推荐微信扫码登录以获得更好的体验!另:🎉建议更新到最新版,以体验新功能!🎉 版本更新记录→

“从那里看世界”系列对话首讲 | 从达喀尔看世界:谁来养活未

字幕摘录

时间英文中文
0:05Good morning and good evening to everyone dialing in from all over the world, I understand.早上好,晚上好,大家从世界各地打来,我理解
0:18Welcome to this first talk of the Yale-McMillan Center and Yale Center Making series on international欢迎收看耶鲁-麦克米兰中心 和耶鲁中心制作国际系列节目
0:30and area studies.和地区研究。
0:32Just a bit of an introduction for those of you who might be unfamiliar to the McMillan给那些对麦克米兰不熟悉的人介绍一下
0:39Center Yale and the Yale Center Beijing.耶鲁中心与耶鲁中心北京.
0:42The McMillan Center is really one of the world's foremost hub for scholarship on international麦克米兰中心是世界上 最大的国际奖学金中心之一
0:52and area studies.和地区研究。
0:54And we're just delighted that we have Jackson School master's candidate Zhijun He leading我们很高兴有杰克逊的老师候选人志军 他领导
1:07this effort and collaboration with my wonderful colleagues at the Yale Center Beijing team这一努力和与我在耶鲁中心北京小组的出色同事的合作
1:14to bring to our audiences from around the world and especially here in Asia voices from将来自世界各地的观众, 特别是来自亚洲的观众
展开字幕全文(885 条)
序号英文中文
1Good morning and good evening to everyone dialing in from all over the world, I understand.早上好,晚上好,大家从世界各地打来,我理解
2Welcome to this first talk of the Yale-McMillan Center and Yale Center Making series on international欢迎收看耶鲁-麦克米兰中心 和耶鲁中心制作国际系列节目
3and area studies.和地区研究。
4Just a bit of an introduction for those of you who might be unfamiliar to the McMillan给那些对麦克米兰不熟悉的人介绍一下
5Center Yale and the Yale Center Beijing.耶鲁中心与耶鲁中心北京.
6The McMillan Center is really one of the world's foremost hub for scholarship on international麦克米兰中心是世界上 最大的国际奖学金中心之一
7and area studies.和地区研究。
8And we're just delighted that we have Jackson School master's candidate Zhijun He leading我们很高兴有杰克逊的老师候选人志军 他领导
9this effort and collaboration with my wonderful colleagues at the Yale Center Beijing team这一努力和与我在耶鲁中心北京小组的出色同事的合作
10to bring to our audiences from around the world and especially here in Asia voices from将来自世界各地的观众, 特别是来自亚洲的观众
11the most interesting, fascinating and cutting-edge places in the world.世界上最有趣、最迷人和最尖端的地方
12I know Zhijun will do a much better introduction for our distinguished speaker today, but you're我知道志军今天会对我们的演讲人 做一个更好的介绍 但你是
13in for sure with our first talk in this series with Anta who is a Yale World Fellow, a politician,我们第一次和安塔谈这个系列 他是一个耶鲁大学世界研究员 政治家
14an amazing woman entrepreneur who had a KFC in her home country, San Diego, and many more.一个惊人的女性企业家,在她的祖国圣地亚哥有一个KFC, 以及更多的。
15And Zhijun himself is a very accomplished scholar and intellectual entrepreneur who志军本人是一个非常有成就的学者和知识企业家
16is studying African studies at Yale, at Yale's Jackson School of Global Affairs, and of course在耶鲁大学、耶鲁的杰克逊全球事务学院学习非洲研究,当然
17doing a lot more, including leading this series in his spare time.做更多的事情, 包括领导这系列 在他的业余时间。
18So without further ado, I'll hand this over to Zhijun.所以,没有进一步的ado,我会把这个交给志军.
19Thank you, Zhijun and Anta, and the Yale Center Beijing team.谢志军与安塔,耶鲁中心北京队.
20Thank you so much, Carol, and that's a hard bar to meet.非常感谢,卡罗尔, 这是一个艰难的酒吧见面。
21So let me begin with the introduction to the series, The Wheel From.因此,让我从系列的介绍开始,《轮子从》。
22It is a series about seeing the world from places we rarely see it from, and today we这是一个关于从我们很少看到的地方看到世界的系列,今天我们
23begin with Dakar.从达喀尔开始。
24So let me first introduce our guest, our distinguished guest, is the Honorable Anta Babacar Ngomdiak.因此,首先让我介绍我们的客人,尊敬的客人是尊敬的安塔·巴巴卡尔·恩贡迪亚克。
25So she grew up inside one of the Senegal's largest poetry producers and helped build所以她成长在塞内加尔最大的诗歌创作者之一 并帮助建立
26an industry that now feeds the country.现在养家糊口
27So she leads the KFC Senegal, where she opened a restaurant run entirely by women and another在那里她开了一家完全由女性经营的餐厅 还有一家
28designed to employ people with disabilities.旨在雇用残疾人。
29Today she serves in Senegal's National Assembly on its Finance Commission, and this year今天她在塞内加尔国民议会财政委员会任职,今年
30she is with us at Yale as a world fellow.她和我们一起在耶鲁,作为一个世界的家伙。
31She had seen her country from the factory floor, from the restaurant counter, and from她从工厂的地板上、餐厅柜台上和从
32the floor of poliarmid.波利米德的地板。
33I can't think of a better person to show us the view from Dakar.我想不出一个更好的人 能给我们展示达喀尔的风景
34Anta, welcome.安塔 欢迎
35Thank you, Carol.谢谢你,卡罗尔。
36Good morning to all, or good evening to some of you all, and thank you for having me.大家早上好,或者说大家晚上好,谢谢你们邀请我
37So let's begin with the question.故先问.
38So nowadays in China, the Western fast food chain is basically everywhere.所以如今在中国,西方的快餐连锁店基本上到处都是。
39In Senegal, the first restaurant of one of the best-known fried chicken chains opened在塞内加尔,一家最有名的炸鸡连锁店第一家开业。
40in Dakar only in 2019, and every piece of chicken it serves was raised in Senegal.2019年才在达喀尔,其服务的所有鸡肉都在塞内加尔饲养.
41So behind it is a 20-year story about how a country decided to feed itself, and our幕后有一个20年的故事 讲述一个国家如何决定养活自己 以及我们
42guest has lived it from the inside.宾客从里面活了下来
43So in 2025, Senegal closed its border to import poultry.因此在2025年,塞内加尔关闭边境进口家禽.
44Two decades later, the chicken Senegalese families eat is raised at home, and the industry20年后,塞内加尔家庭的鸡肉在家中饲养。
45employs tens of thousands of people.雇用了数万人。
46So you have watched this from inside one of the country's largest producers.所以,你从国内观看了 这个国家最大的生产商之一。
47So what did that decision make possible, and what has it cost, whether in prices for families因此,这个决定带来了什么, 它的成本,是否家庭价格
48or in dependence on imported feed?还是依赖进口饲料?
49If you were writing the policy today, under the African Continental Freight Trade Area,如果你今天在非洲大陆货运贸易区下写政策
50what would you keep, and what would you change?你会保留什么, 你会改变什么?
51Thank you.谢谢
52Thank you, Jason.谢谢 杰森
53So in 2003, before the ban, imported chicken sold in Dakar at about $2.50 per kilogram.因此,在2003年禁令之前,进口鸡在达喀尔以每公斤2.50美元的价格销售。
54I'm hearing myself, so maybe you can mute Jason.我听到自己的话了 也许你可以让杰森闭嘴
55Okay, thank you.好的 谢谢
56So I was saying before the ban, we were selling chicken at Senegalese.所以我在禁令之前说 我们在塞内加尔卖鸡肉
57People were eating chicken that was sold at $2.50 per kilogram.人们吃鸡肉,每公斤卖2.5美元。
58At that same time, the local chicken was actually being sold at $3.50.同时,当地鸡肉实际售价为3.50元.
59So our own farmers were a third more expensive than a frozen bird that had crossed the ocean因此,我们的农民 比冰冻的鸟过海要贵三分之一
60because of the importation.因为进口。
61So the border closed in 2006.因此2006年边境关闭.
62And for three years, actually, almost nothing happened in the country.实际上,三年来,这个国家几乎什么都没有发生。
63So the gap there is interesting part between 2006 and 2009.因此,2006年和2009年之间的差距是有趣的。
64The problem was never that the Senegalese farmers couldn't raise chicken.问题绝不是塞内加尔农民不能养鸡。
65The problem was upstream.问题在于上游。
66So before the bird, you need the old chick, you need feed, you need hatcheries,因此,在鸟,你需要老小鸡, 你需要饲料, 你需要孵化器,
67you need slaughterhouse, et cetera.你需要屠宰场等等
68And neither of those appears just because the minister or the president actually signed没有一个只是因为部长或总统签了字
69a decree to close the border.命令关闭边境
70So as you said, my father founded Sedima in 1976, so 30 years before that border closed.正如你说的,我父亲在1976年建立了塞迪玛, 所以30年前边界关闭。
71So hatcheries, feed mill, production farms, et cetera.因此孵化厂,饲料厂,生产场等等.
