
| 125 | I meant to do that, silence. | 我本想这么做的 沉默 |
| 126 | The warm, empathetic kind, | 温和的,爱心的, |
| 127 | to allow her neighbor to reflect more | 让她的邻居更能反省 |
| 128 | and give Ilona a chance to make more sense of their perspective. | 并给伊洛娜一个机会 让他们的观点更有意义。 |
| 129 | Ilona found out that she could tap into something | 伊洛娜发现她可以挖掘一些东西 |
| 130 | called your third ear, | 呼唤你的第三只耳朵, |
| 131 | which is about tuning into what's important but unspoken. | 这是关于调和什么是重要 但没有说。 |
| 132 | And I like to think the third ear is located just next to our heart. | 我想第三只耳朵就在我们心脏旁边 |
| 133 | And our third ear can be more insightful than our conscious intelligence, | 我们的第三只耳朵 比我们有意识的智慧更有洞察力 |
| 134 | which relies on the two ears either side of our brain. | 它依赖于我们大脑的两边 |
| 135 | Afterwards, Ilona reflected | 之后,伊洛娜反应 |
| 136 | that maybe she could enable her neighbor to feel safe, | 也许她可以让她的邻居感到安全, |
| 137 | so they started to trust her and share more of their deeper story. | 所以他们开始信任她 并分享更多更深层的故事 |
| 138 | What Ilona discovered isn't unique to her. | 伊洛娜发现的不是她独有的 |
| 139 | We ran a big global research project with the BBC and the British Council, | 我们和英国广播公司和英国文化委员会 一起经营了一个大型全球研究项目 |
| 140 | recruiting over 1,000 people across 100 countries | 在100个国家招募1 000多人 |
| 141 | to train in deep listening. | 训练深听。 |
| 142 | Something remarkable happened. | 发生了一件了不起的事。 |
| 143 | People didn't just feel safer to express themselves and more connected, | 人们不只是觉得安全 表达自己和更多的联系, |
| 144 | they also started to question their own attitudes. | 他们还开始质疑他们自己的态度。 |
| 145 | And I've seen other research | 我看过其他的研究 |
| 146 | that shows that when people feel truly heard, | 说明当人们真正听到 |
| 147 | they actually soften their beliefs. | 他们实际上软化了自己的信仰。 |
| 148 | Now, that's a powerful incentive for all of us to deeply listen to others. | 现在,这有力地激励了我们大家深刻地倾听他人的声音. |
| 149 | So there's this woman, Hira. | 所以有个女人 希拉 |
| 150 | She's a Lebanese Muslim, | 她是一个黎巴嫩穆斯林, |
| 151 | and she wanted to learn how to listen more deeply. | 她想学习如何更深入地倾听 |
| 152 | Now, Hira's father was determined that she restrict her friendships | 希拉的父亲决定限制她的友谊 |
| 153 | to those with a similar upbringing, | 以同样的教养者发誓, |
| 154 | and she carried those judgments into adulthood, | 她把这些判决带到成年 |
| 155 | telling me that she used to be against Syrian refugees in Lebanon, | 告诉我她曾经反对黎巴嫩的叙利亚难民 |
| 156 | staying clear of them, | 远离他们, |
| 157 | because some allowed their girls to get married at 11 or 13, | 因为有些人允许她们的女儿在11或13岁结婚, |
| 158 | not living a proper Lebanese life, she said. | 她说,黎巴嫩人的生活不合适。 |
| 159 | I got to know Hira while training communities from Lebanon, | 在训练来自黎巴嫩的社区时 我认识了希拉 |
| 160 | and her breakthrough moment came when she understood | 她的突破时刻到了 当她明白 |
| 161 | not just intellectually but emotionally, | 不仅在智力上,在情感上, |
| 162 | that listening someone with different perspectives | 倾听不同观点的人 |
| 163 | is not a surrender or a betrayal of your values. | 不是投降或背叛你的价值观。 |
| 164 | Today, Hira has become sonning of a poster child for deep listening. | 今天,希拉成了一个海报孩子的代言人 来深入倾听。 |
| 165 | Every Tuesday, she now works with teenagers at a school for Syrian refugees. | 每个星期二,她都在一所叙利亚难民学校与青少年合作。 |
| 166 | And by listening in this new way to her students, | 用这种新方式倾听她的学生 |
| 167 | she's come to understand that more than one perspective is possible. | 她开始明白 不止一种观点是可能的 |
| 168 | It felt like a glimpse of light, she told me, | 感觉就像光的一瞥 她告诉我 |
| 169 | though it still takes strength, patience and an open heart. | 虽然这需要力量、耐心和开阔的心 |
| 170 | Hira is aware of the tensions which still exist | 希拉知道仍然存在的紧张局势 |
| 171 | between her ideas and those of others. | 她的想法和别人的想法之间 |
| 172 | She's still passionately against child marriages, | 她仍然热衷于反对童婚 |
| 173 | but she's finding ways to try harder to open and deepen her understanding | 但她正在想办法 更努力地打开和加深她的理解 |
| 174 | whilst keeping true to her values. | 在遵守她价值观的同时 |
| 175 | Now, I have a piece of good news for you. | 现在,我有一个好消息给你。 |
| 176 | You don't need to live in a conflict zone | 你不需要住在冲突区 |
| 177 | to practice deep listening while disagreeing. | 一边深思熟虑一边练习 |
| 178 | So I'd like to offer you a small, slightly risky experiment. | 所以我想给你做个小的,略具风险的实验。 |
| 179 | I'd like you to think of someone you know who sees the world differently, | 我想让你想到一个你认识的人 谁对世界的看法不同, |
| 180 | not the most extreme case, | 不是最极端的情况, |
| 181 | but someone where the disagreement really stings, | 但有一个分歧真的刺痛, |
| 182 | and then take time out to deeply listen to them | 然后花点时间去倾听他们的声音 |
| 183 | with as much curiosity and openness as you can manage. | 尽你所能的好奇和开放 |
| 184 | Notice your discomfort. | 注意你的不适。 |
| 185 | Notice your resistance. | 注意你们的抵抗 |
| 186 | And notice, too, if you have the courage to move past both, | 注意一点 如果你有勇气超越两者 |
| 187 | even if it feels a little awkward. | 即使感觉有点尴尬。 |
| 188 | I've found that over time, these experiences make me feel more alive | 我发现,随着时间的推移, 这些经历让我觉得更活泼 |
| 189 | as I open myself up to profoundly connecting with another person, | 当我打开我自己 与另一个人深刻的联系, |
| 190 | whatever their beliefs, | 无论他们的信仰如何, |
| 191 | and giving them the gift of feeling truly heard. | 并赐予他们真正被听到的感觉 |
| 192 | So deep listening, it's about respect for the other person's dignity | 这么深入的倾听,这是关于尊重他人的尊严 |
| 193 | and the fullness of their humanity, | 以及他们人性的充分性, |
| 194 | whatever they stand for. | 不管他们代表什么 |
| 195 | And now, with the stakes quite so high in our polarized times, | 现在,在我们两极分化的时代, 赌注如此之高, |
| 196 | just think what might be possible | 想想什么是可能的吗? |
| 197 | if we firmly and permanently separate listening from agreement. | 如果我们坚决和永久地分离 倾听与协议。 |
| 198 | Thank you. | 谢谢 |
该视频共有字幕 200 条。解锁更多字幕为会员功能,请移动到 价格