72And that's what we do.这就是我们要做的。
73So when the ban came, the upstream actually existed in Senegal.所以当禁令到来时,上游实际上存在于塞内加尔.
74It was not at the scale the whole country suddenly needed, but you can't multiply a它没有达到全国突然需要的规模, 但你不能乘以一个
75breeding flock overnight.一夜之间繁殖羊群
76So that's actually what made it possible for us.因此,这实际上使我们成为可能。
77Not the decree, not the ban.不是法令,也不是禁令。
78The decree plus 30 years of somebody or some people already building the unglamorous half.法令加上30年的个人或一些人 已经建造了不光彩的那半。
79Then it moved.然后它移动。
80So by 2019, Senegal was producing 114,000 tons.至2019年,塞内加尔的产量为11.4万吨.
81So four times its 2005 output.所以是2005年产出的四倍。
82And the sector then was carrying 60,000 jobs.然后这个部门就承担了6万份工作。
83So Sedima went from $55 million of turnover when I took over as CEO in 2016, and to $100因此塞迪玛从2016年我接任CEO时的5500万美元营业额,到100美元.
84million in 2023, and now $125 million today.2023年是百万,现在是1.25亿美元。
85So two costs, and I'll give you both today.所以,两个成本, 我今天会给你们两个。
86So the first is at the table.故第一义在座.
87So Senegalese ate three and a half kilograms of chicken per person in 2010.因此,塞内加尔在2010年每人吃了3公斤半的鸡肉.
88And it got to seven kilograms by 2019.到2019年时,它达到7公斤.
89So the West African average is nearly 15 kilograms per habitant.因此,西非平均每名居民将近15公斤。
90So we still eat less than half of what our neighbors ate.所以我们还是吃不到邻居吃的一半
91And local chicken went from three and a half dollars a kilogram to about five and a half.当地的鸡肉从每公斤三块半到五块半
92So it's actually more expensive.所以实际上它更昂贵。
93Some of that is inflation, but nobody in Dakar experienced it, of course, as inflation.其中一些是通货膨胀,但达喀尔没有人像通货膨胀一样经历通货膨胀。
94We gained an industry and we paid for it at the table.我们得到了一个行业,我们在桌子上支付。
95I think the trade was worth it.我觉得这交易值得
96It was worth making, but it was a trade.这是值得的,但它是一个交易。
97And anyone who tells you otherwise is actually just selling something.任何告诉你别的事的人 其实都是卖东西的
98The second cost is the feed.第二费是供养.
99And because we mill the feed, but feed is maize and soya mostly for chicken.因为我们加工饲料, 但饲料是玉米和大豆,主要用于鸡肉。
100And Senegal grows almost no soya.塞内加尔几乎没有大豆。
101So the raw material arrives today by boat.所以原料今天乘船抵达.
102We closed the border to chicken and we opened it to grain.我们关闭了边境 鸡,我们打开它 谷物。
103So the dependency did not fully disappear.因此,依赖并没有完全消失。
104It moved on up one step upstream.它向上游移动了一步。
105So into our own feed mills.所以进入我们自己的饲料厂。
106What would I keep then?那我还留着什么?
107The principle that you protect where the upstream already exists.你保护上游地区的原则
108Protection behind an empty hatchery produces shortages or smuggling, et cetera, not an industry.空舱后的保护会造成短缺或走私,等等,不是一个行业。
109So that rule has held for 20 years and I probably wouldn't touch that.所以这个规则已经维持了20年 而我可能不会碰它。
110But I wouldn't then change the ambition.但我不会改变野心
111The problem is the plumbing.问题在于管道
112People assume because we import maize that we can't grow it.人们假设,因为我们进口的玉米不能种植。
113Yes, we can.是的,我们可以。
114Senegal actually grew half a million tons of maize last season.塞内加尔在上个季节实际种植了50万吨玉米。
115But also imported about the same amount of grain.但也进口了大约相同数量的谷物.
116So the problem isn't the field.所以问题不在于领域
117It's actually the calendar.其实是历法.
118Our maize is rain fed.我们的玉米是雨水。
119So the harvest moves.故收而动.
120It fell by 13% in a single season.单季降13%.
121So a feed mill can't run on that.因此,一个饲料厂不能运行在这个。
122It needs tonnage.它需要吨位。
123It is a date, a price.这是一个日期,一个价格。
124So we import not because the maize doesn't exist,我们进口不是因为玉米不存在
125but because the reliability does not.但因为可靠性不是。
126So that's a fixable problem.所以这是一个可以解决的问题。
127And it's where I would actually put the money right now.而这正是我真正会 把钱现在。
128Thank you, Anta.谢谢你,安塔
129So what I'm hearing is this.我听到的是这个
130The ban worked only because the upstream already existed.禁令之所以有效,只是因为上游已经存在。
131It caused Senegal at a table and dependency moved one step upstream into feed.它使塞内加尔坐到桌子上,依赖性向上游移动了一步。
132So keep the rule.故守规.
133Protect only where the upstream exists.只在上游存在的地方保护。
134Fix the plumbing, not the ambition.修管道,而不是野心.
135So we gained an industry and we paid for it at the table.于是我们得到了一个行业,我们在餐桌上付出了代价。
136So you mentioned that industry now carries like 60,000 jobs,所以,你提到, 工业现在有 6万份工作,
137which brings me to the people holding them.这让我来到了持有它们的人。
138So more than half of the Senegal's population is young塞内加尔一半以上的人口是年轻人
139and in many ways a job at home against the journey abroad.在很多方面 在国内找份反对出国旅行的工作
140So at KFC Senegal, you opened a restaurant run entirely by women.在塞内加尔KFC,你开了一家完全由女性经营的餐厅。
141And another designed to employ people with disabilities.另一个旨在雇用残疾人。
142So what did those decisions teach you about what makes a job worth staying for?那这些决定教了你什么 是什么使工作值得留下来?
143And where does a company's responsibility end?公司的责任在哪里结束?
144And where the responsibility of the state begins?国家的责任从何处开始?
145Thank you.谢谢
146Okay.摆
147So today we opened eight restaurants so far.因此,今天,我们开放了8家餐厅。
148And by the end of this year, we'll be at 12.且到今年底,十二点.
149And as you clearly mentioned, the first one for principal reasons,正如你明确提到的, 第一个原因,
150and I just really wanted to make a point,我只是想说一点
151I made it 100% female restaurants to just make sure that other companies我做了百分之百的女餐厅 以确保其他公司
152realized that we needed to actually give more positions to women.我们意识到,我们需要给妇女更多的职位。
153And the same statement was when I opened the one for,同样的声明是 当我打开一个,
154that's employing more than 40% of people living with disability,雇用40%以上的残疾人
155to also set an example to other companies to actually allow those people也为其他公司树立榜样,让这些人能够
156that have this ability to have access to a job.拥有这种工作能力。
157To come back to your question,回到你的问题
158so our lowest wage in KFC Senegal is about $270 a month.因此,我们在塞内加尔的最低工资约为每月270美元。
159And the legal minimal Senegal is about 140.塞内加尔的法定最低数量约为140人。
160So we pay nearly double the floor and I still lose some people.所以,我们付了近一倍的地板 我仍然失去一些人。
161So when somebody leaves me, they go through one of three doors.所以,当有人离开我, 他们穿过一个三扇门。
162Only one of them is about the country.其中只有一个是关于国家的.
163So the first door is another company in Dakar or in Senegal,所以第一个门是达喀尔或塞内加尔的另一家公司,
164and that's the most common one.这是最常见的一个。
165And in a sense, I think it's my fault.从某种意义上说,我觉得这是我的错。
166Because very few employers in Senegal train at an international standard.因为塞内加尔很少雇主按照国际标准进行训练。
167We do at KFC Senegal.我们在塞内加尔KFC做。
168A manager of mine has run a P&L, handed cash, a team, and a back Saturday night.我的一个经理管理着一个P&L, 交了现金,一个团队,以及一个周六晚上。
169So a bank reads that.银行也读了
170A telecom company reads that.一个电信公司读到的。
171So I have become, without ever deciding it,所以,我变成了, 从来没有决定它,
172one of my country's training institutions.我国的训练机构之一。
173And training institutions lose their graduates, as we all know.我们都知道,培训机构失去了毕业生。
174So that's what a graduation is.这就是毕业是什么。
175The second door is the one foreigners never count, actually.第二扇门是外国人从不计数的
176They leave to work for themselves.他们离开是为了自己
177Most work in Senegal is informal,塞内加尔的大多数工作是非正式的,
178and self-employment carries real status, actually.实际上,自营职业具有真正的地位。
179A shop, a trading business, a few taxes, etc.设有店铺,商铺,几税等.
180To be more, to be what they call my own boss.成为更多的人,成为他们所谓的我的老板。
181That's what they actually want, most of them.这就是他们真正想要的, 大多数。
182It's not a fallback in my country.这不是我国的倒退。
183It's an ambition.谓有志.
184So I'm not competing against another salary.所以我不会和别的薪水竞争
185Then I'm competing against independence of someone,然后我就和别人的独立竞争
186which I totally understand.我完全理解这一点。
187And the third door,还有第三扇门
188and I think that's the one you're talking about, Gisele, is abroad.吉塞勒,我想你说的是国外
189And mostly, not the way this audience may probably imagine.基本上,不是观众可能想象的那样。
190So a good majority do leave legally所以多数人合法离开
191to more than 45 countries around the world.给全世界45个以上的国家。
192There is a desperate end to it.它有一个绝望的结局。
193People who pay a smuggler, actually,那些付钱给走私者的人,其实,
194for a price on an open fishing boat to the Canary Islands.开往加那利群岛的渔船上的价格
195And none of them actually arrive.而且他们都没有真正到达。
196As we speak today in Senegal,就在我们今天在塞内加尔发言时,
197the news is two days ago we just lost 39 young people新闻是两天前 我们刚刚失去了39个年轻人
198who tried through illegal immigration试图通过非法移民的人
199to get to the Canary Islands.前往加那利群岛
200But that's the tale, actually.其实这就是故事
201The center is a visa, a plane, and a family that planned it.中心是签证,飞机,以及计划它的家庭.
202Because last year, the diaspora actually sent home因为去年,散居国外的人真的送回家
203close to 12% of our GDP.接近我国国内生产总值的12%。
204More than eight, all the aid the Senegal receives.8个以上,塞内加尔得到的所有援助。
205More than foreign investment.超过外商投资.
206So no family in Senegal loses a son to Europe.因此,塞内加尔没有家庭会失去一个儿子到欧洲。
207A family places, actually, one there.一个家庭的地方,实际上,一个在那里。
208And what comes back is not consolation.而归来非慰劳.
209It's what they call the return.所谓回向者.
210So three different doors.故三门不同.
211And I can't win at any of them on wage.我拿不到工资
212A competitor matches my wage by Friday.一个竞争者在周五之前跟我的薪水相当
213A trading business beats in a good month.交易生意在好的月份里会打赢
214Italy or China or the US beats it by a factor.意大利或中国或美国比它高出一个因素。
215I will never close.我永远不会关闭。
216So my answer to the three doors out所以我对三扇门的回答
217has been to build more doors in.一直在建造更多的门。
218People hear KFC and they picture a counter.人们听到KFC和 他们想象一个柜台。
219So eight restaurants, as I said, 12 by this year,如我所说,今年有八家餐馆 12家
220about a thousand people, employees now.大约一千人,现在的员工。
221But the counter is a fraction to it.但柜台是它的一小部分。
222There is a supply chain, the cold chain,有一个供应链,冷链,
223there is delivery, there is maintenance,有送货,有赡养费,
224there is refrigeration.有冷藏设备
225There is equality and food safety,有平等和食品安全,
226which in our business is a profession, not a checkbox.我们的生意是职业 不是收银机
227There is procurement training, marketing, finance,有采购培训、营销、金融、
228and every new restaurant is built, fitted,每间新餐厅都是新建的,
229and supplied by people who are there和由那里的人提供
230because we are actually opening it.因为我们实际上正在打开它。
231So it happens in my country,所以,它发生在我国,
232but I think it's a nation's job and responsibility,但我认为这是国家的工作和责任,
233a country's job and responsibility国家的工作和责任
234to make sure that we do not lose our young people to the ocean.确保我们不会把我们的年轻人丢在海里。
235Most of them leave Senegal in the research for more hope他们大多离开塞内加尔从事研究工作,以求获得更多的希望。
236because the grass is always greener on the other side因为另一边的草总是绿的
237until they make it.直到他们成功为止
238It's a sad truth that we have to live with.须得生灭此悲 truth真言.
239Every year we lose 100,000 young Senegalese people.我们每年损失10万塞内加尔青年。
240Senegal is a very, very young people塞内加尔是一个非常非常年轻的国家
241and most of them don't even make it to that country.大部分人甚至都到不了那个国家
242But before taking that boat,但是在开那艘船之前
243they're aware that they could actually lose their lives,他们意识到他们可能真的失去生命,
244but they still go ahead and do it.但他们还是继续做
245So people like me who are in business所以像我这样的人在生意上
246or who are in politics or who are in the parliament,或参政或参议会者,
247our first responsibility is how to make sure我们的首要责任就是确保
248that we can keep the youth, keep our young people,我们可以保持青年, 保持我们的青年,
249this new generation in the country这个国家的新一代人
250and that's the best way we're going to develop Senegal.这是我们发展塞内加尔的最佳方式。
251Yeah, thank you, Anta, for telling us about the story.是的,谢谢你,安塔, 告诉我们的故事。
252This is a very happy truth这是一个非常快乐的事实
253and thank you for saying it plainly.并感谢你的直言不讳。
254So before that, you mentioned there are three doors out所以在那之前 你提到有三个门
255and your answer as a company has been built more doors in.你作为一个公司的答案 已经建了更多的门。
256Behind every counter, a cold chain, maintenance,每个柜台后面,一个冷链,维护,
257procurement and food safety,采购和食品安全,
258which you called a profession, not a checkbox.你称之为职业,而不是复选框。
259So the first door is other employers所以第一个门是其他雇主
260because the KFC Senegal has become one of因为KFC 塞内加尔已经成为
261your country's training institutions贵国的培训机构
262and the second door actually caught my ear而第二扇门实际上 抓住了我的耳朵
263because once upon a time,因为从前,
264I lead the informal sector economy portfolio我领导着非正规部门的经济组合
265for the World Bank's social protection世界银行的社会保护
266and jobs global practice and their youth advisory group全球实践及其青年咨询小组
267and that debate often trades informality辩论往往涉及非正式
268as a failure to be fixed.作为无法修复。
269However, you told us it's not a fallback, it's an ambition但是,你告诉我们这不是一个倒退,这是一个野心
270and the third abroad has a really desperate edge.第三个国外的边缘非常险恶
271The 39 young people in Senegal lost just two days ago.仅仅两天前,塞内加尔的39名青年丧生。
272I ourselves are with their families.我和他们的家人在一起
273So, and also you draw the line clearly.所以,还有你画的清晰。
274The company could build doors,公司可以盖门
275but keeping young people from the ocean is the nation's job.但让年轻人远离海洋是国家的职责
276So you have crossed the line yourself所以,你已经越过了界限自己
277onto the finance commission of the national assembly.国民议会财政委员会。
278So when the national budget arrives on your desk,所以,当国家预算到达你的办公桌,
279what do you look first?你第一个看什么?
280And what did business teach you about public money?生意上教你什么 关于公款的事?
281Paulierment跟你说了什么?
282That business never could.这生意绝对不可能
283Thank you.谢谢
284Thank you, Jisun.谢继善.
285What I look first when I see the budget,当我看到预算时,我先看的是什么?
286it's definitely not the total.绝对不是总和
287It's not the bottom line, not even the deficit.这不是底线,甚至赤字。
288I look at the financing requirement.我研究了融资要求。
289The bill that's in front of my committee right now as we speak现在摆在我委员会面前的法案
290proposes spending about 13 billion dollars提议花费约130亿美元
291and revenue of about 10.7 billion dollars.收入约107亿美元。
292The headline deficit is 4.7% of GDP, which sounds manageable.头条赤字占国内生产总值的4.7%,这听起来可以控制。
293I know, but the amount the state has to raise next year,我知道 但明年国家要筹集多少
294new borrowing plus the debt, it must roll over.新借款加债务,必须翻转。
295It's about 11.8 billion dollars, more than it actually collects.大约118亿美元,比实际收集的还要多.
296That's the first thing a business person sees.这是商人首先看到的
297And it's the first thing business teaches you about our public money.这是第一件事 生意教你 关于我们的公款。
298A company doesn't die of losses, it dies of cash.公司不会因亏损而死,而是因现金而死.
299The deficit line is the profit and loss.赤字是损益。
300The financing requirement is the bank account.融资要求是银行账户。
301The document invites you to read the first one first.文件请您先阅读第一个。
302Then I look for one particular line and I look at it twice, actually,然后我找一条特别的线,我看它两次,实际上,
303what agriculture was given.农业得到了什么。
304That's my personal interest.这是我的个人兴趣。
305And what agriculture already received by the end of the year.还有年底农业已经得到的
306Those are almost never the same number.这些数字几乎不一样。
307The first one is always just in the speech第一个总是在演讲中
308and the second one is in the villages.第二个在村里
309I need a budget that way because for 14 years我需要这样的预算 因为14年了
310I was on the receiving end of those lines, not the writing end.我在那些台词的接收端,而不是写作端。
311Most people in that chamber, in parliament, read a budget from the total down.议会的多数人从总数上看预算。
312I read it from the villages up.我从村里读来的
313Two things.两件事
314First, money has a speed.首先,钱有快。
315If you approve something in March and it arrives to the people in November,如果你在3月批准的东西,11月它到达人民,
316you've actually lost a full year.你输了整整一年
317And in public finance, people treat that slowness as weather.在公共财政中,人们将这种缓慢视为天气。
318It's not weather, it's a decision somebody actually made,这不是天气,这是一个决定 某人实际上做了,
319usually by just not making a decision.通常不做决定
320Second, is that every number should have a name attached to it.其次,是每个数字都应该有一个名字附着在其中.
321In a company, it always does.在公司里,总是这样
322In the national budget, a great many numbers have actually no name attached to it at all.在国家预算中,许多预算实际上根本没有任何名字。
323So I can answer your question, Yi Jun, with this week.这样我就能用这个礼拜来回答你的问题了
324Actually, what's happening as we speak.事实上,我们说话时发生了什么
325Three days ago, so the finance committee that I sit in declined.三天前,所以我所在的财务委员会 拒绝了。
326Sorry?你说什么?
327Yeah, three years, three days ago, the committee, the finance committee是啊,三年,三天前,委员会,财务委员会
328declined to approve the revenue and debt section of next year's budget.拒绝批准明年预算中的收入和债务部分。
329One of the things it asked for was the Settlement Act for last year.它要求的一件事是去年的《解决法》。
330That's one of the reasons.这是其中的原因之一。
331A document that says what was actually spent as against to what was voted.一份对投票结果表示实际花费的文件。
332So I want you to notice how ordinary that request is and how unusual it actually is.所以,我要你注意到,这个请求是多么的普通, 以及它是多么的不寻常。
333So no board I've ever sat on in business所以,没有董事会 我从来没有坐过 在商业
334would approve next year's budget without last year's accounts.明年的预算不用去年的帐户就可以批准
335So the question is so obvious that in business, nobody bothers to ask you that.所以问题很明显,在生意上,没人会问你这个问题。
336But in public finance, it hasn't always been so it has not been asked.但是在公共财政中,它并不总是如此,所以它没有被问到.
337So here is what parliament taught me.这就是议会教我的。
338The budget is a plan and the plan is a speech.预算是计划,计划是演讲.
339The account is where a state becomes visible.账户是状态可见的地方。
340Everyone fights over the plan.大家都在为计划而战
341The plan is about the future and the future is free.计划事关未来,未来自由.
342Very few people fight over the account.很少有人为这个账户而战
343And the second thing, which was actually harder.第二件事,其实更难。
344In business, I decided and I made the decision and if I was wrong, it was mine.在生意上,我决定了,我做了决定 如果我错了,那是我的。
345In parliament, I'm actually accountable for money I don't spend and can't follow in real time.在议会中,我实际上要对不花的钱负责,不能实时跟随.
346With thin investigative means and a calendar that's actually not mine.用薄的调查手段 和一个实际上不是我的日历
347So that responsibility without control and it is quite uncomfortable.因此,这种责任没有控制,而且非常不舒服。
348What I had to learn is that the instrument I hold is not the power to decide.我必须学习的是,我持有的工具不是决定权。
349It's actually the power to decline to proceed.它实际上是拒绝继续的力量.
350That's the real instrument.这是真正的乐器。
351And a country gets better at public money.一个国家在公共资金方面会更好
352Not when the plans improve, but when the accounts actually arrive on time.不是计划改善的时候,而是账户实际按时到达的时候.
353And that's the hardest thing to do.这是最难做到的
354And let me add just one thing here.让我在这里补充一点。
355Because this audience will have probably read that Senegal is an oil and gas producer now.因为观众可能会读到塞内加尔现在是石油和天然气生产国。
356That's in our figures from this year's.这是我们今年的数字
357So a new revenue that does not make a budget easier to read.因此,新的收入不会使预算更容易阅读。
358It makes it easier to stop reading.令诸众生方便断念.
359The temptation of a windfall is that it leads you to postpone the account for one more year.意外的诱惑是 它导致你 将账户再推迟一年。
360And then another year.再过一年
361So if you ask me what I'm watching in the next three big budgets,所以如果你问我在接下来三个大预算里 看到了什么
362it's not how much the oil money is going to bring in.石油钱不会带来多少
363It's whether it actually arrives as a line that anyone can follow and on time.这是它是否真的到达 作为一条线,任何人都可以遵循和准时。
364Yeah.对
365Thank you so much, Anta.谢谢你,安塔
366So that is something I really admire.所以我非常钦佩你
367Is that the way you rate a budget is just like the way you rate a company.你对预算的评级就像对公司评级一样
368You mentioned that a company doesn't die of losses.你提到公司不会因为损失而死
369It dies of cash.它死于现金。
370So the deficit is the profit and loss.故曰亏损是损益.
371The financing requirement is the bank account.融资要求是银行账户。
372And very gladly, you look twice at agriculture.很高兴你两次看农业。
373Because like, as you mentioned, what's promised is in the speech.因为,就像你提到的, 承诺在演讲中。
374And what's received is in the villages.且所收于村中.
375And you read the budget from the village up.你读了村里的预算
376And the slowness is not weather.而缓则非天气.
377It's a decision.决定.
378You mentioned that three days ago, your committee asked for last year's account你提到三天前 你的委员会问去年的帐户
379because the budget is a plan and the plan is a speech.因为预算是计划,计划是演讲。
380The count is where a state becomes visible.计数是状态变得可见的地方.
381The polearms taught you the responsibility without control.柱子教你无所不能的责任
382Your real instrument is not the power to decide.你真正的工具不是决定权
383But it's the power to decline and proceed.但它的力量 下降和继续。
384So and your last point really stayed with me.所以,你的最后一点 真的留在我身边。
385The oil and gas, their revenue doesn't make a budget easier to read.石油和天然气,他们的收入并不能使预算更容易阅读.
386It just makes it easier to stop reading.只是让停止阅读变得更容易.
387And that's exactly the heart of my own research这正是我研究的核心
388on the state capacity after the extraction.提取后的状态。
389The new revenue can weaken the very habit of accounting新收入可以削弱会计的习惯
390that makes the state visible.这使得国家明显可见。
391So thank you, Anna, for sharing all of those with us.所以,谢谢你,安娜, 与我们分享所有这些。
392So turning our last point, turning our wheel around towards the audience in Beijing.因此,我们把最后一点转向北京的观众。
393So what do you wish more people in China know about Senegal?那么,你希望中国更多的人知道塞内加尔是什么?
394If they learned a single word of Uluf before arriving, which should it be?如果他们在到达之前学会了乌鲁夫的一句话,应该是什么?
395And for a young person in China who want to work with Africa,而对于一个想要与非洲合作的中国年轻人来说,
396like in agriculture, in business, or in public service,如农业、商业或公共服务部门,
397where would you tell them to start?你会让他们从哪里开始?
398Thank you.谢谢
399So what I want you to know is that, and it's very important to us in Senegal,所以我想告诉你的是 这对我们塞内加尔来说很重要
400is that Senegal has never had a coup.塞内加尔从未发生政变。
401Our neighbors have soldiers in government.我们的邻居有军人参政
402My country is stable.我国局势稳定。
403We've had changes of power, including very bitter ones.我们改变了权力,包括非常痛苦的权力。
404And each time, the ballot actually held.每次投票都举行
405In 2024, I ran for president myself.2024年,我自己竞选总统.
406I was the only woman among 19 candidates.我是19个候选人中唯一的女性
407I didn't win.我没赢
408And the person who won took office, and I went to parliament.而获胜者上任,我去了议会。
409So that sentence is ordinary in Senegal.因此,这句话在塞内加尔是普通的。
410So look at a map of our region, and you see how ordinary it is.所以看看我们区域的地图,你可以看到它是多么的普通。
411So one word that I think people should know before coming to Senegal is Teranga.因此,我认为在来到塞内加尔之前人们应该知道的一个词是Teranga。
412Teranga),通常译作招待.
413And that translation is actually soft,而翻译其实很柔软,
414because hospitality is something you offer, usually.因为招待通常是你提供的东西。
415但Teranga是你欠我的
416If you arrive at my house at the wrong hour, unannounced,如果你来错时间了,不事先通知
417and there is only one plate of food, you eat from it.只有一个盘子的食物,你吃它。
418Not because I'm generous, not because it's what is,不是因为我慷慨, 不是因为这就是,
419but it's probably because that's what is owed to someone who has just arrived.但这可能是因为 这是欠 某人刚刚到达。
420And one day, I'll arrive somewhere else, and it will be owed to me.有一天,我会到别的地方, 它会欠我。
421So Teranga is very important for us.所以泰兰加对我们很重要
422It's not politeness.非礼非礼.
423It's a system of obligation that runs underneath everything,它是一个义务系统 贯穿于一切,
424including even how we do business.包括我们如何做生意。
425So if you come to Senegal and you understand only that word,所以,如果你来到塞内加尔 你只理解这个词,
426you will understand why the meetings start very late,你会明白为什么会议开始得很晚
427and why the relationship actually do last 20 years.和为什么这种关系 实际持续20年。
428So where to start with the last point,那么,从最后一点开始,
429it's I'm going to give you an unromantic answer.我会给你一个不浪漫的答案
430So let me say first that the answer is come.所以,首先让我说,答案来了。
431Come to Africa, come to Senegal.来非洲,来塞内加尔
432People say Africa has the product and only lacks the logistics.人们说非洲有这种产品,但只缺乏物流。
433That's not quite true, and I know it from my own books.这不是真的,我从我自己的书里知道
434My business actually mills feed.我的业务其实是磨坊养活。
435We buy imported maize, as I was telling you, imported soya.我们买进口玉米,正如我告诉你的, 进口大豆。
436But because at the volume and the consistency our factory needs,但是,因为量和一致性 我们的工厂需要,
437we can't yet buy it at home in Senegal.我们还不能在塞内加尔家里买
438So we would rather do it, produce it locally.所以我们宁愿做, 在当地生产。
439And that's exactly where one of the opportunities,这正是其中之一的机会,
440how to produce the soya, the maize, the corn in Senegal.如何在塞内加尔生产大豆、玉米和玉米。
441So what we're missing is not the land, it's not the labor,所以,我们缺少的不是土地,也不是劳动力,
442it's not the demand, it's the middle line这不是需求,这是中间线
443between a farmer and the factory.在农场和工厂之间
444There should be aggregation, grading, storage, processing,应有汇总、分级、储存、处理、
445a laboratory, a cold chain.实验室 冷链
446And in most of our value chain, there is almost not that,在我们大多数价值链中 几乎没有
447which means everything is still to be built.这意味着一切仍然有待建设。
448And whoever builds it first actually has very little competition now.不管是谁先建的 现在几乎没什么竞争
449And notice that I said factory, not containers.注意我说的工厂 不是集装箱
450The first market for Senegal agriculture is not China.塞内加尔农业的第一个市场不是中国。
451It is Senegal and the region around it.它是塞内加尔及其周围地区。
452And 18 million people in Senegal, more than 400 million in West Africa.塞内加尔有1 800万人,西非有4亿多人。
453Buying food, we are perfectly capable of growing.购买食物,我们完全有能力成长。
454So you'd not be getting on an export window,所以你不会进入出口窗口
455but you'll be betting on a market that already exists但你会赌上已经存在的市场
456and is currently served by imports.目前由进口服务。
457So concretely, where will I send you?具体来说,我送你到哪里去?
458I'll send you to four places,我送你到四个地方
459that young person who wishes to come to Senegal.希望来塞内加尔的年轻人。
460First, the middle, as I just described, storage, cold chain,首先,中间,正如我刚才所描述的,储存,冷链,
461grading, processing, and the machines分级、处理和机器
462with the people who can actually service them.和真正能为他们服务的人
463We buy agricultural equipment today in Senegal that we can't repair.我们今天在塞内加尔购买无法修理的农业设备.
464Second, and this is the one I would build if I were you,第二,如果我是你,我就会造这个
465Senegal sits on more than a billion tons of phosphate.塞内加尔拥有十亿多吨磷酸盐。
466Most of what we mine leaves the country,我们的矿井大部分离开这个国家
467largely going to India.主要去印度。
468And we import around 100,000 tons of urea every year to put in our own fields.我们每年进口大约10万吨尿素 用于我们自己的田地。
469So we export thousands tons, we export the rock,我们出口了几千吨 出口了岩石
470and we buy back the fertilizer.我们买回肥料
471We now have gas as well.我们现在也有汽油了
472A fertilizer plant is the simple most useful factory肥料厂是最有用的工厂
473anyone could build in my country, I think.我认为,任何人可以在我国建设。
474And it happens to be exactly what Chinese industry knows very well how to do.而恰巧正是中国工业非常清楚如何做.
475Third is energy.第三是能量。
476A cold chain without power is actually a shed.没有动力的冷链其实就是棚子.
477Gas and solar, both.气与太阳两物.
478And beyond food, my country is actively promoting two others,除了食物,我国还积极推广另外两种食品。
479pharmaceutical, manufacturing.制药,制造。
480We want to make medicines for the regions,我们想给各地区做药
481and not only import them all the time.不仅经常导入
482And digital.而数字化.
483Agriculture is 17% of our GDP,农业占国内生产总值的17%
484and 37% of our jobs in Senegal.以及塞内加尔37%的工作。
485So it is where I would start also.所以我也要从那里开始。
486But those doors are open too.但那些门也是打开的。
487And I think there is an investment agency我觉得有个投资机构
488and special economic zones whose whole job is to open those doors for you.和特殊经济区 他们的工作就是为你打开那些门
489And one last piece is practical advice.最后一篇是实用建议。
490And it's the advice that I would share here.这也是我在此分享的建议。
491So always come to Senegal with a partner,所以总是带着搭档来塞内加尔
492with a Senegalese partner of preference.与塞内加尔的优先伴侣。
493Not because of any rule, but because of the arithmetic.不是因为任何规则 而是因为算术
494A local partner arrives with the license,一个当地合伙人带着执照来了
495the land already cleared, farmers who already delivered,已经清理的土地, 已经交付的农民,
496and the knowledge of which door to knock on.以及知道要敲哪扇门
497Because it's very important to know which doors to knock on when you come to Senegal.因为了解你来塞内加尔时要敲的门非常重要。
498The projects that usually struggle in my country通常在我国挣扎的项目
499are the ones that arrive fully complete.是那些完全到达。
500When you come owning your land, your own team, your own supplies,当你拥有自己的土地,自己的团队,自己的补给,
501nobody actually physically stops them.没人能阻止他们
502They simply end up paying for everything他们只会为一切付出代价
503a partner would have bought on the first day.第一天就会有合伙人买下
504So our poultry industry is the proof.所以我们的家禽业就是证据
505It was built by a few hundred Senegalese families and the equipment.它是由几百个塞内加尔家庭和设备建造的。
506But today, the equipment, the genetics, the techniques, all come from outside.但是今天,设备,遗传学,技术,都来自外部.
507So foreign technology, local ownership,所以,外国技术, 本地所有权,
508and both sides actually make money for 20 years.双方都赚了20年的钱
509So that's the pattern we actually work here.这就是我们在这里的实际工作模式。
510So come and build it with us and the product will appear,来和我们一起建造它 产品就会出现
511including, I hope, my own purchase orders.包括,我希望,我自己的订单。
512Thank you, Anta.谢谢你,安塔
513This is a very impressive answer.这是一个非常令人印象深刻的答案。
514So the first thing you want in China to know所以在中国你最想知道的
515is that Senegal has never had a cope.塞内加尔从未有过应对之道。
516And every time power changed hands, the ballot held, including the 2024,每次权力交替, 投票,包括2024年,
517we run as the only woman among the 19 candidates我们作为19个候选人中唯一的女性参选
518and then went into the parliament, which is absent.然后进入议会,议会缺席。
519And the one word is taranga, not hospitality you offer, but hospitality you owe.只有一个词是塔兰加, 不是你的款待,而是你欠的款待。
520And where to start?从哪里开始?
521Your enromantic answer is come.你的浪漫答案来了
522What's missing isn't land, isn't labor, or isn't demand.所缺少的不是土地,不是劳动力,也不是需求.
523It is the middle between the farmer and the factory.这是农民和工厂之间的中间。
524The factory is not the containers.工厂不是容器
525The first market is in China is Senegal第一个市场在中国是塞内加尔
526and the 400 million people in the entire Western Africa.以及整个西非的4亿人。
527And also you mentioned that there is four places to start.你还提到有四个开始的地方。
528The first one is the middle.初一为中.
529With machines, someone can actually repair.用机器,有人可以真正修理。
530A fertilizer plant, because Senegal export the rocks and buy back the fertilizer.塞内加尔出口石块,
531An energy sector, because a cold chain without power is a shed.一个能源部门,因为没有电的冷链是一个棚子。
532And beyond food, medicines and digital.除了食物,药品和数字。
533And there's one practical rule.还有一条实用规则
534Come with a Senegalese partner.和塞内加尔伙伴一起来
535The projects that struggle are the ones that arrive are already complete,斗争的项目已经完成
536which really lands close to the home of me.离我的家很近的地盘
537So at China Agriculture University's College of International Development所以在中国农业大学国际发展学院
538and Global Agriculture, we talk about parallel experience sharing.以及全球农业,我们谈论平行的经验分享。
539China offering its own development experience, not as a blueprint to be installed,中国提供自己的发展经验,而不是作为要安装的蓝图,
540but as a parallel story to be compared, to be adapted, and sometimes to be rejected.但作为一个平行的故事来比较, 被修改,有时被拒绝。
541So when you just described arriving with a partner所以,当你刚刚描述 到达与伴侣
542rather than a finished package is exactly the idea and practice.而不是一个成品包 恰恰是想法和实践。
543So let me ask this in that spirit.因此,让我本着这种精神问这个问题。
544China and Senegal both trade feeding their people as a matter of national priority.中国和塞内加尔两国都把为本国人民提供粮食作为国家优先事项。
545So what could each learn from each other?那么,谁能互相学习?
546Thank you.谢谢
547The first thing is that that's the way to go.第一义是道.
548So what we've learned from China is that China is actually able to do it today.因此,我们从中国那里学到的是,中国今天实际上能够做到.
549For us in Senegal, it is an ambition to say, okay, we will be feeding.对我们塞内加尔人来说,说:好吧,我们将供餐。
550We can feed our own.我们可以自己养活自己
551Let Africa feed itself.让非洲养活自己。
552And China, I think, is clearly showing the way from the bottom to up,而中国,我认为, 清楚地显示 从下到上的道路,
553because I think it's a national policy.因为我认为这是国家政策
554It comes from the government, this ambition,它来自政府,这个野心,
555and every Chinese person is fully engaged into that,每一个中国人都全力以赴,
556because being able to feed yourself is the first form of freedom and liberty因为能够养活自己是自由和自由的第一形式
557that a country can have.一个国家可以拥有。
558We remember during COVID what happened.我们记得COVID发生的事
559In Senegal or in Africa, when we were not able to feed ourselves,在塞内加尔或非洲,当我们无法养活自己时,
560and most countries actually closed their doors to access either medicine or rice or anything.大多数国家实际上关闭了大门 要么获得药品 要么获得米饭 或任何东西。
561So it's very important for us to actually to learn how to feed one another.因此,对于我们来说, 学习如何互相供养是非常重要的。
562And what China can learn from Senegal,中国能从塞内加尔学到什么
563that's a tough question, because China is actually doing very well.这是一个很难的问题, 因为中国实际上做的非常好。
564But it's the engagement, probably, of the young people around this mission of feeding itself.但是,这可能是年轻人 围绕这个喂饱自己的任务的约定。
565Because in Senegal, this message, you're hearing it a lot from the youth,因为在塞内加尔,这个信息, 你听到了很多 从年轻人,
566understanding that it's our generation's mission.了解这是我们这一代人的使命
567So maybe that's something to put on the table,所以,也许这是 的东西放在桌子上,
568to just make sure that it's engaged fully by the younger generation to make it their own goal.确保年轻一代能充分参与 使之成为他们的目标
569Thank you so much, Anta.谢谢你,安塔
570And so what Senegal could learn from China is that feeding yourself is a national commitment,所以塞内加尔可以从中国学到的是,养活自己是一项国家承诺,
571from the government down to every household,从政府到每个家庭,
572because being able to feed yourself is the first form of freedom.因为能够养活自己是自由的第一种形式.
573And the COVID showed that what happened when borders closed and you can't.而COVID显示 当边界关闭时发生的事情,你不能。
574And what China might learn, the engagement of young people in that mission.以及中国可能学到的东西,青年参与这一任务。
575So if I personally could add one thing,所以,如果我个人可以添加一件事,
576I think what both sides can learn is Taringa.我想双方都能学到的是塔林加
577So as you describe it, it is not generosity, but an obligation that runs both ways.因此,正如你所描述的那样,这不是慷慨,而是一种双向的义务。
578Today I host you, tomorrow you host me.今天我招待你们,明天你招待我
579So cooperation builds on that, with the humility to arrive as guests因此,合作就建立在这种基础上,谦虚地来到了这里作为客人
580and a partner rather than with a finished package, maybe the most durable kind.和一个伙伴,而不是一个完整的包裹, 也许是最持久的。
581So thank you, Anta.谢谢你,安塔。
582And let's now open the floor to our audience in Beijing and all around the world.现在,我们向北京和全世界的观众开放。
583Please put your questions in the question and answer box,请把问题放在问答箱里
584and I will bring them to Anta.我会带他们去安塔
585Thank you.谢谢
586Anyone have...谁有...
587Oh, Carol, please.哦,卡罗尔,请。
588Thank you.谢谢
589Sorry, I think I speak faster than I type, so I'll try to be brief.对不起,我想我说话比打字快, 所以我会尽量简短。
590Anta and Gigi, thank you so much for that illuminating presentation安塔和吉吉,谢谢你的精彩介绍
591and I just feel this could go on forever because there are so many things我只是觉得这可以永远继续下去 因为有很多事情
592to learn from Senegal's experience.学习塞内加尔的经验。
593And Anta, given your background, your very diverse background in government and in business和安塔,鉴于你的背景, 你非常多样化的背景 在政府和商业
594and your critical role now in the finance committee and your government,和你现在在财政委员会和你的政府的关键作用,
595I'm really curious about how to run the finances.我很想知道怎么管理财务
596I mean, what are the similarities and differences in running your business我的意思是,什么是相似和不同 运行你的生意
597as an entrepreneur versus running a government?作为企业家与管理政府?
598You kind of mentioned the power to decline something,你有点提到 能力下降的东西,
599as the true power in some of the instances of public finances,作为一些公共财政中的真正权力,
600but I'm just fascinated by both the difference and the similarities但我只是迷上了 区别和相似
601between public finances and how companies run.在公共财政和公司如何运作之间。
602That's one.就是这样
603And another, I'm very encouraged by, although I feel very saddened还有,我很受鼓舞,虽然我很伤心
604about the hundreds of thousands of young people成千上万的年轻人
605who are risking their lives going abroad,他们冒着生命危险出国,
606I also feel very encouraged by how entrepreneurial the population is我也感到非常鼓舞 人们如何创业
607in terms of how people's first choice is really to be his or her own boss.从人们的第一选择 如何真正成为自己的老板。
608So I would love to hear more about that culture所以我想听更多关于这种文化
609and where you think that came about.以及你认为它来的地方。
610Lots of questions, but you can pick and choose有很多问题,但你可以选择
611and see what you would like to answer.看看你想回答什么
612Thank you so much.非常感谢
613Thank you, Carol.谢谢你,卡罗尔。
614And thank you for both questions.谢谢你的问话
615Actually, your first question is, I hear that very often事实上,你的第一个问题是, 我经常听到
616and in the presidential campaign, people were telling me,在总统竞选中 人们告诉我
617but you know, Anta, running a country is not the same as running your company,但你知道,安塔,经营一个国家 和经营你的公司不一样,
618which, of course, I know.当然 我知道
619But I think running a company teaches you但我认为经营一家公司会教你
620on how to actually better run a country.如何更好地管理一个国家。
621When you run a company, it teaches you how to build.当你经营一个公司, 它教你如何建设。
622Build infrastructure, building the company itself,建设基础设施,建设公司本身,
623building the people, building anything.建设人民,建设任何东西。
624But the nation actually decides on what gets built.但国家实际上决定了什么是建设的。
625And that's essential.这很重要。
626Each one of those sectors have their own power.其中每一个部门都有自己的权力。
627And the reason why I believe that the politics我为什么相信政治
628should be in the hands of those who've learned how to build is that.应该掌握在那些学会建设的人手里
629But also, a private sector business teaches you about transparency,但是,一个私营部门的企业 教你关于透明度,
630which nation needs, mostly mine.国家需要的,主要是我的
631It's about a transparent budget.这是关于一个透明的预算。
632It's about knowing that this public finance这是关于知道 公共财政
633or this public money is not yours to put in your pocket.否则这些公款就不是你的了
634And when you are in a business, when you are in a company,当你在企业, 当你在公司,
635you are actually built to understand that.你其实是想理解这一点
636So it teaches you principles and guidelines因此,它教你的原则和指导方针
637that you must follow for a better way to run your country.你们必须遵循更好的管理国家的方式。
638And also about leadership, about leadership,还有领导力,领导力,
639about building others.关于建立他人。
640In company, we teach you how to build others to be more successful.在公司里,我们教你如何造人 才能更成功。
641When you are a president or you are chief of state当你是总统还是国家首脑
642or you are in the government, it's about building your people,或你进入政府, 这是关于建设你的人民,
643building the youth, helping the women, et cetera, et cetera.培养青年,帮助妇女等等。
644So building others instead of building your own self.所以造别人而不是你自己
645And that's something that our leaders need to learn most,这是我们领导人最需要学习的
646in my country at least.至少在我国
647And your last question was, remind me again, just a little.你最后的问题就是,再次提醒我,只是一点点。
648Sure.当然
649I was very encouraged that you said.你说我很受鼓舞
650Yes, entrepreneurship.是的,创业。
651I want to be their boss.我想当他们的老板
652Yeah, where does that come from?是啊,这是从哪里来的?
653Entrepreneurship.创业.
654Yes.对
655That's so true.没错
656When you go around Senegal and you ask most people当你绕着塞内加尔去问大多数人
657what do you want to do, mostly the young people,你想做什么, 主要是年轻人,
658they will always tell you, I want to become an entrepreneur.他们总是会告诉你,我想成为一个企业家。
659Because I think also we have success stories to look at too.因为我认为我们也有成功的故事可以看。
660We have people who've built champion companies我们有人建立了冠军公司
661from nothing, from the ground.从无,从地面。
662I'm going to go back to this example我要回到这个例子
663that I was giving you, our family company.我给了你 我们的家庭陪伴
664It was built with a hundred dollars in 1976.1976年以百元建成.
665So no major investment, no major capital, just a hundred dollars.所以没有大的投资,没有大的资金,只有一百美元。
666Lots of failures in the process.在这个过程中有很多失败。
667Lots of knocking downs and getting back up.很多打倒,然后站起来。
668And that's not the only example.且不独此例.
669We can today count tens of people who've built from scratch我们今天可以算出几十个人 从零开始建造
670and actually were able to make it something并且实际上能够做一些东西
671that the young people can look forward to.年轻人可以期待。
672But also because Senegal is a land of opportunity.但也因为塞内加尔是一个机会之地。
673And as I was telling you, so much is to build on.正如我所告诉你的, 如此之多是继续。
674So instead of just being employed, most people would be like,所以,不是仅仅被雇用, 大多数人会喜欢,
675let me play my role in this sector because it's empty让我在这个部门扮演我的角色,因为它是空的
676and nobody is there yet.还没有人在那里。
677And they take up on it.他们开始处理这件事
678Most of them succeed, most of them fail.多数成功,多数失败.
679But we're teaching them that success is the addition of your failures.但我们在教他们 成功是你们失败的附加
680So we encourage a lot of people to actually get into entrepreneurship.所以我们鼓励很多人真正进入创业。
681With its hardship, but usually when it works, it works pretty well.困难重重,但通常在工作时,效果相当好.
682You call it a national champion because you started from the bottom.你称它为全国冠军 因为你从底部开始。
683Okay, thank you.好的 谢谢
684I love that.我喜欢
685Thank you so much.非常感谢
686Yeah, thank you so much, Anta.是的,非常感谢,安塔。
687So what business teach you to build is infrastructure, companies, and people.企业教你建设的就是基础设施、公司和人。
688But the nation decides what gets built.但国家决定什么是建设。
689So business also brings two things a state need, which is transparency,因此,商业也带来两件事 一个国家需要,这就是透明度,
690knowing that the public money is not yours to put into our own pocket知道公共资金不是你的 投入我们自己的口袋
691and also a leadership that builds others rather than oneself.以及培养他人而不是自我的领导才能。
692And so, yeah, so, and let's come into one of the audience's questions.所以,是的,所以, 让我们来谈谈观众的一个问题。
693So they ask like, so both of our two guests,所以,他们问喜欢, 所以我们的两个客人,
694they raised one single question from two different perspectives.他们从两个不同的角度提出一个问题。
695So as a Yale World Fellow, so what has life been like at Yale World Fellow?作为耶鲁大学世界研究员,在耶鲁大学世界研究员中生活怎么样?
696And also look ahead, what is on your bucket list,并且展望未来,什么是你的桶列表,
697the drain you will carry back to Dakar after Yale?在耶鲁大学毕业后,你会带回达喀尔的排水沟?
698And also one of them also wanted to say best wishes to Senegal.其中一人也想向塞内加尔表示最良好的祝愿。
699Thank you.谢谢
700Okay, I think this program of Yale World Fellow, as I said, is a gift to myself.好吧,我想这个计划 耶鲁世界研究员, 正如我说的, 这是一个礼物给自己。
701So what is this?这是什么?
702It's 16 people coming from all over the globe有16个人来自世界各地
703who champions in their business and we bring them around the room.谁在他们的生意中赢得冠军, 我们带他们周围的房间。
704At Yale, most of the time, they even leave us alone to walk around campus,在耶鲁,大多数时候, 他们甚至让我们独自在校园里散步,
705to think, to reflect, to write books, but mostly to share,思考,思考,写书, 但大部分分享,
706to share our experiences, our knowledge,分享我们的经验和知识,
707our passion into different classrooms of undergrads and graduates.我们热衷于 不同教室的初中和毕业生。
708And also every week, we welcome professors, authors,我们每周都欢迎教授和作者
709very influential people around the dinner table and we get to challenge them.非常有影响力的人 在餐桌周围 我们得到挑战他们。
710We mostly talk globally about the world.我们主要在全球谈论世界。
711We talk a lot about China.我们经常谈论中国。
712We talk about Africa.我们谈论的是非洲。
713We talk about the changes that are happening in the world.我们谈论世界正在发生的变化。
714But you know what our main topic is, Jisun,但你知道我们的主要话题是什么,吉善
715and this is why my time here was actually worth it.这就是为什么我在这里的时间 是真正值得的。
716We talk about what a good society is我们谈论什么是好社会
717and how each one of us must contribute into building a good society.以及我们每个人必须如何为建设一个良好的社会作出贡献。
718We come in with our stories.我们带着我们的故事来
719We put them on the table.我们把它们放在桌子上。
720We decide on how is ANTA contributing to building a good society.我们决定安塔如何为建设一个良好的社会作出贡献。
721And we receive feedbacks.我们收到反馈
722So leaving Yale, I'm living with bigger hope and a stronger passion所以离开耶鲁,我生活在更大的希望和更强的激情中
723for my country, for my continent,为了我的国家 为了我的大陆
724and a better understanding of what the world has to offer以及更好地理解世界提供
725and how we actually got here.以及我们怎么来到这里的
726How did the world actually got to where it is right now?这个世界是怎样到达它现在的位置的?
727Depending on which regions we are talking about.取决于我们所谈论的区域。
728Getting all the facts and seeing how it's going to impact the work了解所有事实,看看如何影响工作
729and the job that I have to do once I go back.还有我回去后必须完成的工作
730Because the whole idea behind this fellowship is actually also going back.因为这个研究金背后的整个想法 实际上是回溯。
731We don't come to Yale University or come to the U.S.我们不来耶鲁大学,也不来美国.
732with the ambition of actually staying here.带着住在这里的野心
733We come here to share, to get something, to take something.我们来到这里分享, 得到的东西,拿的东西。
734But it's about going back and changing the world而是要回去改变世界
735or at least change your country.或者至少改变你的国家。
736So what do I take back?我该拿回什么?
737Very funny thing, maybe.也许这很有趣
738It's about organization.这是关于组织。
739And this is not a Yale thing.这不是耶鲁大学的事。
740I think it's an American thing.我觉得那是美国的东西
741And Jisun, you probably agree with this.和吉善,你可能同意这一点。
742In Africa, I would make my appointments for just next year.在非洲,我将在明年预约。
743When I've learned that here in Yale or in America,当我在耶鲁或美国得知
744you have to plan a month ahead.你得提前一个月计划
745And that's probably why Jisun every week was like,也许这就是为什么吉善每周都喜欢,
746please confirm.请确认
747I'll be like, I'll be there.我会像,我会在那里。
748But it's about the planning and the organization.但事关规划和组织.
749And having dinner at 6 p.m. is actually totally new to me.下午6点吃晚饭对我来说是全新的
750We have dinner at 9, 10 o'clock.我们9点10分吃晚饭
751But dinner at 6 p.m. at New Haven and eating pizza every day.但是下午6点在纽黑文吃晚饭,每天吃披萨.
752So yeah, it's an amazing journey.所以,这是一个惊人的旅程。
753It's an amazing journey to be a Yale World Fellow.成为耶鲁世界研究员的旅程令人惊叹.
754And it gives you a sense of responsibility.让你有责任感
755Towards the world and the generation you're in,走向世界和你的一代人
756but mostly the generation that comes after you.但主要是你之后的一代人
757Thank you so much.非常感谢
758Guilty as charged, Anta.罪名成立,安塔。
759I promise this is the last please confirm.我保证这是最后一次确认
760And I'm sorry we couldn't offer you like,很抱歉不能给你这样的机会
761we couldn't offer you anything better than pizza at 6 p.m.晚上6点,我们无法提供比披萨更好的东西
762So yeah, so, but become serious, back to serious, seriously.所以,是的,但变得严肃, 回到严肃,严肃。
76316 people from all around the world,全世界有16个人
764always coming back to one single question.总是回到一个问题。
765What is a good society?什么是好社会?
766So, and I really appreciate your idea.所以,我真的很感激你的想法。
767The whole idea is going back, not coming here to stay,整个想法是回去, 不是来这里留下来,
768but really taking something home to change your country.但真的带了点东西回家 改变你的国家。
769So after everything we heard about young people leaving,我们听说年轻人离开后
770I think that really feels like the right note.我觉得这感觉真像字条
771Yeah, and so which actually brings us to our last question,是的,所以实际上 带给我们我们最后一个问题,
772which is really the same question.这其实是同一个问题。
773Yeah, so I think like, I think someone in our audience asked,是的,所以我想,像, 我想有人在我们的观众问,
774how do we balance economic development with public welfare,我们如何平衡经济发展与公共福利,
775protection for vulnerable groups, and the energy transition?保护弱势群体和能源过渡?
776And also Lane asked how social entrepreneurs连恩还问社会企业家
777can fund this kind of work.可以资助这种工作。
778So could you please in a sentence or two each,所以,请在一两句,
779when growth and welfare compete for the same budget line,当增长和福利竞争同一预算项目时,
780how will you decide?你怎么决定?
781And also, where does the first money for social good come from?还有,社会公益的第一笔钱是从哪里来的?
782Thank you.谢谢
783Okay, thank you.好的 谢谢
784Those are really two good questions.这真是两个好问题。
785And I think the time that I have left我觉得我离开的时间
786will not allow me to go really deep into them.不允许我深入探讨
787So I'm just gonna give you a few pointers.所以我会给你一些指导。
788My country, Senegal, is a very social one,我国塞内加尔是一个非常社会化的国家,
789because it's a developing country with lots of issues right now.因为它是一个发展中国家 现在有很多问题。
790If you ask me, when I was writing my presidential program,如果你问我, 当我写我的总统计划时,
791I said, this is the time for industrialization of my country.我说,现在是我国工业化的时候。
792But before you industrialize anything,但在你做工业之前
793people need access to food, to health, to education.人们需要获得食物、健康和教育。
794So the social aspect of it is very important.因此,它的社会方面非常重要。
795It needs now to be balanced,现在需要平衡
796because the people of Senegal rely a lot因为塞内加尔人民非常依赖
797on the state and on the government for help, for support.在州和政府寻求帮助,支持。
798So in the budget, to go back to the commission of finance,所以,在预算中, 回到委托财政,
799I look forward to all the support, all the help,我期待着所有的支持, 所有的帮助,
800all the social aspects that we actually give back to the people.我们真正给予人民的一切社会方面。
801We must balance it right now,我们现在必须平衡
802because if those people are not healthy or they're not eating因为如果那些人不健康 或者他们不吃
803and they don't have access to an education,他们没有机会接受教育,
804they can't contribute back to the economy,他们不能为经济做出贡献,
805because we actually rely on them to build the economy.因为我们实际上依靠他们来建立经济。
806So we must make sure that they have access所以我们必须确保他们能进入
807to the basic necessary needs满足基本需要
808and to come back and contribute to the economy.回来为经济做出贡献
809So it's actually as important as building the feed meals所以,它实际上 与构建饲料餐
810and the industrialization that I'm just so passionate about.我对工业化充满热情
811This actually comes first.这其实是第一。
812The last question was, the social entrepreneur,最后一个问题是 社会企业家
813where does the first money come from?第一笔钱从哪里来的?
814It can come from various places,它可以来自不同的地方,
815but this is my personal recommendation.这是我个人的建议
816I don't think it should come from the bank.我觉得不应该来自银行
817That's what I can tell you.这就是我可以告诉你的。
818I don't think it could come from the bank.我不认为它可能来自银行。
819Very important, the first investment does not have to be large,很重要的是,第一次投资不必很大
820doesn't have to be a big amount.不必大额。
821I think that's where most young people get it wrong.我想大多数年轻人都搞错了
822They think that to start a business or to become an entrepreneur,他们认为要创业或成为企业家
823you need a certain amount of money.你需要一定数额的钱
824You need as little as possible.你需要的尽可能少。
825Don't get it as a first loan.何得为第一贷.
826Loans can come after years,贷款可能几年后,
827but at the beginning, make sure it comes either from your savings但从一开始 确保不是来自你的积蓄
828or support from your family, etc.或来自你家人的支持等。
829But it does not have to come from the bank但不必来自银行
830and don't make it a big amount of money to make sure.并且不要让它成为一大笔钱来保证。
831If it doesn't work, then at least it's not the end of your project vision or future.如果它不起作用,那么至少它不是你的项目愿景或未来的结束.
832Is corruption a problem in Senegal?腐败在塞内加尔是一个问题吗?
833And how does the situation compare with other countries in the region?与该区域其他国家相比,情况如何?
834Corruption is a problem everywhere in the world.腐败是世界各地一个问题。
835I think most countries.我认为大多数国家都这样。
836Yes, it is also a problem in Senegal.是的,这也是塞内加尔的一个问题。
837But there is a change here that's happening in my country.但我国正在发生改变。
838Today, we are so aware that corruption is one of the reasons今天,我们非常清楚,腐败是原因之一
839why we stay behind in our development,为什么我们留在我们的发展,
840that it's actually has become one of the priorities实际上,它已经 成为优先事项之一
841of things we need to fight against.需要战斗的东西。
842And that's why in my speech earlier, you heard me talk about it.这就是为什么我之前的演讲, 你听到我谈论它。
843Most of the young political leaders that you will meet in Senegal你们将在塞内加尔会见的大多数年轻的政治领导人
844or mostly in Africa will tell you about this fight against corruption或大多在非洲会告诉你 这场反腐斗争
845and politics or political leaders comparing or confusing政治或政治领导人比较或混淆
846state money with their own money.州钱和他们自己的钱。
847So it's one of the biggest struggles.所以这是最大的斗争之一.
848And most of the time, it's also discouraging some investors多数时候,这也令一些投资者感到沮丧
849to come to Senegal or to come to Africa.来到塞内加尔或非洲。
850But just keep in mind that it has become a priority但记住,它已经成为一个优先事项
851of one of the fights that we need to win.需要我们赢得的战斗之一。
852And that my generation will definitely win我这代人一定会赢的
853because some people cannot be working to develop the country因为有些人无法发展国家
854and some other people on the other hand just take it back to their money而另一些人却把钱拿回去
855or just make the process extremely complicated或者让过程变得极其复杂
856for somebody to understand it just because they're corrupt administration让别人理解它 只是因为他们是腐败的政府
857or corrupt police forces or corrupt business people, et cetera.或腐败的警察部队或腐败的商人,等等。
858It will hold the development of any country down.它将阻碍任何国家的发展。
859So it's something to fight against.故以抗之为事.
860And that's what we're doing also in Senegal.这也是我们在塞内加尔所做的。
861谢 you,积善.
862And thank you for all.谢谢大家
863Thank you so much.非常感谢
864Yeah, thank you, Anta.谢谢,安塔
865And so basically, so for the journey, and also on the last question,基本上,对于旅程, 以及最后一个问题,
866your answer echoes everything we heard about the budget.你的回答回响了我们听说的关于预算的一切
867The corruption is everywhere.腐败无处不在.
868And what's changing in Senegal is the awareness that holds development back.塞内加尔正在改变的是 阻碍发展的意识。
869And also the first money for social good should not come from the bank社会公益的首笔钱 也不应该来自银行
870as small as possible.尽可能小
871So just like those companies that really starts with $100.就像那些从100美元开始的公司一样。
872So we began this morning with a single check-in所以今天早上我们开始 单次登机
873and ended with the question of a good society.以一个好社会的问题结束
874And thank you for showing us the view from Dakar with honesty,谢谢你诚实地向我们展示达喀尔的风景
875with numbers, and Taringa.还有塔林加
876And thank you.谢谢
877Thanks for Carol.谢谢你卡罗尔。
878And also to Professor Sunil Amrish,还有苏尼尔·阿姆里希教授
879the Vice Provost of Global Affairs at Yale University.耶鲁大学全球事务副校长
880And to the Macmillan Center and Yale Center Beijing team.以及麦克米兰中心和耶鲁中心北京队.
881And to everyone who joined us from Beijing and all around the world.并向从北京和世界各地加入我们的每一个人致敬。
882Jerry Jeff and Asante Sana and good night to Beijing.杰瑞・杰夫和阿桑特・萨娜 晚安到北京
883Yeah.对
884Bye.再见。
885Thank you so much.非常感谢
该视频共有字幕 887 条。解锁更多字幕为会员功能,请移动到 价格